When does a human foetus have a right to life?

Because rights don't work that way. A right to life does not obligate someone else to support you or provide you with the means to live.

Technically that's inexact. There are two types of rights:

1. "Negative rights": You have a negative right to X, if nobody can forbid you to do X. Or sometimes it's put a "negative rights permit or oblige inaction". E.g., you have a right to live in that other people are forbidden to kill you. When it comes to terminating your life, the law/right says I should not act.

2. "Positive rights": which mean pretty much just that someone is expected or obligated to act in such a way that grants you that right. E.g., rights like "habeas corpus" are actually very much positive rights. It says that whoever has you in custody and the legal system _must_ do something when asked to.

Ditto for, say, the right to vote (someone has to provide you with all it takes to exercise that right), the right to seek remedy for having your rights violated, the right to an education (at least the version from the Universal Declaration Of Human Rights implicitly says that someone must give you that), etc.

So, yes, rights can exist where someone is actually obligated to act as to give you that right.

If you accept, for example, that a fetus has a full right to live, the strongest conceivable argument you could make based on that is that if the fetus was viable without its mother, the mother wanted to remove it, and someone else wanted to provide for the fetus' needs at their own expense, the mother was obligated to remove the fetus in such a way that the other person could keep it alive. It's just like I can fire you from your job, even if that means you'll starve to death. But I can't lock you inside my factory if you wish to leave.

But that's actually the kind of thing I'm getting at. The pro-lifers at least are turning it de facto into a positive right. The debate against abortion isn't trying to turn it into a "ok, if anyone wants to keep the foetus alive, they should be able to get it", but in something where they force a woman to carry that foetus.

They're not using the usual "right to life" which only says, basically, "thou shalt not kill your patient... but can still refuse to give him a place in your hospital, if he can't pay", but rather into something where someone has to do everything to keep it alive, including grant it use of her own body. Which is already turning it into a positive right.
 
"Positive rights": which mean pretty much just that someone is expected or obligated to act in such a way that grants you that right. E.g., rights like "habeas corpus" are actually very much positive rights. It says that whoever has you in custody and the legal system _must_ do something when asked to.

Ditto for, say, the right to vote (someone has to provide you with all it takes to exercise that right), the right to seek remedy for having your rights violated, the right to an education (at least the version from the Universal Declaration Of Human Rights implicitly says that someone must give you that), etc.

So, yes, rights can exist where someone is actually obligated to act as to give you that right.
Against individuals, all these rights require (if anything) is that they not infringe them. Your right to vote doesn't require any individual to do anything but not interfere with your voting -- it's the government that must have elections, count your vote, and so on. The right to habeas corpus doesn't require any private individual to do anything.

But that's actually the kind of thing I'm getting at. The pro-lifers at least are turning it de facto into a positive right. The debate against abortion isn't trying to turn it into a "ok, if anyone wants to keep the foetus alive, they should be able to get it", but in something where they force a woman to carry that foetus.
And that's where their argument goes off the rails. If a fetus had a positive right to life, that wouldn't require the woman to do anything, it would at most require the government or society to provide for the fetus if the woman refused. Even positive rights are not claims against individuals.

They're not using the usual "right to life" which only says, basically, "thou shalt not kill your patient... but can still refuse to give him a place in your hospital, if he can't pay", but rather into something where someone has to do everything to keep it alive, including grant it use of her own body. Which is already turning it into a positive right.
It's not turning it into a positive right as they are otherwise used, it's converting it into something unlike any generally accepted right and more like the purported rights that all civilized societies reject. (Such as the 'right' to compel someone to donate their kidney if someone else needs it to live.)

The whole argument over whether a fetus does or doesn't have a right to life doesn't change the answer to the question of whether the mother has a right to personal bodily integrity that means she can remove the fetus if she doesn't want it there anymore. And in all civilized societies (except when it comes to abortion where we seem to have a moral blind spot) the right to bodily integrity trumps any right to life anyway.
 
Last edited:
Against individuals, all these rights require (if anything) is that they not infringe them. Your right to vote doesn't require any individual to do anything but not interfere with your voting -- it's the government that must have elections, count your vote, and so on. The right to habeas corpus doesn't require any private individual to do anything.

So in relation to some entities they don't apply, or are reduced to effectively negative rights. Doesn't change that much.

Also positive rights in relation to individuals exist too. Think a child and his/her parent. As long as that child is in your custody, you must feed him/her, you must take him/her to a doctor when sick, you must supervise him/her before a certain age, etc. Those are positive rights. Those are things you must do, not just not prevent the child from doing. I can pretty much guarantee to you that if you let a toddler die instead of taking him/her to a doc, taking the "well, I wasn't preventing him/her from going to a doctor" defense wouldn't really fly.

And that's where their argument goes off the rails. If a fetus had a positive right to life, that wouldn't require the woman to do anything, it would at most require the government or society to provide for the fetus if the woman refused. Even positive rights are not claims against individuals.

A positive right which isn't an obligation for _someone_ is an oxymoron. What you're trying to say there is that it's a negative right then.

It's not turning it into a positive right as they are otherwise used, it's converting it into something unlike any generally accepted right and more like the purported rights that all civilized societies reject. (Such as the 'right' to compel someone to donate their kidney if someone else needs it to live.)

Indeed we generally refrain from giving positive rights in relation to private persons, but nevertheless that's what they're turning it into.

But anyway, if the "positive right" idea derails it, let's just call it "obligation" and be done with it. That's what they're trying to handwave in.

I only introduced the distinction between "positive rights" and "negative rights", because such rhetoric tends to just use "right" and equivocate between the two meanings. They start from some "nobody will prevent you" kind of right and turn it into a "someone must provide it to you" kind of situation down the line. At some point you have to be able to say "that's not what that rights says", regardless of what words you use to emphasize the difference.

The whole argument over whether a fetus does or doesn't have a right to life doesn't change the answer to the question of whether the mother has a right to personal bodily integrity that means she can remove the fetus if she doesn't want it there anymore. And in all civilized societies (except when it comes to abortion where we seem to have a moral blind spot) the right to bodily integrity trumps any right to life anyway.

Yes, well, I agree with you there. In fact that's kind of the point I was getting at.
 
There's far too many people as it is without including ante-people in the mix.
 
So in relation to some entities they don't apply, or are reduced to effectively negative rights. Doesn't change that much.
In relation to all entities except the government.

Also positive rights in relation to individuals exist too. Think a child and his/her parent. As long as that child is in your custody, you must feed him/her, you must take him/her to a doctor when sick, you must supervise him/her before a certain age, etc. Those are positive rights. Those are things you must do, not just not prevent the child from doing. I can pretty much guarantee to you that if you let a toddler die instead of taking him/her to a doc, taking the "well, I wasn't preventing him/her from going to a doctor" defense wouldn't really fly.
The only example of this that you will find, other than very narrow 'emergency' examples, is parent/child. I would argue that it's an error to characterize this as 'positive rights' that the child has as opposed to obligations we impose on the parent.

But in any event, the slam-dunk argument against this is that this obligation can't possibly supercede a person's right to bodily integrity. No civilized society, for example, would compel a parent to donate a kidney even if it is the only way to save their child's life.

So you cannot argue that this justifies prohibiting abortion. You'd still have to argue that we should make abortion an exception to the way parental obligations normally work.

But this is the key -- if they want to make the argument, the only cases they can argue from are parent/child obligations or emergency obligations. A broad "right to life" doesn't do it.

A positive right which isn't an obligation for _someone_ is an oxymoron. What you're trying to say there is that it's a negative right then.
Positive rights are rights against the government. Essentially, they're what we expect a government to provide its citizens. Against individuals, they're just negative rights.

Indeed we generally refrain from giving positive rights in relation to private persons, but nevertheless that's what they're turning it into.
Sure, but then the argument still has to say abortion is an exception. -- So abortion should be prohibited because a fetus has a positive right to life that, unlike any other such right, imposes obligations on private parties that supercede their right to bodily integrity. -- Well, why?

But anyway, if the "positive right" idea derails it, let's just call it "obligation" and be done with it. That's what they're trying to handwave in.
Exactly. They use the notion of rights because everybody thinks they know what a "right to life" is. It sounds nice, and it's generally accepted uncritically.

I only introduced the distinction between "positive rights" and "negative rights", because such rhetoric tends to just use "right" and equivocate between the two meanings. They start from some "nobody will prevent you" kind of right and turn it into a "someone must provide it to you" kind of situation down the line. At some point you have to be able to say "that's not what that rights says", regardless of what words you use to emphasize the difference.
Exactly. And they analogize to other kinds of rights that are in no way analogous. They are nothing like rights against the government. They are nothing like negative rights.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom