Why I despise the Truthers

I don't appreciate being called an idiot.

Please see post 1353 for CptColumbo's reasons why the Nixon tapes were a different situation.

You kept asking over and over for "why wouldn't Bush and Cheney" testify under oath. I gave you a reason OTHER than 9-11 of why NO president wants to do this. This is an educational forum, and thought you might learn something.

Because of poor reading comprehension and a lack of WILLINGNESS to learn, I fear that for you education is out of the question.

And by the way - look at the thread title. It is not about a new investigation which you seem to be harping on.
I don't appreciate being accused of moving the goal posts. I'm responding here. As for the title of this thread I started out with that subject and was soon asked for an explanation of the NIST report. As if...

I'm not having a one sided conversation here. Go back and read. I'm sorry some of the old and tired tactics of official version believers don't work on me. Just go back and read Gravy and what happen when I wouldn't follow down the Gravy straw man highway. He put me on ignore.


Good.

Next.
 
I hope then that you don't expect us to fall for the old and tired tactics of conspiracy believers, mmmkay?
 
I wasn’t the one to bring up these asinine arguments. One idiot claims Dubya can't testify under oath because it would set a precedent and could be used politically to get the President to swear under oath on a whim. I said that's not true they would have to prove it has to have equal or more importance then 9-11.

Zen's knowledge of politics : 0

It’s all just avoidance.

Aw, does the fact that people disagree with you hurts ?
 
Cpt: I think he answered the "investigating committee" would decide, but I'm not sure - you know, they would have to show it was similar to 9-11, but to whom? The goalposts and arguments are swirling, and I'm getting dizzy. I don't think the Zen-man realizes the hole he is digging. Note: to Zen - first thing to do when you are digging yourself a hole is to put down the shovel.
I read it more as the procedures needed to get a sworn testimony, rather than the screening process.
 
Cpt: Possibly. I thought the comment was regarding whoever is investigating would have to show that the issue was "as important" as 9/11.

I think I'm giving up trying to educate or enlighten Zen.
 
It makes sense in the context of what you posted. Why would the insurance companies pay up? When I pointed out that they didn'tpay up right away and that they were being threatened with fines you then claimed they always fight paying it.

Makes no sense? Why don't you makeup your mind?


Once more, they paid up because their legal avenues for reducing and delaying the payment had run out.

One legal avenue that they did not pursue, for the five and a half years until they fully paid up, was making a case that the attacks were an inside job. If they could have done so, that would have reduced their liability far more than did the legal avenues that they did pursue, vigorously and at great expense.

I conclude from this that they could not make such a case, not even with hundreds of millions of dollars at their disposal, five and a half years to work on it, and billions at stake.

Just think of the size of the reward they could have offered to any credible witness who offered to come forward and say something like, "I was on the team that placed demolition charges in the towers," and back it up with evidence and information (dates, materials used, methods, command structure, etc.) that would lead insurance investigators to more evidence. A reasonable reward for information leading to the exposing of an insurance fraud is ten percent of the money the insurance companies would save having to pay out. In this case that's 468 million dollars for the WTC claims, probably double or triple that when other 9/11 related insurance payouts are considered.

Respectfully,
Myriad
 
I don't know whoever you're claiming would use it on a whim. I then show how Nixon was forced to comply with a subpoena.

Then one of the idiots or maybe a whole new idiot chimes in and claims that’s a precedent.
You should really look up the word "precedent" in the dictionary, because I don't think you understand the meaning.

So the precedent’s already been set? There you go. Who brought it up? Me?
No. You cited a previous precedent regarding the President using "executive privilege" to withhold physical evidence and being compelled to turn it over. If you have been paying attention to the recent events involving testimony from Presidential aides, you would see that there is no precedent regarding testimony from the executive branch. There are rules regarding what congress can do to force someone to testify, but it is a long process that would include needing congress to be in session, and it may take a decision by the Supreme Court to determine if the Executive Branch should be included.
 
I think one thing we've let happen here is allow this Truther to lead us down a rabbit hole. In typical Truther fashion, he has obsfucated and side-stepped the real issue. The question that began this whole discussion regarding Bush's refusal to testify under oath was this one:

Why would a man who supposedly orchestrated an insidious plot to murder 3,000 people suddenly get cold feet when it comes to perjury?

Now, here's the problem you're going to face with this question, ZEN. You won't be able to answer it by linking or pasting something you found on a conspiracy website. You'll actually have to apply something called critical thinking.

My expectation is that this question will continue to be ignored, or be given an insubstantial, dismissive response so that our Truther friend can then go back to niggling over insignificant details.
 
I think one thing we've let happen here is allow this Truther to lead us down a rabbit hole. In typical Truther fashion, he has obsfucated and side-stepped the real issue. The question that began this whole discussion regarding Bush's refusal to testify under oath was this one:

Why would a man who supposedly orchestrated an insidious plot to murder 3,000 people suddenly get cold feet when it comes to perjury?

Now, here's the problem you're going to face with this question, ZEN. You won't be able to answer it by linking or pasting something you found on a conspiracy website. You'll actually have to apply something called critical thinking.

My expectation is that this question will continue to be ignored, or be given an insubstantial, dismissive response so that our Truther friend can then go back to niggling over insignificant details.
No you asked me who would decide. I didn't claim it was the same exact thing. There are precedents regarding executive privilege. I pointed to a Supreme Court decision where Nixon was order to comply. This points out who decides. If there needs to be another ruling because withholding information under executive privilege or refusing to testify sighting executive privilege are two different things then the Supreme Court can decide on that also. No?
 
I think one thing we've let happen here is allow this Truther to lead us down a rabbit hole. In typical Truther fashion, he has obsfucated and side-stepped the real issue. The question that began this whole discussion regarding Bush's refusal to testify under oath was this one:

Why would a man who supposedly orchestrated an insidious plot to murder 3,000 people suddenly get cold feet when it comes to perjury? .

And I answered it. This will be about the third time without cutting or pasting anything. All convicted criminals were put under oath before they were convicted. The reason to put someone under oath even if they're a murderer with no conscience is because even if they perjure themselves that perjury has to match with others who have testified separately under oath on the same subject. And it wouldn't match. That's how they get caught. That's why Cheney and Bush would not testify separately or under oath. They specifically refused to do this. They’re hiding information period. It has nothing to do with anything other then covering their own chicken a**.
 
And I answered it. This will be about the third time without cutting or pasting anything. All convicted criminals were put under oath before they were convicted. The reason to put someone under oath even if they're a murderer with no conscience is because even if they perjure themselves that perjury has to match with others who have testified separately under oath on the same subject. And it wouldn't match. That's how they get caught. That's why Cheney and Bush would not testify separately or under oath. They specifically refused to do this. They’re hiding information period. It has nothing to do with anything other then covering their own chicken a**.

Most of us know why someone is put under oath in a criminal proceeding, but you seem to be a little foggy on the issue. You might want to tivo an episode of "Law and Order" to get yourself up to speed. Since someone accused of a crime can't be forced to testify under oath, they are usually convicted by the use of something called "evidence", not conflicting testimony.

So, it is your theory that George Bush and Dick Cheney, two key players in the most massive, audacious and complex conspiracy in the histroy of human events, which they managed to pull off almost flawlessly (if it wasn't for you meddling kids!), would have somehow failed to have gotten their stories straight in the last six years and that's why they are now "too afraid" to testify under oath?

Really?

Remember that thing I mentioned earlier called critical thinking? Are you familiar with how it works?
 
Ladies & Gentlemen,

I've got an up-date about Loose Change creator, Dylan Avery:

On MySpace Dylan Avery has refused to answer our questions we posed to him about the money issue. Instead he has sent one of his friends to respond for him. In the letter it states that "Dylan told me he just gave up on replying to you", also another letter said: "9/11/06 cost them $30,000 and they didn't ask for a DIME.". As for whom they gave the $30,000 to is unclear. They refuse to give details about the money.

Also: "They give away everything. 10,000 DVD's, 600 shirts. All free. When's the last time you did that?"

Hmm..if everything is free...why does the DVD cost $17.95 at the Loose Change Store?

Avery says that over 50,000 copies have been sold. SOURCE

I still want to know what Dylan's current job is.
 
Most of us know why someone is put under oath in a criminal proceeding, but you seem to be a little foggy on the issue. You might want to tivo an episode of "Law and Order" to get yourself up to speed. Since someone accused of a crime can't be forced to testify under oath, they are usually convicted by the use of something called "evidence", not conflicting testimony.

So, it is your theory that George Bush and Dick Cheney, two key players in the most massive, audacious and complex conspiracy in the histroy of human events, which they managed to pull off almost flawlessly (if it wasn't for you meddling kids!), would have somehow failed to have gotten their stories straight in the last six years and that's why they are now "too afraid" to testify under oath?

Really?

Remember that thing I mentioned earlier called critical thinking? Are you familiar with how it works?
Theory? They would have failed miserably and they know it. That's why they refused to even try. Like I said... chicken.

Cheney's accounts of that morning already don't even match with his previous accounts. First he claimed he got to the bunker after the plane had already hit the Pentagon then that was later revised to just after the plane hit the pentagon. Neither of these accounts match Mineta’s version of events. Not even close. The problem is Mineta testiomony is the only one under oath. Now this is where it would have been useful to get the Presidents version of events separately under oath.

Here’s a couple of other interesting fact about your official version of the truth that might be better well done in a future investigation.

NORAD ' S testimony was deemed to be "so far from the truth" according to Kean himself after the release of the report. ""It was just so far from the truth. . . . It's one of those loose ends that never got tied."


“Leaders of a federal commission investigating the Sept. 11 attacks complained Tuesday that the Bush administration has been too slow to provide access to key documents and is intimidating witnesses by insisting that CIA and FBI "minders" attend sensitive interviews. “- LA Times.com
July 9, 2003.
 
Zen, did you even read Johnny Karate's comment?

Sometimes I think talking to you twoofers is just a waste of time and energy. At least I hope some fence-sitters read Johnny's post and understood its cleverness.
 
Out of context ?

Tell me, Zen. What "context" could possibly change the meaning of those sentences ?

Please, I need a good laugh.
You're taking replies of mine where I state the question originally asked to me and cutting it out like I was the one who originally asked it. Go back and read.

For instance

"Why would the insurance companies pay up?"

That was asked of me and what you cut out was the beginning of my answer. I replied it took them 5 years to pay out and they were threatened by a politician with fines.

Do you just cut things out of context or do you also read out of context?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom