Will Caroline Kennedy Be The Next NY Senator?

Cicero bet me to it :mad: ;), but here's a link.

If you are willing to count one father and son as a dynasty – the Cuomos in NY. However, at one time the son was married to a Kennedy.

Mario Cuomo was governor of NY from 1983 to 1994 and his son Andrew Cuomo is currently the Attorney General of NY State.

Mario Cuomo teased the country for about 10 years as to whether he would run for president. He never did. Andrew Cuomo was in President Clinton’s Cabinet. He is currently in the running to be appointed Senator.

As an aside, Caroline Kennedy didn’t express interest in the position until one of her cousins (don’t recall which one) decided he didn’t want it. I was surprised that she didn’t have the same reluctance to run against Andrew Cuomo because he was, I thought, her cousin by marriage. It turns out that he’s been divorced from his ex-wife for a few years now. So .. even though he's the father of some of her other cousins (first, once removed) I guess he’s no longer family!

FWIW, I hope he's not appointed. I disagree with the position he’s taken on internet related topics (Facebook and Usenet). It’s mentioned in the Wiki article in case anyone is curious.

I can’t think of any other dynasties at the moment. But I’d bet that some others had existed on a more local level.

In the UK, it goes without saying that the House of Lords by definition has dynasties. What about the House of Commons? Has that ever occurred?

ETA: Ah -- one more family, the Harrisons. They produced two presidents, several governors, several state senators and representatives and more.
 
Last edited:
I feel bad for Nita Lowey, who is my Congresswoman. She was slated by the NY Democrats to run for that seat in 2000, and she would have won handily. For eight years, she dutifully endorsed Senator Clinton in her run, and re-election in 2006. She's been a solid Rep, a Democrat who will buck her party when appropriate. She knows her district and the State. But the Democrats made it clear the empty seat was going to go to an Obama supporter. So, dutifully, she declined. At first people were talking about Andrew Cuomo (shiver). And now Caroline Kennedy. I'm beginning to feel like New York only has one Senate seat. The other one has been designated the "Celebrity Seat". Sigh.

Governor Paterson should stick it in the Establishment's eye and nominate Republican Vito Fossella!
 
Last edited:
Regarding political dynasties in the US, I gather the Gore family is one, the Roosevelts obviously another, Kennedy and Bush have been mentioned. Are there any more that come to mind?
The Oklahoma Sooners from 1953-58 with a record of 60-3-1.

They won 47 games in a row and held two national titles while defeating opponents by an average of 28.6 points per game.
 
@ CapelDodger and PuppyCow: I worked your comments into my e-mail and just sent it now. I did not give you any credit in the letter. :p;)

:o

Thank you for having the gumption to actually send my opinion to the relevant person. I hope he will do the right thing.
 
In the UK, it goes without saying that the House of Lords by definition has dynasties. What about the House of Commons? Has that ever occurred?

Pitt the Elder and Pitt the Younger. Balfour was a Cecil through his mother, and Cecils crop up a lot. More recently, Tony Benn and Hilary Benn are father and son.

A complicating factor is that the heirs of peers can serve in the Commons until they inherit the title.
 
:o

Thank you for having the gumption to actually send my opinion to the relevant person. I hope he will do the right thing.

I hope somebody reads it!:D

Perhaps all the stupidity happening in Illinois will motivate Paterson to make an excellant choice.
 
I feel bad for Nita Lowey, who is my Congresswoman. She was slated by the NY Democrats to run for that seat in 2000, and she would have won handily. For eight years, she dutifully endorsed Senator Clinton in her run, and re-election in 2006. She's been a solid Rep, a Democrat who will buck her party when appropriate. She knows her district and the State. But the Democrats made it clear the empty seat was going to go to an Obama supporter. So, dutifully, she declined.

I agree Lowey got a raw deal in 2000 and that's one of the reasons I didn't support Hillary Clinton for president.

I've seen nothing to indicate that Lowey wants to run for the Senate now though. She is 71 years old and has a senior position in the House Appropriations Committee. If she went to the Senate she would have to start over as a junior and who knows how long it would take her to get back to a similar postion of power.

Governor Paterson should stick it in the Establishment's eye and nominate Republican Vito Fossella!
:D That would go over very well!
 
Caroline Kennedy continues to take steps to secure NY senate seat -

… several people who have counseled the governor on the pending vacancy said that Ms. Kennedy has emerged as a clear front-runner, if she proves able to withstand the intense scrutiny and criticism that her decision to seek the seat is likely to provoke.

<snip>

Ms. Kennedy is now launching a public effort to demonstrate that she has both the ability and the stomach to perform the job, with plans to visit parts of the upstate region. The governor, who has expressed frustration with other elected officials for campaigning too openly, has done nothing to discourage her, said a person who has spoken with Ms. Kennedy.

<snip>

The person, who spoke on condition of anonymity to avoid antagonizing the governor, said that Mr. Paterson also had come to see Ms. Kennedy as a strong potential candidate whose appointment would keep a woman in the seat and whose personal connections would allow her to raise the roughly $70 million required to hold on to the seat in the coming years.

Under state law, Ms. Kennedy would have to run and win in 2010, to finish out the last two years of Mrs. Clinton’s term, and again in 2012, to win a term of her own.

<snip>

On Monday, she called dozens of political figures to let them know she was interested in the job. Besides Mr. Paterson and Christine C. Quinn, the New York City Council speaker, Ms. Kennedy called upstate officials like Representative Louise M. Slaughter and Byron Brown, the mayor of Buffalo; the Rev. Al Sharpton, the civil rights leader; and Charles E. Schumer, New York’s senior senator.

<snip>

Ms. Kennedy has also retained Knickerbocker SKD, a well-connected political consulting firm founded by Josh Isay, a former chief of staff to Mr. Schumer. The firm counts among its clients Mayor Michael R. Bloomberg, Ms. Quinn, and Mr. Brown, and enjoys close ties with some of New York’s powerful labor unions. Several of those called by Ms. Kennedy said that she had not asked for their endorsement, but merely expressed her interest in the job and willingness to earn it. Those discussions seemed intended to soothe some of the feathers already ruffled among the many elected officials, including some in New York’s Congressional delegation, who are seeking the seat.
 
I wonder when Paterson will make his decision. Will it come before the end of the year? There's not too much time left before the new congress convenes, is there?
 
I wonder when Paterson will make his decision. Will it come before the end of the year? There's not too much time left before the new congress convenes, is there?

How can he make a decision until after "Snipery" Hillary vacates/resigns from the Senate? She has to be approved by the Senate and that will not happen. if it happens, until next year.
 
How can he make a decision until after "Snipery" Hillary vacates/resigns from the Senate? She has to be approved by the Senate and that will not happen. if it happens, until next year.

So you think that she will not resign until she is confirmed?
Obama already resigned his seat (not sure exactly why he didn't wait because now it's going to be some time before he can be replaced because of the Blago mess, and there are still some votes where he could potentially make a difference, like the auto bailout).
 
So you think that she will not resign until she is confirmed?
A blogger, Jonathan Singer, quotes Ben Smith of politico:

Senator Clinton intends to remain in office through confirmation," emails spokesman Philippe Reines.

UPDATE: Says New York Governor David Paterson in a statement: "In order to appoint the best possible candidate to replace Senator Clinton, I am consulting with a wide variety of individuals from all across New York State. I expect to announce Senator Clinton's replacement when the position becomes officially vacant."

Politico hasn't been a good source of information in regard to RFK Jr but the above looks accurate. I've seen the Patterson statement in various newspapers and its logical for Clinton to wait until she's confirmed in her new position before she resigns her old one. Aside from the reason anyone would expect, Singer explains:

... the Senate is extremely unlikely to reject a nomination from its membership because a rejected nominee would have the power as Senator to seek retribution against members voting against him or her, through filibusters, through holds, and the like. In the not too distant past, the Senate has rejected a former member, John Tower, but again, former members, unlike sitting members, don't have the capacity to hit back against Senators voting against his or her nomination.

This isn't to say that Clinton would otherwise have difficulty getting through the nomination process, because I don't think she will. That said, when one has leverage in politics, there is no reason to give it away for free, so it makes eminent sense for Clinton to hold on to her Senate seat until she is confirmed.


Puppycow said:
Obama already resigned his seat (not sure exactly why he didn't wait because now it's going to be some time before he can be replaced because of the Blago mess, and there are still some votes where he could potentially make a difference, like the auto bailout).

I also wondered why he resigned so quickly after the election, and for the same reason. Perhaps this is a way for him to distance himself from an extremely corrupt situation? Anyone recall what other senators have done after becoming the president-elect?
 
Last edited:
Connections matter in polictics. Result is that children of former politicians are going to have something of an advantage.
 
$70,000,000 matters in politics. That's how much the NYTs article says the 2010 and 2012 senate campaigns will cost. (I don't know how they estimated it.) Paterson thinks that Caroline Kennedy can either raise that much money or would be willing to spend her own money. Apparently she's also willing to help him raise money for his reelection campaign in 2010.

I wish meritocracy was more important and that more people (both the voters and other politicians) cared about having someone appointed to the senate seat who is a known quantity and has a history of public votes. But money, either the ability to raise it or spend your own may end up being the deciding factor here.

Geni, does it cost as much to win an election in the UK also?
 
Last edited:
Princess Caroline is even less qualified to be the junior senator from New York than Sarah Palin is to be VPOTUS.
 
Connections matter in polictics. Result is that children of former politicians are going to have something of an advantage.

Will the person Patterson picks have the same committee assignments and seniority as Clinton or will the new Senator be considered a freshman?
 
Princess Caroline is even less qualified to be the junior senator from New York than Sarah Palin is to be VPOTUS.

Don't expect Eleanor Clift, Diane Rehm, Keith Olbermann, Raychill Maddow, Naomi Wolf, Thomas Mann, etc, vociferous critics of Palin, to echo this sentiment.
 
Geni, does it cost as much to win an election in the UK also?

At todays exchange rate no. It's not that far above what it costs one of the main parties to contest a general election (that is the cost to contest almost every single seat at once) but individual seats are more in the £10K region (although you can win with less).
 
At todays exchange rate no. It's not that far above what it costs one of the main parties to contest a general election (that is the cost to contest almost every single seat at once) but individual seats are more in the £10K region (although you can win with less).

Even a comparable seat for a region that would include one of the largest cities in the UK? That's an astronomical difference. If I looked up the exchange rate correctly that is $7,203 vs. $35,000,000 or .002% of the cost! Any thoughts as to why its so much less expensive? Is there a downside? Do you have more lunatics trying to run or form parties because it's much less expensive to do so than in the States?
 
Even a comparable seat for a region that would include one of the largest cities in the UK?

There is no comparible seat in the UK. Pretty much all constituencies are the same size (the largest is the Isle of Wight at 108,253 which is an anomoly due to georaphical issues). A better comparison is congress seats.

That's an astronomical difference. If I looked up the exchange rate correctly that is $7,203 vs. $35,000,000


I think you got the echange rates the wrong way around.

Any thoughts as to why its so much less expensive?

Because there are fairly solid laws in place stopping people spending more. The areas covered are also smaller and there just isn't a tradition of spending large amounts of money.

Is there a downside?

Free speach issues would be one.

Do you have more lunatics trying to run or form parties because it's much less expensive to do so than in the States?

To an extent but mostly a by-election thing. For the most part they lose so there is no real problem in them running. You have to put down £500 to run which you lose if you get less than 5% of the vote. There are some people who will pay their £500 and have a bit of fun but it doesn't generaly cause problems.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom