Why Liberal Suck at Understanding Conservatives and Why it Matters

If you're popping caps at imaginary creatures, it's an accurate description.

I didn't know I had ever done that.........So, your hypothetical doesn't fit, yet the criticism of me to that end remains........Does this make you feel superior in some way? Chris B.
 
Why would spending the same amount on healthcare as the USA does at the moment but covering everyone mean some kids would not get sufficient nutrition? That seems a rather contrived hypothetical.
You seem to be assuming that the expenditure wouldn't increase? I'm not following why you think it would be the same amount spent, but now everyone gets covered? I'm sure there's a simple piece I'm missing :)
 
I didn't know I had ever done that.........So, your hypothetical doesn't fit, yet the criticism of me to that end remains........Does this make you feel superior in some way? Chris B.
No, I don't feel superior, I feel pity.

ChrisBFRPKY said:
Same reason I wouldn't shoot you dmaker, I respect life. Now don't get me wrong, I'm not willing to die if I'm attacked. But unless that happens the pistol stays in the holster. Chris B.
I also fear for the person near you when you unholster your weapon and fire at the creature of your delusion.

Remember, you've posted pictures of shadows you imagined were bigfoot; what happens when you fantasize one of those shadows is attacking you?
 
I have no need of gun. I'm not afraid of the world.

But as a gun person isn't using a gun to just make a noise bad gun safety? Aren't you always supposed to assume that the bullet will hit something. Even just firing in the air is unsafe. Why would you use a gun to just make a noise? That seems to be rather irresponsible gun ownership.

Knowing where your bullet goes is an important part of gun safety of course. I think I was 9 when I was taught that. What you're doing is falling back to the typical Liberal stance on guns and gun owners. You're portraying that the gun owner doesn't know these things. You think having a gun is irresponsible no matter what. That's fine, I expect as much and I'm not surprised.
Chris B.
 
No, I don't feel superior, I feel pity.


I also fear for the person near you when you unholster your weapon and fire at the creature of your delusion.

Remember, you've posted pictures of shadows you imagined were bigfoot; what happens when you fantasize one of those shadows is attacking you?

Wrong topic for Bigfoot old buddy. I don't discuss that with you guys anymore and I'm not interested in rekindling it here thanks.

The only evidence of delusion I've seen is your descriptive hypothetical fantasies of me acting irresponsibly with firearms. You really believe this stuff you make up. Scary.
Chris B.
 
Wrong topic for Bigfoot old buddy. I don't discuss that with you guys anymore and I'm not interested in rekindling it here thanks.

The only evidence of delusion I've seen is your descriptive hypothetical fantasies of me acting irresponsibly with firearms. You really believe this stuff you make up. Scary.
Chris B.
Using your own posts and words, I demonstrated that you believe in bigfoot and pack heat in the woods in case you're "attacked". Anyone can go to the thread I linked earlier and read for themselves about how you're packin' large. They can also view the photos and video you claim to contain bigfoot, and they can decide for themselves what is scary.
 
This is special pleading

No, it's not.

Do you keep only the bare minimum needed for your own survival, and send every cent beyond that to people starving in foreign countries? Do you forego television, movies, internet, etc. because that funds you spend could save someone's life in Somalia?

No, because that's a false dichotomy, and a fairly ridiculous one at that. You were talking about healthcare. I am more than willing to be taxed more, and I believe everyone else should be as well, to have a healthcare system that provides for everyone. It's been proven it can work, and there are more than enough examples in the world to show that it's possible. Keep your random ass hyperbole to yourself. This isn't a "Either you give everything, or you're still the problem." Mind boggling

Unless you do, you are equally guilty of refusing to give up anything that you want in order to help others.

No, I'm not "equally guilty". I mean, to you I might be, but I try to look beyond fallacies. I give up plenty in order to help others, not that I have to rationalize anything to you, but again. Learn what a false dichotomy is and then come back. There is middle ground.

Clearly, you are not adhering to the principle of collective unity that you espouse. Why then do you feel righteously justified in condemning others for not being willing to give up the exact same things that you yourself are unwilling to give up?

Because I'm not *********** requesting everyone else to give up everything either. That's something you've made up. Good work. :thumbsup:
 
Knowing where your bullet goes is an important part of gun safety of course. I think I was 9 when I was taught that. What you're doing is falling back to the typical Liberal stance on guns and gun owners. You're portraying that the gun owner doesn't know these things. You think having a gun is irresponsible no matter what. That's fine, I expect as much and I'm not surprised.
Chris B.
I'm not portraying the gun owner as anything. I don't think just having a gun is irresponsible. I think being irresponsible with a gun, like oh, using it as a noisemaker, is irresponsible.

BTW: I was 12 when I learned gun safety. Never said I haven't used them, I just don't own one nor have any need to own one.

And yes I am a Liberal, thank you for capitalizing it, and you think every Liberal hates guns. That's fine, I expect as much and I'm not surprised.
 
I agree skepticism can always improve its image and reputation. In sense, that is connected to what I am talking about, here. Though, more broadly than to just us skeptics.

I came to Haidt through a more general investigation into rhetoric. My goal was to develop science based strategies for Skeptical Outreach.



That is a good example! (Though, a bit extremeist.)
It is elitist attitudes like that that I hope we can change, though understanding our fellow humans better. Cowing the opposition will continue to backfire, in the form of Trumps and Brexits, until we do!

MORE RESPONSES TO COME!

Haidt's proposals (assuming his model is accurate) is all about developing a messaging strategy. Within Skepticism, we've usually called this the "Tone" Debate.

But I still think there's an important role for assembling correct information in the first place. I feel a lot of the political chasm is due to an information gap. Misinformation has played a stronger role in this election than liberal/conservative miscommunication I think.

A related book is [Uninformed: Why People Seem to Know So Little about Politics and What We Can Do about It], by Arthur Lupia. The book discusses general challenges to educating the public about politics, but I feel the information generalizes to any topic that weighs in on peoples' values.

Subject Matter Competence has four components:
  • Value Diversity (which Haidt's work you introduce in this thread covers well)
  • Issue Complexity
  • Political Roles
  • Learning Costs

I think this seems to generalize enough to work for Skepticism's subjectmatter and not just apply to political education.

I feel Skepticism has ignored the actual fundamentals of learning, and merely resorted to repeating facts. It's not working, it's obviously not working, and I think my mission for the last half decade has been to develop a new sort of Skeptical Outreach manifesto based on objective evidence, and then, I guess, I'll try to pitch it.
 
I would say that Liberals in the USA have bent over backwards to try and 'understand' Conservatives to the point where they have all but ceased to exist. In a practically endless effort to bridge the gap they have allowed the 'centre' in US politics to be dragged so far to the right that the likes of Eisenhower and Nixon would be classed as 'liberals'.

The problem isn't a lack of understanding by Liberals, it's that they've given up trying to advance any alternative to the mean spirited and self-centred philosophy that's become the mainstream.
 
No, it's not.

No, because that's a false dichotomy, and a fairly ridiculous one at that. You were talking about healthcare. I am more than willing to be taxed more, and I believe everyone else should be as well, to have a healthcare system that provides for everyone. It's been proven it can work, and there are more than enough examples in the world to show that it's possible. Keep your random ass hyperbole to yourself. This isn't a "Either you give everything, or you're still the problem." Mind boggling

No, I'm not "equally guilty". I mean, to you I might be, but I try to look beyond fallacies. I give up plenty in order to help others, not that I have to rationalize anything to you, but again. Learn what a false dichotomy is and then come back. There is middle ground.

Yeah, I'm responding to what you wrote:
And we all know, even though we are a community here on Earth, we shouldn't act like it.

...

It's not that we, as a collective, should decide to disregard those who need help. It's just that, we don't really want to give up anything that we have or want to help them.
You've decided that you're willing to give up more... and you've decided that your decision is sufficient for everyone, and that everyone else should do what you want them to do. Despite the fact that you've made your decision in light of your own specific experience, you're unwilling to consider that your decision might affect other people in a different way. Instead, you resort to shaming and derision to try to coerce people in to feeling guilty that they may not be in the same financial situation as you. You hyperbolize and throw guilt around about the "community on earth" and you attempt to shame people for not being willing to "give up anything that we have or want to help them". But then you turn around and call it a false dichotomy when it's pointed out that you're not doing this yourself. You are putting your own petty selfish desires for comfort, convenience, and niceties above the well-being of your fellow man. You yourself make this decision every day.
 
Yeah, I'm responding to what you wrote:

You've decided that you're willing to give up more... and you've decided that your decision is sufficient for everyone, and that everyone else should do what you want them to do. Despite the fact that you've made your decision in light of your own specific experience, you're unwilling to consider that your decision might affect other people in a different way. Instead, you resort to shaming and derision to try to coerce people in to feeling guilty that they may not be in the same financial situation as you. You hyperbolize and throw guilt around about the "community on earth" and you attempt to shame people for not being willing to "give up anything that we have or want to help them". But then you turn around and call it a false dichotomy when it's pointed out that you're not doing this yourself. You are putting your own petty selfish desires for comfort, convenience, and niceties above the well-being of your fellow man. You yourself make this decision every day.

You asked me if I lived off of the bare essentials, it's right there in the post I quoted. I said that wasn't required because I am willing to pay MORE in taxes to help out the greater good. We're not that badly taxed here in the U.S., no matter what the whining masses may say. You gave me a false dichotomy, whether you believe you did or not. You implied that either I gave everything I could and had nothing for myself, or I was part of the problem. That's what you said, right? Don't answer, anyone can read it.

Which isn't at all what I said.

I'm not shaming anyone or anything. I'm saying it's my personal opinion that there is no reason why we wouldn't be willing to pay more to provide healthcare for everyone. Something that is absolutely an issue in this country. People shouldn't have to *********** fear bankruptcy on top of suffering through an illness. That is literally retarded. It is literally slowing down the progress of our country. If you find shame in that, then maybe you need to evaluate yourself. I don't know.

I go out of my way to help my fellow man, and your statement is still ********. You're still implying that because I have internet, or because I have TV or because I have my own stuff, that I couldn't care about anyone else. Talk about hyperbole, jesus christ. I am willing to give up some of my money, vis-a-via paying more in taxes, to help everyone in the U.S. get healthcare. The GOP is NOT willing to do that, and, in fact, their platform states as much. Good God.
 
I would say that Liberals in the USA have bent over backwards to try and 'understand' Conservatives to the point where they have all but ceased to exist. In a practically endless effort to bridge the gap they have allowed the 'centre' in US politics to be dragged so far to the right that the likes of Eisenhower and Nixon would be classed as 'liberals'.

The problem isn't a lack of understanding by Liberals, it's that they've given up trying to advance any alternative to the mean spirited and self-centred philosophy that's become the mainstream.

Depressingly true. I watched the war on Liberals and liberalism begin with Nixon's Southern Strategy to exploit backlash from the Civil Rights movement. I watched it go mainstream with Reagan's rhetorical assaults on liberalism to save the country from "welfare queens." I saw it develop into an actual industry with the rise of Limbaugh and his clones, cranking out increasingly mean-spirited anti-liberalism and Liberal character assassination. And then, we got Fair & Balanced Fox News to turn the war on liberalism into a fully polished, professional product. Today, from Fox News down to the sleaziest part of the internet, there are forces powerful enough to create full-blown alternate realities, and they got together and decided to elect Donald J. Trump.

Depressingly true.
 
You're still implying that because I have internet, or because I have TV or because I have my own stuff, that I couldn't care about anyone else.

And yet you have implied the exact same thing about other people - that if they aren't willing to give as much as you think they should have to give, they are selfish, greedy, and don't care about their fellow man.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom