Why is the Government Truth Movement© so angry, defensive, and abusive?

I don't debate the Truther position anymore then I would debate the position that said 2+2=5. There is a minimal level of intellectual honesty and foundation both sides must have in order to have a debate. The Truther position does not met those levels.

I don't think the Truther position should be debated. It should be marginalized, debunked, and opposed. There is a difference.

The key is to 'identify' which one has a 'truth' worth looking for. You chose the wrong one.

Theory vs Delutional Theory. There is a difference.
 
I see the Truthers are taking a page from the Fundies and when their sad attempt at making a logical argument out of a bunch of unsupported nonsense has been proven wrong from every possible angle 34,432 seperate times they fall back on the sad, sad, sad dodge of their opponents being "meanies."

On the contrary, you government truthers have proven nothing. Zip. Zilch.

But I guess it's good to always remind yourself that you have.
 
Nah, I pointed out a while ago the logical conclusion that it is China doing that, not AQ
Oh please. Everyone knows the logical conclusion is that the Jews are behind it.
tumblr_m10nnq2mJM1qe37bxo3_1280.png


What the heck is the Government Truth Movement? Is it an organization pressing for more openness in government? Is it to stop politicians from lying or not keeping their promises?
I went to debate the Truthers in Venice once and one of them asked me, "Why aren't you out here too with a sign that says 'the government's right'?" Maybe if I did do that (I won't ;)) I would be called a Government Truther?
 
So, you are jumping to conclusions about an entire group based on your personal interactions with them. I am also a "truther" and quite frankly, I've yet to have my conclusions undermined, either here or by P4T/CIT. What I've found is that some people are so biased and believe so strongly in their "intellectual" arguments that they fail to see the flaws in them. I suspect that is why both sides of the debate degrade into the "angry, defensive, and abusive" eventually.

Rational people can look at the same set of "facts" and yet reach different conclusions. When we become so biased towards our own conclusions that we present them as "facts" and the "only way to see it", then things get messy.

You, sir, are a voice of reason.
 
I don't think the Truther position should be debated. It should be marginalized, debunked, and opposed. There is a difference.
Well, okay, but the issue in this particular occasion is that BCR has done more to debunk the kind of nonsense you're talking about than most of the people here.
 
Well, okay, but the issue in this particular occasion is that BCR has done more to debunk the kind of nonsense you're talking about than most of the people here.

Perhaps I have drastically misunderstood something here, but BCR is an admitted Truther. I fail to see how that equates to "debunking the kind of nonsense I'm talking about." since the Truther position is the very kind of nonsense I'm talking about.
 
Well, okay, but the issue in this particular occasion is that BCR has done more to debunk the kind of nonsense you're talking about than most of the people here.

And I believe that he will undoutedly continue. Cheers John.
 
Okay then someone fill me in. (And that's dead serious no snark)
 
Last edited:
Perhaps I have drastically misunderstood something here, but BCR is an admitted Truther. I fail to see how that equates to "debunking the kind of nonsense I'm talking about." since the Truther position is the very kind of nonsense I'm talking about.
But the problem in that is you're assuming all truthers believe the same laundry list of garbage. I'm not blaming you for that - I often use the term as a shorthand in much the same way - but BCR is a very good example of someone who isn't like that in the slightest.

If you want to find out more, just search his posts. This one is a good summary.
 
If this is gonna turn into some sort of "Well they are good Truthers and bad Truthers" bit you can save it. That's like saying "Well of course I don't think we didn't land on the moon. What am I crazy? I'm just saying we never proved it's not made of green cheese."

Unless the term "Truther" is being used here to describe something in a way I have never heard it used before, I'm not buying.

From reading his posts I get the impression he's a "Let it happen" Truther vice a "Made it happen" Truther. That's not exactly a big upgrade in my book.
 
Last edited:
From what I have read of his posts, BCR doesn't believe in any of this 9/11 conspiracy crap. I don't know why he calls himself a truther; he must know the negative connotations it carriers.
 
Unless the term "Truther" is being used here to describe something in a way I have never heard it used before, I'm not buying.
BCR is using it in the way it should be used, about someone who wants to find the truth, as opposed to the more typical truther who just tries to find reasons to support what he wants to believe.

Which is why he's obtained a vast amount of material to help us better understand the events of the day - ATC and FAA recordings, videos, radar, documents, all kinds of things - and has done plenty to combat the likes of P4T and CIT.

Now I don't think wondering about some LIHOP-type possibilities takes away from all that. As I said, he's done more to help reveal the truth about 9/11 than just about anyone here. But I'm not going to go on about this: believe what you want.
 
Using such a loaded term seems rather intentionally confusing.
That's the point: the term "truther" doesn't mean the same thing to everyone. People are different. Beliefs vary. The issue really isn't that that is confusing - it's more that assuming they all think and act the same way is an oversimplification.

(And by the way, I'm not getting at you for thinking otherwise. Most of the time I'd agree with you. All I'm saying is that sometimes, just occasionally, you'll be way, way, way off.)
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom