Why does the electoral college protect smaller states rights?

Not representing the people who provide the food for the country could pose a problem.

Which I would worry about if a majority weren't such conservative, beating off to the bibble, blindly following the local preacher or untersturmfuhrer swine.
 
Which is why I do not worry about the plight of the farmer as much as I otherwise would.
 
I think part of the problem here is not necessarily the concept of the electoral college and indirect election, but how it plays out in part because of "winner-take-all" states. In theory, my vote in Vermont would have more per-capita punch than, say, a vote in Florida, since Vermont is over-represented. But the most any Vermont vote can do is influence the three electoral votes in the state. By contrast, because Florida is a winner-take-all state, a small number of votes that tips the balance changes 29 electoral votes at once. A squeaker of a victory in Florida (or any other big "swing" state) outweighs the entire vote count of the seven least populous states.
 
So how would this not be the case if the president was elected through a popular vote?
Because some states have such tremendously, overwhelmingly larger populations than others that they'd be guaranteed a win every time on every issue. Those of you across the ocean might not be able to imagine just how low our population densities still are in some places. You can drive for hours at over a mile a minute through some areas and still not see a town of more than a couple thousand people, and even those could easily be separated by an hour at a time of nothing but farms, with miles between one building and the next. But we still have some of the biggest, densest cities on the planet, which makes for some stark contrasts. I grew up in a city with more people than some whole states, and it was still only the second biggest city in that state and the 26th biggest city in the country.

What's the advantage of making the president elected out of the approval of individual states rather than people
At the time the Constitution was written, "the people of the USA" was roughly equivalent to "the people of Europe", not "the people of Germany" or "the people of Italy". People identified themselves as Pennsylvanians or Georgians or such, not as Americans, and the USA was a coalition of those independent countries, like the UN or European Union. And a multinational entity like that makes its decisions by the participation of its member nations. It wasn't a matter of advantages or disadvantages; it was just the logical arrangement for the type of organization that the USA was, just like today when the UN or the European Union makes a decision using input from "Spain" rather than from "the Spaniards". It only got weird over the following century as the cultural nature of the USA as a single country rather than an alliance of countries evolved while its political structures didn't.

Is it to prevent big population centers from dictating the outcome and allowing small states to have some say? If so, what's wrong with that?
Two things are wrong with it.

One is a matter of voters' rights. A popular vote, while sounding like it gives everyone their representational rights in theory, would in fact utterly fail to do so in a situation where there's one demographic group who win every single time and another demographic group who lose every single time. The latter essentially ends up with no representation or voice or influence in government, which is a right being denied to them. Bothering to let them vote with no influence on the outcome would be fakery by technicality, merely pretending to have a functionally democratic system, no different from simply not letting that demographic group vote in the first place.

The other is a matter of practicality. Going issue by issue, one idea at a time, you'll often find that people in cities tend to think one way and people in rural land tend to think another way. In a straight popular vote with an overwhelmingly urban population, whichever idea appeals to the urbanites is sure to win, and whichever one appeals to the ruralites is sure to lose. In other words, the outcome is determined not by the contents of the ideas being voted on, but by which idea appeals to the group of people who always win instead of to the group of people who always lose. That will only coincidentally yield the better policy in cases in which the better policy happens to be the one that appeals to the always-wins group, and coincidentally yield the worse policy in cases in which the better policy happens to be the one that appeals to the always-loses group. A system that's weighted to cancel out the population effects, so there isn't an always-wins group and an always-loses group, at least yields results based on how convincing a policy is overall, its ability to gain support regardless of group affiliation.

Of course, fixing either of those problems isn't really why the Electoral College exists, and even if it were, its effectiveness at that purpose has only decreased over the years as the population density has gone down where it was already low and up where it was already high. If balancing out the lopsidedness of the population were truly the goal, we'd have to devise a scheme to deviate from a straight popular vote even more strongly than what we've got now.

Districts aren't equal sized?
They are not. The number assigned to a state is based on that state's fraction of the national population, except that each state is guaranteed a minimum number of districts (I think 2, but maybe 1) even if its population isn't high enough for it if going by fractions alone. States distribute them internally to get districts of roughly equal populations, but usually don't want to split a single community into two districts, so moving a border around to put a community entirely on one side of the border or the other can also shrink one district and enlarge the other. However, the lines are redrawn periodically, in theory to account for shifts in population, but it's negotiated and voted on by politicians who often try to use the "redistricting" process to favor their political parties, so they can come out with roughly equal sizes (within the same state) but silly shapes.
 
Edited: George W. Bush won 2004 election 286-251. Afterward some "TIME" magazine staffers with way too much time on their hands tried to figure out how would election turn out if ALL states had the same system as Maine and Nebraska. Astonishing outcome: 286-251, exactly same.

Actually I read of a study done that found Bush would have won by a greater number of electoral votes. Don't know what study it was, it was in that Larry Sabato book.
 
I'm not sure of the details or if I just imagined it, but is there some 'representative' of the electoral college in each state? Seems like i heard there is and they are supposed to officially cast the vote for their state for whoever got the most votes, but aren't actually required to do so. So even if candidate X wins the state, the 'representative' can still cast his vote for candidate Y. Its never happened, but nothing besides 'honor' is preventing it.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom