What did Republicans do wrong?

What did Republicans get wrong in the two years immediately preceding the 2026 midterm elections?

  • Cost of living / affordability / inflation

  • Other general economic issues

  • Immigration / deportation / border security

  • Healthcare provision / availability

  • Taxing / budgeting / spending

  • Foreign policy (other than war)

  • War

  • Democratic institutions / authoritarian backsliding

  • Corruption, graft, etc.

  • Data centers / AI regulation

  • Other important issues somehow left off this list

  • On Planet X, the truth is out there


Results are only viewable after voting.
Pretty sure most people consider the issues with ICE to not actually be immigration related?
LOL
What notable person or persons on the right are engaged in this fight against MAGA?
Thomas Massie, notably.

Less well known, folks like Charlie Syles, Sarah Longwell, Jon V. Last, Adam Kitzinger, Liz Cheney, George Conway, Rick Wilson, Steve Schmidt, Michael Steele, David French, Sam Stein, Tim Miller, Mona Charon.
 
Last edited:
This post in which you cheerlead the shuttering of USAID by DOGE is dated February 4th, 2025:




This post in which you cheerlead ICE detaining tourists for six weeks for overstaying their visas is dated February 24th, 2026:




This post in which you cheerlead justifications to start a war with Iran is dated March 3, 2026:


It should be noted that these examples were really easy to find and there are more like them in the respective threads.



"Somehow" doing a lot of heavy lifting here, but when exactly did you realize Trump's actions were stupid and counterproductive?

To most of us it was not only immediately apparent but we actually predicted it.



A link to one of these posts from "a while ago" would be helpful.
This seems very personal for you. I can't really help with that.
 
Pretty sure there was a specific policy reason why they were set loose on the streets.
Which has been eclipsed by their actions.

"Immigration" is one thing, open borders and all that. Siccing a pack of wild dogs with Amazon vests loose on the streets to harm both citizens and immigrants indiscriminately is quite another.
 
It seems somewhat too charitable to separate the mission of mass deportation from the foreseeable consequences thereof.
To my eye, and many others, they are seperate (though obviously related) matters.

Deporting criminal illegal immigrants, I have no problem with. Enabling ICE to operate like the ◊◊◊◊◊◊◊ Gestapo on our streets is a solidly seperate matter.
 
Observing from the outside, I would say that unerringly stepping on every rake that they themselves proudly and patriotically scattered about the lawn was probably not the best choice.

Deifying a clearly demented geriatric former nepo-baby moron, ajudicated sex criminal and convicted fraudster who had never been a successful businessman (but did play one on TV) may also have been a mistake, along with really leaning into the racism and related xenophobias...

I could go on, there's the refusal to acknowledge/eager support of the incessant gaslighting and war-criming, buggering up of restoration and repair projects, bogus lawsuits...

Edited because I am trying an experiment wherein I try to say what I mean, but without swearing. So far, I don't like it. Lacks emphasis and stuff.
 
Last edited:
Deifying a clearly demented geriatric former nepo-baby moron, ajudicated sex criminal and convicted fraudster who had never been a successful businessman (but did play one on TV) may also have been a mistake…
It was an awful mistake on multiple levels, but that wasn't remotely obvious from the 2024 election results in the House and Senate. What changed?
 
Thomas Massie, notably.

Less well known, folks like Charlie Syles, Sarah Longwell, Jon V. Last, Adam Kitzinger, Liz Cheney, George Conway, Rick Wilson, Steve Schmidt, Michael Steele, David French, Sam Stein, Tim Miller, Mona Charon.

These people operate outside of the Republican mainstream. Some of them are outright pariahs. And come January the only one who currently holds office (Massie) will join the others who once did in exile.

If these are the best fighters against MAGA the right has to offer, I guess that explains why we haven't seen much of an impact in separating MAGA from Republicans.
 
Last edited:
It was an awful mistake on multiple levels, but that wasn't remotely obvious from the 2024 election results in the House and Senate. What changed?

Millions of people who had their brains melted by their social media feeds and voted for MAGA experienced what actual MAGA governance looks like and either changed their vote or stayed home.
 
Millions of people who had their brains melted by their social media feeds and voted for MAGA experienced what actual MAGA governance looks like and either changed their vote or stayed home.
Precisely! OP asks which discrete policy issues/outcomes driven by actual governance were most determinative for those folks—and for others who were never brain-melted by algorithmic feeds but came around nonetheless.
Am I going to regret this?
Probably, since reply posts would most likely get binned or moved. That said, "65% said they wanted to hear less about trans athletes and surgeries" is only really promising from a progressive policy perspective if you go on to ask respondents if they've already made up their minds and they answer they want to see more of both of those things happening in the world as a result of fewer bans or barriers—even as politicians talk about these issues less often.

Erin definitely wants to see existing bans repealed and barriers lowered, so it seem odd that she would celebrate politicians being encouraged to move on from the issue and allow the status quo to prevail, especially in light of how the ballot measures listed here turned out.
 
Last edited:
Precisely! OP asks which discrete policy issues/outcomes driven by actual governance were most determinative for those folks—and for others who were never brain-melted by algorithmic feeds but came around nonetheless.

This has pretty much been asked and answered with the polling data that's already been provided, so I'm not sure how much more granular we can get.

Nor do I think this can be framed as "politics as usual" policy failures and voter discontent.

The Trump administration has been an abject disaster on every level and has demonstrated a complete lack of competent governance. People noticed.

Probably, since reply posts would most likely get binned or moved. That said, "65% said they wanted to hear less about trans athletes and surgeries" is only really promising from a progressive policy perspective if you go on to ask respondents if they've already made up their minds and they answer they want to see more of both of those things happening in the world as a result of fewer bans or barriers—even as politicians talk about these issues less often.

Erin definitely wants to see existing bans repealed and barriers lowered, so it seem odd that she would celebrate politicians being encouraged to move on from the issue and allow the status quo to prevail, especially in light of how the ballot measures listed here turned out.

The "status quo" on this issue was nobody giving a ◊◊◊◊ and every just living their lives.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom