What is "The Pattern"?

So don't spend more than you earn. It's not complicated.

The problem is that politicians have this habit of spending too much, borrowing in my name (usually from private bankers who have cronies at the Fed, who in turn have the legal right to counterfeit and debase my currency), and then handing me a tax bill to service the interest. If I don't pay the taxes, big guys with guns come after me. So it's at least a little more complicated than your simple advice would indicate.
 
Last edited:
The problem is that politicians have this habit of spending too much, borrowing in my name (usually from private bankers who have cronies at the Fed, who in turn have the legal right to counterfeit and debase my currency), and then handing me a tax bill to service the interest. If I don't pay the taxes, big guys with guns come after me. So it's at least a little more complicated than your simple advice would indicate.

The above is accurate but not complete. Some politicians do try to spend only a reasonable amount, however they are removed at the elections by the people Tippit is referring to in the above post.
 
I keep getting investment emails about "the pattern" that is supposedly shaping up in virtually every sector of the economy (not just financial, but energy production, food production, etc) that supposedly points to a catastrophic collapse within the very near future.

I did some checking online about "the pattern", and I find a lot of reference TO it, but not what it actually is, nor anything about the theory behind it and/or the reliability of the analysis.

Supposedly, a team of economists and other experts have briefed the UN and various world leaders on the issue.

Typical article here: link

Does anyone know anything about the actual analysis behind "the pattern"?

I was able to find this video online about the situation, but I still don't know what to make of it: link

I am a sound money advocate. Everyone who has read any of my posts knows that. I am also very suspicious that inflation is as "tame" as the official numbers suggest (my grocery bill last week was up an average 10% over the previous week for the same basket of goods, with 3/4 of the items showing a price increase).

But this video seems to be saying that ALL of our economic systems are on the same knife edge and about to be pushed off.

The pattern is a "hockey stick", and it is appearing in numerous places at the same time, e.g. human population, debt, fiat money, fossil fuel consumption...

There is only one economic system. We live in a globalised world. The imminent crash is caused by two massive factors coming together. The first is an inherently unsustainable debt-based monetary system which has reached the point of unsustainability, and the second is peak oil (which itself is just the most important of a whole series of non-renewables which have peaked or will do so soon.)
 
How can it be everywhere at once?

Because all the occurrences are manifestations of the same underlying factor, and that is human population growth and/or total human consumption levels.

What causes "the pattern"?

Unlimited amounts of cheap energy have caused the pattern.

How can everything from energy production to food growing to economics all show the exact same thing?

Because there is only one system, and it is globalised.

And who are these experts who have studied this pattern? Has anyone else examined their methodology and conclusions?

Anyone who has the eyes to see should arrive at the same conclusion. There is only one possible outcome, and it is a major crash.
 
Is it the case that an exponential function has to collapse critically instead of changing to some other type of function?

Not necessarily, no. You have to examine the specific circumstances. And in this particular case, it has to collapse catastrophically. The reasons for this are political and psychological. There is no physical or logical reason why human civilisation could not make a transition to a sustainable civilisation, without the sort of catastrophe we are talking about happening. But it would require a cultural/political/psychological revolution that no realist can believe in.

Are there historical examples of this pattern in action -- I expect there must be many and my guess is that other factors come online to replace those that go off.

Yes, but previously the pattern was either localised (and so was the collapse that followed) or the resource in question turned out to be replacable after all (e.g. whale oil being replaced by crude "rock" oil.) What is different this time is that oil can't be replaced, but backing that claim up is a compicated business. A key thing to understand is EROEI, which is what Kev's graph is about. As we pass the peak, the whole dynamics of oil economics changes. There's still plenty of oil in the ground, but it gets more and more expensive/difficult to get hold of. This pushes up the price, which stifles economic growth. And eventually you get to the point where it takes a barrel of oil's worth of energy to get hold of a barrel of oil, and then the game is over.
 
Last edited:
How has this worked for other resources? For example, I assume at one time the US was land rich, in that supply greatly exceeded demand. In that scenario, land was an exploitable resource -- for example, free range cattle. Now that land is much less "freely available," how has that changed the market? Did it follow an exponential relationship and crash or did other things happen?

I don't know enough about history or economics to come up with a good example, but surely such things have been happening for some commodities as long as we've built industries on something easy and cheap.

So what actually happens?

While there are examples from history that can give us some clues, you have to understand that crude oil is a resource like no other. It is very energy-dense, has been easy to get hold of (until now), and can be turned into all sorts of other things. It is the ultimate fuel and the ultimate raw material. Money doesn't make the world go round; crude oil does.

If you take that into account, you should be able to see that nothing else can replace cheap oil. That's why we've ended up pursuing the insane policy of using food crops to make ethanol for fuel. All this has actually achieved is to delay the energy crisis for small time, while bringing forward the timetable for a global food crisis instead. The price/availability of oil and the price/availability of food are directly linked.
 
Yes, but previously the pattern was either localised (and so was the collapse that followed) or the resource in question turned out to be replacable after all (e.g. whale oil being replaced by crude "rock" oil.) What is different this time is that oil can't be replaced, but backing that claim up is a compicated business. A key thing to understand is EROEI, which is what Kev's graph is about. As we pass the peak, the whole dynamics of oil economics changes. There's still plenty of oil in the ground, but it gets more and more expensive/difficult to get hold of. This pushes up the price, which stifles economic growth. And eventually you get to the point where it takes a barrel of oil's worth of energy to get hold of a barrel of oil, and then the game is over.

I have a hard time thinking in global terms for a commodity. Why, for example, wouldn't you see some countries failing before others, and which countries are those? In other words, who has already fallen off the cliff? Surely there are countries not modeled on continuous expansion of their economy from cheap (oil-based) energy? I hate not knowing this stuff, so I'm going to guess one of the Scandinavian countries might be an example, or, maybe easier to find, a country that can't readily use cheap energy to grow their economy, maybe Afghanistan? I'll have to rely on others to shoot down my hunch or support it.

I am also curious as to why nuclear power isn't mentioned as an available alternative, if not to "cheap energy" (whatever that means, since 'cheap' is relative), at least as a long term, stable replacement for oil.

Then there's coal, natural gas and so on. It seems a bit too complicated to wedge into a simple graph. As catchy as the picture is, my guess is it's too cartoonish.

I did find this from Forbes: http://www.forbes.com/2008/07/03/en...iz-energy_cx_jz_0707efficiency_countries.html it's from 2008 and talks about how countries vary on energy efficiency stats. This makes me think the exponential nature of the graph can be directly attacked with conservation measures, although, without changing where energy comes from, any finite supply would eventually run out. It does argue against a catastrophic failure though. Countries that have to import energy do use less as a cost saving measure, and I don't see why this wouldn't happen in other places as prices rise.
 
Last edited:
I hope this is relevant.

Your post is more misleading than it is useful. I'm guessing from what you've posted that you have not looked into peak oil theory very deeply. They are typical misunderstandings from peak oil newbies.

People keep saying we are running out of oil. This statement is true. When the first drop of oil was removed from the Earth we started running out of oil, hence it says nothing. People have also been saying we have only a few years left of oil.

The people who say we are running out of oil are either being loose with their terminology, or don't understand peak oil. The statement is in fact FALSE. We are not running out of oil. We will never run out of oil. What we have already run out of is cheap oil.

Peak oil is the point of maximum production, the maximum flow-rate, and the point where the price of oil can no longer be controlled downwards by a cartel of producers (although they can still send it upwards if they choose.) Peak oil is the point at which growth in consumption of crude oil is necessarily replaced by a reduction, because of physical limits.

This has several problems.
1. The amount of oil that is known to exist is not published. So no one really knows the total amount of oil that has been discovered.

There are political reasons for this. However, we do have reasonably accurate estimates for the discoveries of major oil fields over the history of oil production globally.

2. The amount of oil that is undiscovered is unknown.

OK...time for basic peak oil theory.

Peak Oil theory was discovered/invented by M. King Hubbert, and it was based on a very simple observation: the larger an oilfield is, the easier it is to find. This is just the same as it being easier to find your opponent's battleship in a game of battleships. This holds true over any area - a single US state, the whole of the United States, or the whole world. And it means that all of the really big oilfields were discovered decades ago. The peak of discoveries of oil was over FORTY years ago. Since then we've been heading downhill, and when you hear these days of "big discoveries" you are not hearing about anything "big" in historical terms. In short...it may be true that we don't know exactly how much undiscovered oil there is, but it is also true that we know there are no major fields left to be found. Anywhere. All that is left is a "mopping up exercise."

3. As technology improves the the amount of oil that can be recovered from any one oil well keeps on going up.

Only marginally, and this makes the oil cost more.

4. As the price of oil goes up then the amount of effort that is worth expending to get more oil goes up, thus we can have more oil at a higher price.

Which stuffs us economically, because it stifles growth.

5. The demand for oil may not go up in the future as alternatives to oil start to be used.

Indeed. "Demand destruction" has already made a mockery of the price predictions of some major figures in the peak oil world. They simply did not understand how much economic havoc would be unleashed by the first major spike in oil prices (2008.)

In short no-one really knows what the price of oil will be in the future, nor how much will be available.

On the contrary, we can say with absolute certainty that the price of oil will stay as high as the economic collapse permits, and that the peak in consumption of conventional crude oil has already happened (in 2008.)

You could also say the same for a few other resources.

You could say it for inexhaustible resources...
 
Right.

Why Black Death? Wouldn't dinosaur extionction, but on humans, be sexier?

I have the perfect quote lined up for this...

http://www.newcolonist.com/ghawar.html

You're Invited to the Funeral

Measured up against the big scheme of things, the death of Ghawar and our oil-powered industrial civilization will fall somewhere between the Black Plague of 14th Century Europe and the meteor that wiped out the dinosaurs. Unlike the plague, this will effect humans world-wide, but unlike the meteor, it will effect only humans. Chickens may some day cross the road with impunity. Animals both large and small will prosper (Hey, you try whaling in a row boat!) And the earth will undoubtedly cool off a bit. Too bad we all won't be here to enjoy it.

With the death of Ghawar will undoubtedly come the deaths of humans. Many humans, it would seem, the result of probably unavoidable wars for the last remaining oil to the much-predicted pandemics and mass starvation. Estimates on the sustainable limit to humans on this planet have ranged from an utterly dismal 1/70th of the current population (about 100 million) to an almost cheerful (by comparison) two billion. Keep in mind there's six billion of us here right now, so some of you will have to leave. You'll stay for the funeral, though, won't you? I mean, after all, Ghawar is dying.
 
I have a hard time thinking in global terms for a commodity. Why, for example, wouldn't you see some countries failing before others, and which countries are those? In other words, who has already fallen off the cliff?

Well, it all depends on who has oil and who has access to oil. The only places which have "fallen off the cliff" so far are certain failed African states which were basket cases anyway. The closest to actually falling off happened in 2008 when the price of food got to the point where people in poor places who have no choice but to buy food at world prices couldn't afford to feed themselves anymore. The result was food riots in 27 countries. This is just a taste of what is to come.

Also important is something called the "export land model." Oil exporting nations tend to use as much oil as they want to fuel internal population booms, which end up consuming much of the previously-exported oi. That means that places like Saudi Arabia will stop being oil exporters much sooner than most people are expecting. It also means that they will be protected from falling off the cliff for longer than most other places, but will eventually arrive at the cliff edge bloated and completely unprepared. Contrast to somewhere like Cuba, which has been coping with oil shortages for many years already, or Greece, which will find itself in the same situation before very long.

Surely there are countries not modeled on continuous expansion of their economy from cheap (oil-based) energy?

Hmmmm. Apart from some very small islands and a couple of Himalayan principalities, the answer is no.

I am also curious as to why nuclear power isn't mentioned as an available alternative, if not to "cheap energy" (whatever that means, since 'cheap' is relative), at least as a long term, stable replacement for oil.

That's another very complicated debate. Part of the problem is that nuclear is not cheap at all. If you take in decommissioning costs then it is very expensive. Can we be certain our descendents will be in any sort of position to safely decommission them? Even if that wasn't a problem, there simply isn't enough recoverable uranium for the whole world to convert to nuclear power.

Nuclear can only help to soften the blow. It cannot provide a foundation for a new sort of industrialised civilisation. Although it is not impossible that somebody will figure out how to make a Thorium reactor work, and that does have the potential to change the game. This is some way off, though, if it is going to happen at all.

Then there's coal, natural gas and so on. It seems a bit too complicated to wedge into a simple graph.

Understanding this is about as complicated as it gets. I post regularly on the UK peak oil forum (powerswitch). The debates on that site are very wide-ranging, and often very in-depth. It's involves various branches of science, oil technology, economics, history, politics, anthropology and psychology, and even philosophy and religion. We are talking about the end of the world as we know it, and a unique turning point not only in human history but in the history of life on Earth. What is about to happen (has started happening) could and can only happen once. Even if humans were to end up wiping ourselves out, there will never again be oil and coal deposited on the scale they were during the carboniferous era. You would have to re-run evolution.
 
There is only one economic system. We live in a globalised world. The imminent crash is caused by two massive factors coming together. The first is an inherently unsustainable debt-based monetary system which has reached the point of unsustainability, and the second is peak oil (which itself is just the most important of a whole series of non-renewables which have peaked or will do so soon.)

Anyone who has the eyes to see should arrive at the same conclusion. There is only one possible outcome, and it is a major crash.

Not likely, given that a real collapse, on a scale not seen since the Black Death, is just around the corner.

:dl:
 
I'm willing to be convinced, but a graph does not a model make. A mathematical formula can describe something, but you have to show it applies -- it's not enough to say math proves something unless we can show the elements driving the equations are real and do what we say they do.

Can you clarify for the cheap seats?

If you really want to understand I cannot recommend watching the Martenson video I posted highly enough. he is a scientist, this is not Loose Change, not by a long way.

at the beginning, he poses a question to frame the "exponential" issue.

you are in a stadium, a massive arena, at the top, and he has handcuffed you to the railings. imagine he is down on the centre line, with a magic eye dropper, which when used to dispense one drop of water, it doubles every minute..

1min = 2 drops
2mins = 4 drops etc.
at 6 minutes you have a thimble-full.

so, starting at midday, how long do you have to escape the handcuffs and stadium before you drown?

obviously, given a known volume, this is calculable, but the answer might surprise you. .... 50 minutes.

but more importantly, at what time was the stadium still 97% empty space? (and hence nobody realised the seriousness of the predicament?)

..FIVE minutes earlier. that exponential speeding up is a bitch.

and the chart I posted is absolutely accurate, in terms of the crude oil supply picture EROEI curve.

forget $cost, ultimately its not important how many dollars a barrel costs, they print dollars, the fundamental force at play is EROEI.

when we first discovered and started pumping oil, we were getting 100+ to 1 energy returns from crude, all you had to do was stick a hole in the ground, and up it gushed. this dropped steadily through the 70's and 80's, and the new *miracle* discoveries with tar sands and shale etc are more like 3:1, we are starting to head down that slope fast.

and they would not be doing this stuff if there were better cheaper alternatives

think of the extra energy used to drill 26000 feet under the sea bed and pump this stuff up, and deliver it to land.

think about the extra energy involved in even making the extra machines, rigs etc needed for deepwater deep drilling, and to tow them out further and further with other ships.

or tar sands where they scoop up huge vats of gooey sand on monster mining machinery, and have to heavily process it to make it usable..

peak cheap oil is already past. fact.

the chart I showed is simply the oil EROEI supply story, it is not implying anything about demand, alternatives or anything else, only that if the last 40 years has been built on the back of this cheap energy, that the next 40 years will not be like the past.

there are alternatives to some uses of oil, but liquid fuels that run the food transport and distribution system worldwide are problematic, and require huge infrastructure investment, converting vehicles, gas stations and supply lines etc, that as usual will only ever start to happen after the problems are well advanced.

in the past, we have generally always been upgrading to better fuels, ie coal to oil, which was a huge bonus energy-wise and a whole new master resource that enabled a whole new world of possibilities.

it is critical however to understand the exponential function properly, did you know for example that in the last 23 years, we have burnt half of the total amount of oil ever pumped?

oil useage is accelerating and there is a finite production threshold. fact.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom