When does a human foetus have a right to life?

I would like to encourage women to choose. I know I thought differently in the past, but after analysing the topic and noticing that unwanted kids are usually really mistreated, also, that the world is growing too small for all of us, also, that the bigger number of people the bigger ammount of cheer ignorance, and mostly, that religious people consider a virtue to have a family as big as possible (yes, they want to outnumber us), I think to choose to abort when you can't/ don't want to have a children should be legal everywhere.

Why can't a couple decide to undo a mistake they did? Tons of lifes, mostly teenagers lifes, are wasted because of young pregnancy.
 
I always liked the good old question:

You are in a room in a clinic that is on fire. There is a 6 year old kid lying to your left. There is a jar with 100 fetuses to your right. You can only save one. Which do you grab?

Depends on how hungry I am at the time.
 
No it isn't. There are actual medical benefits for the mother (which makes sense), and the argument is faulty, since it does not even get there by its own will or strength or instinctual desire (or whatever you would like to call it).
And I have yet to hear of a parasite where the host provides 50% of the parts. I would be happy to be corrected, if you can show me another example.

The only medical benefits that I know of are as a result of the suppliments you have to take to sustain both you and the parasite. Seriously, I am interested in finding out benefits caused by the actual pregnancy.
 
When the mother decides to have it. It's nobody else's business.
 
Last edited:
Can anyone logically defend the supposition that it has a "right to life" at all?

I'll give it a shot.
We live in a broad society where each of our interests is protected by a number of factors, but overall, a certain level of reciprocity is pretty key. I don't go around stealing stuff because I don't want to help create a world in which stealing stuff is considered acceptable, since it would be far less stable for my interests. The same goes for killing, etc.

This is not just abstract, formalized and organic means have arisen where feedback happens in real time. Think of all the situations in which you might kill someone. You may be in a war, in which case, automatically people are trying to kill you. You may be in a gang and participating in murders through that, in which case, rival gangs and the police are after you.

Now, if I induced an abortion in someone who loved and wanted to keep heir child, where does that fit in? I've taken something away from them, so suddenly I'm on their crap list. I'm also on the crap list of everyone who agrees with them that they don't want to live in a society where such things are routinely taken away, and that list happens to include law enforcement.

There are a number of people who have the same feeling about fetuses that are in other people's wombs. All attachment is emotionally based, so this isn't really more or less rational than their attachment to their own fetuses (Although it is less inevitable since attachment to one's own fetus is chemically, conceptually and biologically more reinforced)

TL;DR Fetuses and everything else has rights because enough people think they do.If enough people drop that belief, that right disappears.
 
Currently the limit on abortion in the UK is set at 24 weeks because the state of medical technology makes it unlikely for foetuses of younger gestational age to survive. This appears to be the point where a human foetus is considered to have a right to life (but still less than the mother's right to life).

What if in the future technology advanced so that foetuses of much younger gestational age could survive outside the womb. Would and/or should the limit on abortion be correspondingly reduced?

I don't think so. But then I think that the authority to make the decision of whether or not to abort should belong to the person/people who must shoulder the responsibility of caring for the child until adulthood.
 
Even if a foetus is considered a parasite, I'm not sure why that means it cannot or should not have a right to life given to it at some point in its development.

I wouldn't concede that point.

I think that people should choose on their own, and they need enough time to detect the pregnancy within reason and enough time to think about how it affects their life, and finally what to do about it. As long as those conditions are met, it's reasonable.
 
Currently the limit on abortion in the UK is set at 24 weeks because (blah blah)
What if in the future technology advanced so that foetuses of much younger gestational age could survive outside the womb.
I think that current technology should be enough to sustain the life of much younger fetuses, the point is that we don't invest immense resources and personnel for it. In future we might learn to feed sperm and egg cells with the correct nutrition, so that would make all the billions of them potential survivors.

My stance on this issue is less technological and more historical: I see no problem in the Spartan way of choosing on the day of birth whom to nurse and whom to throw down the cliff. Which is an instant and painless way to die, by the way. Modern humans have an obsession to nurse with latest technology babies that never had the genes to survive in the first place.
 
Last edited:
Yes. I think so. But I am dead against abortion anyway, except for medical grounds and rape. I know, this is rather an unpopular position.
I will not tell others not to abort if they wish, but it would not be an option if I was the father of the child. My wife has the exact same stance, so even if she would become "accidentally" pregnant, we would not abort.


Your position shouldn't be unpopular at all among people who believe that a woman should have the right to make the choice for herself.

You are against abortion personally but will not try and force your beliefs on others. I'm staunchly pro-choice and I find your position very reasonable.
 
Currently the limit on abortion in the UK is set at 24 weeks because the state of medical technology makes it unlikely for foetuses of younger gestational age to survive. This appears to be the point where a human foetus is considered to have a right to life (but still less than the mother's right to life).

What if in the future technology advanced so that foetuses of much younger gestational age could survive outside the womb. Would and/or should the limit on abortion be correspondingly reduced?

I would think if you could nuture the foetus outside the womb it wouldn't be abortion to do so. Or have I mis-understood you?

Now you have the question what right to life does a foetus have in an artificial womb. You could claim it's right to life is absoulte in an artifical womb since no other person's life is affected by its development.
 
Your position shouldn't be unpopular at all among people who believe that a woman should have the right to make the choice for herself.

You are against abortion personally but will not try and force your beliefs on others. I'm staunchly pro-choice and I find your position very reasonable.

Thank you! :)
 
There are thousands of frozen embryos in storage all over the world. If we grant a fetus rights, should we also grant it the right not to be imprisoned? Shouldn't we be implanting these embryos back into the mother so they can be free?
 
I always liked the good old question:

You are in a room in a clinic that is on fire. There is a 6 year old kid lying to your left. There is a jar with 100 fetuses to your right. You can only save one. Which do you grab?

You grab the jar.

Then the mustard. Send the kid off for the buns.
 
Yes. I think so. But I am dead against abortion anyway, except for medical grounds and rape. I know, this is rather an unpopular position.
I will not tell others not to abort if they wish, but it would not be an option if I was the father of the child. My wife has the exact same stance, so even if she would become "accidentally" pregnant, we would not abort.

Looking at it from the fetal perspective, what does it care if it is the planned product of a loving relationship or the result of a violent rape?
 
Looking at it from the fetal perspective, what does it care if it is the planned product of a loving relationship or the result of a violent rape?

Simple really.

Rape babies are people but they make us uncomfortable, and therefore don't have the same right to live as people without that original sin.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom