SpuriusMaximus
Penultimate Amazing
- Joined
- Mar 2, 2009
- Messages
- 25,810
Because rights don't work that way. A right to life does not obligate someone else to support you or provide you with the means to live.
Technically that's inexact. There are two types of rights:
1. "Negative rights": You have a negative right to X, if nobody can forbid you to do X. Or sometimes it's put a "negative rights permit or oblige inaction". E.g., you have a right to live in that other people are forbidden to kill you. When it comes to terminating your life, the law/right says I should not act.
2. "Positive rights": which mean pretty much just that someone is expected or obligated to act in such a way that grants you that right. E.g., rights like "habeas corpus" are actually very much positive rights. It says that whoever has you in custody and the legal system _must_ do something when asked to.
Ditto for, say, the right to vote (someone has to provide you with all it takes to exercise that right), the right to seek remedy for having your rights violated, the right to an education (at least the version from the Universal Declaration Of Human Rights implicitly says that someone must give you that), etc.
So, yes, rights can exist where someone is actually obligated to act as to give you that right.
If you accept, for example, that a fetus has a full right to live, the strongest conceivable argument you could make based on that is that if the fetus was viable without its mother, the mother wanted to remove it, and someone else wanted to provide for the fetus' needs at their own expense, the mother was obligated to remove the fetus in such a way that the other person could keep it alive. It's just like I can fire you from your job, even if that means you'll starve to death. But I can't lock you inside my factory if you wish to leave.
But that's actually the kind of thing I'm getting at. The pro-lifers at least are turning it de facto into a positive right. The debate against abortion isn't trying to turn it into a "ok, if anyone wants to keep the foetus alive, they should be able to get it", but in something where they force a woman to carry that foetus.
They're not using the usual "right to life" which only says, basically, "thou shalt not kill your patient... but can still refuse to give him a place in your hospital, if he can't pay", but rather into something where someone has to do everything to keep it alive, including grant it use of her own body. Which is already turning it into a positive right.