Why is the Government Truth Movement© so angry, defensive, and abusive?

Government Truth Movement© Directives No. 1 through No. 5:

1. Evidence compiled by government sources is to be accepted as true at all times.

2. Pretend that there is no "official story" or prevailing narrative.

3. Denounce as a "troll" anyone who refuses to adhere to the events put forth in the "official story" while always insisting that there is no "official story".

4. The burden of proof only applies to those who refuse to accept the "official story", never on those who do.

5. See Directive No. 1.

and that's exactly what an Al Queda operative would suggest. Next.
 
Government Truth Movement© Directives No. 1 through No. 5:

1. Evidence compiled by government sources is to be accepted as true at all times.

2. Pretend that there is no "official story" or prevailing narrative.

3. Denounce as a "troll" anyone who refuses to adhere to the events put forth in the "official story" while always insisting that there is no "official story".

4. The burden of proof only applies to those who refuse to accept the "official story", never on those who do.

5. See Directive No. 1.

This is yet another clear example of how conspiracy sites tell these kids to think. This is a standard practice of most cults, tell the minions to label everyone outside of their cult as lost souls that are swayed by their imagined boogieman. Only by joining the cult can you be saved and on the side of good... One of the oldest cult tricks there is...
 
Last edited:
Why is the Government Truth Movement© so angry, defensive, and abusive?
Serious question. There seems to be an oversupply of piss and vinegar here. Why? Why not just chill out and discuss the 9/11 topic calmly and without so much emotion?

Discuss.


Projection and confirmation bias on your part.

"Abusive"? You mean like Truthers talking about which Debunkers will be the first against the wall when the revolution comes? I don't see Debunkers baying for the blood of Truthers on this site and when Debunkers here do cross the line into talk of violence they are rightfully censured. Debunkers here realize what you don't; namely that your average conspiracy theorist is almost to a man (and yes they are almost always for some reason male) an angry attention-starved teen and/or someone suffering from some form of mental illness and therefore deserve patience or pity, not scorn.

Having said that, you'll see some short tempers and snark from Debunkers who have been here for years because they've seen it all many many many times before. Some naive under-educated soul with authority issues will watch a random YouTube video and have some half-baked epiphany and then come here trying to lecture others here about his revelation when in fact he doesn't have the slightest idea what he's talking about. Debunkers here start to get perhaps a little jaded, like grade school teachers who have to teach the exact same subject every year to a different batch of students. There are at least two differences though:

1. The new students at JREF dribble in here every few weeks, not once a year, and never seem to be willing or able to check to see if their questions/concerns have been already thoroughly covered one or one hundred times before.

2. Even the most obstinately uneducable 1st graders generally don't tend to brand their teachers as "Government Shills" just because the teacher refuses to unconditionally accept the student's "commonsense theory" that 1 + 1 = 11. It's at that point where the teacher has every right to say to the student "prove to me that 1 + 1 = 11. If you can't, then break the habit of a lifetime by kindly shutting up for ten minutes, let the grownup talk and maybe you'll learn to your horror and bemusement that maybe, juuuuuust maybe, you are the one who's wrong".


Oh, FSM, save us from the cult of the amateur! It's a far more pernicious (not to mention real) threat to civilization than some supposed shadowy cabal of super-villains.
 
The government truth movement?

You make up your claims and say you don't need evidence.

What does Watergate have to do with 9/11?
... Operation Northwoods ...?
LOL, Glad you asked!

You say 911 is a Government conspiracy, you offer no evidence, you can't support your speculation. Watergate was a government conspiracy, cover-up and more, between very few people. Your claims of government involvement in 911 would require thousands of people. Watergate solved and earning a Pulitzer in less than 2 years; Nixon resigned. BIG EVENT~

You make claims, and after 10 years you can't be specific, you can't list evidence, and you can't make a point.

Watergate is an example, like Northwoods, of why the government does not do crazy plans, and gets caught when they do crazy plans. Debunks 911 truth.
You lied about Northwoods, saying it was to kill Americans.
No wonder there is no unity with 911 truth pushers of fantasy.

How are they even remotely comparable?
911 was not a government inside job or cover-up, Watergate was a cover-up and inside job. Watergate shows it is hard for the government to hide conspiracies. Means you have to be specific and prove your delusions on 911 with evidence, the stuff you don't have.

Did Watergate have the same national security and geopolitical implications as 9/11?
911 was murder. Not done by the government. 911 truth makes up lies about 911.
Watergate was a break-in. Done by the government. Pulitzer earned for exposing the story!
Two crimes. Both crimes have major security and geopolitical implications!

Watergate involves all the things you claim made it possible for the government to pull off 911. Watergate failed. Watergate was not about killing Americans. Your fantasy on 911, you claim the government conspired to kill Americans.


Is this really the crux of the government truther position? The Pulitzer? Ha, ha, ha...
Take any 911 truth claim, if 911 truth had evidence, there would be a Pulitzer! Simple stuff. But you are fooled, you think the government is all evil, and controlling, you can't get your Pulitzer. The evil government is keeping your evidence locked up, in Al Gore's lock-box, and will not let you contact MSM to earn that Pulitzer. You can't do anything, the government is keeping you down. Boo hoo, wait, there's no crying in baseball...

mean, evil government, keeping the truth ...

Mixing your anti-government with your empty claims on 911, is a big reason there will be no unity with those spreading false information for the fun of it, disrespecting those murdered.

No, the government doesn't have to open up the books.
Yes they do. And they did, where have you been? Bet you can't support your claim.

That's what you fail to understand.
That is because you don't do research, you make up ideas based on opinions, and post them, never supporting them with evidence. Be specific next time. You never have supplied evidence to support your nonsense, and fail to understand you make the claims, you must supply the evidence. Makes you not even, puts you behind, as in failed to make a point.
No evidence claims made by you are indicative of why there will be no unity with those who push failed fantasies.

The government can at any time invoke the state secrets privilege, no matter how guilty they are.
Like Nixon did. That worked well. Wait, Nixon resigned. oops

Due to lack of knowledge in 911 Truth, unity may not be an option. History might be on the list of subjects 911 truth prohibits.

Right, sure. I'm sure the government is just going to come out and admit they allowed the 9/11 attacks to occur so they could have an excuse to wage multiple decades of war and occupation throughout the Middle East.
You are confusing politics with 911 as an event. We did not have to go to war, and if you get everyone together, we can stop the funding, tomorrow. Vietnam, no funding, we had to come home. Do some research.

Lack of research, a reason for no unity with 911 truth; 911 truth skips research and logic, making conclusions up based on biases.


Of course the evidence is inconclusive, since it was primarily provided by the primary suspect in a criminal case.
Not according to big 911 truth nuts!
You need to get on the same page with the rest of 911 truth! Why are you changing the 911 truth platform? Is it a big tent, the tent of super-macro-flip-flop?
Of course the evidence is inconclusive, ...
Col. George Nelson disagrees, he says, "Irrefutable Proof of the 9/11 Conspiracy", he does so like you; without posting the evidence, but you say you don't have any? For you the evidence is inconclusive, but your fellow 911 truthers say the evidence, the stuff they don't have is conclusive, 911 was an inside job. Why the discrepancy, do you have the wrong 911 truth playbook?

Of course the evidence is inconclusive, ...
Yukihisa Fujita says otherwise – A patriot, lol from Japan, says - "David Ray Griffin has revealed dozens of omissions, distortions, and contradictions in the official story in a way that provides undeniable evidence of its falsity." Reality, DRG books have not earned a Pulitzer. DRG has no, evidence, like you.


I have evidence you said the government will not release. Are you spreading a lie, or what?
http://www.ntsb.gov/doclib/foia/9_11/Rec_Radar_Data_Study_all_aircraft.pdf
RADAR summaries, and people can find the raw RADAR data on line and plot their own paths. Because we are the government, the People are the government, we have procedures to get what we already own. You live in a fantasy world where you make up fantasy, and never prove anything. You lied about the government not releasing data; why?
This data matches the witnesses seeing the planes, and it matches video in NYC, and where all four planes crashed, and murdered the people you make fun of by making up fantasy.
http://www.ntsb.gov/doclib/foia/9_11/AAL77_fdr.pdf
Here is the FDR information from Flight 77. I got it from the government, because we own the government. You don't know your rights.
I have the RAW data, and 3 different independent Decode of the FDR. Why don't you? Because you don't care, you don't do research, you don't try, you like to spread your fantasy.

Why can't the be unity, because you don't come to class prepared, you are flunking out. You act like you lost your homework. Wait, you claim you did not do your homework, you made up your answers. Unity?

With this evidence we can analyze one of the dumbest groups on 911, pilots for truth delusional Balsamo claims.
Balsamo says... to sum up. Hani Hanjour, took a 757, with zero time in type, did the maneuver described, a 400 knot 330 degree sprialing dive at full power, with a very steady hand as to not overshoot or hit the lawn, inside ground effect, at 460 knots impact speed, but was refused to rent a 172 cause he couldnt land it at 65 knots? C'mon... sounds like a bad B movie...
Balsamo implies Hani can't fly a big jet because he only flew small planes, planes with props. It is easier to fly jets. I am an expert, I have thousands of hours in heavy Boeing Jets, and an ATP. Some pilots egos are too big to admit how easy it can be to fly.
Balsamo is wrong, the 400 knot 330 degree spiraling dive at full power; was a 300 knots knot less than standard rate turn to loose altitude because the terrorist pilot arrived too high to make a near normal decent, had to do do a big lazy turn with poor bank control. The full power is a lie, the "dive" was done at engine settings as low as 50 percent. Balsamo lied, he makes it up. At full power the plane could not come down, it is physics. Another unity issue.
The terrorist pilot did not have a steady hand, he was ham-fisted.


Balsamo made up the "very steady hand", like you make up your claims.
11BankAnglecompare.jpg

Airline pilot smooth, terrorist pilot not smooth.
11RADAR77.jpg

Here is the RADAR for 77, it matches the FDR information.
11RADARdata.jpg

RADAR for 77, and you said no government data was released. You are 10 years behind!


... , the government doesn't have to open up the books.
You made up a lie, the government gave me data, you can get it, but, you don't do research.
Crashing is the easiest thing to do in flying. Balsamo can't figure out 911 because he makes up his claims, like you do.

You have no way of knowing one way or another whether or not they provided you with 100% of the evidence, therefore the evidence is inconclusive.
I do, you don't. Means we are not even, you are behind, 100 percent behind.




Summary on why no unity with 911 truth, because they can't keep on topic and end up in other threads. Do you understand the irony of 911 truth calling what happen on 911 the Government Truth Movement? No.
Some 911 truthers, like some one we know, say there is no evidence to support anything, while the rest of 911 truth claims there is ample evidence to prove all 911 truth claims. 911 truth logic, why has if failed for 10 years? No evidence.

Try answering your questions!


This is a skeptics forum, 911 truth posts nonsense, and claims victory. You confirm the evidence free methods used by 911 truth, lead to failure. It is best to claim you are even, or winning, it matches your fantasies on 911.
 
Last edited:
What the heck is the Government Truth Movement? Is it an organization pressing for more openness in government? Is it to stop politicians from lying or not keeping their promises?
This isn't the forum dealing with Fantasy.
 
I see the Truthers are taking a page from the Fundies and when their sad attempt at making a logical argument out of a bunch of unsupported nonsense has been proven wrong from every possible angle 34,432 seperate times they fall back on the sad, sad, sad dodge of their opponents being "meanies."
 
I see the Truthers are taking a page from the Fundies and when their sad attempt at making a logical argument out of a bunch of unsupported nonsense has been proven wrong from every possible angle 34,432 seperate times they fall back on the sad, sad, sad dodge of their opponents being "meanies."

Why the attack on Fundies? I'm a "Fundie" and not sure I see your point except to make a broad general attack on an entire group based on some experience you have had with a few individuals.
 
Why the attack on Fundies?

Because they use the same tactics. Passive aggressive calls for "niceness" or jumping on the "Agree to disagree" everytime someone proves them wrong on an intellectual levels. I've never been able to discuss the intellectual faults with religious literalism with anyone without them resorting to some variation of this.
 
Because they use the same tactics. Passive aggressive calls for "niceness" or jumping on the "Agree to disagree" everytime someone proves them wrong on an intellectual levels. I've never been able to discuss the intellectual faults with religious literalism with anyone without them resorting to some variation of this.

So, you are jumping to conclusions about an entire group based on your personal interactions with them. I am also a "truther" and quite frankly, I've yet to have my conclusions undermined, either here or by P4T/CIT. What I've found is that some people are so biased and believe so strongly in their "intellectual" arguments that they fail to see the flaws in them. I suspect that is why both sides of the debate degrade into the "angry, defensive, and abusive" eventually.

Rational people can look at the same set of "facts" and yet reach different conclusions. When we become so biased towards our own conclusions that we present them as "facts" and the "only way to see it", then things get messy.
 
So, you are jumping to conclusions about an entire group based on your personal interactions with them.

I've had thousands of conversations with Fundies and hundreds with Truthers. I'm satisified with my sample size.

Rational people can look at the same set of "facts" and yet reach different conclusions.

Yes but when one side is looking at made up delusions and not facts, that changes the dynamic a bit.
 
The burden of proof only applies to those who refuse to accept the "official story", never on those who do.

Under US law, the burden of proof is on the prosecution. Zacharias Moussaoui was proven beyond reasonable doubt and convicted in federal court to have participated in the 9/11 attacks as a member of Al-Qeada.

Your claim is therefore invalid.
 
Anytime you refer to reality as the "official story" you lose the argument.
 
I've had thousands of conversations with Fundies and hundreds with Truthers. I'm satisified with my sample size.

OIC. None-the-less, you have your outlier (me) who you have painted with your broad brush. I don't appreciate it.
 
OIC. None-the-less, you have your outlier (me) who you have painted with your broad brush. I don't appreciate it.

*Shrugs* There's only so many brushes you can paint a Truther with. Your philosphy doesn't leave me many positive lights to put you in.
 
*Shrugs* There's only so many brushes you can paint a Truther with. Your philosphy doesn't leave me many positive lights to put you in.

Take a breather. I think you misunderstand this 'truther'. He doesn't quite fall in line with your interpretation of 'truther'.
 
*Shrugs* There's only so many brushes you can paint a Truther with. Your philosphy doesn't leave me many positive lights to put you in.

See Joe, that is why you are not someone I would ever take seriously or even attempt a "debate" with. You are exactly what the OP describes. Such individuals exist on both sides of the "debate" and are simply a waste of time even attempting a conversation with.
 
I don't debate the Truther position anymore then I would debate the position that said 2+2=5. There is a minimal level of intellectual honesty and foundation both sides must have in order to have a debate. The Truther position does not met those levels.

I don't think the Truther position should be debated. It should be marginalized, debunked, and opposed. There is a difference.
 
See Joe, that is why you are not someone I would ever take seriously or even attempt a "debate" with. You are exactly what the OP describes. Such individuals exist on both sides of the "debate" and are simply a waste of time even attempting a conversation with.

There can be only one...


Fake truthers have damaged the name.


People who spread false claims, Balsamo is like a big dam of BS with leaks, you plug the FDR leak, and the the ACARS leak starts. Balsamo's non-theory theories have nothing to do with what happened. The more technical and proprietary the systems the more BS Balsamo can spin, in an effort to fool people and sell DVDs filled with dumbed down speculation and nonsense. Then SHC comes with nothing. Balsamo tries to tie his nonsense with some evidence, SHC explains there is no evidence to support anything, and starts threads he thinks will insult posters, and he is a poster.
 
Last edited:
If only i had a dollar for everytime i saw some 911 cult kiddie online spout about how much he will laugh when those that didn't believe are executed.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom