Just another reason not to fight like you claim they would have if they suspected foul play.
Sorry, that makes no sense.
First, they'd had five years before that letter was sent to act upon any suspicions of foul play. And if they'd uncovered any reasonable grounds for such suspicion during that time, they could have brought it to court to gain more time for further investigation.
Second, the letter was from a representative to a New York State official, urging certain actions. It had no legal force to demand anything from the insurance companies. It wasn't even addressed to them.
Third, the insurance companies didn't respond to the letter. The wheels continued grinding and the money was eventually paid almost a year later, after all other legal recourse for the insurance companies had run out.
Do you think these corporations, the same corporations that spent tens if not hundreds of millions of dollars on legal actions to minimize and delay their payment as much as possible, will part with billions of dollars that they supposedly have reason to believe is being exacted from them under false pretenses, because a U.S. Representative sends a letter to a State Insurance Commissioner? A letter that obliquely threatens the seizure of interest profits that amount to a small fraction of those huge, supposedly fraudulent, claims that they wouldn't have to pay at all if they could make a case that the attacks were an inside job?
"Cut off your own leg and hand it to me, or else I'll step on your big toe" is not a very effective threat. Do you see why?
Respectfully,
Myriad