White Anti-Gunner Assaults Black Man With CCW

Video



Idiot almost took out a kid with the tackle.

eta: longer vid and different angles

 
Last edited:
But I have guns and I don't walk around with them on display.* I don't walk around with my penis out either.


*I can barely lift one, it's not highly portable.
Do you still give them illegally to irresponsible people who promptly get the stolen?

Why aren't you giving up your guns? You consistently take the side of the "ban them" people here, shouldn't you lead by example?
 
Don't forget, if it had been two terrorists armed with AKs the gun owner would have taken them out.
 
Are...are people really arguing that the fact this CCW holder didn't shoot the unarmed man who assaulted him is evidence guns are useless for self defense, or that not shooting the unarmed man was a bad thing, or...something?

The opposing spin would be that it proves that gun owners aren't actually eager to shoot people, and this holder did the right thing by identifying it wasn't a threat to his life and resolving the situation in a different way.

My own position is that a gun can be used for self-defense, that it's a useful tool for that. It is not a perfect tool for that however, and there are plenty of situations where even a well trained person won't be able to bring it to bare even if they wanted to. Situations like say, being blindside tackled by someone in public then put in a choke hold. People tend to, somehow, over-estimate the use of a gun while under-estimating the dangers. Other people under-estimate the use and over-estimate the danger. This situation proves little besides that a gun is not always useful in any assault and gun owners don't always want to shoot people.

How did the white guy know the gun-holder wasn't a cop? :boggled:
 
Are...are people really arguing that the fact this CCW holder didn't shoot the unarmed man who assaulted him is evidence guns are useless for self defense, or that not shooting the unarmed man was a bad thing, or...something?

The opposing spin would be that it proves that gun owners aren't actually eager to shoot people, and this holder did the right thing by identifying it wasn't a threat to his life and resolving the situation in a different way.


In all honesty, I think some people, myself included, are assuming that Mr. Daniels was unable to use his weapon. That may not actually have been the case.

Here's one big problem I have with guns: their lethal use allows for the creation of an entirely different, often one-sided narrative (in "the winner writes history" vein). If Mr. Daniels had shot and killed Mr. Foster, then it would inevitably become almost self-evident that Mr. Foster "deserved" to die for his violent behavior. However, since Mr. Foster is still alive, we can see that he's actually just some misguided guy who thought he was being a hero, more annoying than truly dangerous.
 
Last edited:
How do posters think that it might have ended if Mr. Foster also had a gun? Wouldn't he have that right under current law? If Mr. Foster truly believed that Mr. Daniels was a danger to all, and given that Mr Foster physically attacked Mr. Daniels without waiting for an explanation, do people think that Mr. Foster might have shot Mr. Daniels in the same way? If you don't think that, why?
 
Do you still give them illegally to irresponsible people who promptly get the stolen?
Show me where the transfer was illegal under the laws of that state. Got a link?
Why aren't you giving up your guns? You consistently take the side of the "ban them" people here, shouldn't you lead by example?
I'm on the side of rationality. Both extremes have problems, as "certain people here" so amply demonstrate.
 
How do posters think that it might have ended if Mr. Foster also had a gun?

Legally or illegally?

If Mr. Foster had a gun legally, then he would probably have been aware of the relevant laws, and would not have assumed that another concealed carry holder was a criminal.

If Mr. Foster had a gun illegally, he would probably not be a civic-minded citizen interested in protecting others, or in revealing his own lawless carrying.

Wouldn't he have that right under current law?

No. He was (rightfully) charged with assault for what he did. Doing it with a gun wouldn't have made it any more legal. You badly misunderstand the law of self-defense if you think it does.

If Mr. Foster truly believed that Mr. Daniels was a danger to all

That doesn't suffice. The fear must be reasonable, and it wasn't.
 
Legally or illegally?

If Mr. Foster had a gun legally, then he would probably have been aware of the relevant laws, and would not have assumed that another concealed carry holder was a criminal.

No. He was (rightfully) charged with assault for what he did. Doing it with a gun wouldn't have made it any more legal. You badly misunderstand the law of self-defense if you think it does.

That doesn't suffice. The fear must be reasonable, and it wasn't.

Of course let us assume that Mr. Foster had a gun legally, perhaps purchased for his self-defense. Of course Mr. Foster, by simply buying the gun, would have been somehow made aware of all the relevant laws and would have assumed that the other guy with a gun had a permit and was not a criminal. In Googling, I didn't see where applicants for a concealed carry in Florida are directed to read this law, let alone are required to prove that they read it, but I am certain that Mr Foster would somehow have learned and followed the law if Mr. Foster either had concealed carried, or even open carried, a legal gun.

I never argued that the attack was legal, or that it would have been if Mr. Foster attacked with a gun rather than a body blow. It seems illegal to me no matter what. I suspect a proper jury will convict Mr. Foster of assault. Luckily, Mr. Daniels will be able to testify in the trial given the circumstances of the actual event.
 
Of course let us assume that Mr. Foster had a gun legally, perhaps purchased for his self-defense. Of course Mr. Foster, by simply buying the gun, would have been somehow made aware of all the relevant laws and would have assumed that the other guy with a gun had a permit and was not a criminal. In Googling, I didn't see where applicants for a concealed carry in Florida are directed to read this law, let alone are required to prove that they read it, but I am certain that Mr Foster would somehow have learned and followed the law if Mr. Foster either had concealed carried, or even open carried, a legal gun.

Foster would not necessarily, by virtue of buying a gun, have been made aware of concealed carry laws. But he would have been made aware of concealed carry laws if he were to obtain a concealed carry license, because the process of obtaining a license will obviously inform you of the ability to obtain a license. Plus, of course, the application instructions actually includes an extensive section on the relevant laws.

As for open carry, Florida prohibits it except in situations which would not apply here.

So the only way for Foster to have a legal gun on him at the time would be for him to be a concealed carry license holder, and a concealed carry license holder would rather obviously know that people can, well, get licenses to carry concealed. And given such an understanding, it seems unlikely that he would simply assume that another concealed carry permit holder was carrying illegally.
 
Foster would not necessarily, by virtue of buying a gun, have been made aware of concealed carry laws. But he would have been made aware of concealed carry laws if he were to obtain a concealed carry license, because the process of obtaining a license will obviously inform you of the ability to obtain a license. Plus, of course, the application instructions actually includes an extensive section on the relevant laws.

As for open carry, Florida prohibits it except in situations which would not apply here.

So the only way for Foster to have a legal gun on him at the time would be for him to be a concealed carry license holder, and a concealed carry license holder would rather obviously know that people can, well, get licenses to carry concealed. And given such an understanding, it seems unlikely that he would simply assume that another concealed carry permit holder was carrying illegally.
I appreciate the link to the pdf, because although I could easily google the application form, I did not find the instruction book in my search. I am curious: is there a test in Florida that requires people to demonstrate that they have read and understood the book before giving them a concealed carry permit? I presume this would make sense, but I can't tell.

Of course, understanding the law doesn't ensure that everyone follows it. And it is legal to have an air gun in most states, but I guess in the heat of the moment a mistake can be made and someone can be shot dead, even by trained police. But it is a start, isn't it?
 
Are...are people really arguing that the fact this CCW holder didn't shoot the unarmed man who assaulted him is evidence guns are useless for self defense, or that not shooting the unarmed man was a bad thing, or...something?

The opposing spin would be that it proves that gun owners aren't actually eager to shoot people, and this holder did the right thing by identifying it wasn't a threat to his life and resolving the situation in a different way.

My own position is that a gun can be used for self-defense, that it's a useful tool for that. It is not a perfect tool for that however, and there are plenty of situations where even a well trained person won't be able to bring it to bare even if they wanted to. Situations like say, being blindside tackled by someone in public then put in a choke hold. People tend to, somehow, over-estimate the use of a gun while under-estimating the dangers. Other people under-estimate the use and over-estimate the danger. This situation proves little besides that a gun is not always useful in any assault and gun owners don't always want to shoot people.

How did the white guy know the gun-holder wasn't a cop? :boggled:

I think the most bodacious of us are simply riffing on the "anti-gun" spin that the OP chose. It was just to raise hackles, so we're posting with hackles arisen.

Whether the tackler had a weapon, or what if the tacklee had a knife and what this all proves involves trips off to Hypothetic Valley, as do most of these threads. Clearly, from this evidence and the shootings in Paris the gun is not the great equalizer. You can be out-gunned(Paris) or you can be out-maneuvered (Walmart).

And yeah, a knife or dagger or straight razor would be a far more effective tool if you're in a choke hold, so that could be proof.... IN THIS INSTANCE. But then you'd need your gun for situations that weren't up close and personal and your blade for when someone blindsides you and maybe a taser and some pepper spray for other situations. If you go out thinking you need to protect yourself from all possibilities, you wind up needing the Bat Belt full of gadgets.

The issues in the thread itself are whether the guy would've tackled a white guy with a concealed weapon - unanswered, and why the OP thinks that anti-gunners, who he believes are all ascared of guns like little girls, would aggressively take on a gun-wielding sociopath (which gun devotees all think is what gun sanity advocates think of them).
 
Show me where the transfer was illegal under the laws of that state. Got a link?
You claimed the gun was registered. I know of no state or municipality that registers firearms that allows the registered owner to transfer it to someone else without notifying the registration agency. Did the irresponsible person you transferred it to then register it in her name?

I'm on the side of rationality. Both extremes have problems, as "certain people here" so amply demonstrate.
I don't recall you ever suggesting what you think should be done, and you consistently agree with posters who would like a ban.
 
I think the most bodacious of us are simply riffing on the "anti-gun" spin that the OP chose. It was just to raise hackles, so we're posting with hackles arisen.
On the "Moms demand Action" social media sites there's lots of people who say they will call the police on, attack, harass, etc people they see with concealed weapons. Hell Claus Larsen did it on this very forum wrt Air Marshals in an infamous thread back in the day, it's hardly an uncommon course of action fantasized about by anti-gunners. I eagerly await more information on this case.

And let's not forget the guy in the Ohio Walmart who called the police on the guy with the BB gun, who told the 911 dispatcher he saw him loading it and pointing it at people. Exactly the course of action that many anti-gunners claim they will pursue on social media sites.

And I also wonder about the guy who SWATed the guy in Oklahoma who subsequently shot (and didn't kill thankfully) the sheriff who responded to the call. The guy's Facebook page had lots of pics of him posing with guns, I can't help but wonder if he was chosen because of that by an anti-gunner who thought it would be funny to SWAT a "gun nut".
 
On the "Moms demand Action" social media sites there's lots of people who say they will call the police on, attack, harass, etc people they see with concealed weapons. Hell Claus Larsen did it on this very forum wrt Air Marshals in an infamous thread back in the day, it's hardly an uncommon course of action fantasized about by anti-gunners. I eagerly await more information on this case.

And let's not forget the guy in the Ohio Walmart who called the police on the guy with the BB gun, who told the 911 dispatcher he saw him loading it and pointing it at people. Exactly the course of action that many anti-gunners claim they will pursue on social media sites.

And I also wonder about the guy who SWATed the guy in Oklahoma who subsequently shot (and didn't kill thankfully) the sheriff who responded to the call. The guy's Facebook page had lots of pics of him posing with guns, I can't help but wonder if he was chosen because of that by an anti-gunner who thought it would be funny to SWAT a "gun nut".

So idle speculation, then. You could've just said so, but then Gawdzilla and I wouldn't have been able to wile away the hours, so there's that.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom