What About Wake Vortex?

The thing is that wingtip vortices are a danger when a large aircraft is flying at slow speeds. At high speeds, the vortices are not an issue. If they were, you wouldn't have in-air refueling or formation flying. Add to that the fact that they descend at 500 fpm, they would have been below the blast.
 
Notice the angle of attack on your crop duster there.

Also notice that your crop duster isn't exploding. Heat, fire and explosive force would probably have an critical altering effect on such things as the vortex following the plane ....anyone?
 
I might add that it's visible if you create a cloud of smoke before the plane passes through it.

I still say that what you're seeing is the effect that the wake vortex has on that smoke, not the actual vortex.

My piont being it's not unexpected that there was no sign of a wake vortex in the wake of 175 because atmospheric conditions at that altitude were not conducive to one being visible, there was no smoke before impact for the flight to fly through, and 175 was not spraying pesticides.
 
Last edited:
My piont being it's not unexpected that there was no sign of a wake vortex in the wake of 175 because atmospheric conditions at that altitude were not conducive to one being visible

Also, couldn't the building itself nullify any residual vortex forming in the wake of the plane's passing?
 
Do you also understand that the wake vortex IS NOT EVER VISIBLE. Only the effects of the wake vortex are visible. Get it?

well... depending what you mean by "effects"... the center of a wingtip vortex can be marked by condensation if there is sufficient atmospheric moisture present.
 
[FONT=Verdana, Helvetica]An aircraft, like a ship, will leave a wake behind it. An aircraft's wake is in the form of two counter-rotating swirling rolls of air—the wake vortices—that trail from the wings of the aircraft. The wake vortex pair may last for several minutes and stretch for many kilometers (km) behind the aircraft. The strength of the vortices basically depends on the aircraft weight divided by the product of air density, flying speed, and wingspan. This property generally increases with aircraft weight.

http://www.nasaexplores.com/show_912_teacher_sh.php?id=030103130242
[/FONT]

[FONT=Verdana, Helvetica]
[/FONT]
 
Last edited:
OK. Let's.

[qimg]http://killtown.911review.org/images/flight77/lawn/wtc2_blast.jpg[/qimg]
We're looking at the left hand explosion. It appears to be comparable to the width of the tower, I'd say it's about 180 feet back into the flight path, and dust and smoke have fallen downwards for around 200 feet. All in that area is where you say the vortex would be.
Did you bother to read the part about relative energy between a blast and a descending wing tip vortex? Did you understand it? No.

The picture you use is useless for discussing this phenomenon. You need to draw a line on a 500 fpm slope away from the building on precisely the flight path of the aircraft. See also Terry's point to you about smaller vortices at lower angles of attack. The plane was a full speed, that means lower angle of attack.

Truth, go learn about what wingtip vortices are. Take the link I gave you. Then, use Google. No more spoon feeding.

DR
 
Note "divided by flying speed". Since the planes were going fast, the vorticity being shed was weak.
 
[FONT=Verdana, Helvetica]An aircraft, like a ship, will leave a wake behind it. An aircraft's wake is in the form of two counter-rotating swirling rolls of air—the wake vortices—that trail from the wings of the aircraft. The wake vortex pair may last for several minutes and stretch for many kilometers (km) behind the aircraft. The strength of the vortices basically depends on the aircraft weight divided by the product of air density, flying speed, and wingspan. This property generally increases with aircraft weight.[/FONT]


[FONT=Verdana, Helvetica]
[/FONT]
You missed the footnote in your cut and paste job, Truth, and you still have said nothing relevant to the OP's insinuation: absence of evidence, visual, in camera shots, of a non visible phenomenon taking place along the path to the building, not at the building, is apparently, evidence of absence of an airplane?

Where's a woodchipper when I need one?

DR
 
Oh great, he's using killtown. Ever read killtown's explanation of how FLT 93 wings could not have made the gouge in the field? He ignores both gravity and the negative lift vector of an inverted aircraft.
 
In this picture we see dust and smoke falling gently down. The blast force pushed material sideways, but now it is falling down. It is falling down into the area directly underneath the flight path. Directly underneath the flight path is where the wake vortex is. A 757 is a heavy plane, which was banking left. Behind the right wing, particularly, we would expect a significant vortex.

These vortexes are enough to flip small planes. Surely there would be a visible swirling effect on the smoke, dust, and debris falling (not being blasted, falling) down through this zone.


wtc2_blast.jpg
 
Notice the angle of attack on your crop duster there.

Don't be insane. A single-engine, prop-driven crop duster is identical in every way that matters to a 757 at full throttle.

Some people, I swear. Sheesh. :rolleyes:
 
Oh great, he's using killtown. Ever read killtown's explanation of how FLT 93 wings could not have made the gouge in the field? He ignores both gravity and the negative lift vector of an inverted aircraft.

Have you ever seen Killtown and TS1234 in the same place at the same time?

Case closed.
 
These vortexes are enough to flip small planes. Surely there would be a visible swirling effect on the smoke, dust, and debris falling (not being blasted, falling) down through this zone.

Surely based on what scientific evidence? Your best guess?
 
In this picture we see dust and smoke falling gently down. The blast force pushed material sideways, but now it is falling down. It is falling down into the area directly underneath the flight path. Directly underneath the flight path is where the wake vortex is. A 757 is a heavy plane, which was banking left. Behind the right wing, particularly, we would expect a significant vortex.

These vortexes are enough to flip small planes. Surely there would be a visible swirling effect on the smoke, dust, and debris falling (not being blasted, falling) down through this zone.


[qimg]http://killtown.911review.org/images/flight77/lawn/wtc2_blast.jpg[/qimg]


OFCS

The material that is falling out of the blast is obviously larger and denser material, that is why it is falling out and down in the first place. the wingtip vortices by this time have had a few seconds to dissapate against the surrounding air and against the side of the building. In fact the blast itself comes about a half second after the impact of and subsequent destruction of, the wings with its inherent abrupt ending of the generation of lift and any vortices.

The larger , denser material, the only material that is anywhere near where the vortices would be interacting with the side of the building, are simply going to be moved very little by any dissapating vortices. That material in no way represents the smoke in the NASA photo.

The blast front itself is going to be affected very little by a wing generated vortice even if it encounters one since the energy behind the blast is so much greater than the energy within the vortex. You might as well ask why a flag in a 20 MPH wind does not stray from its downwind pointing when you are blowing at it as hard as you can.
 
So let me take this to its conclusion...

Truthseeker1234 - are you saying that there really wasn't an airplane? If so, how do you explain the thousands of witnesses, photos, and video by non-government people from every conceivable angle showing you and I planes hitting the buildings? It would seem that you're no plane theory (if that's what you're implying) is just wrong simply because of the overwhelming evidence against the theory.

I think Occam's razor dictates that your inexpert assumptions about how the smoke should have looked that day are just wrong in the face of all of this other evidence. Could that explain it more simply than inventing a no-plane theory out of thin air? Pun intended.
 
All these pictures are taken significantly after the plane entered the building. The overpressure from the fuel combustion has already canceled out any wake vortex. You're looking for a fart in a windstorm TS, good luck.
 
This is still a pointless argument considering thousands of people saw the airplanes!

Although a discussion of wing vortexes could be interesting
 
Last edited:
This is still a pointless argument considering thousands of people saw the airplanes!

Although a discussion of wing vortexes could be interesting

Then you believe in UFO's correct? Considering the vast number of people who see UFO's then they must exists.

For the record, I'm not a no planer, but I'm waiting to see how this all pans out.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom