What did Republicans do wrong?

What did Republicans get wrong in the two years immediately preceding the 2026 midterm elections?

  • Cost of living / affordability / inflation

  • Other general economic issues

  • Immigration / deportation / border security

  • Healthcare provision / availability

  • Taxing / budgeting / spending

  • Foreign policy (other than war)

  • War

  • Democratic institutions / authoritarian backsliding

  • Corruption, graft, etc.

  • Data centers / AI regulation

  • Other important issues somehow left off this list

  • On Planet X, the truth is out there


Results are only viewable after voting.
What changed in the last two years? Trump is still acting like an authoritarian strongman with mercantilist tendencies while the Xn nationalists still want to make domestic policy more theocratic across the board. It's all feeling very Ecclesiastes 1:9 from where I'm sitting.
 
LOL

Thomas Massie, notably.

Less well known, folks like Charlie Syles, Sarah Longwell, Jon V. Last, Adam Kitzinger, Liz Cheney, George Conway, Rick Wilson, Steve Schmidt, Michael Steele, David French, Sam Stein, Tim Miller, Mona Charon.
Pretty much everyone associated with the Dispatch and Bulwark have been notably criticizing Trump and MAGA. I'd say fighting but you can say a minnow is fighting a shark but it's not much of a fight.
 
Once those folks are socially defensetrated from the upper floors of the conservative motte, they are no longer pressured to identify with all aspects of movement conservatism and may well start to resemble normies with a mixed bag of political ideas rather than the ideologues they once were.
 
Once those folks are socially defensetrated from the upper floors of the conservative motte, they are no longer pressured to identify with all aspects of movement conservatism and may well start to resemble normies with a mixed bag of political ideas rather than the ideologues they once were.
It's more the opposite, they mostly remain conservative ideologues, MAGA on the other hand has a grab bag of political ideas with no real ideology beyond Trump says so.

Bulwark is somewhat what you say, as they are basically just center left.
 
MAGA on the other hand has a grab bag of political ideas with no real ideology beyond Trump says so.
This is sort of tautologically true in that MAGA consists of those who remain loyal to the dear leader regardless of how many promises he breaks. We don't exactly have a name for former MAGA folks who broke ranks because of those broken promises.
 
Last edited:
Did those somehow shift between 2024 & 2026?
The important swing vote people thought that Trump was promising to focus on the economy and that he wasn't really as bad as people said he was. Trump made sure when he ran that he wouldn't have moderating forces in his new administration, only obsequious fools.

He got their vote and ignored them completely. Conservative people who thought he was tough but rational found out just who erratic and unpredictable he really was.
 
The MAGA types ride the waves of whatever anti-intellectual conspiracy tells them that they are not the problem, everyone else is.

Tea Party, Qanon and MAGA are just the contemporary versions of the KKK and the John Birch Society.
 
Pretty much everyone associated with the Dispatch and Bulwark have been notably criticizing Trump and MAGA. I'd say fighting but you can say a minnow is fighting a shark but it's not much of a fight.

Sure, I guess. But it's hard to call a handful of outliers who no longer operate within the Republican mainstream criticizing MAGA as a "fight on the American right" in any meaningful way. It's not as if the Republican Party itself is roiling with internal turmoil.
 
Once those folks are socially defensetrated from the upper floors of the conservative motte, they are no longer pressured to identify with all aspects of movement conservatism and may well start to resemble normies with a mixed bag of political ideas rather than the ideologues they once were.
It's more the opposite, they mostly remain conservative ideologues, MAGA on the other hand has a grab bag of political ideas with no real ideology beyond Trump says so.

Bulwark is somewhat what you say, as they are basically just center left.
This is sort of tautologically true in that MAGA consists of those who remain loyal to the dear leader regardless of how many promises he breaks. We don't exactly have a name for former MAGA folks who broke ranks because of those broken promises.

You both seem to be operating under the misapprehension that MAGA is somehow separate or distinct from conservatism, some kind of aberration. It's not. Conservatism has been wholly captured by MAGA, so much so that it is reasonable to conclude that MAGA is in fact conservatism in its true form.
 
What changed in the last two years? Trump is still acting like an authoritarian strongman with mercantilist tendencies while the Xn nationalists still want to make domestic policy more theocratic across the board. It's all feeling very Ecclesiastes 1:9 from where I'm sitting.
If you think his first term was exactly like his second term, you haven't been paying attention.
 
If you think his first term was exactly like his second term, you haven't been paying attention.
Dictionary example of a non-sequitur:

Alfa: Why did swing voters shift so hard from being optimistic about the GOP to pessimistic about it over 2024-26?

Beto: If you think that what happened from 2017-20 is akin to 2024-2026, you haven't been paying attention.​

Nothing in the OP or any subsequent posts mentioned Trump's first term, so it's pretty weird to rebut claims about how it compares to the first half of the last one.
 
Last edited:
Nothing in the OP or any subsequent posts mentioned Trump's first term, so it's pretty weird to rebut claims about how it compares to the first half of the last one.
Yeah but that's what a lot of posters think is the primary variable. Both the power brokers and voters thought "Trump.is my boy" in 2024, based on his performance in his 2016 term (and what they could forecast from that), and saw they were on a Titanic-level sinking ship come 2026. It was simply that, more than any specific policy issues. Trump destroyed conservative respectability.
 
power brokers and voters thought "Trump is my boy" in 2024, based on his performance in his 2016 term
What makes you confident of this claim? I'd've guessed the power brokers were mostly attracted to his ability to be bought (regardless of macroeconomic competence and performance) whereas ordinary voters lacking powerful partisan alignment or much in the way of economic literacy simply bought into the idea that Biden failed to curb inflation or at least bring wages up to meet it.
[they] saw they were on a Titanic-level sinking ship
I'm assuming you're mostly talking about the economy here, but it could be a reference to much else besides (e.g. national debt/GDP ratio).
 
Last edited:
Yeah but that's what a lot of posters think is the primary variable. Both the power brokers and voters thought "Trump.is my boy" in 2024, based on his performance in his 2016 term (and what they could forecast from that), and saw they were on a Titanic-level sinking ship come 2026. It was simply that, more than any specific policy issues. Trump destroyed conservative respectability.
He started saying the quite parts out loud this time. That could be due to cognitive decline, but even if it isn't it displayed the corruption clearly to the American people and did so unapologetically.

That's one main reason things changed.
 
What makes you confident of this claim? I'd've guessed the power brokers were mostly attracted to his ability to be bought (regardless of macroeconomic competence and performance)
That's why Trump was their boy. He wouldn't even need to be bought, so much as pointed in the desired economic direction with a hearty "fetch".
whereas ordinary voters lacking powerful partisan alignment or much in the way of economic literacy simply bought into the idea that Biden failed to curb inflation or at least bring wages up to meet it.
I hear this a lot, but doubt it, because I have faith in humanity. I very sincerely (with not a touch of hyperbole or snark) believe that no rational.person could look at that buffoon and think he should take our Nation's highest office. No matter where your politics land, he is objectively a very weak and stupid person.
I'm assuming you're mostly talking about the economy here, but it could be a reference to much else besides (e.g. national debt/GDP ratio).
I mean his message and actions in toto, not just the state of the economy. Again, with no snark intended, you can't consider the effects of his policies without first being stonewalled by how ◊◊◊◊◊◊◊ stupid this person is. How do you even get past how humiliating it is to have a half wit serving as Chief Executive, to even get to the point of considering what he and his bootlickers might have done better?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom