WeWork: overhyped, overvalued

They were advertising on the NFL this weekend, so that could be part of their burn rate. It sounds like they're offering little more than executive office suites. Hard to see how that equates to a multi-billion dollar company. They aren't anything new; I rented an office in one back in the 1980s.

But they have an APP
 
It's Theranos 2.0, just caught a little quicker. Nobody really looked into their books until they started talking about an IPO. Now, nobody can figure out how they're margins could possibly be as high as they're claiming because they have no new ideas or processes, really.

Yeah, Theranos comes to mind. Elizabeth Holmes had like this Steve Jobs cargo cult thing going on. Jobs wore black turtlenecks and jeans, so Holmes also wore black turtlenecks and jeans. She surrounded herself with the superficial trappings of Steve Jobsness.
 
Yeah, Theranos comes to mind. Elizabeth Holmes had like this Steve Jobs cargo cult thing going on. Jobs wore black turtlenecks and jeans, so Holmes also wore black turtlenecks and jeans. She surrounded herself with the superficial trappings of Steve Jobsness.

And Uber.

Uber is a cab company that's figured out how to pay drivers less. Not an exciting technology breakthrough, just 19th century wage cheapness.

AND THEY STILL CAN'T TURN A PROFIT
 
And Uber.

Uber is a cab company that's figured out how to pay drivers less. Not an exciting technology breakthrough, just 19th century wage cheapness.

AND THEY STILL CAN'T TURN A PROFIT
I think Uber is substantially *not* a cab company. (If they were a cab company, their app would suck. Ass.)
 
Sounds like the CEO is doing a fine job of extracting cash from this project before it goes tits up. Good for him, I guess. Hope he enjoys it before he is sued/incarcerated.


He's already voluntarily paid the company back millions. Of course, his motivation is to increase solvency and investor confidence enough to get that sweet, sweet IPO money.


Commercial leases generally aren't so heavily regulated. So long as WeWork isn't taking on residential properties, they can probably avoid a lot of these problems. Locking someone out of their rented office isn't going to land you in housing court the way an self-help apartment eviction would.


Generally, I agree. I still think being in the landlord business is much more difficult than it initially seems.


What exactly is the "that" which you don't think anybody can deliver?


They cannot deliver the services they promise at the profit margin they claim. The next largest company doing the same thing lives on a tenth the profits that WeWork claims it will make. They have no new tech, patent, or idea that isn't already established.

But they do have an app, so that's something. I mean, it isn't anything, but it's available for download.
 
A couple more stories here:

https://slate.com/business/2019/09/wework-adam-neumann-blew-it.html

Still, the money kept pouring in: $700 million in bond sales last year and $2 billion earlier this year from the Japanese telecom Softbank, which raised $100 billion for tech investments from sources like Saudi Arabia’s sovereign wealth fund.

The Saudi sovereign wealth fund is one clue. It reminds me of something I heard about recently on the Planet Money podcast, about negative interest rates:

https://www.npr.org/2019/09/20/762748958/episode-940-interest-rates-why-so-negative

You might wonder why on earth anyone would invest in something that is guaranteed to lose money. Because that's what negative interest rates mean. You'll get less money back than you invested, guaranteed. It has to do with things like the Saudi sovereign wealth fund, as well as other large investors all over the world who are desperate to invest money. Saudi Arabia wants to diversify its economy so that all of its eggs aren't in one basket. And so SoftBank was happy to take the Saudi money and invest it in "tech startups" like WeWork.
 
He's already voluntarily paid the company back millions. Of course, his motivation is to increase solvency and investor confidence enough to get that sweet, sweet IPO money.





Generally, I agree. I still think being in the landlord business is much more difficult than it initially seems.





They cannot deliver the services they promise at the profit margin they claim. The next largest company doing the same thing lives on a tenth the profits that WeWork claims it will make. They have no new tech, patent, or idea that isn't already established.

But they do have an app, so that's something. I mean, it isn't anything, but it's available for download.

I would say the app is new tech, for a number of related reasons I won't get into here. But apparently not revolutionary enough to produce the expected revenues.
 
Another High tech start up that overpromises and underdelivers. Like that has never happened before.
Recently, Elizabeth Holmes comes to mind.
 
Last edited:
And Uber.

Uber is a cab company that's figured out how to pay drivers less. Not an exciting technology breakthrough, just 19th century wage cheapness.

AND THEY STILL CAN'T TURN A PROFIT

The knock on Amazon in the early years was that it was not profitable and this persisted for many years. I think the company was founded in 1994 and only turned profitable a couple years ago (a very brief search didn't reveal the exact year to me, but I believe that it was over 20 years after the founding that they finally turned into the black). Now their profits are in the over $10 billion range annually. This has also led to the situation where they aren't paying taxes on those profits, because they can still claim losses from earlier years to offset those tax liabilities. (Amazon Will Pay a Whopping $0 in Federal Taxes on $11.2 Billion Profits)

But not every tech startup is going to eventually become another Amazon. Investors may be hoping that Uber will eventually turn profitable like Amazon did, but it's a gamble.
 
But not every tech startup is going to eventually become another Amazon. Investors may be hoping that Uber will eventually turn profitable like Amazon did, but it's a gamble.


I read a confusing financial article that said that the Saudi's, who invested heavily in WeWork, need losses to offset their gains. They're willing to diversify knowing that it will be, in some cases, wildly unsuccessful.

I didn't understand all the negative interest rate nonsense, but I don't understand nearly enough about financial markets in general to form an opinion.


ETA: Article linked by Puppycow in post 27.
 
Last edited:
Coworking is a thing already. I have a buddy that owns two spaces that he has turned into small offices and open desk areas that people pay a membership fee and can use the space they pay for. Something like that on a larger scale is what I’m envisioning that my wife could use. She would bring her own equipment and supplies and use it for the couple three days she is in town. Coupled with an app she could log into and see what’s currently available. She pays a fee; they provide her with space. I don’t see how that would run afoul of landlord/tenant laws. She wouldn’t be a tenant; just renting office space hotel-like.

In fact, our current idea is to simply check into a hotel and rent a conference room or something. That’s what I think would be cool - a hotel conference room arrangement but without the hotel and on an demand basis.

It sounds to me like this is what WeWork is trying to do and it’s a sound idea. It’s just run by idiots.
 
I read a confusing financial article that said that the Saudi's, who invested heavily in WeWork, need losses to offset their gains. They're willing to diversify knowing that it will be, in some cases, wildly unsuccessful.

I didn't understand all the negative interest rate nonsense, but I don't understand nearly enough about financial markets in general to form an opinion.


ETA: Article linked by Puppycow in post 27.

It's an NPR podcast which I listen to on my commute, but I realize that not everyone necessarily has headphones or the time to listen to it, so I'll try to summarize the gist of it to the best of my recollection.

There's a "global savings glut" that is arising in developed economies due to aging demographics (older people tend to save and invest more than younger people. This situation is viewed as being likely to continue for the foreseeable future because the demographics aren't going to change overnight. In fact the aging trend is projected to continue in the coming decades, and there's little reason to believe that birth rates will increase significantly in the advanced economies. This leads to a macroeconomic situation where consumer demand is soft and a lot of people are saving money that they want to invest. The more demand there is for things like savings bonds, the higher the price, and the lower the interest rate becomes. It can even become slightly negative because the alternative of hoarding cash also has costs. (Are you going to put it in your mattress? No, you need a bank vault and armed guards and security systems to protect a Scrooge McDuck-style giant pile of money. It costs money to hoard cash.) So interest rates can even become a bit negative, but not too much.

But that's just bonds. Basically there's not much money to be made by investing in bonds these days because the price of them (the safer ones anyway) has already been bid up to about as high as it can theoretically be. But of course there are other possible investments: companies, real estate, etc. The global savings glut would affect these things too. It's likely what led to the last financial crisis, caused by real estate prices being bid up too high and then crashing (among other things).

In other words: too many investment dollars chasing too few genuinely good investment opportunities. Inevitably some of those dollars will go into bad, overhyped investment schemes like this one.
 
Well, everyone will be relieved to know that things worked out very nicely for Adam Neumann. Other employees, not so much:

Here’s what WeWork is giving laid-off employees who aren’t named Adam Neumann
WeWork’s CEO walked away with $1.7 billion and left the company in shambles. His former employees say they are getting shafted.
WeWork recently laid off its first round of employees after the coworking company’s recent implosion — and some former staffers are unhappy with the severance packages they’re being offered.

Recode obtained a severance package that was extended to a recently laid-off employee of Meetup, an app for in-person social events that WeWork acquired. On Monday, Meetup laid off 25 percent of its workforce, or about 50 employees, according to a source. Today, another WeWork-owned company, the coding bootcamp Flatiron School, also laid off dozens of employees.

Meetup is one of several companies WeWork acquired in the past few years that is reportedly up for sale.

The severance offer Recode reviewed (which may not apply to all terminated employees) provides three months of “garden leave” — in which an employee remains on the payroll with benefits but stops working — as well as one month of severance pay.

While four months of pay might sound pretty generous, it’s in stark contrast to the $1.7 billion golden parachute investors handed to WeWork founder and former CEO Adam Neumann. The contract also asks laid-off workers to sign away their right to sue the company over workplace issues and agree to a non-compete clause. That would mean the employee cannot work for a company that competes with WeWork’s wide array of business lines under a preexisting employment contract that sources say could last for between six and 12 months.

As anxious WeWork employees await larger cuts of up to 4,000 jobs in total, this first round of layoffs is raising questions among an already upset staff about whether WeWork rank and file should be getting a better deal, particularly when Neumann walked away with an unprecedented sum for a CEO who brought his company from record heights to near financial ruin.

(I like the photo of Neumann they ran with the story, giving the old victory sign. I would have embedded it, but I'm not sure if that's allowed, so you'll just have to click the link to see the photo.)

With Neumann gone can SoftBank turn around the company to the point where they can justify their total investment, including what they had to pay Neumann to make him go away? I'm still skeptical.
 
With Neumann gone can SoftBank turn around the company to the point where they can justify their total investment, including what they had to pay Neumann to make him go away? I'm still skeptical.

I'm not sure either. Neumann pilfering as much wealth as he can from the company was only one issue. WeWork seemed to be running on the "tech startup" model where the business loses money while trying to become ubiquitous. It's hard to say if the business itself is viable.

I've never really been clear why short-term business sub-leasing is a viable avenue for silicon valley disruption type business.

What has WeWork really done? They advertise heavily and raised a lot of money to buy or lease a lot of office buildings, then turn around and rent them out. That's just called real estate, there's nothing revolutionary here.
 
What has WeWork really done? They advertise heavily and raised a lot of money to buy or lease a lot of office buildings, then turn around and rent them out. That's just called real estate, there's nothing revolutionary here.

Darat had it nailed. They had an App. An App.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom