What defines a religion?

What defines a God-given religion is its original form-not what came later due to human ulterior motives.

Ahhh but how do you know she is a witch it is god-given, without having some pesky subjective human decision that it is so?

If it is as simple as the sort of "she turned me into a newt...I got better" testament of other humans I am afraid you still have a "man-made" religion to at least some extent.
 
More seriously, I used to think about this question a lot. As Radrook said, it is an important question - if you believe there was a genuine foundation of revelation, and that we (well men anyway) have mucked it up God's efforts over time.

[cynic = hi]
You could easily spend a lifetime looking into what might have gone wrong.
[cynic = med]

I don't know if this is helpful, but I tend to divide "RELIGION: The Business" from "Spirituality: the art form".

Spirituality has an innocent quality. It has many forms and sounds. We tend to think of it in supernatural terms but I think it is a very natural, evolved human quality that we can nurture if we choose to.

Religion as a business, even if worked at its best, highest sense - is like a kindly old man who loves cats, and rises early to feed the birds. He does not seem to ever notice that the cats feed well on the birds, and the cats always seem to come no matter how well intentioned his kindness. "Spirituality" is like those birds.
 
But we are still humans. How do we know which form of the God-given religion is its original form?


[off-topic]
For that matter, how do we tell which religion(s) are God-given and which are man-made?
[/off-topic]

If we assume a religion to have been of devine origin than it is illogical to accept later contradictory modificationsbased on human whim as genuine. That's the point I'm trying to make.
For example-if Christianity required love of neighbor and I teach hatred instead, obviously I am deviating from the original concept and do not have an acceptable basis to call what I am teaching Christianity. Neither would the acceptance of such a deviation by millions make it so.
 
Last edited:
If we assume a religion to have been of devine origin than it is illogical to accept later contradictory modificationsbased on human whim as genuine. That's the point I'm trying to make.
For example-if Christianity required love of neighbor and I teach hatred instead, obviously I am deviating from the original concept and do not have an acceptable basis to call what I am teaching Christianity. Neither would the acceptance of such a deviation by millions make it so.

If you assume a religion to have been of devine origin than you are illogical regardless of what else you accept. Logic is not the mechanism through which man finds faith in God!

Upchurch: I totally agree. Religions are constantly changing and have fuzzy boundaries, we can only define them through generalizations. What a religion used to be, is supposed to be, or could be, while important, does not change what it actually is.
 
Anything calling itself a religion, which pre-dates L. Ron Hubbard getting an electric typewriter, and still exists today. I'd be somewhat comfortable with that definition.

I think religion is a rather hard thing to define without a context.

If the goal is to call science, belief in evolution :jaw-dropp, or something else a religion in order to confuse the argument.. then I don't think it much matters what you would define it as. ;)

All Praise Science!
 
If we assume a religion to have been of devine origin than it is illogical to accept later contradictory modificationsbased on human whim as genuine. That's the point I'm trying to make.

But the point everyone else is making is: "how do you decide what is original and what is a modification?"

And why should you limit your worries to condradictory modifications. What about an addition which contradicts nothing?
 
If we assume a religion to have been of devine origin than it is illogical to accept later contradictory modifications based on human whim as genuine. That's the point I'm trying to make.
That would surely be reasonable if religions kept a change log. Using the Christianity example, it's been 2 to 3 to 6 thousand years or more (depending on which divine revelation you choose to use) since the religion was "God-given". This allows plenty of time for us to muddle it up.

The question still remains: How do we mere mortals know which form of the God-given religion is its original form?

(BTW, I don't expect you to have an answer. Short of divine intervention, there is no way for us to know.)


For example-if Christianity required love of neighbor and I teach hatred instead, obviously I am deviating from the original concept and do not have an acceptable basis to call what I am teaching Christianity.
But the concept of "just war" has been a part of Christianity since Augustine. I doubt you'll find a Christian today who will not defend himself when attacked, physically or verbally.

Except the Amish, maybe. That is one amazing group of people once you get to know them.
 
If the Bible were the definitive authority for what is or is not Christianity, there would not be different sects of Christianity.
Put another way: if there had not been different sects, establishing one text as the definitive authority would have been a piece of cake. But there were, and it wasn't. It's not that the teachings started out pure and were modified later; right from the beginning, there were deep divisions over important questions such as the nature of Jesus and his relationship to the Father.

How do you know what belongs in the Bible? The test is: is it "inspired"? How do you know what is inspired? Where the New Testament is concerned, that call was made by a bunch of Bishops at a series of Ecumenical councils beginning with the First Council of Nicaea in 325 AD. At that time, "the bible" existed only as a loosely connected set of writings, and "Christianity" existed as a loosely connected set of beliefs.

You could assume that, like the original authors, these Bishops were also inspired -- but they couldn't all have been inspired, because (like the various texts and beliefs they were trying to unify) they didn't always agree (and they weren't just quibbling over nuances, either). If they were making reasoned judgements, how would they have done that? By examining the content of each text in question to determine whether it is consistent with certain essential teachings. As the authoritative basis for that, each of them would naturally have wanted to use the teachings and the texts HE favored, but they didn't all favor the same teachings or use the same texts; that was the whole problem. So what they did was put it to a vote. The Trinitists won. The teachings of the chief opponent, Arius, were denounced as heresy, his books were burned, and he was exiled.

Ask any "Christian" about this, and he will most likely be able to tell you...

...absolutely nothing about any of it.
 
Where the New Testament is concerned, that call was made by a bunch of Bishops at a series of Ecumenical councils beginning with the First Council of Nicaea in 325 AD.

{snip}

You could assume that, like the original authors, these Bishops were also inspired -- but they couldn't all have been inspired, because (like the various texts and beliefs they were trying to unify) they didn't always agree (and they weren't just quibbling over nuances, either).
I like to call this "Holy Scripture By Committee".

It's much less funny if you've ever worked on a committee.
 
That would surely be reasonable if religions kept a change log. Using the Christianity example, it's been 2 to 3 to 6 thousand years or more (depending on which divine revelation you choose to use) since the religion was "God-given". This allows plenty of time for us to muddle it up.

Which is totally irrelevant to whether it has been or hasn't been muddled up.

The question still remains: How do we mere mortals know which form of the God-given religion is its original form?

Immortality isn't a requirement to acquire accurate knowledge. Neither is your doubt in the accuracy of the scriptures universally shared.

(BTW, I don't expect you to have an answer. Short of divine intervention, there is no way for us to know.)

In certain individual cases that might be true.

But the concept of "just war" has been a part of Christianity since Augustine. I doubt you'll find a Christian today who will not defend himself when attacked, physically or verbally.
Except the Amish, maybe. That is one amazing group of people once you get to know them.


Jesus told Christians not to be part of this world and first century Christians understood that to be neutrality in wordily affairs. Actually, prior to Constantine Christians were persecuted because they refused to offer incense to the emperor and take part in the worlds military and political conflicts. So what you are referring to is the apostasy which has absolutely NOTHING to do with original first century Christianity and much less with Christ himself.


BTW
I accross the street from an Amish Farmer's Market.
 
Which is totally irrelevant to whether it has been or hasn't been muddled up.
Sorry, I don't understand. What is irrelevant to whether religion has been muddled up?

Immortality isn't a requirement to acquire accurate knowledge. Neither is your doubt in the accuracy of the scriptures universally shared.
It doesn't have to be universally shared. All that matters is discrepancies in human understanding of a set of scriptures. (I know you are speaking specifically about the Bible, but it could be true of any religious text.)

In certain individual cases that might be true.
It may or may not have been true in individual cases, but without the ability to peer inside someone's head we have no way to determine whether or not they have genuinely had a divine intervention or if they just think they have.

So what you are referring to is the apostasy which has absolutely NOTHING to do with original first century Christianity and much less with Christ himself.
So you say based on your understanding of the relevant texts. Others say differently based on their understanding of the relevant texts. Which one is correct and how would you determine that?
 
Radrook said:
The question still remains: How do we mere mortals know which form of the God-given religion is its original form?

Immortality isn't a requirement to acquire accurate knowledge. Neither is your doubt in the accuracy of the scriptures universally shared.

You seem to be missing the point of his question. Let me rephrase it for him...

How do we mere mortals know which form of the God-given religion is its original form?

Can you answer this, please?
 
... Anyone disagree?


Let me try... 'disagree' for 200, Upchurch. :D

I think religions are all of what you list: syncretic "onions" of founder, text, belief, institution, ritual, and community. A sketchy definition:

At the core of a religion is its founder. That doesn't change. It's also worth noting that every religion considers its founder/leader a "perfect" exemplar: either godlike or god. Ideally, followers of a religion agree that the exemplar is infallible and look to his/her words and deeds for inspiration.

The next layer is the transmission of the exemplar's words and deeds. These may be from the exemplar directly, or passed on secondhand. Any direct records of the exemplar are guaranteed sacred; less direct records are sacred if subsequent leader(s) agree to their authenticity, or orthodoxy.

Any confidantes of the exemplar take on special status. Successors who inherit that status will use it to sort out doctrinal matters, as authority figures in lieu of the exemplar. This is the institution of the religion.

From the words and deeds of the exemplar come the rituals of the religion. Rituals are a metaphorical imitation of the exemplar, conceived as a way to share in and gain strength from her/his perfection. Ritual practices also reinforce orthodoxy and belief.

Next up are the words and deeds of exemplary predecessors, peers, or followers of the exemplar. Once elevated to exemplary status by popular avowal and authority consent, their records are added to the religion's canon: second only to the founding exemplar's.

Then are the followers' interpretations and understanding. These of course tend to change over time, as the followers' concerns change with society. (If enough followers believe a certain text or reading of a text or ritual, practice, conduct, or exemplary follower or current leadership is not valued enough or too much or just plain wrong, the religion schisms.)

Finally, is the followers' conduct. This may be based on extensive "knowledge" of the inner layers, or superficial familiarity; strict adherence and devotion to tradition, or pragmatic negligence of all but convenient and useful aspects. And here again, followers' interpretations of what is convenient and useful, and/or what is tradition, will vary with the person.

Some argue, as you do in the OP, it's this outermost layer that defines the religion, that the way the most sensible or sensitive or radical followers behave is all that matters; others, that a religion is defined by its core, by its founding beliefs, by its exemplar. I think the whole onion should up for grabs when one discusses religion -- as long as one is careful to distinguish which layer is being peeled away for discussion (minimizes the inevitable tears). :cry1
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom