What harm can it do?

Ed writes:

First off, if it has not happened to you, you cannot judge. The numbers may be trivial but the impact is not.

I agree. Singular tragedies are always worse when they are personal. The impact, however, is great on individuals, not on everyone. This still doesn't mean the larger numbers don't prevail.


Secondly, based on your wording, it appears that you actually believe that there are such things as vampires and penis snatchers. Say it ain't so.

Nope. They are definitely hoaxes. I said that above. These stories regularly come out of Africa where people don't have enough other things apparently to keep them occupied and educated about such matters. The bank scams coming out of Nigeria, Liberia and Ghana and now more recently even South Africa are an example in the creativity involved in perpetrating such hoaxes. I received one the other day from an alleged banker, with a good e-mail address. The bank existed, it had a website and the signer even was listed thereon. Of course the website itself could've been a hoax. Citibank (and its customers) which has an online banking service was and still is the victim of a hoax. I got their offiicial logo page as an e-mail saying I needed to change my password as my account was compromised , to enter it and hit repy!

Then another Citibank message came saying I needed to provide the first 4 numbers of my ATM card! LOL. Just forwarded these messages to the FBI and Citibank security. I wonder how many people fell for this?

How come we don't see these hoaxes and scams coming out of Denmark, France or Germany?
 
SteveGrenard said:
Nope. They are definitely hoaxes. I said that above. These stories regularly come out of Africa where people don't have enough other things apparently to keep them occupied and educated about such matters. The bank scams coming out of Nigeria, Liberia and Ghana and now more recently even South Africa are an example in the creativity involved in perpetrating such hoaxes.

"People don't have enough other things apparently to keep them occupied and educated about such matters"??? What kind of ignoramus are you, Steve? How can you generalize in such an obtuse manner? Do you really think that is it a matter of finding things to do?

Steve, living in Africa is more often than not a very unpleasant experience. They have to deal with diseases we have forgotten all about. They have to deal with grinding poverty, not just on a personal scale, but also on a continental one. They fight corruption, AIDS, environmental disasters, natural disasters, hunger...the list is virtually endless.

But, according to you, all they do is perpetrate hoaxes meant to scam Americans and Europeans out of money. They shun survival of their families, they forego education, just so they can scam white people.

What kind of person are you, Steve? What makes you post such a preposterous claim?

SteveGrenard said:
I received one the other day from an alleged banker, with a good e-mail address. The bank existed, it had a website and the signer even was listed thereon. Of course the website itself could've been a hoax.

So, why was it "good"?

SteveGrenard said:
Citibank (and its customers) which has an online banking service was and still is the victim of a hoax. I got their offiicial logo page as an e-mail saying I needed to change my password as my account was compromised , to enter it and hit repy!

Then another Citibank message came saying I needed to provide the first 4 numbers of my ATM card! LOL. Just forwarded these messages to the FBI and Citibank security. I wonder how many people fell for this?

I wonder why you don't investigate, instead of just coming up with innuendos....

SteveGrenard said:
How come we don't see these hoaxes and scams coming out of Denmark, France or Germany?

We do. Hoaxes and scams occur here too. However, our infrastructure makes it easier to find the crooks. The African countries do not have that luxury.
 
SteveGrenard said:
How come we don't see these hoaxes and scams coming out of Denmark, France or Germany? [/B]


Steve, old bean:

In spite of yourself you have sort of hit the nail on the head.

What we see from the western countries, including the US are different sorts of hoaxes, perpetuated by seemingly well meaning people such as yourself. Things like talking to dead people, homeopathy, magnet therapy and a whole host of others. More damaging to mind and wallet than anything our dusky bretheren are up to.

As you say:

"These stories regularly come out of Africa where people don't have enough other things apparently to keep them occupied and educated about such matters."

Substitute the words United States or England and this certainly holds true. The millions of your countrymen who spend money and time on vain persuits for the dead, getting "read" by astrologers, buying and supporting frauds in the "psychic" realm by purchasing their books and watching their TV shows is a crime against humanity given the opportunity cost.

Fifty years of research which can be allegorized as a cow flop.

You don't need to look as far as africa to see poor benighted savages, just look around at the pathetic followers of the "teachings" of your erstwhile buddy Schwartz and your new buddy Keen. Re-read the pitiful end of Targ and about the delusional people she was so afraid to offend. Then look closer, Steve, look at yourself and other reasonably well off and intelligent people who, for reasons best known to themselves, support moribund notions of immortality against all evidence and allow the likes of Keen et al. to flourish.
 
It must be frustrating for Steve to get zinged as often as he does by Ed, Claus, and others. Steve tries so hard to make a point and often completely misses the target.
 
xouper said:
It must be frustrating for Steve to get zinged as often as he does by Ed, Claus, and others. Steve tries so hard to make a point and often completely misses the target.

But, but, but.........

We get into these micro arguments about whether or not there is one decent paper on homeopathy, for example. Steve does a googol and upon investigation we find that they are mostly crap. Steve comes back with something on the biosphere or whatever. The point is that he misses the meta issue. Really misses it. (and right now, as he is reading this, he really does not apprehend what meta view I am talking about) His post about the Nigerian scam is an example, one which I gently tried to bring home.

He evidentially has a world view wherein things exist that are rejected by various authority figures. If he succumbs to evidence, this view collapses, perhaps catastrophically. His seeming reasonable perspective on Homeo is evidence of this. A truely reasonable person would move on.

Odd, and interesting. I wonder where his posts will take him next.
 
I can only sit here and marvel at the way Steve has managed to hijack this thread from "people who die because of someone's pet beliefs" to "the quality of news reporting from Africa".

Steve, once again, your data on the numbers of medical-error deaths has nothing to do with the subject under discussion, which--once again--is, "What harm does it do to let people have their pet beliefs?"

And also, the subject of "which news stories from Africa are hoaxes" ALSO has nothing to do with the subject at hand. Please try to stay on topic.

Please address the issue of "American white people who imperil their children because of their religious beliefs which forbid certain medical treatments". This issue, at least, cannot be dismissed as a hoax. Read some of this link.

http://www.parkridgecenter.org/Page567.html

How do you feel about that? Should they be allowed to do that?

How about the Jensens of Utah? Not Africans. Not a hoax.

Sunday, October 12, 2003 · Last updated 12:50 p.m. PT

Utah medical neglect case opens new front

By PAUL FOY
ASSOCIATED PRESS WRITER

SALT LAKE CITY -- Only weeks ago, Daren and Barbara Jensen appeared to be prevailing in the fight to keep their 12-year-old son off chemotherapy - just as their son, Parker, seemed to be beating his battle with cancer.

After a public outpouring of sympathy for the family, Utah authorities last month dropped a bid to get custody of the boy, along with kidnapping charges against the parents for taking their son out of state to avoid the court-ordered chemotherapy. The Jensens insist the boy is cancer-free and refuse to give him the toxic treatment.

But a key complaint against the Jensens remains. State officials refuse to withdraw a petition accusing the parents of medical neglect - a complaint that could cost Daren and Barbara Jensen custody of their son and restore the chemotherapy order.

A juvenile court judge set a trial for Nov. 17-19. State child-welfare authorities say the longer Parker goes without chemotherapy, the more likely he is to die.

< snip >

Daren Jensen says he's getting immune system therapy for Parker and giving him health supplements. The family is consulting an out-of-country physician, who is working with "several" doctors in this country. The Jensens are refusing to provide details, saying Utah authorities already interfered by warning an alternative cancer clinic in Texas against consulting with the family.
How do you feel about that?
 
xouper said:
Yes, that's another way of saying what I meant.

Sorry, did not mean to be patronizing. I felt like writing something and I just did a riff on your post. You said it well.



:)
 
Goshawk said:

Please address the issue of "American white people who imperil their children because of their religious beliefs which forbid certain medical treatments". This issue, at least, cannot be dismissed as a hoax. Read some of this link.

http://www.parkridgecenter.org/Page567.html


How do you feel about that?

Tell themr when she buries the cold, small, lifeless body of her child her experiment in "alternative medicine" will be over. Point out that it will be too late, unless of course she believes that she can talk to dead people. Then things will be just fine.

See, I knew it would come in handy.
 
Child abuse is child abuse. If a parent wilfully neglects to do everything possible to treat their child's illness and puts their life at risk they should be held accountable. If they wish to try what are otherwise harmless alternative interventions such as prayer, touch or whatever, but not to the exclusion of mainstream medicine, I have no problem with that. This is why such "medicine" is also called complemnetary. It is the very essence of the definition for this area; a violation of that, the use of such things in lieu of standardized treatment , is child abuse. I also feel parents who smack their kids around, neglect them, torture them, kill them directly and even allow them to be vastly overweight are also guilty of such abuse. I have no tolerance for such parents. We lament the fact you need a license to drive but anybody can have a kid. I have seen it all working in NYC emergency rooms. I have yelled and screamed at parents who called up to cancel a hospital appointment for their kids because they had tickets to a matinee or some such similar excuses. The one that really gets me is the parent who cant bring their kid in on a weeknight to be tested in the sleep lab because they have school the next day. I often remind them that their kid is falling asleep and failing in school so what difference does it make? Bring them in and solve the problem. These people are truly clueless.

I trust that answers your questions from my perspective on this topic. I have been administering conventional medical treatment for 35 years and in no way feel they should be set aside for unproven, unsafe or alternative treatments.
 
If they wish to try what are otherwise harmless alternative interventions such as prayer, touch or whatever, but not to the exclusion of mainstream medicine
Okay, but we're not talking about "not to the exclusion of mainstream medicine". We're talking specifically about "the exclusion of mainstream medicine". We're talking about "people who die because of someone's pet belief". The OP is asking, "What harm do pet beliefs do?" and we're discussing what harm "pet beliefs" can do, namely, that people can die because of them.

So we're discussing "parents who refuse mainstream medical treatment for their child because of a pet belief, whether specifically religious, as in Christian Science, or whether merely a belief in alternative therapies--and the kid dies". Am I correct in assuming that you would condemn that? And that therefore you would agree that it's a Bad Thing when someone dies because of a person's pet belief, and that therefore having pet beliefs can sometimes be a Bad Thing? That sometimes pet beliefs can "do harm"? Because sometimes people can die because of them? That's what the OP is asking--"what's the harm?"
 
Goshawk asks (quotes):

Am I correct in assuming that you would condemn that?

Yes.

And that therefore you would agree that it's a Bad Thing when someone dies because of a person's pet belief, and that therefore having pet beliefs can sometimes be a Bad Thing?

Yes if they are not complementary to mainstream or conventional medicine. You may be interested in knowing that some 500 or more mainstream US hospitals offer patients complementary medical techniques. The emphasis here is on the world "complementary." They also allow clergy inculding Catholic Clergy to conduct healing services on site. Pet beliefs do not kill except if they are used in any manner other than as a complementary technique. There are a few exceptions to this such as exorcisms for behaviorally challenged children which directly resulted in their death by suffocation. This was inexcusable.

Another exception concerns herbals.
Are some herbals dangerous? Indubitably. They should not be taken without consulting a physician as to their side effects and modes of action.


That sometimes pet beliefs can "do harm"? Because sometimes people can die because of them?

Aside from the examples given above, I know of no deaths attributable to any so-called pet belief that has killed anyone. If you are saying that prayer, TT or homeopathic water preparations or one-a-day vitamins have killed people directly please furnish evidence of that. On the other hand if these things are not used as a complement to mainstream medicine they could be considered indirectly responsible for deaths in persons with potentially fatal but otherwise curable or controllable diseases.

I guess I need another rubber stamp regarding the definition of the word complementary.


edited to add:

PS: What's "the OP? Did you mean AP or the non-existent Arctic Penguin?

Also: is the name of this thread "What harm can it do?" I didn't see anything that does not qualify or disqualify the complementary principle. Maybe I missed it. We can't discuss this without considering this factor.
 
"OP" is a common term used on Internet message boards, meaning both "original post" and "original poster". It refers to the subject of the thread.
 
The subject of this thread is, "What harm does it do to let people keep their pet beliefs?"

The response so far has been, "Well, sometimes people's pet beliefs mean that other people die. This happens in two ways--when people have superstitions that cause them to believe somebody else might be better off dead, and when people have religious or other beliefs that cause them to fail to seek timely mainstream medical treatment for themselves and/or their loved ones."

So the response so far has been, "Yes, letting people keep their pet beliefs sometimes does harm."

We are not discussing whether alternative medicine is good or bad, or better or worse than mainstream medicine. We are discussing whether it's good or bad to allow people to keep their pet belief in a particular brand of alternative medicine, or should we try to argue them out of it, as happens frequently here on the JREF.

So far the consensus is, "Yes, it's good to try to argue them out of it."

I know of no deaths attributable to any so-called pet belief that has killed anyone.
Prayer killed the boy in the Wisconsin exorcism.

This vegan baby died.
A High Court jury in Auckland has watched a video as the manslaughter trial of Deborah and Roby Jan Moorhead continues.

The Dargaville couple have denied causing the death of their six-month-old child Caleb by failing to provide the necessaries of life.

In an interview with a detective, Jan Moorhead said he never knew his son was going to die until his final breath of life, because of his faith in the herbal remedies which he was treating him with.

He said in hindsight there is a possibility he may have done the wrong thing, but he said the doctor at Starship Hospital could also be wrong.

< snip >

The Seventh-day Adventist couple took Caleb out of the Starship children's hospital and went into hiding.

The jury heard that the couple believed their son would be healed through the use of alternative remedies.

He died in March last year from medical complications due to a lack of vitamin B12.

This woman with HIV will probably not live out a normal lifespan. And her baby probably has HIV, too.
The couple believe in the effectiveness of alternative medicine and say it has kept the mother healthy so far.

All these children died.
Twelve-day-old Carie Sealy died of pneumonia without receiving any type of medical attention. Her parents, Kenneth and Bonnie Sealy, were members of the Faith Assembly Church. They believed that if God could not help, no man could (Larabee, Mark "The Battle Over Faith Healing"The Oregonian Nov. 28, 1998.).

Newborn infant Warren Reed died of pneumonia and meningitis. His parents recognized the symptoms, but refused to get medical care. Dr. Rob Kurtzman stated that the heart defect Warren had at birth is rarely fatal if medical help is given. His parents Billy and Barbara Reed are members of the General Assembly Church of the First Born ( Lofholm Nancy Denver Post August 3, 2000)

Sonia Hernandez, a one-year old, died of pneumonia. Her parents Guillermo and Luz Hernandez were members of End Time Ministries. The girl was blind, deaf and suffered from cerebral palsy. The parents also believed in faith healing as a substitute for medical attention (Callahan, Joe Lake City Reporter, September 4, 1992)

In Colorado, 18-month-old Warren Trevette died of suspected congested heart failure while his parents and church elders of the General Assembly of the First Born prayed for his cure (Torkelson, Jean Rocky Mountain News July 28, 2000 ).

In Boston, two-year-old Robyn Twitchell died of peritonitis and a twisted bowel after a five-day illness that began with his screaming and vomiting. His parents, members of Christian Science, refused to get medical treatment for their son. http://www.childrenshealthcare.org

Two-year-old Justin Barnhart, whose parents were members of the Faith Tabernacle Church, died of Wilm's tumor because the parents depended on prayer and rejected medical help. Medical intervention is successful in 90% of these cases. (Cult Observer, May/June 1988, p. 6. From "U.S. Supreme Court Will Be Asked to Review Faith-death Conviction," CHILD Newsletter, Spring, 1988, p. 4). http://www.csj.org

Natili Joy Mudd, a four-year-old from Indiana whose parents were members of the Faith Assembly Church, died from an eye tumor the size of her head. Police discovered blood trails on the walls where the nearly blind girl attempted to go from room to room. The Mudd's other 5-year-old daughter died after a court ordered operation to remove a basketball-sized tumor in her stomach (Mark Latrabee "The Battle Over Faith Healing" The Organian, Nov.28 1998).

In Oregon City, four-year-old Alex Dale Morris received prayers for 46 days before he died. His parents, members of the Followers of Christ church denied the boy medical attention. His autopsy revealed that massive infection in his chest had filled one entire side of his chest with pus. Antibiotics could have saved him. (Van Biema, David " Faith Or Healing" Time Magazine August 31, 1998 Vol.152 No. 9)

In Florida, Amy Hermanson, aged 7 died of diabetes. Her parents are members of the Christian Scientist Faith, and claimed their religious beliefs kept them from taking her for medical attention. "The Unacceptable Cost Of Religious Superstition" 26 Feb. 2001.http://www.geocities.com/Heartland/Woods/1327/child-abuse.html

Bo Phillips, 11, died Feb. 23 of diabetes after suffering painful symptoms for a week. His death could have been prevented with medical care. His eyes were sunken and his face was yellow. His parents were members of the Followers of Christ Church. When his father was asked why he let the boy die, the father said it was his choice (Van Biema, David "Faith Or Healing" Time Aug. 311998 vol. 152 No9).

In Alberta, Calahan Shippy, age 14, died of diabetes as a result of his parents refusal to get medical help. His father stated he has the right to not seek medical help for his eight children. The father is a member of the Followers of Christ sect. A pathologist said the boy might have lived if he had received medical help a few hours before he died (" Alberta Couple Gets Suspended Sentence In Diabetes Death" Ottawa Citizen, June 26, 2000).

Sixteen-year-old Shannon Nixon died of treatable diabetes complications. Five years before, her younger brother Clayton died of an inner-ear infection. Their parents, Lori and Dennis Nixon, were members of the Faith tabernacle Church and refused to let their children have medical attention (Blair, Jeffroy "Faith-Healing Convictions Upheld" Deloit Daily News Apr. 30, 1997).
And one of the lucky ones, from the same link.
In Philadelphia, one-year-old Patrick Foster, whose parents were members of Faith Tabernacle Congregation Church, is another example of a child suffering due to religious beliefs. Patrick needed help to lift his head because his body was engulfed by a growth that emerged from his kidney and attached itself to his liver and heart. The police came for Patrick. At the hospital, it was discovered that Patrick had a Wilm's tumor, a childhood cancer that 90% of the patients survive if they receive prompt medical treatment. Fortunately, Patrick lived because of police intervention (Larabee, Mark "The Battle Over Faith Healing The Oregonian Saturday, November 28 1998 ).

On the other hand if these things are not used as a complement to mainstream medicine they could be considered indirectly responsible for deaths in persons with potentially fatal but otherwise curable or controllable diseases.
Exactly my point. However, people who believe in alternative medicine rarely use them in conjunction with mainstream medicine. They use them instead of mainstream medicine. So it's kind of pointless to stipulate "a pet belief in alternative medicine is okay as long as you're using it in conjunction with mainstream medicine", because people rarely use it like that.
 
Goshawk said:
However, people who believe in alternative medicine rarely use them in conjunction with mainstream medicine. They use them instead of mainstream medicine.

Do you have an links to any JAMA articles to provide evidence for that claim?
 
T'ai Chi said:


Do you have an links to any JAMA articles to provide evidence for that claim?

I can't believe I'm doing this, but I actually agree with T'ai Chi. I would be inclined to say that in my experience, it has been the other way around. Most people 'mix' their therapies.

This IMHO is what makes it dangerous. People try 'conventional' medicine and, on seeing it not work for whatever reason (remember, at no point do we say doctors/scientists/researcher etc. are gods and have all the answers), they try acupuncture, homeopathy etc. Sometimes their symptoms fade, or they get better (medicine is about helping the body to repair itself) without due intervention.

This is problem number 1 - a few incidents set up a precedence which becomes anecdotal evidence. 'Acupuncture cured me where conventional medicine did not'.

Problem number 2 is where people associate small measures of medical 'fact' in alternative medicines with medical facts in conventional medicine. For instance, immunology with homeopathy, a common 'cross-over' of facts.

Athon
 
Pakaran said:


Like the Milwaukee Cannibal, then? Who was not an "actual" cultural cannibal, but just a really messed up fellow?
He did eat dead people. If that ain't a cannibal, then I don't know what is.

I think your analogy doesn't fit because the working definition of vampire for most people has to do with the supernatural, undead stuff, ie., doesn't really exist -- hence US's "nickname" comment.
 
Vampire bats are NOT myths .............

http://www.batconservation.org/content/meetourbats/vampire.htm

Orgnization for Bat Conservation


by Denise Tomlinson

Vampire Bats. The name conjures images of Count Dracula and other vampires, eerie creatures of the night that suck blood from their victims that turn into vampires themselves. ,snippedy>

The legends of vampires were developed well before the discovery of vampire bats in the New World. Vampire bats got their name from these legends from Europe.

Bram Stoker himself was so fascinated by the discovery of bats that drank blood in the New World that he incorporated them into his book Dracula.

Vampire bats have been around for 6-8 million years. These bats are placed in the family Phyllostomidae. However, there are some scientists that believe that they warrant their own family, so some text books place them in the family Desmodonitidae. Fossil records show there used to be more species of vampire bats. Today, there are just three species. Two species prefer avian blood and are less abundant. These bats are the White-winged vampire bat (Diaemus youngi) and the Hairy-legged vampire bat (Diphylla ecaudata). The most abundant and most studied vampire bat is the Common vampire bat (Desmodus rotundus), which prefers mammalian blood. All three are found in the New World tropical and subtropical regions (Central and South America) and are considered medium sized bats.

How vampire bats evolved is still as mystery. There are 3 theories of origin.

<okay-snipping the evolutionary theories X3.>

Vampire bats are capable of jumping straight up and flying. This technique is uncommon in other bats.< ..this is interesting think ill leave it in >


The most intriguing aspect of vampire bats is their diet and how they get their food. Due to a diet exclusively of blood (called sanquivory), vampire bats have many adaptations that make them very specialized. Vampire bats have the fewest teeth of all bats. ,taking out he part about the tummy expanding>

,the saliva thing is interesting>

The most fascinating adaptation is in the saliva of vampire bats. The saliva of vampire bats contain 3 active ingredients to keep the blood flowing, allowing them to eat. An anticoagulant is the main ingredient and prevents the blood from congealing. There is also a chemical that keeps the red blood cells from sticking together. The last ingredient inhibits constriction of veins under the wound. There has been a drug developed from research on the anticoagulant in vampire bat's saliva called Draculin, which is used to treat heart patients.

Vampire bats need 2 tablespoons of blood each day. They can eat approximately 1.5 times their body weight in the wild. The Common vampire bat cannot go 2 nights without food, otherwise it starves to death.

.

Denise Tomlinson graduated from Western Michigan University with a degree in Biology. She is the director of operations at the Organization for Bat Conservation.

(free to fair use; no C notice) Thanks Denise. People who are interested in bats should join your group. They can find it at :

http://www.batconservation.org


Vampire bats exist. Thanks for helping to prove that. Wonder how the modern myth got started in Africa? Probably from the blood drinking human tribes here.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom