Why does the electoral college protect smaller states rights?

Undesired Walrus

Penultimate Amazing
Joined
Apr 10, 2007
Messages
11,691
I understand that at its basic level, the United States' electoral college is designed out of the concern that large states would otherwise control elections.

How?

In the same vein, it was designed to give all states a voice in the selection of a nation's leader.

Again, how? How does a small number of electoral votes for Utah put it on equal standing with California?
 
Hm? The electoral college is more because of the idea that the common person isn't or wasn't knowledgeable enough about politics to vote for high-ranking officials. It was also why the senate was voted for by state legislators until the 17th amendment.
 
I understand that at its basic level, the United States' electoral college is designed out of the concern that large states would otherwise control elections.

How?

I'm not sure offhand if this was the historical justification, but the modern defense of it is that with a simple national popular vote standard, candidates would focus their attention on the larger cities and states because there's more "bang for the buck" in terms of money and candidate time.

In the same vein, it was designed to give all states a voice in the selection of a nation's leader.

Again, how? How does a small number of electoral votes for Utah put it on equal standing with California?

Well, it doesn't. I don't think anyone claims that it puts Utah on "equal" standing with California. As I said, the usual defense is that it gives candidates some incentive to try to win smaller states.

As a practical matter, in recent elections Utah and California are probably equally neglected by candidates, because neither is a "battleground" state: Utah is reliably Republican, and California slightly-less-reliably Democratic. California still gets more "attention" in the sense that both parties make fundraising trips here.

And that's really the basis behind the recent efforts to achieve a national popular vote standard, either by constitutional amendment or by state legislation: to curtail the trend where the presidential election is really only fought in a handful of battleground states like Ohio, Florida, Pennslyvania, Michigan, and Nevada.
 
Hm? The electoral college is more because of the idea that the common person isn't or wasn't knowledgeable enough about politics to vote for high-ranking officials. It was also why the senate was voted for by state legislators until the 17th amendment.

Well, yes, I just read something from George Mason that sounds like that. So how would it work originally? You would vote for the electors who would then make the decision of President?
 
Also, could someone explain how Maine allocates its electoral votes? I understand it is possible for both candidates to share the votes in the state? Like one vote for the republican and 3 for the democrat?
 
Well, yes, I just read something from George Mason that sounds like that. So how would it work originally? You would vote for the electors who would then make the decision of President?

Technically, that's still how it works. Though it is the actual presidential candidate's name that appears on the ballot these days, technically the voter is voting for a particular slate of electors. The Electoral College still meets and votes and transmits the results to Congress.

There have been occasional "faithless electors" who have chosen not to vote for the candidate they were "supposed" to, though there's never been enough to affect the outcome.

Also, the Constitution leaves it up to each state legislature to decide how to appoint electors. One of the subplots of the 2000 election aftermath is that the Republican-controlled Florida legislature was threatening to designate Bush's electors as Florida's electors regardless of what the courts did. There was the rather ugly possibility of two competing sets of electors showing up and claiming to be the legitimate representatives.
 
Also, the republicans are pushing hard in some states (PA most notably) to allow each district's vote to count separately, rather than combining the votes based on the popular turnout. PA, then, would wind up with more votes going to republican candidates since more districts (12 of 19) slant towards republican while the most populous districts slant towards democrat. This would be a huge sea change in the way presidents are elected and there are many republican heavyweights nationwide who have come out opposed to the change, based simply on (gasp) principal.
 
How does a small number of electoral votes for Utah put it on equal standing with California?

It doesn't. The purpose was never to put Utah on an equal footing with California. Rather, the purpose is to reduce the disparity in influence between more populous states like California and less populous states like Utah.

Think of the Electoral College as putting a cap on how much federal government more-populous states like California can impose on less-populous states like Utah against their will.

We expect that to a certain extent, California should have more influence on federal policy than Utah. The EC is part of the system that defines that extent.
 
Also, the republicans are pushing hard in some states (PA most notably) to allow each district's vote to count separately, rather than combining the votes based on the popular turnout. PA, then, would wind up with more votes going to republican candidates since more districts (12 of 19) slant towards republican while the most populous districts slant towards democrat. This would be a huge sea change in the way presidents are elected and there are many republican heavyweights nationwide who have come out opposed to the change, based simply on (gasp) principal.
Principle. I know it's a word not usually associated with politicians.:)
 
Think of the Electoral College as putting a cap on how much federal government more-populous states like California can impose on less-populous states like Utah against their will.

So how would this not be the case if the president was elected through a popular vote?

Just trying to wrap my head around the arguments in favour. What's the advantage of making the president elected out of the approval of individual states rather than people. Is it to prevent big population centers from dictating the outcome and allowing small states to have some say? If so, what's wrong with that?

Not saying there is a problem with EC, just not understanding it fully.
 
Whatever the electoral college was meant to accomplish, it's difficult to see what it's good for now. As things now stand, in small states, whether or not they're technically over-represented at the electoral level, the voters are essentially disenfranchised.

It may have made more sense when the difference between large and small population areas was smaller. Now, a small state like Vermont is outweighed so many times over by large states that it no longer matters in comparison to even a single district of a state with "winner-take-all" electors.
 
Also, the republicans are pushing hard in some states (PA most notably) to allow each district's vote to count separately, rather than combining the votes based on the popular turnout. PA, then, would wind up with more votes going to republican candidates since more districts (12 of 19) slant towards republican while the most populous districts slant towards democrat. This would be a huge sea change in the way presidents are elected and there are many republican heavyweights nationwide who have come out opposed to the change, based simply on (gasp) principal.
They GOP in PA has since killed that proposal, or at the very least, are leaning that way.

http://www.humanevents.com/article.php?id=47171

http://www.pennlive.com/midstate/index.ssf/2011/10/activist_gene_stilp_says_to_dr.html
 
Last edited:
Last edited:
Also, could someone explain how Maine allocates its electoral votes? I understand it is possible for both candidates to share the votes in the state? Like one vote for the republican and 3 for the democrat?
Yes. Maine has two congressional districts, thus 4 electoral votes. The winner of one district gets one electoral vote. The winner of second district gets second vote. The winner of Maine overall gets remaining two votes. So votes can go 4-0 or 3-1, but never 2-2.

Nebraska has the same system, except it has 3 congressional districts, thus 5 electoral votes. In 2008 Obama won one of Nebraska's districts and McCain won other two, creating 4-1 split. Maine electoral votes never actually split yet.

Edited: George W. Bush won 2004 election 286-251. Afterward some "TIME" magazine staffers with way too much time on their hands tried to figure out how would election turn out if ALL states had the same system as Maine and Nebraska. Astonishing outcome: 286-251, exactly same.
 
Last edited:
Is it to prevent big population centers from dictating the outcome and allowing small states to have some say? If so, what's wrong with that?
Not representing the people who provide the food for the country could pose a problem.
 
Districts aren't equal sized?
Only in idealist's imagination - though they should be - with boundaries set so the populations in each are the same to no worse than 5%. If you mean same population size (and I do) and random otherwise (and I do)
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom