Well if there is no crazy conspiracy theory....

Well, if you want me to speculate on a grainy low resolution representation of a news report, here goes.

The big hole that the helicopter focused on so much was no where near the size the guy interviewed talked about. Assuming the building sharing the video space is a two car garage, then that hole is maybe 4 feet by 8 feet. The guy describes a hole 15 to 20 feet by about 10 feet - about double or a little more the size of the hole in the helicopter footage. We're not seeing the same hole. Why did the news video crew concentrate on that instead of the larger one? Maybe the video crew was more interested in the damage to the home and other buildings than a seemingly empty crater. The other possibility is the other witness is horrible at estimating the size of a hole (or I am).

jbs



Ooooh, is this the problem? That the video does not match the narration by the reporter?

Easy answer, the reporter cannot see the video that is being shown to the audience. She even says so when she says "there is a large crater in the ground and I hope you all can see it". The reporter does not know what is being shown as she speaks so to characterize her as describing the small crater in the video portion is to display a lack of English comprehension.
 
Last edited:
The camera focuses and zooms in on the large black "thing" in front of the garage at just the moment the reporter says "There is a large crater in the ground...and I'm hoping you all are seeing it as I'm talking about it."

This should tell you a couple of things:

The reporter cannot see the live feed at the moment she is speaking.

The copter taking video is not over the impact site as she speaks, but over a debris field nearby.

There is no way for us to tell from this footage alone if what we are seeing is a hole, a burn mark, or an old oil stain from engine repair done near this garage in the past.

Where is the plane?

She told you. It's in little tiny pieces. It hit the ground really, really hard, and really, really fast, and when that happens, there aren't any big pieces left to see.

The plane is still there. It's just in little pieces. Many, many little pieces.

As were the people.
 
What claim am I making? I came here to ask a few questions because I've heard before that this is the place to bring this type of things. I tried to come here once but was instantly turned off by the very low level replies I received repeatedly.

So today I came here and asked a couple of questions about News footage and an unexplained anomaly concerning the Flight 93 crash.

One person thinks the quality is too poor so it's dismissed.
Another says there's just as much footage of plain old trees.
Another tries to insinuate that this video is "highly edited" as if there is something sinister about it.
Another is too busy speculating about what they think I think it is.

Got it.........
I'm sorry. I don't get it. I didn't see a question in the initial post.
I saw two statements:
TC329 said:
This came be explained away easily and rationally.
and
TC329 said:
I went and watched the Initial News Footage of the scene to see if I saw something I didn't see before and this suddenly dawned on me :
some pictures, and then a demand:
TC329 said:

I don't see the question. I don't see a subject to explain.
It isn't until your second post in the thread that we get an actual question from you:

TC329 said:
1) What caused this crater?
2) Why are there no other images of it?
3) Why would the media focus in on this and not the plane shaped crater a few hundred feet away?
4) What is the "official" explanation for it?

My replies to those, though, would be:
1) I don't know; is it a crater? What is its relevance, if any?
2) I don't know that there are no other images of it. Why do you think there aren't?
3) If there aren't any other images of it, what leads you to believe that "the media" (a plural, thus generally indicating more than one) focused on it?
4) I don't know; does there need to be one?

As to the "low level" of replies:
It is difficult to get information from low-quality videos.

Personally, I would interpret the comments on the video being edited down merely to indicate that the subject of the video was of the small crater, so of course that's what it shows, rather than trying to indicate the editing was sinister. That was followed by someone making the point that a lot of footage gets edited out before being aired. You are, of course, welcome to your interpretation.

If people are having to speculate on what your meaning is, I would say that reflects more on your writing skills than on anyone on the forum. It isn't until your third post, which I quoted at the beginning of my reply, that you actually mention the subject of the thread you started: Flight 93.

Just out of curiosity, what form would high level, satisfactory types of replies have taken?
 
There may be better images of the area in an EPA presentation that I linked from here, but - d'oh! - they've taken it down. And I can't find my copy. Anyone remember this or have the original file & can look?
 
Ya see TC329, when you title a thread "Well if there is no crazy conspiracy theory..." right away we know what you believe. Claiming that you are just asking questions is not a legitimate excuse for stupidity. I am not trying to attack you, but you have got to put it into perspective. If you ask dumb questions, you are not going to be taken very seriously (even though CT questions usually are pretty dumb). For example, if I went up to a bunch of historians and asked them a question about the holocaust, like "Well if it really did happen, where are all of the jews bodies?" I would not be taken very seriously now would I? They would immediately know that I was one of those crazy holocaust deniers and that I was trying to prove that the holocaust never happened. So don't put on that act about how you are just here to ask questions. It does not work, and it does not make you look any less crazy/illogical/dumb.
 
I went and watched the Initial News Footage of the scene to see if I saw something I didn't see before and this suddenly dawned on me :

Explain.
​

What suddenly dawned on you?

I see a black splotch, but for the life of me, I can't parlay the splotch into anything sinister. If you want something explained to you, be sure to actually ask a question.
 
1) What caused this crater?
2) Why are there no other images of it?
3) Why would the media focus in on this and not the plane shaped crater a few hundred feet away?
4) What is the "official" explanation for it?

What crater? That is a dirt rock road. What do you see?

Never saw any focus on it.

What are you talking about?

Tell us your story, why is this anything!

Thanks for the video, now I see how everyone is telling lies; there is a lot of plane crash parts! I have seen many Air Force accidents, and that looks like a plane went into the ground and the same kind of stuff all around as your video show!

Looks like more proof a plane at high speed hit the ground!

I am taking questions all day. Questions? More proof 93 hit the ground at high speed!

Thanks again
 
After reading through the insults, innuendos, and some utter nonsense I suppose I will have to draw my own conclussion on what "skeptics" believe happened. So correct me where I'm wrong but :

Flight 93, a Boeing 757 passenger plane, was piloted into the ground by suicidal extremists at a very high rate of speed. Because of the "spongy" soft dirt from this being a reclaimed coal mine the plane burrowed 50 feet into the ground while simultaneously shattering into thousands of little scraps no bigger than a phone book and spreading out over an 8 mile area. A couple pieces like an engine was reported to have "bounced" (i.e. not burrowing into the ground nor shattering into thousands of tiny little pieces) over 600 yards away into a small pond. It would only be logical to come to the conclusion that another rather significant part of the plane also "bounced" (i.e. not burrowing into the ground with the rest of the plane nor shattering into tiny little pieces) and created this 10'x5' (guestimated) crater around 300 yards away into a completely different direction than the engine which makes sense since the plane was heading in two different directions when it hit while it was simultaneously burrowing and shattering and, as I learned on the 5th Anniversary while visiting the site, "vaporizing" as well.

This was the crater shown on local tv in western PA that day and to my recollection the only crater shown on tv that day (not saying the other crater wasn't there, because it was.) Yet after 9/11 not another image was ever seen of it anywhere nor was this footage ever aired again or an explanation for what caused a crater in the ground hundreds of yards away from a plane that was burrowing/shattering/vaporizing.

I wondered if perhaps any of the more enlightened "skeptics" would have a legitimate answer to what is the cause of this crater and how it could have ended up in that area suffering an entirely different fate from the rest of the entire airplane.
 
looks more like a parked ATC to me

It does look like an ATC from the still pictures, but if you look at the video, it just looks like debris.

The rest of the video shows smaller but similar dark debris around, even on the buildings, as well as the white debris.

This is clearly a debris field, so first consideration of this object should be debris. The anouncer is not aware of what is being shown when she talks about the crash crater.

The interviewed photographer talks about a "big gouge in the earth and some broken trees" which does not describe this object. He is talking about the main crash site, even though he gives an absurd dimension. He might not have had a good view of the crash crater.

Just shows how easy it is to cause speculation with stitched together low resolution video.
 
Last edited:
After reading through the insults, innuendos, and some utter nonsense I suppose I will have to draw my own conclussion on what "skeptics" believe happened.

(strawmen, red herrings, and arguments from personal incredulity snipped)

Why must you guys constantly throw out a stream of fallacies when you don't like the answers you are given?(its a rhetorical question, don't answer).
Here's the short version: A 757, flown by hijackers, was forced down by the passengers and crashed violently. The resultant explosion and concussion, combined with a steady wind, blew some of the lighter debris downwind a few miles toward and even into Indian Lake. Beyond that, its hard to predict the exact dynamics of the crash and explosion unless you are an experienced crash investigator, which something tells me you are not. There is no sense convincing yourself that the crash scene was faked when you've absolutely no evidence of it being so and no field experience in crash investigations. Common sense doesnt apply when high energy impacts and explosions are involved as seemingly strange things happen.....

This was the crater shown on local tv in western PA that day and to my recollection the only crater shown on tv that day (not saying the other crater wasn't there, because it was.) Yet after 9/11 not another image was ever seen of it anywhere nor was this footage ever aired again or an explanation for what caused a crater in the ground hundreds of yards away from a plane that was burrowing/shattering/vaporizing.

I wondered if perhaps any of the more enlightened "skeptics" would have a legitimate answer to what is the cause of this crater and how it could have ended up in that area suffering an entirely different fate from the rest of the entire airplane.

First and foremost, please explain in lucid detail how you came to the conclusion that the splotch is a crater? I don't think anyone else here sees a crater. If you are getting that impression from the reporter in the video, well, I don't know what to tell you other than it's quite clear that she's talking about the main crater.

In my very humble, amateur opinion, you are looking at an area of the ground that was burning. The direction of the crash/explosion would've been toward your "crater", and there seems to be other debris in the immediate area.
 
The reporter is commenting on the footage that is being shown, she is reporting from the scene, on the ground.

It looks like a crater, the reporter states it's a crater (and a 10'x5' crater in the middle of the road could be described as "large") and it is dismissed as an ATC and a piece of debris.

Well if it was debris it was a rather large piece of debris scorched black. But I can't look at that footage and see anything other than a crater in the middle of the road because that's exactly what it is.
 
The reporter is commenting on the footage that is being shown, she is reporting from the scene, on the ground.

It looks like a crater, the reporter states it's a crater (and a 10'x5' crater in the middle of the road could be described as "large") and it is dismissed as an ATC and a piece of debris.
I cant believe I have to explain this, but she is not commenting on the footage.
Firstly, she is describing a large crater. Not even on planet X would the splotch be considered large, let alone a crater. Secondly, she is giving a live interview from the field and not commenting on the video that the viewers are being shown. How do I know this? She says something to the effect of "I hope you all are seeing it as I'm talking about it" and earlier, about 30 seconds in, she says "I dont know whether or not you all can see pictures of this...." Thats because she has no idea what is being shown and the producers just continued showing the helicopter footage and even fast forwarded to your small "crater" as she was describing the actual crater.

Why didn't they show the big crater? Well, I've always maintained that TV newscrews are about the dumbest people on the face of the Earth and its possible that the producer(or director, or whatever) thought that the splotch was the crater she was talking about.

ETA: You actually think that looks like a crater? Craters are not small, black, or shaped irregularly. Google "crater" and select 'images'. See if you can find anything close to your crater.
 
Last edited:
The reporter is commenting on the footage that is being shown, she is reporting from the scene, on the ground.

It looks like a crater, the reporter states it's a crater (and a 10'x5' crater in the middle of the road could be described as "large") and it is dismissed as an ATC and a piece of debris.

Well if it was debris it was a rather large piece of debris scorched black. But I can't look at that footage and see anything other than a crater in the middle of the road because that's exactly what it is.



You cannot possibly tell what that object is from that footage.

If you think you can, you're imagining it.

-Gumboot
 
The reporter is commenting on the footage that is being shown, she is reporting from the scene, on the ground.

It looks like a crater, the reporter states it's a crater (and a 10'x5' crater in the middle of the road could be described as "large") and it is dismissed as an ATC and a piece of debris.

Well if it was debris it was a rather large piece of debris scorched black. But I can't look at that footage and see anything other than a crater in the middle of the road because that's exactly what it is.

Interesting, even I got the impression that she was talking about the main impact crater, and I can't even speak english.

Why would you think she was referring to the black spot that happened to be on camera at the moment she was reporting from the scene?


rolleyes
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom