What is "Love" and why is there so much woo-woo around it ?

Joshua Korosi said:


Well wait...when I said "chemistry", I meant that after research, scientists could be able to say "this chemical reaction in the frontal lobe of the brain (for example) indicates the subject is experiencing what is commonly referred to as love". I already said earlier that it's unlikely (in my opinion) that science can quantify the exact causes of that chemical reaction. So when we stop loving somebody, science couldn't explain why; all they would be able to say is that the chemical process isn't occurring anymore.

Nor can it explain why we start loving someone. The reason being is that it has nothing to do with science. Science deals with the physical world only. It could only explain love if the world is physically closed ie if you think we're all robots where everything we ever do, including loving people, is determined by some algorithm.

So, what's it like to be a robot?
 
Interesting Ian said:


Nor can it explain why we start loving someone. The reason being is that it has nothing to do with science. Science deals with the physical world only. It could only explain love if the world is physically closed ie if you think we're all robots where everything we ever do, including loving people, is determined by some algorithm.

So, what's it like to be a robot?

Since you obviously agree with my point of view, why are you trying to initiate an argument? Just for the hell of it?
 
Interesting Ian said:

WOW! You really are stupid aren't you??
I really do love you, Interesting Ian.*


...this is the exact same argument you and I have had over defining consciousness. I won't derail this thread to do that all over again.

*edited to add...I mean this seriously, not sarcastically, in case it was unclear.
 
Mercutio said:
Oops--thanks for the correction--that will teach me to post seriously without my notes.

edited to add...having looked at your profile, it seems you would be a good person to get an opinion from on this matter. What do you think about this model? Is there another you prefer? Do you think the researchers are wasting their time? I look forward to your input.

I think this is a good model though any model is going to be incomplete and every relationship, particularly long-term ones are going to go through phases when the relationship will resemble one state more than another. I think also a problem with this model is perhaps that "consummate love" is something that many people expect to have throughout a long-term committed relationship and that's simply an unrealistic expectation. Another problem is the assumption that "sex" necessarily fits into the passion section of the model whereas its really that the sex of a long term couple in the companionate state would have a different quality than that of a newer couple possibly in romantic or fatuate love. This is also why I corrected your definition of "friendship" because companionate love encompasses more than friendship. Those are my thoughts on the subject of Sternberg's Triangular Model of Love.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom