SteveGrenard said:
Now to why I posted the fact that somewhere between 44,000 and 98,000 persons die every year just in the U.S. due to medical errors. It was to contrast with the trivial numbers of people somewhere in Africa that are vicitmized by vampires or penis snatchers. While we busy ourselves here with truly anecdotal, trivial cases there are real problems that need to be addressed and I simply found it ridiculous that a handful of people victimized by woo-wooism can compare with all the people who die every day due to not only medical errors, drunken and sleepy drivers, child/spousal and elderly abuse, murder, and other social ills.
The issue here in this thread is not "how many people died".
The issue here in this thread is "
WHY they died".
Your thousands of medical-error deaths died because of carelessness or stupidity or greed or accidents.
The few cases we are discussing here died because of
superstition.
Superstition is a totally different thing from carelessness or stupidity or greed or accidents. From Merriam-Webster:
1 a : a belief or practice resulting from ignorance, fear of the unknown, trust in magic or chance, or a false conception of causation b : an irrational abject attitude of mind toward the supernatural, nature, or God resulting from superstition
2 : a notion maintained despite evidence to the contrary
In other words, a "pet belief".
The OP reads, "What harm can it do to let people keep believing their pet beliefs?". None of your medical-error deaths died because of someone's pet beliefs. All of the few cases we are discussing here died because of someone's pet beliefs. We are discussing "dying because of someone else's pet beliefs".
Therefore, your medical-error statistics, while distressing, are not relevant.
Instead we latch onto eye popping headlines from tabloids who knows where and which we have no idea if they are really even true, let alone signficiant...So somewhere in Malawi a newspaper publishes accounts of incipient vampirism and we go all gaga over it. Pathetic.
On behalf of everyone in this thread, including myself, who posted links to
mainstream news sources, and who are only posting at this JREF forum in the first place because we are devoted to rightly dividing the word of truth as regards to tabloids and other "alternative" news sources, allow me to express my
deep resentment at this particularly clueless statement. We Googled those stories just like you Googled yours, Steve, and those are all reputable news sources.
Instead of addressing the question of how your medical-error statistics relate to the OP, you instead choose to sidetrack onto attacking our sources.
Which is stupid.
I will also point out that not everything we are discussing here takes place in far away, "easy-to-scoff-at-because-presumed-full-of-ignorant-tabloids" Africa. I refer you to the Wisconsin story I linked to, about the exorcism. There are also instances of prosperous, educated white Americans imperiling their children because their religion prohibits medical treatment of one kind or another.
Religious groups that avoid medical treatment