Upchurch
Papa Funkosophy
In the politics board, one of the threads I'm participating in has gotten way off topic onto the subject of, in my opinion, what defines Islam and what it teaches. I think it is a question that is equally applicable to all religions and I think it, generally, has the same answer. For familiarity, I will pick on Christianity as my example.
I assert that it is not a religion's holy texts that define the religion. If the Bible were the definitive authority for what is or is not Christianity, there would not be different sects of Christianity. There certainly wouldn't be diametrically opposed sects of Christianity. Especially on this board, we are all acutely aware of discrepancies between what Christians say and what is actually written in the Bible. (As a corollary, I assert that people fit their holy texts to their religion rather than fitting their religion to their holy texts.)
I assert that it is not the religion's founding prophet/teacher/whatever that defines the religion. If s/he were, the religion would presumably stay fairly static over time. I could not help but imagine that Jesus (assuming he existed) would not recognize Christianity as it exists today, or even several hundred years after he lived.
Rather, I assert that it is the current, living practitioners of the religion that defines the what the religion is and what it represents today. The consequence of this is that there is no one true form any religion, although there certainly could be broadly agreed upon trends. For every 10 Christians, you may very well have 10 different forms of Christianity. What was true about Christianity 100 years ago, may no longer be applicable to Christianity today because there are different Christians now with a different set of social norms.
Anyone disagree?
I assert that it is not a religion's holy texts that define the religion. If the Bible were the definitive authority for what is or is not Christianity, there would not be different sects of Christianity. There certainly wouldn't be diametrically opposed sects of Christianity. Especially on this board, we are all acutely aware of discrepancies between what Christians say and what is actually written in the Bible. (As a corollary, I assert that people fit their holy texts to their religion rather than fitting their religion to their holy texts.)
I assert that it is not the religion's founding prophet/teacher/whatever that defines the religion. If s/he were, the religion would presumably stay fairly static over time. I could not help but imagine that Jesus (assuming he existed) would not recognize Christianity as it exists today, or even several hundred years after he lived.
Rather, I assert that it is the current, living practitioners of the religion that defines the what the religion is and what it represents today. The consequence of this is that there is no one true form any religion, although there certainly could be broadly agreed upon trends. For every 10 Christians, you may very well have 10 different forms of Christianity. What was true about Christianity 100 years ago, may no longer be applicable to Christianity today because there are different Christians now with a different set of social norms.
Anyone disagree?