What harm can it do?

UnrepentantSinner said:


I'm confused about that too. The nearest I can gather is that he's trying to show that people die in hospitals, just like they die when people stone "vampires".


It's quite obvious, the first thing that Hospitals do to patients is take blood test. So like vampires Hospitals take blood. Therefor Steve believes hospitals are vampires. Anyone who has read Steve's logic should be able to figure this one out.
 
Clearly some beliefs are more harmful than others, especially if those beliefs are acted on. Some beliefs, however, have no ill consequences.
 
Re: And meanwhile here in the US 98,000 die from medical errors

SteveGrenard said:
Testimony on Patient Safety
Supporting a Culture of Continuous Quality Improvement in Hospitals and Other Health Care Organizations
Carolyn M. Clancy, M.D., Director, AHRQ
Before the Senate Permanent Subcommittee on Investigations, Committee on Governmental Affairs, June 11, 2003
Contents




That's nice, Steve. Let's compare the mortality and morbity rate of medical error to the mortality and morbity rate of "alternative medicine".

Is the former lower or higher than the latter? Please bring the stats to prove this.
 
Ladewig said:
As for the penis snatching incidents, if some people in the crowd are rational enough to ask the accuser to drop his pants, he does so and then says, "that's not my penis - he took mine and replaced it with this one."


I had a date try that story on me once. Didn't fool me. Nice try. :nope:
 
T'ai Chi said:
Clearly some beliefs are more harmful than others, especially if those beliefs are acted on. Some beliefs, however, have no ill consequences.

Immediate ill consequences, perhaps.

But when one supports health sciences that lack quantitative research to back them up, it sets up a precedent that says you don't have to back up claims in today's society. Makes for very shaky foundations for future generations to build upon, and although that might not be as blatant as stoning 'vampires', there cost to society is still going to be great.
 
Re: And meanwhile here in the US 98,000 die from medical errors

SteveGrenard said:
Testimony on Patient Safety
Supporting a Culture of Continuous Quality Improvement in Hospitals and Other Health Care Organizations
Carolyn M. Clancy, M.D., Director, AHRQ
Before the Senate Permanent Subcommittee on Investigations, Committee on Governmental Affairs, June 11, 2003
Contents

Fascinating, Steve. Your point being what exactly?

I assume you are attempting to balance the argument by showing that even 'science' can kill?

Well, you didn't actually say anything (a bit cowardly, don't you think?), so if my assumption is wrong I'm sure you will say so.

The article is pointing out that human error in medicine costs lives. This is a serious issue - health systems over the world are often underfunded, with staff in hospitals overworked and fearful of risking many procedures in case they make an error. In cases where this does happen, they are hounded as if they are fallen gods.

Yes, doctors are human. That has never been denied, and like the rest of the human race, there is a range of expertise, intelligence and ability. Some are good at their job while others are not. This is purely political - there is a balance between getting good health professionals and getting any at all.

So in typical woo-woo style, you've built a majestic straw-man to burn that does not so much as touch on the key issue - bad science and non-critical thinking can indeed cause harm.

Athon
 
Hmm... Steve apparently didn't wait all that long to reapear after stating he was leaving the forum... again..
 
MoeFaux said:



I had a date try that story on me once. Didn't fool me. Nice try. :nope:

Did you suggest it be turned into Lost and Found? or at least handed over to the police as evidence. after all, it might be stolen property, someone might be looking for it. (or belongs to the thief and can be used to id them) :D
 
Marc said:


Did you suggest it be turned into Lost and Found? or at least handed over to the police as evidence. after all, it might be stolen property, someone might be looking for it. (or belongs to the thief and can be used to id them) :D

No, I just asked him to find his original one. :D
 
Marc - as usual you make statements based on your inept and faulty assesment of anything I claim or said. I said I was leaving a particular discussion, a thread. Sorry but I was busy this morning so could not come back here imediately to impress anyone with my replies either.

Now to why I posted the fact that somewhere between 44,000 and 98,000 persons die every year just in the U.S. due to medical errors. It was to contrast with the trivial numbers of people somewhere in Africa that are vicitmized by vampires or penis snatchers. While we busy ourselves here with truly anecdotal, trivial cases there are real problems that need to be addressed and I simply found it ridiculous that a handful of people victimized by woo-wooism can compare with all the people who die every day due to not only medical errors, drunken and sleepy drivers, child/spousal and elderly abuse, murder, and other social ills.

Instead we latch onto eye popping headlines from tabloids who knows where and which we have no idea if they are really even true, let alone signficiant.

There is definitely a lack of priority setting around here.

It is trully amazing how some around here will swallow anything (pun intended) when it suits their biases but torturously question anything that does not. So somewhere in Malawi a newspaper publishes accounts of incipient vampirism and we go all gaga over it. Pathetic.
 
SteveGrenard said:
Marc - as usual you make statements based on your inept and faulty assesment of anything I claim or said. I said I was leaving a particular discussion, a thread. Sorry but I was busy this morning so could not come back here imediately to impress anyone with my replies either.

No, you did not. You said you were leaving "here". You did not specify where "here" was. If you are not precise, you cannot complain if people misunderstand you, especially since you have claimed to leave this forum (leaving no doubt) before.

SteveGrenard said:
Now to why I posted the fact that somewhere between 44,000 and 98,000 persons die every year just in the U.S. due to medical errors. It was to contrast with the trivial numbers of people somewhere in Africa that are vicitmized by vampires or penis snatchers. While we busy ourselves here with truly anecdotal, trivial cases there are real problems that need to be addressed and I simply found it ridiculous that a handful of people victimized by woo-wooism can compare with all the people who die every day due to not only medical errors, drunken and sleepy drivers, child/spousal and elderly abuse, murder, and other social ills.

O..........K. So, why are you not involved in preventing medical errors, but instead choose to spend your time on such trivial matters as the paranormal?

SteveGrenard said:
Instead we latch onto eye popping headlines from tabloids who knows where and which we have no idea if they are really even true, let alone signficiant.

There is definitely a lack of priority setting around here.

Skeptics also investigate medical scams, Steve, some costing many lives each year.

SteveGrenard said:
It is trully amazing how some around here will swallow anything (pun intended) when it suits their biases but torturously question anything that does not. So somewhere in Malawi a newspaper publishes accounts of incipient vampirism and we go all gaga over it. Pathetic.

Very disingeneous of you. You are fully aware that this forum does not primarily deal with these cases, but have lengthy discussions and investigations of e.g. medical claims, Therapeutic Touch to name one. However, in these threads, you are usually trounced.

It could be why you focus on penis snatchers. The reason could be another, given your penchant for weird sexual references.
 
Iamme said:
Mythbusters was great, last night. The two 'scientists' wired up a crash-test dummy fitted with a bladder, homemade urine and a 'penis', and had it pee on the third rail of a mock subway's electified rail of 650 volts. It took them three attempts or so in making revisions, but they did indeed end up electrocuting the penis, and the dummy fell over backwarsds (to signify death). Conclusion: Not a likely story...but it COULD happen under the right circumstances...even though it has never been recorded to date, to have happened.:D


Their conclusion that it is not likely however is flawed, since they based this conclusion on slow motion photography which showed the stream of urine seperating into droplets by the time it reached the rail.

This seperation into dropltets may be true of the mechanism in their experiment, but they failed to show that this is true of an actual human urinating, which of course, may or may not be true, but something which they would need to correlate for their findings to have any validity whatsoever.
 
SteveGrenard said:
the trivial numbers of people somewhere in Africa that are vicitmized by vampires or penis snatchers.


First off, if it has not happened to you, you cannot judge. The numbers may be trivial but the impact is not.

Secondly, based on your wording, it appears that you actually believe that there are such things as vampires and penis snatchers. Say it ain't so.
 
csense said:



Their conclusion that it is not likely however is flawed, since they based this conclusion on slow motion photography which showed the stream of urine seperating into droplets by the time it reached the rail.

This seperation into dropltets may be true of the mechanism in their experiment, but they failed to show that this is true of an actual human urinating, which of course, may or may not be true, but something which they would need to correlate for their findings to have any validity whatsoever.

Hmmmm seems that we have a volinteer.
 
SteveGrenard said:
Now to why I posted the fact that somewhere between 44,000 and 98,000 persons die every year just in the U.S. due to medical errors. It was to contrast with the trivial numbers of people somewhere in Africa that are vicitmized by vampires or penis snatchers. While we busy ourselves here with truly anecdotal, trivial cases there are real problems that need to be addressed and I simply found it ridiculous that a handful of people victimized by woo-wooism can compare with all the people who die every day due to not only medical errors, drunken and sleepy drivers, child/spousal and elderly abuse, murder, and other social ills.
The issue here in this thread is not "how many people died".

The issue here in this thread is "WHY they died".

Your thousands of medical-error deaths died because of carelessness or stupidity or greed or accidents.

The few cases we are discussing here died because of superstition.

Superstition is a totally different thing from carelessness or stupidity or greed or accidents. From Merriam-Webster:

1 a : a belief or practice resulting from ignorance, fear of the unknown, trust in magic or chance, or a false conception of causation b : an irrational abject attitude of mind toward the supernatural, nature, or God resulting from superstition
2 : a notion maintained despite evidence to the contrary

In other words, a "pet belief".

The OP reads, "What harm can it do to let people keep believing their pet beliefs?". None of your medical-error deaths died because of someone's pet beliefs. All of the few cases we are discussing here died because of someone's pet beliefs. We are discussing "dying because of someone else's pet beliefs".

Therefore, your medical-error statistics, while distressing, are not relevant.

Instead we latch onto eye popping headlines from tabloids who knows where and which we have no idea if they are really even true, let alone signficiant...So somewhere in Malawi a newspaper publishes accounts of incipient vampirism and we go all gaga over it. Pathetic.
On behalf of everyone in this thread, including myself, who posted links to mainstream news sources, and who are only posting at this JREF forum in the first place because we are devoted to rightly dividing the word of truth as regards to tabloids and other "alternative" news sources, allow me to express my deep resentment at this particularly clueless statement. We Googled those stories just like you Googled yours, Steve, and those are all reputable news sources.

Instead of addressing the question of how your medical-error statistics relate to the OP, you instead choose to sidetrack onto attacking our sources.

Which is stupid.


I will also point out that not everything we are discussing here takes place in far away, "easy-to-scoff-at-because-presumed-full-of-ignorant-tabloids" Africa. I refer you to the Wisconsin story I linked to, about the exorcism. There are also instances of prosperous, educated white Americans imperiling their children because their religion prohibits medical treatment of one kind or another.

Religious groups that avoid medical treatment
 
I agree that some few cases due to ignorant superstition and religious beliefs are no less important than a hundred thousand due to neglisence and errors, especially to those directly involved up close and personal. But they still pale in comparison to the numbers needing action. I am happy to say that such action, after decades of neglect, is being taken as the press releases from the fed indicate.

These are our priorities. The greater number prevails. That was and is my point.

Those who try and make it seem like these few deaths, however, are commonplace are seriously deluded. These are rare cases worthy of local action which they receive as prosecutions in such matters proved in the Colorado deaths campaigned by Linda Rosa did. I would ask Rosa if such deaths were commonplace? Do they happen daily and twice on Sundays? No. She has a lot of spare time on her hands between incicdents of this type.

And those who think that a Reuters tagline on a story gives it mainstream status are also seriously in error. Do you know how newservices such as Reuters, especially in places such as Malawi work.? They have paid stringers, locals, who mine the local press or marketplace for these stories. They are headline grabbers. If you honestly believe that some first class investigative journalist with the highest possible ethic sitting in an office in London is fact checking such stories, you are also seriously deluded. Many of these stories from places in Africa are complete hoaxes. The continent is talented at producing authentic sounding stories complete with government and police sources and names to back them up. The Africans in some countries are particularly good at such scams. Have you read some of the letters they send out trying to share millions of dollars with you if you would just send them your bank account number and bank coding reference so they can send you the money? What they will do is actually empty your bank account if you are stupid enough to fall for this. But the letters are pure masterpeices of creative fiction. Somebody should collect them all and publish them as an anthology. along with these ridiculous news stories.
 
traveller said:
I suspect that Ed and CFLarson are also ****ing closet draculas.

True, but not each other:D

Fact is that CL and I are nosferatu. He had to move back to Denmark cuz we were using up too many human critters and people were starting to notice. You can see how we cleverly made it look like OJ out in California and how we framed Scott Peterson. The Chandra Levy thing was pretty good too.

See, we creatures of the paranormal like to stay on sceptic boards like this to divert attention from our true activities. Think about it, if you were a vampire or a guy who could talk to the dead the last thing you would want is attention. Ipso facto, any "paranormal" bloke who goes public is a fake.

Lucianarchy is really correct and will be delt with presently (another reason Claus had to go back to Europe). Occasionally we use those under our power (Renfield like ... incidentially, Dracula was largely autobiographical, Ann Rice is my main squeeze) to post under pseudonyms. It works well, we make belieers look rediculous so that we can carry out our nefarious plots. I can't tell you what they are, only that they are nefarious.

unfortunately, we have to kill all of you now in order to keep our secret safe. It may take a while but, rest assured, within 100 years we will have gotten all of you.

Well, gotta fly now:D
 
SteveGrenard said:
I agree that some few cases due to ignorant superstition and religious beliefs are no less important than a hundred thousand due to neglisence and errors, especially to those directly involved up close and personal. But they still pale in comparison to the numbers needing action. I am happy to say that such action, after decades of neglect, is being taken as the press releases from the fed indicate.

These are our priorities. The greater number prevails. That was and is my point.

Then, you should investigate claims why people die from cardiac arrest.

SteveGrenard said:
Those who try and make it seem like these few deaths, however, are commonplace are seriously deluded. These are rare cases worthy of local action which they receive as prosecutions in such matters proved in the Colorado deaths campaigned by Linda Rosa did. I would ask Rosa if such deaths were commonplace? Do they happen daily and twice on Sundays? No. She has a lot of spare time on her hands between incicdents of this type.

Ah, you don't think that delusion is a problem that has serious implications?

SteveGrenard said:
And those who think that a Reuters tagline on a story gives it mainstream status are also seriously in error. Do you know how newservices such as Reuters, especially in places such as Malawi work.? They have paid stringers, locals, who mine the local press or marketplace for these stories. They are headline grabbers.


This, from someone who posts claim after claim after claim, without being able to back it up with anything that even resembles evidence.... :rolleyes:

SteveGrenard said:
If you honestly believe that some first class investigative journalist with the highest possible ethic sitting in an office in London is fact checking such stories, you are also seriously deluded. Many of these stories from places in Africa are complete hoaxes.

Please present your evidence of this. Along with a statistical analysis of which are hoaxes and which are not.

What, don't have it?

SteveGrenard said:
The continent is talented at producing authentic sounding stories complete with government and police sources and names to back them up. The Africans in some countries are particularly good at such scams. Have you read some of the letters they send out trying to share millions of dollars with you if you would just send them your bank account number and bank coding reference so they can send you the money? What they will do is actually empty your bank account if you are stupid enough to fall for this. But the letters are pure masterpeices of creative fiction. Somebody should collect them all and publish them as an anthology. along with these ridiculous news stories.

The Nigerian Money Scams are already being investigated, so no news there. However, I think I detect a certain....tone in your description of "The Africans". The way you generalize, the way you so eagerly appoint a whole "continent" as "talented" in "producing" these scams...What's going on, Steve?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom