What defines a God-given religion is its original form-not what came later due to human ulterior motives.
Ahhh but how do you know
If it is as simple as
What defines a God-given religion is its original form-not what came later due to human ulterior motives.
But we are still humans. How do we know which form of the God-given religion is its original form?
[off-topic]
For that matter, how do we tell which religion(s) are God-given and which are man-made?
[/off-topic]
If we assume a religion to have been of devine origin than it is illogical to accept later contradictory modificationsbased on human whim as genuine. That's the point I'm trying to make.
For example-if Christianity required love of neighbor and I teach hatred instead, obviously I am deviating from the original concept and do not have an acceptable basis to call what I am teaching Christianity. Neither would the acceptance of such a deviation by millions make it so.
words
, or something else a religion in order to confuse the argument.. then I don't think it much matters what you would define it as. If we assume a religion to have been of devine origin than it is illogical to accept later contradictory modificationsbased on human whim as genuine. That's the point I'm trying to make.
That would surely be reasonable if religions kept a change log. Using the Christianity example, it's been 2 to 3 to 6 thousand years or more (depending on which divine revelation you choose to use) since the religion was "God-given". This allows plenty of time for us to muddle it up.If we assume a religion to have been of devine origin than it is illogical to accept later contradictory modifications based on human whim as genuine. That's the point I'm trying to make.
But the concept of "just war" has been a part of Christianity since Augustine. I doubt you'll find a Christian today who will not defend himself when attacked, physically or verbally.For example-if Christianity required love of neighbor and I teach hatred instead, obviously I am deviating from the original concept and do not have an acceptable basis to call what I am teaching Christianity.
Put another way: if there had not been different sects, establishing one text as the definitive authority would have been a piece of cake. But there were, and it wasn't. It's not that the teachings started out pure and were modified later; right from the beginning, there were deep divisions over important questions such as the nature of Jesus and his relationship to the Father.If the Bible were the definitive authority for what is or is not Christianity, there would not be different sects of Christianity.
I like to call this "Holy Scripture By Committee".Where the New Testament is concerned, that call was made by a bunch of Bishops at a series of Ecumenical councils beginning with the First Council of Nicaea in 325 AD.
{snip}
You could assume that, like the original authors, these Bishops were also inspired -- but they couldn't all have been inspired, because (like the various texts and beliefs they were trying to unify) they didn't always agree (and they weren't just quibbling over nuances, either).
That would surely be reasonable if religions kept a change log. Using the Christianity example, it's been 2 to 3 to 6 thousand years or more (depending on which divine revelation you choose to use) since the religion was "God-given". This allows plenty of time for us to muddle it up.
The question still remains: How do we mere mortals know which form of the God-given religion is its original form?
(BTW, I don't expect you to have an answer. Short of divine intervention, there is no way for us to know.)
But the concept of "just war" has been a part of Christianity since Augustine. I doubt you'll find a Christian today who will not defend himself when attacked, physically or verbally.
Except the Amish, maybe. That is one amazing group of people once you get to know them.
Sorry, I don't understand. What is irrelevant to whether religion has been muddled up?Which is totally irrelevant to whether it has been or hasn't been muddled up.
It doesn't have to be universally shared. All that matters is discrepancies in human understanding of a set of scriptures. (I know you are speaking specifically about the Bible, but it could be true of any religious text.)Immortality isn't a requirement to acquire accurate knowledge. Neither is your doubt in the accuracy of the scriptures universally shared.
It may or may not have been true in individual cases, but without the ability to peer inside someone's head we have no way to determine whether or not they have genuinely had a divine intervention or if they just think they have.In certain individual cases that might be true.
So you say based on your understanding of the relevant texts. Others say differently based on their understanding of the relevant texts. Which one is correct and how would you determine that?So what you are referring to is the apostasy which has absolutely NOTHING to do with original first century Christianity and much less with Christ himself.
Radrook said:The question still remains: How do we mere mortals know which form of the God-given religion is its original form?
Immortality isn't a requirement to acquire accurate knowledge. Neither is your doubt in the accuracy of the scriptures universally shared.
How do wemere mortalsknow which form of theGod-givenreligion is its original form?
Oooh. Sorry.You seem to be missing the point of his question. Let me rephrase it for him...
... Anyone disagree?

What defines a religion?