What the Palestinians Really Want

What part of "Palestine is an Islamic Waqf consecrated for future Moslem generations until Judgement Day" makes you think non-Muslims will be allowed to live there?

Do you know what "waqf" means?

...............and waiting.
 
Sorry, but no and no.

There is no international law that says Palestinians are entitled to all the land on the other side of those borders.

There is international law saying that the land is not Israel's. Even East Jerusalem is considered occupied by international law. So too, still, is Gaza.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Palestinian_territories#Legal_status

If you want to split hairs and say this doesn't mean the land is Palestinian, then go ahead. It seems to me that you'll be arguing that the Palestinians come to the negotiating table with absolutely nothing. And I'm sure that isn't the way the international community see things.


What part of "Palestine is an Islamic Waqf consecrated for future Moslem generations until Judgement Day" makes you think non-Muslims will be allowed to live there?

Muslims inherit Palestine forever. That doesn't mean no-one else lives there. That would be obvious to anyone who has read the parts of the charter which speak of all religions living under the wing of Islam.



that's not exactly clear either.

how does one have annihilation and life at the same time?

It doesn't say at the same time. It says "He who accepts life without religion, has taken annihilation as his companion for life."

So, throughout your life, you walk hand in hand with annihilation. What that means I don't know. Maybe he doesn't believe that atheists get eternal life in hell, but that doesn't seem to fit with general Muslim belief.

No clues in googling the phrase. I only find the quote itself, not its original context. Here's wiki on the author:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Muhammad_Iqbal
 
Last edited:
...............and waiting.

A waqf is a permanently donated property, usually for a religious purpose. For instance, a plot of land may be donated by someone for the location of a mosque. The key elements of a waqf are that it is donated in perpetuity, and that it can never be inherited, sold, gifted, mortgaged, rented, lent out, or anything like that. Once donated for a specific purpose, it's to be used for that purpose, and only that purpose, forever.

So, when Hamas says in their charter that they want Palestine to be "an Islamic Waqf consecrated for future Moslem generations until Judgement Day", what they mean is that the land, all the land, of the whole territory of Palestine, is intended only to be used by Muslims, until the end of time, and can never be sold, rented, etc. to non-Muslims like, say, Jews, ever, because it's holy ground to Muslims akin to that of a mosque or Muslim cemetery.
 
Last edited:
So, when Hamas says in their charter that they want Palestine to be "an Islamic Waqf consecrated for future Moslem generations until Judgement Day", what they mean is that the land, all the land, of the whole territory of Palestine, is intended only to be used by Muslims, until the end of time, and can never be sold, rented, etc. to non-Muslims like, say, Jews, ever, because it's holy ground to Muslims akin to that of a mosque or Muslim cemetery.

that's nice, but you have no Hamas source for this stuff.

so when Hamas rules all of Palestine, NO non-Muslems will be allowed to reside there?

evidence please.
 
that's nice, but you have no Hamas source for this stuff.

so when Hamas rules all of Palestine, NO non-Muslems will be allowed to reside there?

evidence please.

Well, we can start here. And here. How about there? This is another one (might be a copy of one of the other links). A few zillion more similar quotes from the last 20+ years here.

Hope that helps. There is more where that came from -- lots, lots more, Mr. Hamas apologist.
 
Whatever you want to tell yourself. At the end of the day, it remains a pathetic, dishonest attempt at character assassination.

I disagree. Noting and reporting associations between groups, especially political groups, is completely legitimate. I think you don't like it because you understand the obvious conclusions people would draw, but I think that comes from being on the wrong side of the argument. Understanding how close groups such as the ISM or Atlanta Palestine Solidarity are to groups such as Hamas, PFLP, Hizballah, etc is helpful to understanding the issues, who is making what claims, and why.

What the hell does ISM have to do with this? :confused:

Oh come on, wouldn't you agree that Atlanta Palestine Solidarity was essentially a sub-group of the ISM? To me this seems like purposeful obfuscation, but if you think it's not, why not describe what you think the substantial differences are. To me it seems like making a distinction between a national political party and its local affiliate. Technically accurate, perhaps, but substantially irrelevant.
 
You didn't see any of my posts in that other thread, then?
I hope you're not a detective.

I read that thread and didn't see any arguments that are compelling. Obviously you feel there was something there that "won" the argument for your side, so why don't you pick that out and present it again?
 
Well, we can start here. And here. How about there? This is another one (might be a copy of one of the other links). A few zillion more similar quotes from the last 20+ years here.

Hope that helps. There is more where that came from -- lots, lots more, Mr. Hamas apologist.
I don't think Thunder would be convinced even if Meshaal visited him in his home and explained it to him over his kitchen table.
 
Israel is ultra capitalist?

How so?
I'm guessing it's because the place is run by Jews, and, well, you know how they are.

But yeah, it's hard for me to see how a country that pretty much eschews private land ownership and has an extremely generous social safety net, among other things, can be described as "ultra capitalist".
 
There is international law saying that the land is not Israel's. Even East Jerusalem is considered occupied by international law. So too, still, is Gaza.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Palestinian_territories#Legal_status

If you want to split hairs and say this doesn't mean the land is Palestinian, then go ahead. It seems to me that you'll be arguing that the Palestinians come to the negotiating table with absolutely nothing. And I'm sure that isn't the way the international community see things.

So you grudgingly admit that under international law it's not Palestinian or Israeli.

Nobody is saying Palestinians come to the table with nothing, surely you see that as both a straw-man and an argument from negative consequences.

The issue of what international law says about the status of the disputed territories has been addressed in these forums many times. Specifically, UNSCR 242.

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=2476799#post2476799

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?p=475909&highlight=caradon#post475909
 
I disagree. Noting and reporting associations between groups, especially political groups, is completely legitimate. I think you don't like it because you understand the obvious conclusions people would draw, but I think that comes from being on the wrong side of the argument. Understanding how close groups such as the ISM or Atlanta Palestine Solidarity are to groups such as Hamas, PFLP, Hizballah, etc is helpful to understanding the issues, who is making what claims, and why.

This is merely equivocating for the fact that it's an attempt to paint me as sympathetic with Hamas - ie, character assassination. Deal with it.

Oh come on, wouldn't you agree that Atlanta Palestine Solidarity was essentially a sub-group of the ISM? To me this seems like purposeful obfuscation, but if you think it's not, why not describe what you think the substantial differences are. To me it seems like making a distinction between a national political party and its local affiliate. Technically accurate, perhaps, but substantially irrelevant.
Uh....No, you're completely wrong here. APS was no more a "sub-group" of the ISM than it was a "sub-group" of the American Friends Service Committee or the American Arab Anti-Discrimination Committee.

But thank you for essentially admitting that your goal is to draw "associations" whether or not they are based in reality.

Pathetic.
 
Last edited:
I'm guessing it's because the place is run by Jews, and, well, you know how they are.

Yeah, Jews are either capitalists or communists, depending on which one you hate more.

But yeah, it's hard for me to see how a country that pretty much eschews private land ownership and has an extremely generous social safety net, among other things, can be described as "ultra capitalist".

Yeah, no private land ownership, public health care, kibbutsim (sp?) that are essentially communist in nature...by USA/Canadian standards it's a lot closer to Marx than to Friedman.
 
So you grudgingly admit that under international law it's not Palestinian or Israeli.

Nobody is saying Palestinians come to the table with nothing, surely you see that as both a straw-man and an argument from negative consequences.

The issue of what international law says about the status of the disputed territories has been addressed in these forums many times. Specifically, UNSCR 242.

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=2476799#post2476799

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?p=475909&highlight=caradon#post475909

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United...42#French_version_vs._English_version_of_text

"Withdrawal of Israel armed forces from territories occupied in the recent conflict"

That can be interpreted as some of the territories, rather than all. Fair enough. It is ambiguous. Strange how you don't see the same some/all ambiguity in the Hamas charter, even after other quotes are given which speak of Jews living under Islam. One would think such quotes would remove the ambiguity and clarify that only some Jews would be killed in the fighting.

Since that sentence from UN242 is ambiguous, you give some quotes in the linked thread on this ground:

So who cares what Eugene Rostow, Lord Caradon, and Arthur Goldberg think? Well, if you want to invoke UNSCR 242, you should. They’re the guys who wrote it.

But it kind of comes down to what people thought they were voting for, doesn't it? Rather than what the authors think they may have pulled.

As well as arguments for both sides, wiki has this quote: "We were likewise gratified to hear the United Kingdom representative stress the link between this paragraph of his resolution and the principle of inadmissibility of the acquisition of territories by force..." which seems to give a context to the ambiguous English.

That's in the section which compares the English/French translation. It seems to indicate what the French thought they were voting for.

ETA:
You should read the next section of the wiki article, too. It gives the statements of various representatives. eg: India "It is our understanding that the draft resolution, if approved by the Council, will commit it to the application of the principle of total withdrawal of Israel forces from all the territories - I repeat, all the territories - occupied by Israel as a result of the conflict which began on 5 June 1967"


BTW, wiki also says: "During a symposium on the subject Lord Caradon said that Israel was in clear defiance of resolution 242. He specifically cited the "annexation of East Jerusalem" and "the creeping colonialism on the West Bank and in Gaza and in the Golan.""

I thought you'd be interested in that, seeing as you value what the authors of 242 say.
 
Last edited:
What the Palestinians really want;

They want the same thing they've always wanted. The destruction of Israel. That's been the internal propaganda and pronouncements since forever. They know they can't defeat Israel militarily, or with terrorism so they're content to sit there stealing as much of the foreign aid as possible.

To foreigners who can't read Arabic, they'll tell you whatever you want to hear.

There's no solution until the Palestinians undergo a major shift in attitude. Until then, they'll just have to get used to it.
 
Last edited:
What the Palestinians really want;

They want the same thing they've always wanted. The destruction of Israel. That's been the internal propaganda and pronouncements since forever. They know they can't defeat Israel militarily, or with terrorism so they're content to sit there stealing as much of the foreign aid as possible.

To foreigners who can't read Arabic, they'll tell you whatever you want to hear.

There's no solution until the Palestinians undergo a major shift in attitude. Until then, they'll just have to get used to it.

Silly.
 
What the Palestinians really want;

They want the same thing they've always wanted. The destruction of Israel. That's been the internal propaganda and pronouncements since forever. They know they can't defeat Israel militarily, or with terrorism so they're content to sit there stealing as much of the foreign aid as possible.

To foreigners who can't read Arabic, they'll tell you whatever you want to hear.

There's no solution until the Palestinians undergo a major shift in attitude. Until then, they'll just have to get used to it.

you should make a thread in the CT section about that huge Conspiracy Theory.

:rolleyes:
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom