Why do Americans like their beer cold?

Why was damn near every ale I tried, and in two weeks touring with a band I drank almost nothing else and never had the same one twice, at near 3% alcohal? Why did all but 1 that I tried seem to completely lack hops?

I know you guys take your beer very seriously, but despite that I have to say you seem to be doing it wrong.

Seriously? What were you drinking, and how long ago was this? You'd be very hard pressed to find a 3% ABV beer in Britain. Most bitter sold in pubs or supermarkets is in the 4½% - 5½% range.
 
American beer doesn't taste very good, so you have to drink it cold.

Stop fixating on that Bud and Corona piss and find some microbreweries. A lot of them make good beer, and some of them make fantastic beer.
 
American beer doesn't taste very good, so you have to drink it cold.
This also just in: blacks are crooks, Mexicans are lazy, and white people can't dance. :rolleyes:

There is a lot of quality American beer and not all beer in other countries - including England, which I think stride for stride has the best - is good by any means.

Anyway, IMO most beer tastes best just slightly cool - but many are great room temp too.

I hate that canoe joke, because it is just stupid. Beer is always mostly water, and doesn't matter how strong or thick it tastes; you are always looking at around 85% water or more. If it was less water than that than it wouldn't be beer anymore. There is a limitation to the amount of alcohol that can be produced from fermentation, and all those flavor and thickness of say a stout is mostly an illusion; it is still mostly water.

I just hate the joke, because it really isn't that clever even if it supposed to be about taste.
Bravo. I hate it because it doesn't even make sense. American breweries have porters, stouts, etc etc and have for a long time. There's a hell of a lot more to American beer than Bud and Miller etc. What jibberish.

I like everything from the "lightest" beers (not meaning "lite beer," which I agree is very "watery") to the darkest/heartiest.
 
Seriously? What were you drinking, and how long ago was this? You'd be very hard pressed to find a 3% ABV beer in Britain. Most bitter sold in pubs or supermarkets is in the 4½% - 5½% range.

1 year ago, and damn near every bitter and IPA I could find, in failed hopes of finding one with hops, almost exclusively at pubs. Our hosts were cider and lager/pilsner drinkers, so supermarket runs were not helpful.

ETA: And it's not like I went over there with an agenda, either. It was quite the unpleasant surprise when I kept trying ales to keep not liking them. I believe the term "sheer bloodymindedness" is the phrase for why I kept ordering them.
 
Last edited:
Guiness stout is usually cold as is Bass ale or Newcastle Brown ale and many other good imported beers. Americans drink that cold also.
No beer ale should be drunk cold, no matter where it was brewed. If I pull one out of a cooler I let it warm up a bit.

eta: accidentally wrote "beer" instead of "ale".
 
Last edited:
For me it depends on the type of beer, just as it does with wine.

If it's too cold it sucks the flavor out of the beer. In some cases this is a good thing.
 
This. I've tried warm beers before (which were "meant" to be not cold), and it did nothing for me other than to cause a gag reflex.

I'm curious, which beers are "meant" to be served warm are you talking about? And what temperature is warm?
 
America has some of the best beer in the world, you just won't find them at your local 7/11. The myth of bad American beer is just based on the Bud/Coors/PBR type brands who have lots of marketing money.

A lot of European beers are supposed to be served at cellar temperature, which is far from warm, but not exactly cold, either. There aren't many beers that I know of that are supposed to be served "warm" but it does happen a lot in some countries.
 
I'm curious, which beers are "meant" to be served warm are you talking about? And what temperature is warm?

Almost anything except lager style beers. "Warm" is cellar temperature. Around 15°C or 59°F. So it's only relatively warm compared to beer that's chilled.

I remember reading an article by a publican who had an old "Guinness" branded cellar thermometer, which had (IIRC) 59°F marked as "perfect" cellar temperature. He was bemoaning the fact that the Guinness rep now insisted on a much colder temperature for his product. If the publican didn't comply, he'd have his supply withdrawn. He tried to keep an unchilled barrel for some regulars who still liked their Guinness warm, but woe betide him if the rep ever found out.

Nowadays Guinness in UK pubs is served chilled as "Guinness" or even more chilled as "Guinness Extra Cold". I think they find they sell more to young drinkers who like the brand image but don't like the taste. Serve it freezing cold and you can't taste a thing.
 
America has some of the best beer in the world, you just won't find them at your local 7/11.

True. Beer is like bread. The mass produced brands are generally anaemic, bland and disappointing. The very best is made locally, by a craftsman who cares and uses the best ingredients available to produce an astonishing complexity of flavours. Then it becomes one of life's great pleasures.

Ben Franklin (allegedly) said: "Beer is proof that God loves us and wants us to be happy". That's a nice line, even for an unbeliever like me.
 
I'm not sure whether this is accurate or not, but I've heard the theory that Prohibition is to "blame."

It goes something like this: when Prohibition ended, the brewing industry experienced rapid growth in the U.S., as breweries either started up from scratch or expanded their operations. Refrigeration technology had progressed by this point, so it was much more practical and cost-effective to make lagers than had been the case in the past. So there was a shift towards lagers, which are meant to be served colder than ales.

I really haven't noticed much of a difference in beer temperatures during my travels. What I have noticed is that cold, mass-produced lagers seems to be gaining in popularity everywhere: I was stunned to see how much Budweiser was being sold and consumed in Irish and British pubs. (I also saw a lot of "extra cold Guinness" taps.) This anecdotal experience would be consistent with the Prohibition theory, in that it suggests that people everywhere tend to like cold beers, and that the U.S. was just quicker to cater to that taste because it had to rebuild its brewing industry right around the time that it became easier to brew and serve cold beers.

My contrary data point, though, is water. American restaurants tend to bring you water that is half ice, while overseas it seems to be closer to room temperature.
 
On occassion I talk to a Brit or german working here in Atlanta ga. They don't like their beer as cold as we do. Theres nothing wrong with drinking room temperature beer but I like it cold myself. I talked to a Polish girl at my watering hole and she told me that some cultures like their beer warm enough to steam a bit.

Here in the American southeast I can understand. It gets darn hot here so we drink cold soda, iced tea and we prefer our beer as cold as we can get it without it actually freezing.

Ok Most caucasian americans ancestors come from England, Germany etc. Why do we like it as coold as we do? What changed us?


Cold masks the taste of Horse Pee American Beer.

PBS had a program a few years back about American Beer. At the turn of the 20th century, America was known as a producer of some of the world's best beer. Miller, Strohs, Pabst, Coors, Anheuser-Busch, Schlitz - all of these were German Brewmasters.

Then came Prohibition. Of course this had a devastating effect.

According to PBS, what finished-off the American beers was WWII. Shortages of barley led beer makers to use rice to make beer.
 
And someone hit reply without reading the thread.
 

Back
Top Bottom