What is "Love" and why is there so much woo-woo around it ?

Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: What is "Love" and why is there so much woo-woo around it ?

DanishDynamite said:
The term "love" has two major branches. One branch very much includes sexual attraction, the other doesn't.


{shrugs} Agape and eros. The word love in its proper sense is used in the agape sense.

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Are you saying my definition is incorrect?
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Not so much incorrect, just limited. In the English language, "love" means many things.

People use it to mean many things. I'm talking about the real definition.

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Whether we want to or not, we can't look at love in a scientific sense anymore than any other aspect of consciousness. And I care less than nothing at all that it means nothing in a scientific sense.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Of course we can look at love in the scientific sense. Love is pure science.

Simply contradicting me doesn't impress me.
 
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: What is "Love" and why is there so much woo-woo around it ?

Interesting Ian said:


As I say it is unfortunate that people use it so loosely. That doesn't mean to say the concept itself has an indefinite meaning! :eek:

I am not so sure about that. I think that it is a personal thing, Like calling something "Good" or "Bad". What is "good" to me might be totally indifferent or even "bad" to you. Likewise what may be "love" to one person might be viewed as lust to another and mere infatuation to a third. That's what I mean when I say the definition changes.

I see nothing particularly wrong with my definition.

Well why don't you give one then?

If you ask me to define "love" in general, I will freely admit that I am not up to the task. I am neither a philosopher nor a scientist, such work is in their realm (take your pick on which is more qualified) not that of a humble coder of accounting software. Entire books can be written on the subject ,and have been. Your definition works, in that sense, as well as any. For purposes of this discussion, though, I think a simpler but more concrete definition will suffice (though I will admit that I am not good at putting abstract concepts into words) "Whatever combination of thoughts, feelings and emotions one personally has toward one's wife/husband/boyfriend/girlfriend/whatever or potential wife/husband/boyfriend/girlfriend/whatever". That's the way I am taking it anyway. I'll admit though, that your definition sounds a lot more poetic. I may even steal it for use with my wife someday when I have gotten myself into big trouble. ;)
 
With my luck with skepchicks, I could teach a class on love...






...wait a minute, I already have (honest!). Of course one can examine love scientifically. There is a huge literature in social psychology on love. Rather than run to my bookshelf and start quoting, I'm going to watch this thread for a bit and see what you folk come up with...

just a couple of things, though.

1) If love is as important as we claim it is, doesn't it deserve scientific investigation?

2) Once you know the research behind love, and see what we can and cannot say with relative certainty about love, sex, intimacy, attachment, etc....I guarantee, it still makes you weak in the knees. Nothing (qualifier: for me, so far) that we know about love makes it one iota less powerful.
 
Mercutio said:
With my luck with skepchicks, I could teach a class on love...

...wait a minute, I already have (honest!).
Like they say, "those who can't -"
Sorry, I can't do it. This one is too obvious, even for me.
 
Mercutio said:
Of course one can examine love scientifically.

We most certainly cannot.

There is a huge literature in social psychology on love.

So what? If we cannot scientifically explain why consciousness exists, then a fortiori we will not be able to say anything about particular conscious states. The most you could conceivably study are the effects of love. Even then how could you ever know anyone is experiencing love? Recall my definition.


1) If love is as important as we claim it is, doesn't it deserve scientific investigation?

There's nothing science can say about it.
 
arcticpenguin said:

Like they say, "those who can't -"
Sorry, I can't do it. This one is too obvious, even for me.

*sigh*

et tu, waterfowl?:D

edited to add smiley...
 
Interesting Ian said:


We most certainly cannot.
Hmmm...we already do, which kinda puts a kink in yer hose, there...you may certainly quibble with operational definitions and such, but when you do so, you are engaging in part of the process of science. Certainly, there have been those who agree with you. A U.S. Senator, sen. Proxmire, gave a "golden fleece" award to some love researchers as a waste of government money.

So what? If we cannot scientifically explain why consciousness exists, then a fortiori we will not be able to say anything about particular conscious states. The most you could conceivably study are the effects of love. Even then how could you ever know anyone is experiencing love? Recall my definition.
Yeah, um, we've kinda been around the block a couple of times about consciousness, haven't we? Society defines love in much the same way as we define consciousness--that is, poorly. One of the biggest challenges of a scientific approach to love is operationalization. This is, of course, a legitimate complaint; you may operationalize love very differently from me. However, this is par for the course in scientific investigation, and we can expect to converge on better and better definitions (although, by definition, no operational definition will ever be perfect) of love.

There is no a priori reason to think that this particular subject should prove immune to scientific inquiry. If love is special, then we will be unable to find empirical trends. The proof of the pudding is in the tasting--the proof of a scientific investigation of love is in the results. We have found useful information. (BTW, none of the useful information involves the planets Venus and Mars--if anyone thinks that psychology's study of love is best reflected in Gray's work, please please please think again.)

There's nothing science can say about it.
Close. There is nothing science can say about it that interesting ian will listen to would probably be closer to the truth. There is quite a lot that science can say about it that you will ignore. Such is life.
 
Mercutio said:
Hmmm...we already do, which kinda puts a kink in yer hose, there...you may certainly quibble with operational definitions and such, but when you do so, you are engaging in part of the process of science. Certainly, there have been those who agree with you. A U.S. Senator, sen. Proxmire, gave a "golden fleece" award to some love researchers as a waste of government money.
Yeah, um, we've kinda been around the block a couple of times about consciousness, haven't we? Society defines love in much the same way as we define consciousness--that is, poorly. One of the biggest challenges of a scientific approach to love is operationalization. This is, of course, a legitimate complaint; you may operationalize love very differently from me. However, this is par for the course in scientific investigation, and we can expect to converge on better and better definitions (although, by definition, no operational definition will ever be perfect) of love.

There is no a priori reason to think that this particular subject should prove immune to scientific inquiry. If love is special, then we will be unable to find empirical trends. The proof of the pudding is in the tasting--the proof of a scientific investigation of love is in the results. We have found useful information. (BTW, none of the useful information involves the planets Venus and Mars--if anyone thinks that psychology's study of love is best reflected in Gray's work, please please please think again.)
Close. There is nothing science can say about it that interesting ian will listen to would probably be closer to the truth. There is quite a lot that science can say about it that you will ignore. Such is life.

I'm not prepared to argue about it. You simply don't understand what science is about. Science deals with the physical world. It has nothing to say about love. Mystical experiences like NDE's tell us what love is.
 
Interesting Ian said:

I'm not prepared to argue about it. You simply don't understand what science is about. Science deals with the physical world. It has nothing to say about love. Mystical experiences like NDE's tell us what love is.
I respect your right to disagree, Ian, but our scientific view of love is based on the wild idea that the folks who fall in love are members of the physical world. That their actions, even their feelings, are part of the physical world. I already know you disagree with this, but at least we are consistent. Yup, science deals with the physical world. Even if we have to stretch our definitions so much as to include people in that world.


Oddly enough, I have been in love, but have never had an NDE...so I'm not quite certain what to make of your last sentence.
 
DanishDynamite said:
Love, just as everything else we experience, is pure brain chemistry.

Well obviously it's brain chemistry.

My point was that the exact processes haven't been quantified yet.
 
Joshua Korosi said:
Well obviously it's brain chemistry.

Ok I have a question not only towards you Joshua.

What happens when we stop loving somebody. Where does this chemistry go?

Also, in another thread in the P&R forum we discuss about how Religion affects Relationships. Some of us have experienced outrageous behaviors that questioned our intelligence, patience and choices and yet "the chemistry" didn't evaporate....

How Science explains that?
 
Joshua Korosi said:

Well obviously it's brain chemistry.

My point was that the exact processes haven't been quantified yet.
Even if it is reducible ultimately to brain chemistry (or ultimately to natural selection, take your pick of structural or functional ultimate causes), I don't think that is a useful level of analysis. The problem is not at the level of neurochemistry, but at a definition of love. The neurobiologist might be able to identify the chemicals involved in the feeling of "being in love" (one author has termed this feeling "limerance", a term I love--to no one's surprise), but as has been stated on this thread, not all loving relationships involve that feeling. So we have other feelings, other behaviors, each of which is of course reducible to brain chemistry...but of course, we won't be able to point to one neurotransmitter or one pathway and say "there--that is love".

The trick of defining love is to recognize that it is a category label for a number of different behaviors (I use the word "behavior" as a radical behaviorist, including thinking, feeling, remembering, as well as sonnet-writing, singing underneath balconies, staring deeply into obsidian eyes, etc.). When we learn the word "love", we learn it in all these contexts, and we necessarily learn to label our feelings imperfectly (because those who teach us the labels for what we feel do not have access to our feelings themselves). We say that we do these things, feel this way, because of love, when in fact the causation goes the other way; we call it love because we do these things and feel this way. Of course, I expect Interesting Ian to disagree.

That said, there have been a number of attempts at defining love in such a manner as to include all of what the category means. One current model is Sternberg's triangular theory, which uses a triangular model (duh), the corners of which are labeled "intimacy", "passion" and "commitment". Intimacy is not sexual intimacy, but the ability to share with another, to talk about things, to be interested in one another's lives. Passion is the possessive, sexual (literally or metaphorically), physical desire. Commitment is the intent to remain together.

One can have different amounts of each of the three "ingredients", which will put your own "love" at a particular part of the triangle. Intimacy and Passion, but no commitment, is labeled "romantic love" (think paperback novels); Passion and Commitment, but no intimacy, is "fatuous love". Commitment and Intimacy, but no passion, is "friendship"; all three ingredients together are "consummate love". Of course, these are labels for particular combinations, but in theory an infinite variety of combinations is possible.

Of course, this is not the only attempt at a definition. I present it here only to say that yes, we do try to study love scientfically. Perhaps I'll try to find and post some of the scales that measure love according to Sternberg's model.


I really didn't mean to write this much...
 
Mercutio said:

Commitment and Intimacy, but no passion, is "friendship";

Just one little change - commitment and intimacy together is "companionate love", there's also passion alone which is "infatuation", commitment alone which is "empty love", and intimacy alone which is "liking"
 
Cleopatra said:


Ok I have a question not only towards you Joshua.

What happens when we stop loving somebody. Where does this chemistry go?

Also, in another thread in the P&R forum we discuss about how Religion affects Relationships. Some of us have experienced outrageous behaviors that questioned our intelligence, patience and choices and yet "the chemistry" didn't evaporate....

How Science explains that?


In this case it would help to consider the brain as a computer (which is, more or less). Our love for a person may be a program that we install and it runs all the time in the traybar. It may demand more or less of our computer's memory depending on the situation. It is possible to uninstall it sometime, either in whole or just a few add-ons it may have. But of course it is possible that we didn't remove it completely and it is still running, although we may be unaware of it. It could be slowing down our system, like a virus, while we think we have uninstalled it ;)

One more demonstration of my metaphor-creating abilities :D
 
rachaella said:


Just one little change - commitment and intimacy together is "companionate love", there's also passion alone which is "infatuation", commitment alone which is "empty love", and intimacy alone which is "liking"
Oops--thanks for the correction--that will teach me to post seriously without my notes.

edited to add...having looked at your profile, it seems you would be a good person to get an opinion from on this matter. What do you think about this model? Is there another you prefer? Do you think the researchers are wasting their time? I look forward to your input.
 
Cleopatra said:


Ok I have a question not only towards you Joshua.

What happens when we stop loving somebody. Where does this chemistry go?

Also, in another thread in the P&R forum we discuss about how Religion affects Relationships. Some of us have experienced outrageous behaviors that questioned our intelligence, patience and choices and yet "the chemistry" didn't evaporate....

How Science explains that?

Well wait...when I said "chemistry", I meant that after research, scientists could be able to say "this chemical reaction in the frontal lobe of the brain (for example) indicates the subject is experiencing what is commonly referred to as love". I already said earlier that it's unlikely (in my opinion) that science can quantify the exact causes of that chemical reaction. So when we stop loving somebody, science couldn't explain why; all they would be able to say is that the chemical process isn't occurring anymore.
 
Ok, since I didn't encounter any strong opposition to my rationalizing of the mechanisms of love, I will assume that with a little introspection we can all identify -to a certain degree- the earthy, tangible and perhaps even mercenary reasons that have led us to select and love our current (or a previous) mate.

So, I will proceed to what has been the latent question from the beginning: What if these "love-inducing" factors disappear ? Are you going to to stay by the side of the chosen mate even if you are fully aware of the fact that the vanishing quality is what attracted you to him/her in the first place ? Examples:

  • You fell in love with someone because she was very beautiful. Because of an accident she becomes disfigured. Can you still love her ?
  • You fell in love with someone because you were seducted by the power and the self-confidence that his belongings gave to him. He loses everything. Can you still love him ?
  • You have been an insecure teenager but you met this guy who gave you all the love you needed and as result you loved him back. Now you have grown up and you are no longer insecure and fragile. You realize you don't really have much in common with this person. Can you still love him ?
  • You had loved your wife because she used to like the same stuff you did and the two of you had been doing a lot of things together: Cinema, hiking, sports, etc. But after a few years you realize that you don't seem to enjoy the same activities anymore. Do you still love her ?

I realize that the initial passion will inevitably fade with time. But I'm talking about something else here, the loss of a significant characteristic of the other person, something that may well be completely independent of time. For example, the rich boyfriend you first met 6 months ago, has suddenly lost everything.

Assuming that there are no kids or other responsibilities that would force you to stay together, would you dump someone in any of the above cases ? Is an instantaneous event like a disfiguring accident or a bankruptcy enough to sweep away what would have been an "eternal love" ?
 
Mercutio said:
Even if it is reducible ultimately to brain chemistry (or ultimately to natural selection, take your pick of structural or functional ultimate causes), I don't think that is a useful level of analysis. The problem is not at the level of neurochemistry, but at a definition of love. The neurobiologist might be able to identify the chemicals involved in the feeling of "being in love" (one author has termed this feeling "limerance", a term I love--to no one's surprise), but as has been stated on this thread, not all loving relationships involve that feeling. So we have other feelings, other behaviors, each of which is of course reducible to brain chemistry...but of course, we won't be able to point to one neurotransmitter or one pathway and say "there--that is love".


I've told you; chemistry has nothing to do with love. The fact that the feeling of love might precipitate certain activity in the brain and a higher level of a certain chemical does not mean that love is such activity or is this chemical.
 
Mercutio said:
The trick of defining love is to recognize that it is a category label for a number of different behaviors (I use the word "behavior" as a radical behaviorist, including thinking, feeling, remembering, as well as sonnet-writing, singing underneath balconies, staring deeply into obsidian eyes, etc.). When we learn the word "love", we learn it in all these contexts, and we necessarily learn to label our feelings imperfectly (because those who teach us the labels for what we feel do not have access to our feelings themselves).

I rather suspect we have an innate understanding of what love is.

We say that we do these things, feel this way, because of love, when in fact the causation goes the other way; we call it love because we do these things and feel this way. Of course, I expect Interesting Ian to disagree.

WOW! You really are stupid aren't you??

That said, there have been a number of attempts at defining love in such a manner as to include all of what the category means. One current model is Sternberg's triangular theory, which uses a triangular model (duh), the corners of which are labeled "intimacy", "passion" and "commitment".

It means something more than any of those things. Tell Mr Sternberg he is stupid.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom