What's wrong with this definition of God: maker of heaven and earth and everything?

I am inviting you to think with me on the default status of being: existence or non-existence, and explain ourselves.

Gibberish. If you live you exist in a state of being. Tell me which bit of that you don't understand and I'll try and help you. Why should we have to explain ourselves? Explain ourselves to you? Agatha already answered your question, didn't you notice?
 
Last edited:
I already answered your question in post #2207. Here is the relevant part again with the answer highlighted for you:



It's quite rude for you to accuse people of running away from challenges when your questions have been answered, but you have simply failed to read the thread to find such answers.

Cheeky too, considering that Yrreg never answers questions. Yrreg, do you agree with my definition of gods? If not, why not?
 
That is the trouble with atheists, they have a very limited horizon.


Here, read what I was into when I said that a pilot can fly straight upward from the North Pole above it to farther north in the sky.




Now, what I would like to invite atheists here is to work together to find out what is the psychological smugness of the guy who poses the rhetorical question:
"What lies north of the North Pole?​
aside from betraying his narrow outlook of the whole span of existence man should be oriented to, which is typical of atheists, they put themselves in a dungeon and want everyone else to join them inside and never get out.

And then also I would like to invite atheists here to work with me to find out what is the point of reference of man's existence in the universe for themselves -- you guys atheists?



Yrreg
You're still wrong. The celestial pole is a line, and an imaginary one at that. Once you're there, on that line, you're exactly as far north as you can ever go. You may, in celestial pole terms, not go away from the north if you go straight up, but you will never get any further north. Even when you look up the explanations you still get it wrong. Time to give it a rest.
 
Okay, very good Agatha, you can think, now let's get going.

[...]

To your question (the first time you have asked me to my recollection, so why "again" I do not know) - 'being' and 'existence' have the same meaning in English, so I'm not clear what you are asking. Perhaps you could rephrase the question in a way which makes a little more sense?



Okay, very good Agatha, you can think, now let's get going.


The question is what is the default status of being: existence or non-existence, and explain.


First, we work together to come to our concurring concept of what is it to be the default status of something.

Like for example, you are a woman and if I may assume perhaps a mother also, anyway you know what is a mother.

Now, we ask ourselves from our experience and the experience of mankind, what is the essential nature of a mother, so that she can be an office worker, an actress, a corporate executive, a beauty parlor worker, a scientist, etc., but when we push her reset button, voilà, she is a mother above anything else.

Get that?

So, what is the default status of being: existence or non-existence, and explain.

Think of another word/concept of existence as of non-existence, a singular noun or better pronoun in a way paradoxically a concrete pronoun.

[ You might have to correct me about nouns and pronouns what they are and if the ones I am referring to can be concrete ones. ]



Yrreg
 
Okay, very good Agatha, you can think, now let's get going.


The question is what is the default status of being: existence or non-existence, and explain.


First, we work together to come to our concurring concept of what is it to be the default status of something.

Like for example, you are a woman and if I may assume perhaps a mother also, anyway you know what is a mother.

Now, we ask ourselves from our experience and the experience of mankind, what is the essential nature of a mother, so that she can be an office worker, an actress, a corporate executive, a beauty parlor worker, a scientist, etc., but when we push her reset button, voilà, she is a mother above anything else.

Get that?

So, what is the default status of being: existence or non-existence, and explain.

Think of another word/concept of existence as of non-existence, a singular noun or better pronoun in a way paradoxically a concrete pronoun.
[ You might have to correct me about nouns and pronouns what they are and if the ones I am referring to can be concrete ones. ]
A prime example of Yrregspeak. Totally devoid of meaning. Can we get back on topic? I don't agree with your definition of god,what is your opinion of my definition of gods? The highlighted part is sheer gibberish.
 
Last edited:
...what is the default status of being: existence or non-existence, and explain.


Why do you keep asking this question? It's been pointed out to you several times that it doesn't make any sense.
 
Existence has been encrusted by atheists with a lot of distractions, but press the...

Originally Posted by yrreg

And along the way, please contribute to my collection of stupid [sorry] foolish slogans of atheists, who feel that they have thought enough with rote memorizing of sour slogans, from their fellow masters of deceit who stumble blindly....
​
Going for a mod ban instead of responding to the request for clarification, are you, yrreg? Not the best way to conduct a discussion, but the insults you type are your responsibility.

You ask:
What is the default situation of being, existence or non-existence?
​

As being and existence are synonyms, the question is poorly phrased. Non-existence would be the same as non-being, so obviously anyone would say that the answer is existence. Why do you ask? Do you recognise that being and existence are synonyms?
__________________
People assume that time is a strict progression of cause to effect, but actually, from a non-linear, non-subjective viewpoint - it's more like a big ball of wibbly wobbly... timey wimey... stuff.
Last edited by Agatha; Today at 05:58 AM. Reason: Add the quote as the thread is moving quickly


Existence has been encrusted by atheists with a lot of distractions, but press the reset button and it will come up clearly that there is always something.

Now, I ask you, is it to your thinking that there is always something and that is the default status, or are you subscribing to the desperate tack of atheists today who now go into the default status of existence as nothing?

Because they are now into telling mankind that there was nothing then something came forth and that is the universe.


Okay, to be brief, think and answer: Has there always (always here is both a logical always and a chronological always) been something instead of nothing.

You are to choose between something and nothing as the all complete total absolute indispensable explanation for existence.


And don't forget since you are a woman and perhaps mother also, about the reset button for you to get back to mother status when you forget your essential nature of being a mother, that is an illustration of what I mean by default status.




Yrreg
 
Oh dear. Yrreg is confusing evidence with questions

QUESTIONS ARE NOT EVIDENCE.

Step 1: Assert a position
Step 2: Produce evidence

Rinse, lather repeat
 
Okay, to be brief, think and answer: Has there always (always here is both a logical always and a chronological always) been something instead of nothing.

I'm not used to these abstruse cosmological terms, but I'll have a go. Since t==0 there has been something, but something can be nothing and nothing can be something but nothing is sometimes something when nothing is sometimes nothing and sometimes nothing is nothing except when it's something, but only sometimes.
 
Last edited:
And Gee, just let me know when you are going to bring up the evidence card again, and I will challenge you again to work with me to concur on what is evidence.


No. I will challenge you to actually understand the many clear explanations that have already been provided. Everyone else here already concurs. As I said before, any failure to concur belongs to you.
 
Okay, very good Agatha, you can think, now let's get going.

The question is what is the default status of being: existence or non-existence, and explain.
As being and existence are synonymous (words which mean the same thing), I have already answered and explained: something which is in a state of being is by definition in a state of existence.

we work together to come to our concurring concept of what is it to be the default status of something.
Not everything has just one simple default state, especially when you are talking of complex organisms such as human beings. For example, my usual default state at this time of night in my time zone is to be asleep. In the morning my default state will be to be awake. I think that the concept you are working towards is not best expressed by the phrase "default status".

Like for example, you are a woman and if I may assume perhaps a mother also, anyway you know what is a mother.
I see no particular reason why you would be quite so creepy and personal, but yes I do have children.

Now, we ask ourselves from our experience and the experience of mankind, what is the essential nature of a mother, so that she can be an office worker, an actress, a corporate executive, a beauty parlor worker, a scientist, etc., but when we push her reset button, voilà, she is a mother above anything else.
Sadly this is not universally true; in the first place humans do not have a reset button and in the second place not all mothers display mothering characteristics at all times. Hence the number of women who have committed crimes of abuse, neglect and even murder against their children. Fewer than the numbers of fathers, I believe, but that is a derail.

Get that?
Get what? That you seem to have a one-dimensional, patriarchal and outdated view of humans? Yes, I got that.

So, what is the default status of being: existence or non-existence, and explain.
Again? OK, as being and existence (sorry it's tiresome putting in UBB code on my phone, or would have italicised those) are synonymous, so if something is in a state of being it is by definition in a state of existence. What is there to explain? It's just two words which mean the same.

Think of another word/concept of existence as of non-existence, a singular noun or better pronoun in a way paradoxically a concrete pronoun.
This is another nonsensical sentence, and your lack of fluency in English makes it difficult for any reader to determine what you are asking. If you want another synonym for existence, I am sure you can find an online thesaurus, and it would be easier for you to consult such a site than me, given that I am typing on my phone rather than on my laptop.

[ You might have to correct me about nouns and pronouns what they are and if the ones I am referring to can be concrete ones. ]
A noun is a 'naming word', names of things, places or people or concepts. An abstract noun is naming a concept rather than a thing, place or person. Aconcrete noun is a word for something tangible, something that you can see, smell, touch ir taste. A pronoun is a word like 'you' or 'she' or 'him'. Pronouns can be subject or object pronouns depending on what part of a sentence they are in. While I am at it, a verb is a 'doing word' which describes action of some sort ( the verbs "be" and "exist" describe the action of existence). Adverbs modify verbs, and adjectives modify nouns. So 'purple' is an adjective, and 'clearly' is an adverb. Does that help with any confusion you may have about the English language and parts of speech?

To get back to your request for another word which is synonymous with existence, I will have to let you look that up as I can't easily on my phone.

I am not running away from your questions but going to bed, as my default state at after half past midnight is to be asleep.

If you have more questions, please can you attempt to put them in clear language rather than the jumble of words you've used above. It is the duty of the writer to phrase things clearly, not the duty of the reader to disentangle clauses, sub-clauses and malapropisms.
 
Existence has been encrusted by atheists with a lot of distractions, but press the reset button and it will come up clearly that there is always something.

Now, I ask you, is it to your thinking that there is always something and that is the default status, or are you subscribing to the desperate tack of atheists today who now go into the default status of existence as nothing?

Because they are now into telling mankind that there was nothing then something came forth and that is the universe.
Okay, to be brief, think and answer: Has there always (always here is both a logical always and a chronological always) been something instead of nothing.

You are to choose between something and nothing as the all complete total absolute indispensable explanation for existence.


And don't forget since you are a woman and perhaps mother also, about the reset button for you to get back to mother status when you forget your essential nature of being a mother, that is an illustration of what I mean by default status.
Please refrain from personalising this, it's rude and rather creepy.

In reference to the part I have highlighted, this is a strawman on your part as nobody has said that there was nothing and then there was something. What people have said, several times, is that as far as we can tell with science's current understanding, time started (this is called t=0) at the beginning if the universe. The entirety of the matter which comprises the universe was in existence at that point. This is a gross simplification but it's late here and you can read about it on this site: http://www.ugcs.caltech.edu/~yukimoon/BigBang/BigBang.htm

ETA The Catholic Church agrees that the big bang theory is the best explanation for our universe, which might help you accept the explanation.
 
Last edited:
See, every reader here, Agatha can't think, she dares not accept my challenge.

Here is my invitation again, and forgive me for embarrassing you because I love all women: they are the mothers of mankind i.e. humanity which embraces women of course.

I am inviting you to think with me on the default status of being: existence or non-existence, and explain ourselves.


Dear readers here, she will again slip away from that challenge.


And everyone else here who can think, please let us work together to resolve the issue, what is the default status of being etc.



Yrreg

The default status of being is that it exists. Although some people would argue that one can exist without being, one cannot be without existing, because the definitions of being and existence are, though not quite identical, tautological that way. Wow, that was some hard hard philosophy there. I feel like A.J. Ayer reborn!

I'm not sure about etcetera though. The status of that is somewhat varied.
 
Because they are now into telling mankind that there was nothing then something came forth and that is the universe.

No. No, no, no, no... NO!

There wasn't "nothing" before the universe. There is no evidence that there is even a such thing as "before the universe". There is no time on the beyond the Big Bang. Time does not go on and on forever behind us. There is no need to explain how the universe could have "come forth from nothing" because there is no indication that this ever happened.
 
No. No, no, no, no... NO!

There wasn't "nothing" before the universe. There is no evidence that there is even a such thing as "before the universe". There is no time on the beyond the Big Bang. Time does not go on and on forever behind us. There is no need to explain how the universe could have "come forth from nothing" because there is no indication that this ever happened.

Oh FSM, we'll be back to what is north of the north pole again.
 
Aristotle solved this with his law of immutablility. For god to be perfect he cannot do anything. Of course this is above my pay grade.
 
To tell the truth, I'm so sick of people's ideas of a god on these threads, they are all so simple and childish.


Paul


:) :) :)

This thread is a prime example. I'm not bored with it yet, I can't wait to see what Yrreg comes up with next.
 
due to a recent spat of bad behavior, this thread is now set to Moderated status. It will be cleaned out and MAY come off after that is complete. Do not start new threads or post about this topic in other threads to circumvent this status.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: kmortis
 
Anyway.

I hate to say this, but Loss Leader is here and he has not reacted to my charges.


Now that you zooterkin bring up evidence again, I invite you to dialog with me on evidence: what is it, what is its target, and how it operates to hit its target.

Perhaps Loss Leader will take up my invitation to work with me hopefully this time without looping and retracting his words and thoughts, on a second round of my project to seek agreement with atheists on concepts in re God debate.



Yrreg

I see you still haven't learned how to debate people in a concise and respectful manner. You should also stop lying about people retracting their words because you haven't proved that at all.
 
Anyway.

I hate to say this, but Loss Leader is here and he has not reacted to my charges.


Now that you zooterkin bring up evidence again, I invite you to dialog with me on evidence: what is it, what is its target, and how it operates to hit its target.

Perhaps Loss Leader will take up my invitation to work with me hopefully this time without looping and retracting his words and thoughts, on a second round of my project to seek agreement with atheists on concepts in re God debate.



Yrreg

I wasn't talking to you.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom