White Anti-Gunner Assaults Black Man With CCW

Oh come on, you can't possibly be that dense. Everywhere, from literally every source including you. Why do people carry in the first place? For self-defence. :rolleyes:

The most idiotic part of the story is that the guy went for a takedown rather than alerting security or the police. Who does that?
You forgot the link. I'm assuming it's because you don't have one and are making it up, yes? Because I'm certain I never made such a ridiculous claim.
 
Good thing Mr. Foster wasn't intent on or succeeded in killing Mr. Daniels, or gun control advocates might have something to point to and ask, "Being armed didn't help this poor guy, did it?"

The would-be-hero is lucky he didn't get his dumb ass shot.


I'd say that Mr. Daniels, the gun owner, is too.

Strictly curious, but what makes you think the white guy was anti-gun?


Anti-gun in the same way that cops who shoot armed suspects are "anti-gun", I guess.

a. Why did the assaulter not notify the police that there was an armed person;


I suspect it's a hero fantasy/mentality similar to that possessed by a certain number of gun owners: "no time; have to do something right now before people get hurt."
 
I think it's interesting how this story, which seems to me to demonstrate a good reason why idiots shouldn't have guns, and why guns are of limited use in self-defence scenarios, is being spun by a gun enthusiast as a myth about the evils of gun control.

If the idiot in this case had been armed, this could have ended in a fatal shooting much more easily. Fortunately they were unarmed and nobody was seriously hurt.

Of course even this could have been avoided if nobody was carrying a gun at all.

Yet it's now somehow a pro-gun story? Weird.
 
I think it's interesting how this story, which seems to me to demonstrate a good reason why idiots shouldn't have guns, and why guns are of limited use in self-defence scenarios, is being spun by a gun enthusiast as a myth about the evils of gun control.

If the idiot in this case had been armed, this could have ended in a fatal shooting much more easily. Fortunately they were unarmed and nobody was seriously hurt.

Of course even this could have been avoided if nobody was carrying a gun at all.

Yet it's now somehow a pro-gun story? Weird.
Maybe the idiot in this story should have minded his own business and not assaulted someone when there was no evidence a crime had occurred, was occurring, or was about to occur.
 
Maybe the idiot in this story should have minded his own business and not assaulted someone when there was no evidence a crime had occurred, was occurring, or was about to occur.


He obviously felt that Mr. Daniels' possession of a firearm was criminal and an imminent threat to the lives of innocent bystanders. Turns out it wasn't. We shouldn't be so hard on him. Being a vigilant civilian is dangerous work. And he's not even being paid for it.
 
Last edited:
Nice idea, but what if it explodes accidentally? What if you forget which one is which?

My idea would be to have a switch on it you would activate when handing it over. One that would not go off in your pocket. You get three seconds to get out of the way. Or maybe a remote detonator? Come on, it would be fun!

Use at your own risk! ;)
 
Anecdote about how I handled a situation with a possible gun carrier (California)...

I managed a small nightclub some years ago. One of our "regulars" approached me and said that he saw a gun in another guys waistband.

I grabbed a bouncer for backup, politely asked the guy to step outside so I could talk to him, and then asked if he was carrying. It was a beeper (remember those?). He was so scared I actually had to calm the poor guy down.
 
The thing this story actually reminded me of most was some of those "What Would You Do?" experiments that ABC did. Like this one:



Not saying the guy was necessarily racist, it just makes me wonder if race was a factor (whether on a conscious or subconscious level).
 
Good thing Mr. Foster wasn't intent on or succeeded in killing Mr. Daniels, or gun control advocates might have something to point to and ask, "Being armed didn't help this poor guy, did it?"

That would be a silly argument.


I think it's interesting how this story, which seems to me to demonstrate a good reason why idiots shouldn't have guns, and why guns are of limited use in self-defence scenarios, is being spun by a gun enthusiast as a myth about the evils of gun control.

If the idiot in this case had been armed, this could have ended in a fatal shooting much more easily. Fortunately they were unarmed and nobody was seriously hurt.

I don't see how it demonstrated anything about why idiots shouldn't have guns. Saying it "demonstrated" something based on a hypothetical scenario is a stretch. Of course it doesn't demonstrate anything about the evils of gun control either.
 
You don't believe that people carry for self-defence?

That claim that you attributed to WildCat and others was that people who carry guns never get attacked. Not that people carry guns for self-defense.
 
That claim that you attributed to WildCat and others was that people who carry guns never get attacked. Not that people carry guns for self-defense.
You're right - my bad.

That said, if someone is carrying a gun for self-defence, what is their expectation of being attacked?
 
Being Canadian - I am not up to speed on all the rules regarding concealed carry in the US. However - the thing that stands out to me is that the operative word in "concealed carry permit" must be "concealed".

When I was a police officer working plain clothes (not undercover) - it was important to carry your service firearm in a concealed manner so as not to alarm members of the public who did not know you were a cop.
We had the usual trouble with a few rookies doing recruit field training who thought flashing the gun would show they were cool - but it just attracted derision and scorn from the more seasoned members and often resulted in a long and loud lecture from the boss in the corner office.

Carrying a firearm is a huge responsibility. Black, White, Hispanic, or Martian - the fault lies with the fool who couldn't - or wouldn't - responsibly conceal his firearm - IMHO.
 
Last edited:
Good thing Mr. Foster wasn't intent on or succeeded in killing Mr. Daniels, or gun control advocates might have something to point to and ask, "Being armed didn't help this poor guy, did it?"

It wouldn't be relevant as he is clearly a coward for not properly defending himself in the first place despite being armed.
 
Maybe the idiot in this story should have minded his own business and not assaulted someone when there was no evidence a crime had occurred, was occurring, or was about to occur.

Yep that is the job of the police to do that.
 
Being Canadian - I am not up to speed on all the rules regarding concealed carry in the US. However - the thing that stands out to me is that the operative word in "concealed carry permit" must be "concealed".

When I was a police officer working plain clothes (not undercover) - it was important to carry your service firearm in a concealed manner so as not to alarm members of the public who did not know you were a cop.
We had the usual trouble with a few rookies doing recruit field training who thought flashing the gun would show they were cool - but it just attracted derision and scorn from the more seasoned members and often resulted in a long and loud lecture from the boss in the corner office.

Carrying a firearm is a huge responsibility. Black, White, Hispanic, or Martian - the fault lies with the fool who couldn't - or wouldn't - responsibly conceal his firearm - IMHO.

Absolutely. And he should be given a stern talking to. That's no kind of example to set for the other officers on the force. Oh, wait... he's not an officer. He's a guy who was getting out of his vehicle and who holstered his gun and someone saw him do so.

And, have you heard? That someone then decided to come up behind him and put him in a choke-hold.

And you're saying it's the carrier who's the problem?
 
Maybe the idiot in this story should have minded his own business and not assaulted someone when there was no evidence a crime had occurred, was occurring, or was about to occur.

This appears to be about the long and the short of it.

Where it's legal to carry then the mere sight of a gun really shouldn't be of any note at all.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom