What will be the result of the Israeli attacks on Gaza?

What will the Israeli strikes on Gaza accomplish?

  • Hamas will not stop the rockets and will begin suicide attacks in Israel.

    Votes: 20 46.5%
  • Hamas will stop the rockets but launch suicide attacks in Israel.

    Votes: 5 11.6%
  • Hamas will continue the rocket attacks.

    Votes: 13 30.2%
  • Hamas will stop the rocket attacks and seek a cease-fire.

    Votes: 5 11.6%

  • Total voters
    43
  • Poll closed .
Palestinian woman and Children, also men that are not terrorists.

i dont agree about nuking civillian citys.
How about just fire bombing cities? You appear to have this odd view about what war is. It is life or death for the parties involved. If you are not in it to win then either quickly surrender OR don't start a chain of events you have no intention of carrying out. The I/P conflict is probably the longest war of attrition in modern history and it is because, so far, one side doesn't have the means ie, the Palestinians or the resolve ie. the Israelis to put an end to it once and for all. It is neither humane or rational to keep kicking the can down the road for the next generation to deal with.

There is another resolution and it has been on the table for years and that is for the Palestinians to finally decide that Israel is a legitimate state and start to build their own country. The entire world would pour almost unlimited resources into helping them do just that.
 
Bickering moved to AAH. Please keep it civil, and on topic.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: chillzero
 
Well those pulling for the Palestinians had better hope that does not end up being the case because in a one state solution it will be Israel as the last man standing. Israel could wipe out every Palestinian in 48 hours even without nukes.

If you had bothered to read the OP of the other thread you responded in, you would know that this is what Olmert thinks about the one-state solution:

http://www.haaretz.com/hasen/spages/929439.html

Haaretz said:
"If the day comes when the two-state solution collapses, and we face a South African-style struggle for equal voting rights (also for the Palestinians in the territories), then, as soon as that happens, the State of Israel is finished," Prime Minister Ehud Olmert told Haaretz Wednesday, the day the Annapolis conference ended in an agreement to try to reach a Mideast peace settlement by the end of 2008.

"The Jewish organizations, which were our power base in America, will be the first to come out against us," Olmert said, "because they will say they cannot support a state that does not support democracy and equal voting rights for all its residents."

There is not another nation on earth that would exhibit the restraint Israel has shown. Whether that is a strength or weakness on Israel's part is yet to be determined. History is against it though.

1) Britain showed much more restraint than Israel. And I know, you will say that our "troubles" were nothing like Israel's. Well, D'uh! That's because we didn't escalate them to those high levels. Even when the IRA hit a hotel where Thatcher was staying. (And Norman Tebbit, see below).

Many British governments swore they would not negotiate with the IRA. Sinn Fein were not allowed to speak on TV -- their voices had to be dubbed. Crazy.

So crazy it couldn't go on. Talks happened. Change happened. And we haven't had an IRA bomb in a long time.

You may think that peace with the IRA was a simple matter. That it was natural for them to stop bombing. They're european terrorists, after all -- so much more reasonable.

Perhaps you should meet with Norman Tebbit. I have sympathy for his views. But I am glad his views did not stand in the way of peace.

http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/uk_politics/4344461.stm
(From 2005)

Former Tory chairman Lord Tebbit has attacked Tony Blair for suggesting the Tories are soft on terror while himself making "no move" against the IRA.

[...] Lord Tebbit was among 34 people wounded in the 1984 attack which killed five.

[...] Lord Tebbit, whose wife Margaret was paralysed, told the newspaper the IRA had killed more British people than al-Qaeda killed Americans in the 11 September attacks.

He said: "Considering Blair is the man who let out of prison a whole battalion of murderers, including the man that crippled my wife, that nearly killed me and murdered my friends, I find it difficult to take his claims seriously."

"I feel a sensation of nausea that a man so detached from reality and truth could be the prime minister of this country."

And a more personal statement from the same year:
http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/uk_politics/4727129.stm

I would probably illustrate the point better with statements from the 80's and 90's. But they're never on the frontpage of google.


2) you say History is against Israel. What do you mean? That the methods Israel has chosen hardly ever win?
 
Last edited:
How about just fire bombing cities? You appear to have this odd view about what war is. It is life or death for the parties involved. If you are not in it to win then either quickly surrender OR don't start a chain of events you have no intention of carrying out. The I/P conflict is probably the longest war of attrition in modern history and it is because, so far, one side doesn't have the means ie, the Palestinians or the resolve ie. the Israelis to put an end to it once and for all. It is neither humane or rational to keep kicking the can down the road for the next generation to deal with.

There is another resolution and it has been on the table for years and that is for the Palestinians to finally decide that Israel is a legitimate state and start to build their own country. The entire world would pour almost unlimited resources into helping them do just that.

so the whole conflict is the fault of only one side?
accordig to your ideology it is Israels fault, they didnt finish their jop in the war and erase the palestinians from the map, or not?
 
If Hamas had the power, there would be no Israel and there would be peace. Decisive victories bring peace. Stalemates, standoffs, ceasefires, and middle east peace treaties are recipes for continued violence.

As demonstrated by the collapse of the Israeli peace deals with Egypt and Jordan. Oh, wait...
 
Sounds like you agree with Hamas following it's present course of action.
That is an interesting point. It may be one I would agree with. As of today Hamas has brought a knife to an F16 fight. The knife has done some damage to Israel but Isreal can failry easily destroy Hamas completely should it have the will to do so. That is the decision the leaders of Israel are struggling with now. They can either simply hurt Hamas of kill it once and for all.If they only hurt Hamas and then revert to the status quo then given enough time Hamas can come back with a gun and then later with a guided missile and then later with chemical weapon until Israel has lost its advantage of overpowering military superiority. But if Hamas is killed now it will be far less bloody and far more likely that a peace process can be achieved. So maybe I am urging Hamas to continue poking Israel with its knife.
 
That is an interesting point. It may be one I would agree with. As of today Hamas has brought a knife to an F16 fight. The knife has done some damage to Israel but Isreal can failry easily destroy Hamas completely should it have the will to do so.

Fairly easy? About as easy as NYC exterminating all the rats. In fact, it would require similar tactic.
 
Fairly easy? About as easy as NYC exterminating all the rats. In fact, it would require similar tactic.
That is true. But it would be closer to methods used by the allies in WW2.
 
Last edited:
Looks like "Texas" and "DrBaltar" won't be satisfied with anything less than a Palestinian equivalent of the Hama massacre. Jesus.
1. It worked.

2. Haffez Assad was left alone after he did that, wasn't he? No Hague trial for him, eh?

3. Does it begin to sound to you like Milosevic got a raw deal? :p

4. Dr Baltar says that which you fear: that the only solution may be by blood and iron. What woo is this that you follow, what unreasoned belief that conflict must needs only be solved by bloodless means?

The significant downside to his proposal is political, and profoundly important. Once such a bloodletting is complete, it can't be undone, and the sun rises the next day. Play is continuous. Can Israel survive politically if that is the case? My guess is that in Tel Aviv, the answer is: no. If it were "yes" they'd probably do it.

DR
 
Last edited:
The significant downside to his proposal is political, and profoundly important. Once such a bloodletting is complete, it can't be undone, and the sun rises the next day. Play is continuous. Can Israel survive politically if that is the case? My guess is that in Tel Aviv, the answer is: no. If it were "yes" they'd probably do it.

I think I outlined that scenario a year ago.

(please no new discussions about accuracy in details. It was only meant as black humor)
 
1. It worked.

Yes, I know. That's why I mentioned it, as I suspect a similar amount of carnage would be necessary for Israel to win on the terms of certain posters here.

2. Haffez Assad was left alone after he did that, wasn't he? No Hague trial for him, eh?

Yes, but Syria was already a longtime international pariah in the eyes of the West. Israel isn't. If Israel were to become some rogue dictatorship there'd be no Hague trials either, until someone conquered them. What's that got to do with my post?

3. Does it begin to sound to you like Milosevic got a raw deal? :p

You mean his being tried for war crimes when Hafez al-Assad wasn't? It's not so much that Milošević got a raw deal as it is al-Assad getting out of jail free. But that's just because the jailers could never get to him in the first place.

4. Dr Baltar says that which you fear: that the only solution may be by blood and iron. What woo is this that you follow, what unreasoned belief that conflict must needs only be solved by bloodless means?

What kind of silly straw-man is this? And yes, I do "fear", by which I mean strongly disapprove of, wanton disregard for innocent lives, as I think most decent people do. That doesn't mean I don't think Israel has a right to defend herself.

The significant downside to his proposal is political, and profoundly important. Once such a bloodletting is complete, it can't be undone, and the sun rises the next day. Play is continuous. Can Israel survive politically if that is the case? My guess is that in Tel Aviv, the answer is: no. If it were "yes" they'd probably do it.

DR

Yes, exactly. Are "Texas" and "Doctor Baltar" even cognizant of these consequences? I doubt it.
 
Yes, but Syria was already a longtime international pariah in the eyes of the West. Israel isn't. If Israel were to become some rogue dictatorship there'd be no Hague trials either, until someone conquered them. What's that got to do with my post?




Yes, exactly. Are "Texas" and "Doctor Baltar" even cognizant of these consequences? I doubt it.
I clipped this part because it is so inaccurate. Since when has Israel NOT been an international Pariah? Name a single nation outside of the United States (for now), a single international body including the UN, a single "Human Rights Organisation" and a single member of Academia that does not consider Israel a rouge nation oppressing "helpless" Palestinians?
 
If you always do what you've always done.
then you will always get what you've always got.

What do I think?

More of what has happened for decades.

The specifics?

Who cares?
 
If you always do what you've always done.
then you will always get what you've always got.

What do I think?

More of what has happened for decades.

The specifics?

Who cares?

Agreed. Let them kill each other, for all I care. But do it without our (the United States') support for either side, of which there is all too much, imo.
 
I clipped this part because it is so inaccurate. Since when has Israel NOT been an international Pariah? Name a single nation outside of the United States (for now), a single international body including the UN, a single "Human Rights Organisation" and a single member of Academia that does not consider Israel a rouge nation oppressing "helpless" Palestinians?

Australia has a pretty good record of support for Israel's right to exist and its right to security.
 
As does Great Britain but it is fading.

And no-one knows why?

Except that RandFan is wrong:

If you always do what you've always done.
then you will always get what you've always got.

I think that things are changing.
Support for Israel is not what it was. This attack will not maintain the status quo.

Israel has suffered less in the last couple of years than Britain did during the worst of "the troubles". And, yes, Britain committed attrocities like Bloody Sunday. But never anything on the scale Israel has unleashed.

More people are seeing that.
 
I clipped this part because it is so inaccurate. Since when has Israel NOT been an international Pariah? Name a single nation outside of the United States (for now), a single international body including the UN, a single "Human Rights Organisation" and a single member of Academia that does not consider Israel a rouge nation oppressing "helpless" Palestinians?

For this half of year you can include EU.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom