Why I despise the Truthers

From that article.
That’s why you get them all under oath on the record claiming they all don't recall. How many questions could they possibly answer like that and keep up a front of competence? Someone would have to answer something.
 
That’s why you get them all under oath on the record claiming they all don't recall. How many questions could they possibly answer like that and keep up a front of competence? Someone would have to answer something.

Why? Because you want them to? The vast majority of people already have their view of the Admin's competence and Their saying that they can't divulge the information because it would harm national security isn't going to change that. At worst it'll make sure that Bush is reelected for a third term... Oh wait...
 
Why? Because you want them to? The vast majority of people already have their view of the Admin's competence and Their saying that they can't divulge the information because it would harm national security isn't going to change that. At worst it'll make sure that Bush is reelected for a third term... Oh wait...
If it was as simple as just answering "I don't recall" or" It's a matter of National Security" then why the refusal to testify separately under oath? Even without being sworn under oath why did Bush and Cheney demand that they only be questioned together?

How did Libby do in the Plame affair? Was he able to answer "I don't recall" to everything or "it's a matter of National Security"? Or did he slip up?

I would bet that a bunch of Chicken Hawk cowards would also slip up and they knew it. That’s why they chickened out when asked to testify under oath.
 
I would bet that a bunch of Chicken Hawk cowards would also slip up and they knew it. That’s why they chickened out when asked to testify under oath.

How could they possibly slip up when it was their own people asking the questions? The whole commission was a whitewash anyway, right?
 
How could they possibly slip up when it was their own people asking the questions? The whole commission was a whitewash anyway, right?
Then why didn't they take the oath? And yes it was a whitewash but not because the commission controlled it.
 
What's the big deal about being under oath? I assume it's possible for people who don't care that they murdered 3000 innocent people to lie under oath. It's not like 'oath' is some kind of magic truth spell or anything.
 
Then why didn't they take the oath? And yes it was a whitewash but not because the commission controlled it.

I don't understand the "they didn't take an oath" argument. As if anyone that could plan to kill 3000 citizens would have a problem lying under oath.

There actually seems to be a pretty consistent reason presidents have taken the stance to not testify under oath about their administration. If they testify under oath, it sets a precedent that the executive branch can be summoned and have to testify to the legislative, or any other, branch of government at the whim of that branch. All presidents have exercised this claim of "executive privilege", right or wrong.

This doesn't get them out of testifying in a LEGAL proceeding (see Libby), but it certainly appears to be the modus operandi of any sitting president to not let a non-criminal proceeding put them under oath.
 
What's the big deal about being under oath? I assume it's possible for people who don't care that they murdered 3000 innocent people to lie under oath. It's not like 'oath' is some kind of magic truth spell or anything.
I don't know. Why didn't they just do it? If it's not a big deal.
 
I don't know. Why didn't they just do it? If it's not a big deal.

I don't understand the "they didn't take an oath" argument. As if anyone that could plan to kill 3000 citizens would have a problem lying under oath.

There actually seems to be a pretty consistent reason presidents have taken the stance to not testify under oath about their administration. If they testify under oath, it sets a precedent that the executive branch can be summoned and have to testify to the legislative, or any other, branch of government at the whim of that branch. All presidents have exercised this claim of "executive privilege", right or wrong.

This doesn't get them out of testifying in a LEGAL proceeding (see Libby), but it certainly appears to be the modus operandi of any sitting president to not let a non-criminal proceeding put them under oath.
It is also not the image that the White House likes to have seen on the television. How many times have you seen the footage of Oliver North and tobacco executives being sworn in. Whether a person is guilty or not, it is not the piece of video you want looped endlessly on the news.
 
I don't understand the "they didn't take an oath" argument. As if anyone that could plan to kill 3000 citizens would have a problem lying under oath.

There actually seems to be a pretty consistent reason presidents have taken the stance to not testify under oath about their administration. If they testify under oath, it sets a precedent that the executive branch can be summoned and have to testify to the legislative, or any other, branch of government at the whim of that branch. All presidents have exercised this claim of "executive privilege", right or wrong.

This doesn't get them out of testifying in a LEGAL proceeding (see Libby), but it certainly appears to be the modus operandi of any sitting president to not let a non-criminal proceeding put them under oath.
It would set no such precedent for them or any future Ppresident to have to swear under oath on a whim. They would have to draw a legitmate comparison to the weight and importence of 9-11 to get the same request.
 
You may not see it, but a lot of other people WOULD see it as I described.

In your scenario, a president will pick and choose when to testify under oath? Or is it the investigating committee that decides? The "they" in your statement is not clear. You are back to the same problem.
 
It is also not the image that the White House likes to have seen on the television. How many times have you seen the footage of Oliver North and tobacco executives being sworn in. Whether a person is guilty or not, it is not the piece of video you want looped endlessly on the news.
Boy we are just full of excuses. There comes a time when some things are more important then how it might look unfavorable.
 
You may not see it, but a lot of other people WOULD see it as I described.

In your scenario, a president will pick and choose when to testify under oath? Or is it the investigating committee that decides? The "they" in your statement is not clear. You are back to the same problem.
I would believe it's you that claimed "any branch" could try to get the Pres to testify under oath on whim. That's the they.
 
What do you consider media? Do only corporate spoke models reading off of teleprompters apply?
Two reporters for the Washington Post newspaper doggedly pursued the Watergate story and broke it open with solid investigating. Why isn't that happening in regards to 9/11, particularly with newspaper in other major cities in the world? And if there is so much supposedly compelling evidence available? What, no one at the Toronto Star or The Mirror or The Times of India wants to break the biggest story since Watergate? Heck, why not reporters at The Wall Street Journal or The New York Times or the Chicago Tribune, none of them want to be the most famous print journalists since Woodward & Bernstein?
 
Just another reason not to fight like you claim they would have if they suspected foul play.


Sorry, that makes no sense.

First, they'd had five years before that letter was sent to act upon any suspicions of foul play. And if they'd uncovered any reasonable grounds for such suspicion during that time, they could have brought it to court to gain more time for further investigation.

Second, the letter was from a representative to a New York State official, urging certain actions. It had no legal force to demand anything from the insurance companies. It wasn't even addressed to them.

Third, the insurance companies didn't respond to the letter. The wheels continued grinding and the money was eventually paid almost a year later, after all other legal recourse for the insurance companies had run out.

Do you think these corporations, the same corporations that spent tens if not hundreds of millions of dollars on legal actions to minimize and delay their payment as much as possible, will part with billions of dollars that they supposedly have reason to believe is being exacted from them under false pretenses, because a U.S. Representative sends a letter to a State Insurance Commissioner? A letter that obliquely threatens the seizure of interest profits that amount to a small fraction of those huge, supposedly fraudulent, claims that they wouldn't have to pay at all if they could make a case that the attacks were an inside job?

"Cut off your own leg and hand it to me, or else I'll step on your big toe" is not a very effective threat. Do you see why?

Respectfully,
Myriad
 
If it was as simple as just answering "I don't recall" or" It's a matter of National Security" then why the refusal to testify separately under oath?

Why not?


Even without being sworn under oath why did Bush and Cheney demand that they only be questioned together?

Why not?


How did Libby do in the Plame affair? Was he able to answer "I don't recall" to everything or "it's a matter of National Security"? Or did he slip up?

Apples and oranges.

I would bet that a bunch of Chicken Hawk cowards would also slip up and they knew it. That’s why they chickened out when asked to testify under oath.

I would bet you could care less about getting the truth and just want to "get Bush" like the Reps "got Clinton".
 
Boy we are just full of excuses. There comes a time when some things are more important then how it might look unfavorable.
Tell that to Michael Dukakis after his tank ride. It's naive and foolhardy to think that image is not important to a politician. Image is what sways many undecided voters in politics, and influences people in other areas (entertainment, retail industry).
It would set no such precedent for them or any future Ppresident to have to swear under oath on a whim. They would have to draw a legitmate comparison to the weight and importence of 9-11 to get the same request.
And who would be the judge of "the weight import[a]nce" of an event? Would the litigation over "the weight and import[a]nce" of a given event be over before a [P]resident left office?
 
Last edited:
Two reporters for the Washington Post newspaper doggedly pursued the Watergate story and broke it open with solid investigating. Why isn't that happening in regards to 9/11, particularly with newspaper in other major cities in the world? And if there is so much supposedly compelling evidence available? What, no one at the Toronto Star or The Mirror or The Times of India wants to break the biggest story since Watergate? Heck, why not reporters at The Wall Street Journal or The New York Times or the Chicago Tribune, none of them want to be the most famous print journalists since Woodward & Bernstein?
Woodward & Bernstein aren't even Woodward & Bernstein any longer.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom