Why I despise the Truthers

Originally Posted by TerryUK
"If what you are saying were true, many crimes could ever be investigated, without 'indicting by implication' the various people involved.. "
This doesn't make any sense.

Let's say an executive in some corporation or other is running a 'scam', ripping off clients or whatever.
All the various paperwork, correspondance etc. goes through the office and is printed/proccessed/handled/shipped or whatever, by many people in the office.
You say that by claiming a 'scam' [crime] has been commited, this mean all those people are implicated?

No, I'm raising a very important question: If you believe in the CD Theory, can you explain how it was done without the knowledge or involvement of the NYPD, FDNY, and PAPD?

How could I be expected to know that?

If something happened, it happened - I saw a guy once who produced numerous feathered birds apparenly from thin air -- I didn't say to myself "that didn't happen" :)
 
Let's say an executive in some corporation or other is running a 'scam', ripping off clients or whatever.
All the various paperwork, correspondance etc. goes through the office and is printed/proccessed/handled/shipped or whatever, by many people in the office. You say that by claiming a 'scam' [crime] has been commited, this mean all those people are implicated?
Well, of course they are. Under the law, it's called being an accessory. Unless, of course, the scam was perpetrated in such a way that every other person involved in it was completely oblivious as to what was actually happening, which is highly unlikely. This is the untenable position in which supporters of the CD Theory find themselves regarding the NYPD, FDNY, and PAPD. I'm still waiting for one of you to explain how this scenario supposedly took place.


How could I be expected to know that?
It's your theory not mine. It's not my fault if you aren't able to articulate it.

If something happened, it happened - I saw a guy once who produced numerous feathered birds apparenly from thin air -- I didn't say to myself "that didn't happen" :)
Poor analogy. No one saw a CD take place on 9/11. What everyone saw was two commercial jetliners slam into the WTC, cause massive fires, and the eventual collapse of three buildings.

So, once again I make this request of you and any other proponent of the CD Theory: Either describe in detail how a CD would have been possible without the knowledge or involvement of the NYPD, FDNY, and PAPD or admit that your astronomically dubious claims imply guilt on the part of those agencies. You can't have it both ways.
 
Unless, of course, the scam was perpetrated in such a way that every other person involved in it was completely oblivious as to what was actually happening

This sort of thing happens, nothing difficult to understand there - end of story.

If you believe in the CD Theory, can you explain how it was done without the knowledge or involvement of the NYPD, FDNY, and PAPD?

Originally Posted by TerryUK
How could I be expected to know that?

It's your theory not mine. It's not my fault if you aren't able to articulate it.

No. It's NOT my theory - it's YOUR assertion.

If there was a CD at WTC7, there was a CD, period.
 

You were 16 on 9/11.

You've really offered up no evidence that you are an EMT but since you're not claiming to have been at GZ on 9/11 I'll give you the benefit of the doubt. I apologize for saying you are a 'fake' EMT.

I would highly recommend instead of wasting your time on Alex Jones and the Watson brothers that you google "FDNY Oral Histories" and read through them all. Especially if you really want to be FDNY someday.

The Truth Movement is not the enemy of 9/11 Heroes. In fact, it seems to be only the Truth Movement that cares about 9/11 Heroes. We are the side trying to expose the 'cough' the Bush Administration denies exist. We were the ones who sided with the FDNY when they were told they weren't allowed to carry on the rescue efforts and had to leave the fallen in that pile so the evidence could be shipped off and destroyed quickly.

You're still young dude. You gotta a lot of learning to do. Hear me now and believe me later. I hope it works out for you.

peace
 
This sort of thing happens, nothing difficult to understand there - end of story.
Originally Posted by TerryUK
How could I be expected to know that?



So, you’re saying that the NYPD, FDNY, and PAPD carried out a controlled demolition without knowing it. However, you’ve no idea how this happened and it’s not a question that you feel there’s any need to trouble yourself over. That’s truly bizarre.

If there was a CD at WTC7, there was a CD, period.



Petitio Principii.
 
So you believe Dan Rather is a liar and Sean Hannity is not? :jaw-dropp


Sean Hannity is a partisan commentator who advocates for the conservative side. He acknowledges being a partisan commentator.

Dan Rather is a partisan commentator who advocates for the liberal side.
He calls himself an objective journalist.
 
No, not really.
If a corporation sends a directive to one branch of it's operation, the recipient, who may be another executive or management employee does not necessarily know the whole story... he then passes on the essential to his team manager, and at the end of the chain - a lady who works in 'customer relations' finds her self telling a complaining cusomer " I'm sorry I only work here, and I'm following instructions" whatever...

BS, and you know it. If she got the word from the 4th hand that the FDNY was going to bring building seven down, than all the hands prior to that had to AT LEAST know that much, yet none of those hands have admitted this, so they are covering it up...if you believe her story.

TAM:)
 
So, you’re saying that the NYPD, FDNY, and PAPD carried out a controlled demolition without knowing it. However, you’ve no idea how this happened and it’s not a question that you feel there’s any need to trouble yourself over. That’s truly bizarre.

Show me where I said the NYPD, FDNY, and PAPD carried out a controlled demolition.


Originally Posted by TerryUK
If there was a CD at WTC7, there was a CD, period.

Par wrote: Petitio Principii.

Sorry this doesn't apply, I said "if there was a CD, there was a CD, period"

no 'Petitio Principii' there now is there? :)
 
You were 16 on 9/11.

You've really offered up no evidence that you are an EMT but since you're not claiming to have been at GZ on 9/11 I'll give you the benefit of the doubt. I apologize for saying you are a 'fake' EMT.

someone bronze that quote.

I would highly recommend instead of wasting your time on Alex Jones and the Watson brothers that you google "FDNY Oral Histories" and read through them all. Especially if you really want to be FDNY someday.

Yes do that NYCEMT86, but make sure you read the entire histories, not just the cherries left at truther sites.

The Truth Movement is not the enemy of 9/11 Heroes.

says he who belongs to a movement full of those who believe Indira Singh, and believe elements of the FDNY were instructed to bring down WTC7, did so, but then kept it hidden...

In fact, it seems to be only the Truth Movement that cares about 9/11 Heroes.

Based on what??? please provide one example of how debunkers on this forum do not care about the 9/11 heroes? Come on, give me one...Don't forget, I have already shown how those who believe Indira Singh's testimony to be valid, by definition, have to believe certain elements of the FDNY were in on it....no debunkers believe it...

We are the side trying to expose the 'cough' the Bush Administration denies exist.

does Bush have a cold???

We were the ones who sided with the FDNY when they were told they weren't allowed to carry on the rescue efforts and had to leave the fallen in that pile so the evidence could be shipped off and destroyed quickly.

Oh really, who did that? you were there? who was there, at THAT TIME, belonging to the 9/11 truth movement at that time? I do not even think at that time such a movement existed. You are speaking garbage now.

You're still young dude. You gotta a lot of learning to do. Hear me now and believe me later. I hope it works out for you.
peace

Stick with us NYCEMT86, and TC is right, it will work out for you.

TAM:)
 
This sort of thing happens, nothing difficult to understand there - end of story.
Please provide an example or kindly retract your assertion.


No. It's NOT my theory - it's YOUR assertion.
I have asserted nothing. CTers in this thread have made the assertion that 1) The WTC was brought down with CD and 2) the NYPD, FDNY, and PAPD had no knowledge or involvement. I have merely requested that any of them describe a scenario in which this is possible. So far, none have.


If there was a CD at WTC7, there was a CD, period.
As Par has already succinctly put it: Petitio Principii. In other words, you're assuming something that hasn't even been remotely close to being proven. Besides, whether or not you or any other CTer believes that WTC7 was brought down by CD is irrelevant to the request I have made. Your opinions on whether or not a CD took place are inconsequential to this discussion. What I would like to know is if a CD did take place, how was it done without the knowledge or involvement of the NYPD, FDNY, and PAPD?

Anyone?
 
BS, and you know it. If she got the word from the 4th hand that the FDNY was going to bring building seven down, than all the hands prior to that had to AT LEAST know that much, yet none of those hands have admitted this, so they are covering it up...if you believe her story.

TAM:)

What do I know? Only what she's supposed to have said...
make your own mind up.

All I'm saying is she seems to be reasonably specific in what she said...
I believe there is some other statements or at least anecdotal evidence of FD prior warning.
As I said earlier, in would be best to interview these people to verify who said what and when.
I repeat what I said earlier, I think it's pretty ludicrous to suggest that any of the FF are accessories before the fact.
 
You were 16 on 9/11.

You've really offered up no evidence that you are an EMT but since you're not claiming to have been at GZ on 9/11 I'll give you the benefit of the doubt. I apologize for saying you are a 'fake' EMT.

I would highly recommend instead of wasting your time on Alex Jones and the Watson brothers that you google "FDNY Oral Histories" and read through them all. Especially if you really want to be FDNY someday.

The Truth Movement is not the enemy of 9/11 Heroes. In fact, it seems to be only the Truth Movement that cares about 9/11 Heroes. We are the side trying to expose the 'cough' the Bush Administration denies exist. We were the ones who sided with the FDNY when they were told they weren't allowed to carry on the rescue efforts and had to leave the fallen in that pile so the evidence could be shipped off and destroyed quickly.

You're still young dude. You gotta a lot of learning to do. Hear me now and believe me later. I hope it works out for you.

peace


I have read most of the oral histories and have talked to several firefighters and EMTs who were there as well. The one person I have been in contact with mainly is Deputy Chief Vincent Dunn, he wrote a lot of information on building collapses prior to 9/11 and even did a paper on the WTC which included a comparison of the WTC and the Empire State Building.

I am currently an FDNY EMT and I took the promotional exam in January to become a Firefighter.

A lot of people sided with the Firefighters when they were pulled off the pile. So you weren't the only ones. You aren't the only ones trying to help the sick rescue workers either.

Just because I am young doesn't mean I don't know anything.

I am a graduate from the NYS Fire Academy and was a volley firefighter while I was in the academy, thats how I got my EMT certification. I have learned a lot especially from the FDNY instructors who came up to the Academy and did a whole lecture on 9/11 and terrorism.

It's funny though, you guys claim Controlled Demolition. Yet, the Firefighters haven't rallied together to say it was an inside job. Most (and I am not saying all) Firefighter I have talked too, call bull**** on that whole theory.


It wasn't just Alex Jones. Jason Bermas said they were involved because they were paid off, when he retracted his statement he said they were threatened. Most twoofers (not putting words in your mouth) believe that the whole "pull it" statement implicates the FDNY as accessories.

The article Alex Jones and Watson brothers shows their true colors.

I don't believe in the truth movement at all. They haven't given me one piece of factual evidence to prove it was an inside job. Just because someone used the word "explosion" to describe a sound doesn't mean EXPLOSIVES. A lot of firefighters even go on to say "The sound was the building collapsing".

I do have a lot to learn, but its not going to be taught to me by the Truth Movement.

If you want proof that I am an EMT? Ask me any medical question you want, that isn't paramedic ordinated, because that is outside my scope of practice.
 
Last edited:
Show me where I said the NYPD, FDNY, and PAPD carried out a controlled demolition.



So, you don't believe that the NYPD, FDNY, and PAPD had any role in any controlled demolition?


Sorry this doesn't apply, I said "if there was a CD, there was a CD, period"

no 'Petitio Principii' there now is there? :)


Well, it’s either that or a tautology. So, you’re either wrong or daft. You can choose.
 
What do I know? Only what she's supposed to have said...
make your own mind up.

All I'm saying is she seems to be reasonably specific in what she said...
I believe there is some other statements or at least anecdotal evidence of FD prior warning.
As I said earlier, in would be best to interview these people to verify who said what and when.
I repeat what I said earlier, I think it's pretty ludicrous to suggest that any of the FF are accessories before the fact.

I don't want to belabor this point to death, but you have just said that you feel she was pretty specific. If you feel this way, than you can't have it both ways. If you feel she is specific, than that goes for her statement that the FDNY told her THEY were going to BRING WTC7 DOWN. This implicates, directly, people within the FDNY. So, if you believe in the last comment you made, than you must believe her testimony is ludicrous, as that is exactly what her testimony implies...that the FF are accessories before the fact.

TAM:)
 
As Par has already succinctly put it: Petitio Principii. In other words, you're assuming something that hasn't even been remotely close to being proven.

Can't you see the word'if' in my statement? you know, the statement described as 'Petitio Principi'?

" if there was a CD, there was a CD, period"

some of you guy gets things the wrong way around.
e.g." there can't have been a CD, because you don't know how it was done" -- BRILIANT :confused:
 
If you feel she is specific, than that goes for her statement that the FDNY told her THEY were going to BRING WTC7 DOWN. This implicates, directly, people within the FDNY.
TAM:)

As I said, people who simply relay a message are not necessarily implicated.
If what she said is true, it would appears that the fire department got a warning or tipoff - call it what you want- who knows? Now, as to the question 'at what level?' Your guess is as good as mine.
Like I said before, all this is 'hypothetical' and as such doesn't implicate anyone, except hypothetically of course.

edit: so you could say the 'truthers' are hypothetically [ put here whatever you want]
 
Not acceptable.

If Fire Chief X says to Fire Captain Y "We are going to have to bring WTC7 down", and then Fire Captain Y tells this to Fireman Z, who then relays this to Indira, are you telling me that none of them are culpable for relaying this, then allowing it to be covered up as "it came down due to damage", when in fact they relayed a message that it was going to be brought down intentionally?

There is no wiggle room on this issue. I hate to belabor it, but its true.

TAM:)
 
So, you don't believe that the NYPD, FDNY, and PAPD had any role in any controlled demolition?





Well, it’s either that or a tautology. So, you’re either wrong or daft. You can choose.

Well, sometimes one has to say 'daft' things to address absurdities :)

In other word, I said "if it happened , then it happened, period." Some are saying 'it can't have happened because you don't know how it would be done'.
 
Last edited:
Not acceptable.

If Fire Chief X says to Fire Captain Y "We are going to have to bring WTC7 down", and then Fire Captain Y tells this to Fireman Z, who then relays this to Indira, are you telling me that none of them are culpable for relaying this, then allowing it to be covered up as "it came down due to damage", when in fact they relayed a message that it was going to be brought down intentionally?

There is no wiggle room on this issue. I hate to belabor it, but its true.

TAM:)

If what you say here applies, i.e. Fire Chief X says to Fire Captain Y "We are going to have to bring WTC7 down", then of course that would implicate those people.
But that scenario is not necessary for the CD to be a reality.

You have to think 'pre-positioned incendiaries/explosives' a la WTC1 & 2
Therefor, no complicity of the FDNY etc.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom