Why I despise the Truthers

Not acceptable.

in fact they relayed a message that it was going to be brought down intentionally?



TAM:)

They would be likely to be considered 'accessory after the fact'
if they were later deemed to have understood that the forewarning was evidence of a criminal act, and didn't later report it.

N.B. This is all hypothetical :)
 
We are not talking WTC1/2, we are talking WTC7. So are you admitting that if she was handed down a message that ended up conveying to her that the FDNY were going to have to bring down WTC7, then those who relayed the message were complicit, and part of the cover up, since the official story is that it came down from damage and fire?

See, like I said, it comes down to whether you believe what she said literally, you believe her specifics, or you do not, and realize it was more likely something along the lines of,

"With the way that building is looking, we might have to bring it down, before it comes down on its own."

TAM:)
 
...if she was handed down a message that ended up conveying to her that the FDNY were going to have to bring down WTC7, then those who relayed the message were complicit, and part of the cover up, since the official story is that it came down from damage and fire?
<snip>

"With the way that building is looking, we might have to bring it down, before it comes down on its own."

TAM:)

None of these would make sense because:
1) It's very, very questionable they could bring it down i.e. insufficient time to 'rig' it...?
2) Absolutely no reason to try and cover it up afterwards
 
If what you say here applies, i.e. Fire Chief X says to Fire Captain Y "We are going to have to bring WTC7 down", then of course that would implicate those people. But that scenario is not necessary for the CD to be a reality.
Then please describe a scenario in which CD is possible without the knowledge or involvement of the NYPD, FDNY, and the PAPD.

You have to think 'pre-positioned incendiaries/explosives' a la WTC1 & 2 Therefor, no complicity of the FDNY etc.
And yet none of these explosives, or the necessary equipment that would accompany them, was noticed by anyone in the above mentioned agencies, which means either A) There were in fact no explosives, B) the members of those agencies did witness evidence for a CD, but have chosen not to disclose this fact (thus making them complicit after the fact), or C) some implausible scenario that no one in the CT movement can seem to articulate. Which do you suppose it is?

In other word, I said "if it happened , then it happened, period." Some are saying 'it can't have happened because you don't know how it would be done'.
I am not making any claims about the veracity of the CD Theory based on your and every other CTers complete and total inability to explain how it was done. I am simply looking for one of you to either explain how it was done without the knowledge or involvement of the NYPD, FDNY and PAPD or at least have the courage of your convictions to admit you are implying their guilt with your theories.
 
I am not making any claims about the veracity of the CD Theory based on your and every other CTers complete and total inability to explain how it was done. I am simply looking for one of you to either explain how it was done without the knowledge or involvement of the NYPD, FDNY and PAPD or at least have the courage of your convictions to admit you are implying their guilt with your theories.

First, let me make it clear: I am not what you guys call a 'truther', rather more of a 'skeptic'.
I don't have any stubborn, boneheaded, fixed beliefs one way or any other way. Any 'theories' I talk about are exactly that - theories, and hypothetical.

With regard to WTC7, the only CD theory that would seem to make any sense, would be pre-placed incendiary/explosive charges -- with previously set timers -- as part of the plan to totally destroy the WTC complex.

One theory would be: 4 hi-jacked planes by AK operatives, one plane for each building WTC1, WTC2. WTC7, plus one for Pentagon.
Pre-placed charges with timers in buildings #1, #2 and #7. [ pretext: various maintainence etc. work? ]
The goal would be to get maximum effect and insure that the entire WTC was completely flattened.
The planes would be absolutely necessary, to put an unambiguous 'terrorist' stamp on the operation, explosives were also necessary to ensure total collapse of the towers...
The plane for building WTC7 didn't come. [ flight#93? ]

The FFNY would have known nothing about anything, until someone told them "it might be a good idea to get everybody away from #7"

Again this is just hypothesis.
 
None of these would make sense because:
1) It's very, very questionable they could bring it down i.e. insufficient time to 'rig' it...?
2) Absolutely no reason to try and cover it up afterwards

well if that is your view of it, than her testimony is essentially useless with regards to a viable suggestion of CD and the appropirate perps...

I agree, with the first part...that her testimony is useless.

TAM:)
 
well if that is your view of it, than her testimony is essentially useless with regards to a viable suggestion of CD and the appropirate perps...

I agree, with the first part...that her testimony is useless.

TAM:)
Well, if there was a CD, her 'testimony' might indicate a tipoff of some sort
 
The Truth Movement is not the enemy of 9/11 Heroes. In fact, it seems to be only the Truth Movement that cares about 9/11 Heroes

Sorry but you're wrong. My brother-in-law is a 20 year FDNY vet who was there on 9/11 (thank God unhurt) and worked the pile for the next six months. He and his brother firefighters hate the "truth" movement. Don't believe me? Come to any FDNY firehouse in the five boros and ask the men there what they think about 9/11 "truth".
 
As for my writing skills I'm not really concerned what anybody, especially on this forum, thinks. My profs loved me enough too [sic] where I never got anything accept [sic] an A on every paper and ever [sic] written test I took in College [sic]. As I only write part time because writing doesn't pay the bills, I'll remember too return and gloat once I'm officially published.
More than half the governments [sic] original suspects who were supposedly on the plain [sic] and thought too [sic] be dead have been found alive and well. There was another man who had his passport stolen. There [sic] entire investigation into the day of 911 [sic] was a joke. I'm not doubting if somebody was brought into a court of law and tried for 911 [sic] he'd be found guilty especially if he was from the middle east [sic]. Provide a perfect constitutional court setting and allow Assama [sic] too [sic] buy them a top notch lawyer, Isn't [sic] anyway [sic] there could be a conviction.
Phantom [sic] i'm [sic] going too [sic] take your word for it. Considering the information I'd Ple [sic] [sic] Bargin [sic] [sic].
Once again I could [sic] care less of [sic] your opinion. It matters much more what my Profs [sic] thought as they are professionals in there [sic] fields. The audience I'm writing for isn't exactly a close [sic] minded [sic] group. You'd be surprised [sic] the majority [sic] meaning the average American [sic] is going too love my stuff. Knowing what too [sic] write too [sic] attract the majority of readers is the key too [sic] success when writing.
Just a sampling.

OldSchool, you claiming to be a writer is like those who say they're "truth" seekers in regard to 9/11. The evidence at hand puts the lie to the claim.
 
This thread has grown mightily in my absence, so please forgive me for picking this quote from some pages back for comment, I simply had to reply to it...

It's our job as Americans to demand the truth not the half truth or excuses to pacify us.
Would you mind telling me why the media and governments of other nations seem to be so silent on this issue of a conspiracy surrounding 9/11? Citizens of a number of other countries were killed on 9/11 (24 from my country, Canada, to cite one example).

If the evidence is as compelling of U.S. government complicity in 9/11 as some CTers claim, then why are those other nations' media and government not performing their own investigations and registering official governmental protests? Why do they remain quiet? What possible motive could they have for not pursuing the matter?
 
With regard to WTC7, the only CD theory that would seem to make any sense, would be pre-placed incendiary/explosive charges -- with previously set timers -- as part of the plan to totally destroy the WTC complex.

One theory would be: 4 hi-jacked planes by AK operatives, one plane for each building WTC1, WTC2. WTC7, plus one for Pentagon.
Pre-placed charges with timers in buildings #1, #2 and #7. [ pretext: various maintainence etc. work? ]
The goal would be to get maximum effect and insure that the entire WTC was completely flattened.
The planes would be absolutely necessary, to put an unambiguous 'terrorist' stamp on the operation, explosives were also necessary to ensure total collapse of the towers...
The plane for building WTC7 didn't come. [ flight#93? ]

The FFNY would have known nothing about anything, until someone told them "it might be a good idea to get everybody away from #7"

Again this is just hypothesis.
The problem with your hypothessis is it fails to meet the criteria of my request. No where in it to you explain how this all happened right under the noses of the NYPD, FDNY, and PAPD without anyone in those agencies noticing anything suspicious, either before or after the fact. Since common sense dictates that this is highly unlikely, your hypothesis implicates members of these agencies at the very least in being complicit by concealing evidence.
 
This thread has grown mightily in my absence, so please forgive me for picking this quote from some pages back for comment, I simply had to reply to it...

Would you mind telling me why the media and governments of other nations seem to be so silent on this issue of a conspiracy surrounding 9/11? Citizens of a number of other countries were killed on 9/11 (24 from my country, Canada, to cite one example).

If the evidence is as compelling of U.S. government complicity in 9/11 as some CTers claim, then why are those other nations' media and government not performing their own investigations and registering official governmental protests? Why do they remain quiet? What possible motive could they have for not pursuing the matter?
I feel because of a lack of a real investigation that uncovers real implications and evidence the media hasn't had much to report. I wouldn't say that it's been totally ignored though. When the 9-11 truth movement had their symposium in LA it was covered by CSPAN and received some of the highest ratings they've ever had.

Fox News is always looking to get someone from the truth movement on and make them look like they’re crazy or a traitor. Why do they bother?

Also if you look at the present administration 9-11 isn't the only they've been able to avoid as far as public scrutiny and any real accountability. They played hardball with the press from the get go with the leaking false stories and refusing press passes for the white house press conferences and even posing someone as a reporter to ask prepared questions that the president would give a prepared answer to. They’re all about secrecy.

Even so there must be something to this movement or so many wouldn't be trying to discredit it with things like the "counter misinformation team" and articles in magazines that can be linked right back to the current administration. If it's all just nonsense why does anyone care if someone believes it? Would they get that mad at someone who believes in Big Foot or the loch ness monster? If I believe 9-11 was a conspiracy and you know for a fact its nonsense then what’s it matter what I believe? Why do you care?
 
I feel because of a lack of a real investigation that uncovers real implications and evidence the media hasn't had much to report. I wouldn't say that it's been totally ignored though. When the 9-11 truth movement had their symposium in LA it was covered by CSPAN and received some of the highest ratings they've ever had.
None of which addresses my question about the media and governments of other nations. Again, why do they acquiesce?

Also if you look at the present administration 9-11 isn't the only they've been able to avoid as far as public scrutiny and any real accountability. They played hardball with the press from the get go with the leaking false stories and refusing press passes for the white house press conferences and even posing someone as a reporter to ask prepared questions that the president would give a prepared answer to. They’re all about secrecy.
See above.

Even so there must be something to this movement or so many wouldn't be trying to discredit it with things like the "counter misinformation team" and articles in magazines that can be linked right back to the current administration.
See above.

If I believe 9-11 was a conspiracy and you know for a fact its nonsense then what’s it matter what I believe? Why do you care?
Because it's a shame to see someone believing in foolishness. It's like that old slogan from years ago - "A mind is a terrible thing to waste." Perhaps by engaging that mind it may be possible for it to be led away from wasting its efforts on foolishness, especially foolishness that involves serious matters.
 
You were 16 on 9/11.

You've really offered up no evidence that you are an EMT but since you're not claiming to have been at GZ on 9/11 I'll give you the benefit of the doubt. I apologize for saying you are a 'fake' EMT.

And I will give no quarter to anyone who would make such an insulting, condescending remark to someone who is obviously better-schooled in fire science and emergency services than any of the ranting twoofers who plague the web.

You insult all of the fire fighters who post to this site. (That includes me.)

I would highly recommend instead of wasting your time on Alex Jones and the Watson brothers that you google "FDNY Oral Histories" and read through them all. Especially if you really want to be FDNY someday.

Anyone who thinks that A. Jones will even direct you to a useful comment supportive of his position is lacking in reasoning capacity.

Indira Singh may have been told that "they are about to blow WTC 7," but that may also have just been her interpretation of what they told her. Or the person who told her that may have been told at third or fouth hand that the collapse was immenent. It is not all that likely, given the worthless junk that Rudy gave them for radios, that not everyone in the department was aware how badly the building was damaged.

Have you ever played Silent Post? One person tells another a simple fact, and the message is passed down in secret through as many people as are available. You send in a lion and an aardvark comes out of the last person's mouth. That is what happened to communications about what was going to happen to WTC 7.

As for the accounts of some of the fire fighters and EMTs. not all of them are properly quoted by twoofers. Some of them clearly did not see all of what happened. The Naudet Brothers film shows us why. The brother inside the tower was not aware that the other tower had collapsed until he was outside, eating the dust of the tower he had just left.

If you want to see a good example of how worthless eyewitness testimony relative to a catastrophicevent can be, there is one account that a lot of twoofers like to dredge up taken from an interview with an EMT named Ondrovic. She is clearly suffering from PTSD, and is, at the same time, the strongest corroboration of CT, if she is to be believed.

Sorry, but her mental state makes her testimony worthless, for most purposes. She broke down and ran. She deserves disability benefits, for sure, but I do not want her on another disaster site.

We were the ones who sided with the FDNY when they were told they weren't allowed to carry on the rescue efforts and had to leave the fallen in that pile so the evidence could be shipped off and destroyed quickly.

Shipped off immediately? No way. There was quite an extensive examination of most of it before it was released, looking for both evidence and body parts, at Fresh Kills on Staten Island.

You're still young dude. You gotta a lot of learning to do. Hear me now and believe me later. I hope it works out for you.

Twoofers need to grow up. I know 10-year-olds more mature than the kids on most twoofer sites.
 

Attachments

  • 5474.jpg
    5474.jpg
    26.4 KB · Views: 2
  • 4276.jpg
    4276.jpg
    33.9 KB · Views: 1
  • 5464.jpg
    5464.jpg
    23.2 KB · Views: 2
Even so there must be something to this movement or so many wouldn't be trying to discredit it with things like the "counter misinformation team" and articles in magazines that can be linked right back to the current administration. If it's all just nonsense why does anyone care if someone believes it? Would they get that mad at someone who believes in Big Foot or the loch ness monster? If I believe 9-11 was a conspiracy and you know for a fact its nonsense then what’s it matter what I believe? Why do you care?

You're kidding, right?

The shiny happy faces of the "Truth Movement" have slandered and harassed hundreds of people, and dishonored the living and the dead. Just a few examples:

  • Jason Bermas accused the FDNY of being "in on it," then modified his statement to say that he thinks they were "threatened" to keep their mouths shut
  • Hundreds of black-clad miscreants paraded outside Larry Silverstein's office, haranguing him with bullhorns and accusations of complicity
  • Jim Fetzer has repeatedly stated that "there is a special place in hell" for all engineers and architects who defend the "official conspiracy theory"
  • Kevin Barrett recently issued thinly veiled threats to the media for not reporting "the Truth"
  • Val McClatchey and Lloyde England are two individuals harassed online and in print as being "part of the coverup." Their crimes were, respectively, taking a photograph and being hit by a light pole.
  • Just today I was accused of being a "Nationalist" and a "Nazi" for pointing out to a Truther that the FDR evidence of UA93 proves it wasn't hit by an air-to-air missile

Get the picture? We oppose your Movement because your Movement is nothing but vindictive rabble. Our existence has nothing to do with "cointelpro" and it for damn sure doesn't mean that you guys are right. What you are witnessing is nothing more than an expression of human decency. If you have trouble recognizing that, then you have serious problems.

Besides, people here do oppose Bigfooters and Loch Ness fantasists. Ignorance is appalling in all of its forms. Morons are holding back the human race. Don't be one of them.
 
Let's say an executive in some corporation or other is running a 'scam', ripping off clients or whatever.
All the various paperwork, correspondance etc. goes through the office and is printed/proccessed/handled/shipped or whatever, by many people in the office.
You say that by claiming a 'scam' [crime] has been commited, this mean all those people are implicated?

What if the scam is suspected but covered up and all of the people in that office who now know about the suspicions about the scam don't come forward with the evidence they have? Then they're implicated after the fact, yes?

'Truthers' need to drop this tortured attempt to view the events of 911 in complete isolation, as if time stopped on that day and that each and every person who might have unknowingly been part of the 'conspiracy' has completely forgotten about what happened before and during the attacks.

Even if they are unaware at the time (let's say a maintenance crew is told to lay some damaged lightpoles near the road outside of the pentagon on the night of 9/10) after the events of the day, aren't they going to make some connections between what they were asked/ordered to do/supply and the actual attacks which took place? Don't the maintenance crew scratch their chins and say "Hmmmm funny, we put those broken poles there, but now people are saying they were knocked over by a plane."?

Where are all these people who prepped the 'false flag' attack in complete innocence but who now should be talking to the 'truther' amateur investigators, the world's media, the law enforcement agencies, amnesty international etc etc about the orders/instructions they received which now appear strange in the light of the attacks?

The conspiracy is impossibly vast and those that took part must either be ideologically committed to it or too stupid to see their own part in it. Or cowards, which of course is the 'truthers' last line of defence when called out on this. 'Truthers' aren't cowards though (well, they start out a bit nervy when they realise they are going to have to identify themselves if they're going to have any .... acclaim for their work, but that soon goes away when they discover no one is actually out to get them), they would definately come forward if they discovered they had been involved..... wouldn't they?
 
I admittedly don't know much about physics, but it seems to me that in order to protect the explosives enough from being flat-out destroyed by the plane you'd have to completely encapsulate them in the hardest, strongest material on earth (anyone know the name of a good jeweler?)

Of course, you know that diamonds, if that's what you're thinking about, isn't the strongest material on earth. It's hard, but weak as hell.
 
Reality can't be defined.

Of course it can. Reality is consistent across the world, across the universe and from one person to the next. Once we discovered how to test various claims and hypotheses, everything suddenly became consistent.

If reality couldn't be defined, the same things wouldn't hold true for different people, but they do.

Although the human mind is similar there are slight variations for each individual.

In belief, yes.

Albert Einstein would be the perfect example. Although he was very strange by standards of every day life, his genius hasn't been matched even too present day.

How can you say that ? By what standards do you determine one's genius ?

"All matter is merely energy condensed to a slow vibration. We are all one consciousness experiencing itself subjectively. There is no such thing as death, life is only a dream and we are the imagination of ourselves. This is a war on personal Freedom, Okay? Keep that in mind at all times."

That's his opinion, but as usual, reality is immune to opinion.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom