WeWork: overhyped, overvalued

Puppycow

Penultimate Amazing
Joined
Jan 9, 2003
Messages
34,628
Location
Yokohama, Japan
It's a company that essentially rents out office space. Not exactly a unique idea or something that others can't do just as easily.
It isn't profitable yet. I guess the one thing they could say was that their revenue growth was fast, but that can't go on forever.

The WeWork mess, explained

WeWork, the coworking unicorn startup whose IPO has been one of the most highly anticipated public offerings of 2019, has been imploding in recent weeks.

The company, which was about to begin its roadshow to get public investors interested in buying its shares, postponed its IPO last week in a highly unusual move after investors have expressed concern about its business model and leadership structure. And now, reports indicate that some of the company’s board members, including officials representing SoftBank, its biggest investor, want to push out WeWork’s founder and CEO Adam Neumann.

In the months and even years leading up to WeWork’s IPO push, concerns abounded about its massive losses, whether it’s really a tech company, and its hard-partying corporate culture. But investors seemed to be fine with WeWork’s many problems — until it registered to trade on the public markets. Suddenly the company’s insider dealings (like being both its own landlord and tenant), its track record of burning cash without a path to profitability, and reports of poor executive judgment seemed to become an issue.

The abrupt drop in WeWork’s valuation, to just a third of the $47 billion it had previously been valued at in a January funding round, probably had something to do with it. WeWork declined to comment to Recode on the matter. SoftBank did not immediately respond to a request for comment.

Here's the part that suggests it's kinda fraud-adjacent, and not merely over-hyped:
Poor corporate governance

WeWork’s corporate governance issues are myriad, and the company’s corporate structure is at the root of it all. Like many other tech companies that have recently gone public, WeWork has a multi-class stock structure that gives Neumann more power than the company’s other stockholders.

Neumann has been able to maintain control of WeWork because the Class B- and C shares he owns each had 20 votes to every one vote regular shareholders would get for their Class A shares. After a wave of criticism, WeWork amended its S-1 two weeks ago and limited Neumann’s super-voting shares to 10 votes for every one regular share’s voting power — but that’s still a high ratio.

This means it will be hard to get rid of Neumann if he doesn’t want to leave since his super votes still give him the power to fire the entire board. But if Neumann did get rid of his opponents on the board, he would run this risk of making WeWork look even more chaotic than it already is in the eyes of investors, threatening the outcome of an IPO. Neumann is reportedly in discussions to voluntarily give up his role as CEO, according to a Reuters.

Original company filings stated that if he died, his wife Rebekah, the co-founder and the chief brand and impact officer of WeWork, would have been charged with appointing a successor. The updates to WeWork’s S-1 changed that Game of Thrones scenario to one in which the WeWork board would be responsible for finding the next CEO in the event of Neumann’s death.

Rebekah is one of several family members employed at WeWork, including Neumann’s brother-in-law, who serves as its “head of wellness.”

Neumann’s board supremacy has allowed him to enact a number of nonstandard financial practices that many have viewed as a conflict of interest.

WeWork, which at its heart is a company that leases long-term office space in order to rent it to others in the short term, didn’t initially plan to own property. Not doing so saved it from larger expenses that would burden its already laden balance sheet. But earlier this year, the Wall Street Journal reported that Neumann was privately buying property that he then leased to WeWork. And at the same time, Neumann was borrowing money from WeWork at little to no interest. So the company was paying him rent while lending him money.

Responding in part to investors’ concerns, Neumann said he would transfer ownership of these buildings to the company’s real estate investment vehicle, ARK.

In a similar vein, WeWork paid Neumann nearly $6 million to change its name to “The We Company,” a trademark that Neumann owned. In the mea culpa/updated S-1, he gave that money back.

How WeWork is trying to justify its tech company valuation
“Space as a service” does not a software company make.
WeWork, which is officially known as the We Company, released paperwork to go public Wednesday. In it, the coworking company tried hard to defend its whopping $47 billion valuation, which is multiples larger than it would be worth if it were considered a real estate company like its main competitor IWG. What makes WeWork worth more, the company seems to be saying, is that it’s a tech company — meaning its innovation and flexibility make it better than a regular real estate company.

That’s a tough argument to make, given that for a long time, IWG has had substantially more square footage and more customers, and has actually made a profit — yet its market cap is just 8 percent of what SoftBank’s latest funding round thinks WeWork is worth.

WeWork’s filing shows it’s made some huge strides as far as its relative size to IWG, but that still doesn’t explain a valuation that’s more than 10 times higher. WeWork is operating at a huge loss, losing nearly $900 million in the first half of 2019, but it also doubled its revenue when compared with a year earlier.

Today’s release laid on the argument that it is a tech company — and by extension deserves its high price tag — very heavily. [highlight=yellow]WeWork used a version of the word “tech” 123 times in its public filing[/highlight]; that’s more than the video calling software company Zoom did in its 2019 IPO filing, but less than the ride-hailing app Uber did, which also had to contend with arguments that it is basically a taxi company.

At least it's not a public company yet.
 
In the months and even years leading up to WeWork’s IPO push, concerns abounded about its massive losses, whether it’s really a tech company, and its hard-partying corporate culture. But investors seemed to be fine with WeWork’s many problems
Hey, any (legal) way you can convince the fools to part with their money is fine, right?

They could have invested in a responsible business such as Tesla or Berkshire Hathaway, or just left their money in the bank. But they chose to 'invest' in a dubious company that is operating at a huge loss - so why should we care what happens to them?

Here's the part that suggests it's kinda fraud-adjacent, and not merely over-hyped:
Over-hyped? 'Fraud-adjacent'? Unless it's actually illegal I don't see the problem. The only real purpose of a business is to make money - and you get that by convincing others to give it to you. How you do it is just an implementation detail.


WeWork is operating at a huge loss, losing nearly $900 million in the first half of 2019, but it also doubled its revenue when compared with a year earlier.
So there you go, the business is making money, but it's running $900 million more efficiently than if it broke even! I bet their customers are happy with not being charged enough...
 
Hey, any (legal) way you can convince the fools to part with their money is fine, right?
That's not the way I personally see things.

They could have invested in a responsible business such as Tesla or Berkshire Hathaway, or just left their money in the bank. But they chose to 'invest' in a dubious company that is operating at a huge loss - so why should we care what happens to them?
On one level, sure. It's not our money after all, right? Why should we care even if they put it all in a pile and just set fire to it Joker-style? However, if you believe that there's an important role that financiers play in our economy by making investment decisions, there's actually an argument to be made that the role of finance is to allocate capital in the most efficient way, and that the more efficiently money is invested, the better it is for the economy as a whole, and by extension for all the rest of us who live in the economy and depend on it for our livelihood.*

Over-hyped? 'Fraud-adjacent'? Unless it's actually illegal I don't see the problem. The only real purpose of a business is to make money - and you get that by convincing others to give it to you. How you do it is just an implementation detail.
I sense sarcasm here and in the rest of your post as well, but clearly this is an overly simplistic lens to consider business in. We hope that the end result is to improve standards of living. Money itself is only a means to that end. It's the medium we use to exchange value, not the value itself. So if I make money by selling sham medicine that doesn't work for example, I would make money but not add any real value.

So there you go, the business is making money, but it's running $900 million more efficiently than if it broke even! I bet their customers are happy with not being charged enough...
So I take it that you are suggesting that the customers of WeWork are benefiting by receiving more value than they have to pay for? That might be true but there's no guarantee that they actually derive the utility from it that justifies the total cost. It's unlikely that it would.

* To simplify it conceptually, suppose that I am an investor with a finite amount of capital to invest in a company. Company A and Company B both want exactly the amount of money that I have to invest. I have to choose one and let the other other languish. There's no reason to expect that each investment option would lead to equal value creation unless by pure coincidence. If I choose correctly and make the best investment choice, then capital is allocated efficiently, but if not, then the result is suboptimal.
 
I think the underlying idea is sound. Take someone like my wife (please! :) ). She has started a cash based medical practice and she’d like to have offices in several nearby cities -San Antonio, Houston and Laredo- where she has potential to expand her practice. But it makes no sense for her to get into a long term traditional commercial lease. So it would be cool if there was a way for her to get on an app and say, “I’m going to be in in SA next month. I need 2 rooms and a reception area.” Then she can select “on-demand” space at a suitable price and send notices to her patients that she will be there.

Having said that, WeWork does not seem to be the company that’s going to deliver that.
 
I think the underlying idea is sound. Take someone like my wife (please! :) ). She has started a cash based medical practice and she’d like to have offices in several nearby cities -San Antonio, Houston and Laredo- where she has potential to expand her practice. But it makes no sense for her to get into a long term traditional commercial lease. So it would be cool if there was a way for her to get on an app and say, “I’m going to be in in SA next month. I need 2 rooms and a reception area.” Then she can select “on-demand” space at a suitable price and send notices to her patients that she will be there.

Having said that, WeWork does not seem to be the company that’s going to deliver that.


I don't think anybody can deliver that. Thanks to tenants' rights laws nationwide, evicting a tenant can be a months-long procedure with little or no way to recoup losses. And leases generally aren't allowed to circumvent that process. Any landlord-type organization is going to need hefty lines in its budget for legal fees and written-off lease charges (and debt service charges for those who they do pay a debt collector to go after).
 
They were advertising on the NFL this weekend, so that could be part of their burn rate. It sounds like they're offering little more than executive office suites. Hard to see how that equates to a multi-billion dollar company. They aren't anything new; I rented an office in one back in the 1980s.
 
I don't think anybody can deliver that. Thanks to tenants' rights laws nationwide, evicting a tenant can be a months-long procedure with little or no way to recoup losses. And leases generally aren't allowed to circumvent that process. Any landlord-type organization is going to need hefty lines in its budget for legal fees and written-off lease charges (and debt service charges for those who they do pay a debt collector to go after).

Is this analogous to a tenant-landlord relationship or a hotel-guest relationship?

I assume that hotel guests don't have the same rights as long-term tenants. I mean, it wouldn't require a lengthy legal process for a hotel to evict a guest, would it?
 
Is this analogous to a tenant-landlord relationship or a hotel-guest relationship?

I assume that hotel guests don't have the same rights as long-term tenants. I mean, it wouldn't require a lengthy legal process for a hotel to evict a guest, would it?


Length of stay is one factor. States vary, but in New York (a tenant-friendly state) it can be established without a written lease of any kind in 30 days. With a written lease, that time can go as low as a picosecond.

Other factors include the amount of control and privacy a guest/tenant has. In hotels, maids are always busting in and touching your stuff. The "landlord" is literally in there every single day. In your usual hands-off least, like WeWork provided, the landlord rarely, if ever, even shows up in person, let alone wanders in whenever he wants to. Long-term hotels that offer no cleaning, but are rent-by-the-week affairs, have traditionally had a very hard time staying on one or the other side of that line.

A hotel doesn't "evict" a guest, by the way. Landlords evict tenants. A hotel just throws a guest's stuff onto the street. Incidentally, the hotel cannot touch the person or create a loud scene in the process. That would be assault, battery, and breach of the peace. That's the advice I gave to the one hotel that called me during my practice -wait for the guy to leave, put all his stuff in bags, and change the locks while he's out.
 
Length of stay is one factor. States vary, but in New York (a tenant-friendly state) it can be established without a written lease of any kind in 30 days. With a written lease, that time can go as low as a picosecond.

Other factors include the amount of control and privacy a guest/tenant has. In hotels, maids are always busting in and touching your stuff. The "landlord" is literally in there every single day. In your usual hands-off least, like WeWork provided, the landlord rarely, if ever, even shows up in person, let alone wanders in whenever he wants to. Long-term hotels that offer no cleaning, but are rent-by-the-week affairs, have traditionally had a very hard time staying on one or the other side of that line.

A hotel doesn't "evict" a guest, by the way. Landlords evict tenants. A hotel just throws a guest's stuff onto the street. Incidentally, the hotel cannot touch the person or create a loud scene in the process. That would be assault, battery, and breach of the peace. That's the advice I gave to the one hotel that called me during my practice -wait for the guy to leave, put all his stuff in bags, and change the locks while he's out.

Thanks. I guess I don't know all that much about what distinguishes WeWork's business model from the kind of renting out of space that has been going on for millenia. Landlords and inns are an ancient idea. I'm sure it goes back to feudal times and antiquity at least.

Maybe something like a gym is an analogy? Becoming a member of a gym allows you to use their facilities during business hours, but I suppose they could revoke your membership at any time, if you break their rules, couldn't they? Yeah, as you say, they can't physically manhandle a person to force them to leave, but they could in theory call the cops and have the person arrested for trespassing, disorderly conduct and such if they refuse to leave.
 
Thanks. I guess I don't know all that much about what distinguishes WeWork's business model from the kind of renting out of space that has been going on for millenia. Landlords and inns are an ancient idea. I'm sure it goes back to feudal times and antiquity at least.


As far as I can tell, their profits were supposed to come from two places:

1) taking long-term leases at a discount, because landlords will accept less for not having to keep finding tenants; and

2) automating the leasing experience to save manpower.

The first one is dodgy because property/library taxes might increase as may utility or water prices.

The second one is even worse because: a) you still need a human on site to their diligence in making sure their tenant is a company that's solvent or that one or more individuals personally guarantee the lease and b) that you have somebody onsite to check that the property is being used appropriately and that you, as landlord, are doing whatever you need to in order to maintain the property so the leasee doesn't destroy it.

In reality, the company was raising millions from investors, lying about its market cap, and funnelling wildly irresponsible amounts to its CEO/chief shareholder.

Their closest competitor has a market cap of 1/10th of what WeWork claimed to have, which gives you an idea of how irresponsible their claims to investors were. It's Theranos 2.0, just caught a little quicker. Nobody really looked into their books until they started talking about an IPO. Now, nobody can figure out how they're margins could possibly be as high as they're claiming because they have no new ideas or processes, really.
 
Does he talk in an unnaturally deep voice?

Seriously, how many times do dumb rich people need to be fleeced by Steve Jobs clones before they wise up?

WeWork discovered subletting and doesn't turn a profit. What the hell is so disruptive or revolutionary about this?

Sounds like the CEO is doing a fine job of extracting cash from this project before it goes tits up. Good for him, I guess. Hope he enjoys it before he is sued/incarcerated.
 
Last edited:
I don't think anybody can deliver that. Thanks to tenants' rights laws nationwide, evicting a tenant can be a months-long procedure with little or no way to recoup losses. And leases generally aren't allowed to circumvent that process. Any landlord-type organization is going to need hefty lines in its budget for legal fees and written-off lease charges (and debt service charges for those who they do pay a debt collector to go after).

Commercial leases generally aren't so heavily regulated. So long as WeWork isn't taking on residential properties, they can probably avoid a lot of these problems. Locking someone out of their rented office isn't going to land you in housing court the way an self-help apartment eviction would.
 
Yes, hype, cult-like atmosphere, booze and soft drinks. Plus incompetence.
They were betting on WeWork labs finding them a few gold-egg laying geese, but they're as useless as the rest of the company.

Good t-shirts though.
 
Here's some humor, WeWork literally cribbing strategy from the onion:

https://twitter.com/tomgara/status/1174382034195832837

Clickhole parody headline, Jan 2019:
"Coolest Job Ever: This Awesome Digital Media Company Hired Post Malone To Entertain Laid-Off Employees With Amazing Music While They Cleaned Out Their Desks! "


WeWork reality, Sept 2019
"After firing hundreds of staff, the WeWork CEO held a somber all-hands meeting explaining why it was a necessary move, but then trays of tequila were handed out and DMC from Run-DMC burst into the room and performed "It's Tricky""
 
I don't think anybody can deliver that. Thanks to tenants' rights laws nationwide, evicting a tenant can be a months-long procedure with little or no way to recoup losses. And leases generally aren't allowed to circumvent that process. Any landlord-type organization is going to need hefty lines in its budget for legal fees and written-off lease charges (and debt service charges for those who they do pay a debt collector to go after).

What exactly is the "that" which you don't think anybody can deliver?

Month-to-month office space rentals seem to be a well-established and reasonably successful business model. And I've generally had no trouble getting month-to-month rental agreements from various landlords for my living quarters over the years. In fact, one place I lived for a while, month to month was offered as an option up front by the landlord.

Whatever risk of eviction liability you envision, the property rental industry seems to be taking it in stride.
 
Maybe something like a gym is an analogy? Becoming a member of a gym allows you to use their facilities during business hours, but I suppose they could revoke your membership at any time, if you break their rules, couldn't they? Yeah, as you say, they can't physically manhandle a person to force them to leave, but they could in theory call the cops and have the person arrested for trespassing, disorderly conduct and such if they refuse to leave.

Well, gyms actually profit from members who don't use their services. That and retail sales of protein powder to the gullible. I don't the We Work works like that. If you aren't using the service there is no membership fee.

I caught a brief snippit the other day that could be summed up by saying "if you ignore our expenses, we are profitable"
 
The only reason I give a crap is that they own Meetup.com, which was instrumental in getting my local skeptics group organized, and remains a hub for our coordination.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom