What About Wake Vortex?

So far I remain entirely unconvinced that what we see in the videos is incorrect. You've done nothing to establish what we -should- see. If your claim is that we should see an effect roughly equal to the crop-duster, you're going to need to justify that, give how fundamentally different the two scenarios are.

I think this is just more false-analogy fallacy, to be honest. Take an observable effect and pretend it exists, unchanged, at parameters far beyond those in the original experiment.
 
Please go here

http://stinet.dtic.mil/oai/oai?&verb=getRecord&metadataPrefix=html&identifier=ADA389851

and read this study conducted on behalf of the British Government. The study was to determine if the Boeing 767-300 (I am not as on top of the 9/11 issues as some but wasn't one of the planes that struck the towers a 767-300?) could be used as a mid air refueling platform for the RAF. You will see that they found the wake vortex's acceptable enough to study further. The full test (a pdf linked in the abstract) is an interesting read. in my opinion after a very brief scan on the test doc the wake vortex of a 767-300 at speed (as it obviously was when 1000's of people watched it crash into the tower) is minimal

To the troothers reading, feel free to read and cherry pick anything that you feel supports your case while ignoring everything else that doesn't
 
Swing Dangler; said:
For the record, I'm not a no planer, but I'm waiting to see how this all pans out.

Thank god. There's a 2 drink minimum and a 1 "no planer" maximum in this forum at any given time.
 
Then you believe in UFO's correct? Considering the vast number of people who see UFO's then they must exists.

There's quite a difference between, "I watched the plane hit the building," and, "I saw an object I've never seen before."
 
Then you believe in UFO's correct? Considering the vast number of people who see UFO's then they must exists.

For the record, I'm not a no planer, but I'm waiting to see how this all pans out.
Yes, I believe that there are objects that have been seen that are unidentified.
 
This is one of the stupidest CT claims I have come across. Why do you Conspiracy Theorists insist on talking about things you know nothing about?

-Gumboot
 
This is one of the stupidest CT claims I have come across. Why do you Conspiracy Theorists insist on talking about things you know nothing about?

-Gumboot
There is not a lot that they do know.

[Dr. Seuss mode]
They have no Degree, they have a Degrot.
It tells not what they know, but what they know not.
[/Dr. Seuss mode]
 
In this picture we see dust and smoke falling gently down. The blast force pushed material sideways, but now it is falling down. It is falling down into the area directly underneath the flight path. Directly underneath the flight path is where the wake vortex is. A 757 is a heavy plane, which was banking left. Behind the right wing, particularly, we would expect a significant vortex.
I think you've missed one significant thing: in order for the wake vortex to affect a cloud of smoke the aircraft has to fly through that cloud of smoke. You can see a great example of this from the movie Tora! Tora! Tora! where the planes playing the role of Japanese Zeroes fly low over rows of burning U.S. fighters. The columns of smoke are unaffected until after the Zero has flown through the columns of smoke; after it has passed through the smoke columns then the characteristic swirls appear.

On 9/11, the smoke wasn't there until after the jets had impacted the building and exploded. Since there was no passage through the smoke, there is no wake vortex effect visible on the smoke.


To the physics experts here: if I've goofed up on this, please correct me!
 
To sum up:
The vortices were small, because of the high speed/low angle of attack of the aircraft.
The vortices stopped being generated when lift stopped being generated.
The vortices sink behind the aircraft.
The vortices spread apart behind the aircraft.
The vortices are simply moving air. Other moving air, such as the pressure wave from a fuel explosion, can overcome them.
There is a lot more power in a fuel explosion that uses a significant fraction of the aircraft's fuel load in a fraction of a second then there is in wake vortices, whose power is ultimately supplied by the engines (and to some extent, the sink rate of the aircraft). The engines burn a very small fraction of the aircraft's fuel load per second.
So it's not unreasonable for a high power event such as a fuel explosion to disrupt a lower power phenomena such as wake turbulence.
 
It seems like this is a compelling point for a CT'ist due to the fact that many of them have some personal experience with boat wakes, and are mistaking the dynamics involved there with those in aerodynamics. TS1234 himself mentioned boat wakes in an earlier post.

TS, what you may have seen in the wake of a boat does not apply to aircraft. Just as dynamics involved in volcanic eruptions does not apply to building collapse conditions.

Gah. Next the CT'ists will probably start generating theories based on an analogy between expanding dust clouds and yeast-driven expansion in bread dough.
 
I think you've missed one significant thing: in order for the wake vortex to affect a cloud of smoke the aircraft has to fly through that cloud of smoke. You can see a great example of this from the movie Tora! Tora! Tora! where the planes playing the role of Japanese Zeroes fly low over rows of burning U.S. fighters. The columns of smoke are unaffected until after the Zero has flown through the columns of smoke; after it has passed through the smoke columns then the characteristic swirls appear.

On 9/11, the smoke wasn't there until after the jets had impacted the building and exploded. Since there was no passage through the smoke, there is no wake vortex effect visible on the smoke.


To the physics experts here: if I've goofed up on this, please correct me!


I don't think you're right. Those vortices persist for awhile. The question would be whether the smoke, dust and debris drift down into it.

The magnitude of the vortex has to do with the amount of lift. Therefore the weight of the aircraft is the most important factor in trying to estimate the magnitude, this from a NASA website. Speed and wingspan factor in as well, but NASA says weight is the most important variable.

I'd say the weight of a 767 is a lot more than a crop duster.
 
Perhaps a touch off topic but Sprintcars racing at Eldora speedeway have been reported to produce observable wingtip vorticies on humid nights. And in one extremely rare occurance, produced contrails. Unfortunately they were too faint to be photographed at the time
 
I don't think you're right. Those vortices persist for awhile. The question would be whether the smoke, dust and debris drift down into it.
Remember this important point: in those vortex pictures, the aircraft continues to fly along well after the vortex is seen affecting the smoke, and there was nothing interrupting or in the way of the aircraft flightpath. Neither of these is the case on 9/11; the aircraft didn't carry on after striking the buildings, and the buildings were there to interrupt and change the air patterns. That's what I'm really getting at when I mention flying through the smoke to reveal the effect.
 
Last edited:
I don't think you're right. Those vortices persist for awhile. The question would be whether the smoke, dust and debris drift down into it.

The magnitude of the vortex has to do with the amount of lift. Therefore the weight of the aircraft is the most important factor in trying to estimate the magnitude, this from a NASA website. Speed and wingspan factor in as well, but NASA says weight is the most important variable.

I'd say the weight of a 767 is a lot more than a crop duster.



Please stop embarrassing yourself.

-Gumboot
 
Remember this important point: in those vortex pictures, the aircraft continues to fly along well after the vortex is seen affecting the smoke, and there was nothing interrupting or in the way of the aircraft flightpath. Neither of these is the case on 9/11; the aircraft didn't carry on after striking the buildings, and the buildings were there to interrupt and change the air patterns. That's what I'm really getting at when I mention flying through the smoke to reveal the effect.

from 1970/75, I was a Cooperative education student at NASA Flight Research Center (now Dryden) when we mapped the wake vortices off of several aircraft, most notably the 727.
From the research
... The strongest -- and most dangerous vortices -- are generated by aircraft that are heavy, are in a clean gear and flaps-up condition, and are flying at slow speeds like those of landing approaches.
and
NASA research has shown that as large aircraft move through the air, trailing vortices tend to remain spaced less than a wingspan apart while sinking at a rate of several hundred feet per minute. Over time, the sink rate will slow and their strength will taper off. Research has shown, however, that vortices can also rise during conditions of ambient thermal lifting.
Vortices of large aircraft often move laterally at speeds of 2-3 knots when they sink to within 100-200 feet of the ground.
In calm wind conditions, vortices created by large aircraft during landing operations can remain for many minutes over the normal touchdown area. They can also slowly drift from one runway to a nearby parallel or crossing runway.
The third round of flights was in 1973, when a 727-200 three-engine jetliner was the wake generating aircraft and a PA-30, a Learjet, and an F-104 was the probing aircraft. The effort of this round of tests was to study changes occurring in vortex characteristics during the steeper descent path used in a two-stage noise abatement landing approach. Smoke generators were attached to the wing tips of the 727-200 to help chart differences between vortex flows created during normal landing approaches and the noise abatement approaches.
These are the ones I was involved with. We were on the lakebed with movie cameras mounted on transits, and recorded the things from wingtip to ground.
They move fast, and can actually bounce!
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom