Split Thread USA Gun control/regulation

Aren't they already legal? Isn't the de facto position of virtually all congressional Republicans that everything short of a fully assembled machine gun is legal?

I'm sure I could find sticking points to further relax the law.

Something like that in the pipeline would be GREAT for firearms manufacturers. I think they could actually manipulate people into stockpiling firearms by getting a few friendly candidates or congresspeople to propose just such a law - knowing that it will go nowhere. Meanwhile marketing a range of firearms to people and pushing the line that you need a different one for all occasions. My nephew (26, Trump guy, super-patriot) has begun collecting guns and I think it's clear that ultimately he is increasing the odds of one of his weapons being used in an unintended manner. I don't think he makes any pretense that all of them are needed for self-defense; he just loves guns.

No offense to your nephew, but a 26 year old Trumpist would likely get disqualified on the mental exam.

McHrozni
 
I think it would take much longer than that.

There are a lot of people who would not cooperate with a ban and hide guns.

There would still be legal sales and mass shootings etc can still happen with shotguns, rifles etc.

There are tons of originally US guns in Central America, which would form a new supply source.

There are lots of gun makers outside the USA who could also provide a new supply source.

Any ban is unlikely to consistently over the long term as so many people would campaign against it.

I was presenting the most optimistic possibility for a gun ban, wait for 5-10 years and it gets a whole lot better. If the reality is worse than, well, the gun ban is that much harder to keep up.

War on drugs is a fairly good analogy - neither can work well once the market is awash with product. It's ironic that there are so few people that either oppose or support both, which is the only logically consistent position to have.

McHrozni
 
It's an improvement, sure. Whether or not it would be worth it is another matter. You do realize it would take at least 5-10 years after the ban for there to be any significant improvement, right? The country is awash with guns and even if such weapons were banned today, the illegal supply would last quite a long while. Sure you'd end up in a marginally better place in regards to guns but in the meantime you would also energize the deplorables to vote for politicians who will promise to "return their rights".

I think that you are greatly overestimating the size of the gun lobby.

They aren't as large as you think they are, they just shout the loudest. I'm not proposing a ban on guns, or even most guns. Legislation like we have in the UK just wouldn't work in the US without a fundamental paradigm shift.

I'm proposing that the US bans guns that can "shoot lots of bullets, very fast" as another poster puts it. I think that if you had sensible legislation that closed up loopholes in people buying guns with little to no background checks, and banned the guns that noone actually needs then the 'deplorables' have lots less to shout about.

You can make a good case for owing handguns, or rifles or shotguns. So I wouldn't introduce legislation to restrict those.

You can't make a good case for owning an AR-15 type of semi-auto rifle. It has no civilian uses outside of shooting it for fun at a gun range. If you want to shoot those kinds of weapons, then you should have to join the military.

They only need to win once and they undo all of your work. Good luck getting a new gun ban in that case.

Yes. Though I think that Trump is busy killing off the 'deplorables' as a voting block. (we'll see how well the GOP does in the mid-terms. If they lose enough votes then the Republicans might well get rid of the Tea Party wingnut policies and go back to being conservatives)

Some guns are already banned in the US. Fully automatic guns are not available to civilians. Aside from some fringe gun enthusiasts noone is clamouring for them to be made widely available. Why shouldn't extending the already existing ban a little further not also have the same level of support?

The trick is to write the right legislation in the right way so that reasonable people can't really argue against it.

Sure. But there is a very valid question: is it worth it? Mass shootings kill perhaps a few hundred people in the US a year. Car crashes kill well over 30,000 a year. There is a very valid question of whether or not mass shootings are a significantly large problem to address in such hammerhanded manner.

Ask the parents who lost their children at Sandy Hook if they think it's worth it. Or the kids who survived Parkland.

We already have lots of legislation on the books re cars. If you look at the ratio of fatalities/uses then cars are likely safer than guns. Adding more legislation to reduce car deaths further would have a deleterious effect on the economy. People *need* to use cars. We *need* to move freight by road.

Noone *needs* to have high capacity rapid fire guns outside of the military.
Stop comparing apples to grapefuits.

Again I'm not proposing, nor would I support hamfisted legislation to reduce mass shootings. If you are selective over the types of weapons that are banned, and remove loopholes in the existing regs re background checks and actually properly enforce existing laws then that's much harder to argue against.

Whether you agree or not, please consider what is your answer to increased surveilliance and intrusive security to secure against terrorism. The issue is broadly similar and so was the solution. Do you support that, would you support increased police authority to deal with terrorism?

Society is moving towards a situation where privacy doesn't exist.



See that Tom Scott talk for a version as to why. If you're not into watching youtube videos it's a longish talk on how cellphone technology and 'Big Data' is likely to evolve over the next couple of decades.

Technology is also going to solve the car accident problem by the way.

Once cell phone technology advances to the point where you can plug yourself into it, then no-one has privacy anymore and everyone is surveilled all the time. If the benefits of plugging yourself into the network vastly outweigh the costs then it'll become normal. A bit like Gibsons 'Neuromancer' but much better.

I think you need to deal with increased police powers to combat terror on a case by case basis.

Letting the govt compile and sift meta data, I'm OK with that. Letting the govt have a backdoor into any cellphone, hell no.

I generally disagree with anything that there's a "war on" war on drugs, war on terror you can't declare war on those kinds of things. Instead of blanket statements and hamfisted legislation we should have precise, well written and well targeted legislation.
 
If you kept the current US society and just took the guns away you'd likely end up with a society with many more stabbings, vehicular attacks, improvised weapons attacks and such. It would be a step up from the gun violence - it's easier to kill people with a gun than with a hammer - but the situation would still be quite bad. Furthermore achieving this is next to impossible, given that the country is awash with guns.

The proper way to address the issue is to examine the causes why the US culture is so violent. I don't know what causes it, gun ownership may well contribute to it, but it's clear that it's not the only, or even main cause. Figuring out what the other causes are and addressing them should come before gun control.

Why? Gun control is next to impossible to achieve in USA and given the current availability of guns and is unlikely to improve the situation in anytihng less than a generation ... a generation during which the legislation could well change, with the somewhat valid reason "see, your way didn't fix anything". It's a high hanging fruit that isn't even particularily sweet to begin with. It's best to start elsewhere and revisit the issue when you addressed the parts of the problem that don't need the political capital of several generations to fix.

McHrozni
If that were in fact the case, then I would think that would be a very big and serious reason why better gun control is needed, it's certainly not a reason.

How about first take away their guns (important first step) - then take a look at why they are so violent. Seems reasonable to me.
 
If that were in fact the case, then I would think that would be a very big and serious reason why better gun control is needed, it's certainly not a reason.

How about first take away their guns (important first step) - then take a look at why they are so violent. Seems reasonable to me.

That's in line with what I proposed, yes.

McHrozni
 
I'm proposing that the US bans guns that can "shoot lots of bullets, very fast" as another poster puts it. I think that if you had sensible legislation that closed up loopholes in people buying guns with little to no background checks, and banned the guns that noone actually needs then the 'deplorables' have lots less to shout about.

You can make a good case for owing handguns, or rifles or shotguns. So I wouldn't introduce legislation to restrict those.

You can't make a good case for owning an AR-15 type of semi-auto rifle. It has no civilian uses outside of shooting it for fun at a gun range. If you want to shoot those kinds of weapons, then you should have to join the military.

I'm not actually opposed to any of those. I just try to look at what such legislation would do beyond its' intent. It will reduce the number of legally owned firearms, sure, what else?

A lot of that is not nearly as nice. You can't just ignore that.

The trick is to write the right legislation in the right way so that reasonable people can't really argue against it.

The trick is to write the legislation that will survive the next election. Reasonable arguments against it are the least it'll go up against.

Ask the parents who lost their children at Sandy Hook if they think it's worth it. Or the kids who survived Parkland.

Travel back in time to 9/12/01 and an injured 9/11 survivor if increased airplane security would be worth it. Then go back to present and ask a random person.

Do you expect those two answers to differ? If yes you have the same conundrum with guns.

And I do think it would be worth it, mind you. But that doesn't mean it would also be worth the backlash it would create.

We already have lots of legislation on the books re cars. If you look at the ratio of fatalities/uses then cars are likely safer than guns.

Cars are made to bring people from A to be, guns are made to kill people. There are about as many of each in the US and cause about as many deaths (guns killed 33 thousand, cars killed 40 thousand in 2017).

It's difficult to make a case that guns cause vastly more danger to society than cars do, especially since a substantial proportion of gun deaths are suicides. It's quite possible to commit a suicide with a car, I guarantee you that. You're more likely to make it a murder-suicide by accident.

Noone *needs* to have high capacity rapid fire guns outside of the military.

Military and maybe the police, sure. But you need the electorate to agree on it as well.

Society is moving towards a situation where privacy doesn't exist.

See that Tom Scott talk for a version as to why.

I can't listen to the video, but I always thought the reason was "because it's more profitable that way".

McHrozni
 
You can't make a good case for owning an AR-15 type of semi-auto rifle. It has no civilian uses outside of shooting it for fun at a gun range.
This is one of the problems when it comes to writing gun control legislation. Some gun control proponents use the same nonsense argument as above. An AR-15 is entirely suitable for hunting small and large game animals.

Some guns are already banned in the US.
Not true at the federal level.

Fully automatic guns are not available to civilians.
Also not true.

Aside from some fringe gun enthusiasts noone is clamouring for them to be made widely available.
Machine guns are readily available to anyone who properly applies for a license or buys a tax stamp.

The trick is to write the right legislation in the right way so that reasonable people can't really argue against it.
The trick is to write legislation that is not worded so stupid.

Ranb
 
Last edited:
Point 7 also seems relevant to the general thrust of your argument - the US does not have either more crime nor more violent crime than comparable nations. The UK has more of both. What the US has is more fatalities from violent crime, because it has more guns.

Not according to say this for example



Crime levels are 20% higher. that's not insignificant.
 
Last edited:
This generalization ignores the reality that the weapon of choice for spree killers, semi-auto rifles, are not commonly used in ordinary street crime. Rifle deaths in the country are practically insignificant compared to pistols and revolvers, despite those being inferior killing tools. Portability and concealibility are important factors unless you're a lunatic going on a suicide mission.
Perhaps, but it makes me think. I wonder what proportion of gun deaths by hand guns are related to crime and criminal gangs, vs innocent people being gunned down.

Mass shootings generally kill innocent people.

If hand gun shootings have a very high percent of non gang related shootings then ok, hand guns are the problem. But if most of that is due to gang violence, I wonder how much of whats left compare to the rate of long gun shootings.
 
How many times do we have to drop hints before you dumb Democrats get it? Didn't you guys see the headlines about the most recent weekend in Chicago? The problem isn't guns; it's black people.
 
Perhaps, but it makes me think. I wonder what proportion of gun deaths by hand guns are related to crime and criminal gangs, vs innocent people being gunned down.

Well, 2/3 of gun deaths are suicides and slightly under 2% are accidents, less than 1% is unknown, the rest are homicides, guns account for about 2/3 of homicides in the US.

A gun ban would definitely help to make US a better place, if it could be done without significant negative consequences. Currently there is no reason to think it would be possible to even maintain it so it's rather hard to argue USA would be better off with a gun ban anytime soon.

But hey, maybe Trump will discredit the deplorables so badly it'll be possible within a decade. There is hope.

McHrozni
 
This is one of the problems when it comes to writing gun control legislation. Some gun control proponents use the same nonsense argument as above. An AR-15 is entirely suitable for hunting small and large game animals.

Please help me to not make nonsense arguments then. I am not well versed in guns. In what way is an AR-15 suitable for hunting? I'm just using AR-15 as it's the gun name that crops up most often. You could substitute any high capacity semi-auto or similar type of gun here.

If such types of guns were restricted so they were not outright banned, but much harder to get. Would many hunters go through the extra time and expense to obtain one as opposed to a less restricted bolt action rifle say. i.e. are they much better for hunting such animals than a bolt action rifle?

Machine guns are readily available to anyone who properly applies for a license or buys a tax stamp.

Would it be fair to say that such guns are significantly harder to obtain for an average US citizen?

If that is the case then I'd be happy with new gun legislation in the US that made guns that fire "lots of bullets very fast" (high capacity semi-autos as I understand things) just as difficult to obtain. It needn't be a full ban.
 
I was presenting the most optimistic possibility for a gun ban, wait for 5-10 years and it gets a whole lot better. If the reality is worse than, well, the gun ban is that much harder to keep up.

War on drugs is a fairly good analogy - neither can work well once the market is awash with product. It's ironic that there are so few people that either oppose or support both, which is the only logically consistent position to have.

McHrozni

There have been huge attempts over the years to restrict and control drugs and alcohol. Both have failed. I beats me why people think guns can be restricted and controlled.

As with drugs and alcohol, the best policy is to learn to cope.
 
Please help me to not make nonsense arguments then. I am not well versed in guns. In what way is an AR-15 suitable for hunting? I'm just using AR-15 as it's the gun name that crops up most often. You could substitute any high capacity semi-auto or similar type of gun here.
Any gun used for hunting needs to be portable, powerful and accurate, enough. Most semi-auto rifles including the AR-15 are suitable; but in a way the AR-15 and modular rifles like it are unique. The AR-15 can be chambered in 17-50 caliber cartridges, weighs 6-25 pounds and can be accurate out to 600 meters. It is the 50 caliber variants that weigh the most; they are also single shots and effective out to a mile.

If such types of guns were restricted so they were not outright banned, but much harder to get.
If they were restricted like machine guns (NFA of 1934) which require a bkgd check, fingerprints, photos and take several weeks/months for approval then most would go the less restrictive route.

Would many hunters go through the extra time and expense to obtain one as opposed to a less restricted bolt action rifle say. i.e. are they much better for hunting such animals than a bolt action rifle?
A bolt gun is better in my opinion as they usually have a better combination of weight/accuracy than any semi-auto rifle. In my opinion only in those rare circumstances that a rapid follow up shot is required on dangerous game would semi-auto come in handy and most semi-auto rifles are not intended for large/dangerous game.

Would it be fair to say that such guns are significantly harder to obtain for an average US citizen?
A gun controlled by the NFA is no longer harder to obtain since the Obama administration eased certain restrictions (signature from the local sheriff) but it is still more expensive and time consuming. Ironically it might be Trump's legacy that he did less to ease restrictions on guns in the USA than Obama. :)

If that is the case then I'd be happy with new gun legislation in the US that made guns that fire "lots of bullets very fast" (high capacity semi-autos as I understand things) just as difficult to obtain. It needn't be a full ban.
So far there are only state level restrictions on semi-auto.
 
This generalization ignores the reality that the weapon of choice for spree killers, semi-auto rifles, are not commonly used in ordinary street crime. Rifle deaths in the country are practically insignificant compared to pistols and revolvers, despite those being inferior killing tools. Portability and concealibility are important factors unless you're a lunatic going on a suicide mission.

Well, 2/3 of gun deaths are suicides and slightly under 2% are accidents, less than 1% is unknown, the rest are homicides, guns account for about 2/3 of homicides in the US.

A gun ban would definitely help to make US a better place, if it could be done without significant negative consequences. Currently there is no reason to think it would be possible to even maintain it so it's rather hard to argue USA would be better off with a gun ban anytime soon.

But hey, maybe Trump will discredit the deplorables so badly it'll be possible within a decade. There is hope.

McHrozni

Perhaps, but it makes me think. I wonder what proportion of gun deaths by hand guns are related to crime and criminal gangs, vs innocent people being gunned down.

Mass shootings generally kill innocent people.

If hand gun shootings have a very high percent of non gang related shootings then ok, hand guns are the problem. But if most of that is due to gang violence, I wonder how much of whats left compare to the rate of long gun shootings.
http://www.bbc.com/news/world-us-canada-41488081
2/3s of gun deaths in the US are suicide, nearly all of those are hand guns, for obvious reasons. Roughly 2/3s of gun murders involve hand guns. If we banned handguns the deaths from guns would plummet. Unfortunately, that is the least likely type of gun to be controlled in the US.

Side note, the BBC article linked above has a pie chart for types of guns used in murder; handguns, rifles, shotguns, other. What is other? Civil war canons?

Mass shootings account for effectively zero percent of US gun deaths, but they get the most coverage and drive the discussion. We are clearly irrational.
 
Last edited:
Side note, the BBC article linked above has a pie chart for types of guns used in murder; handguns, rifles, shotguns, other. What is other? Civil war canons?
Machine guns, AOW's, DD's perhaps? I think it most likely means a projectile weapon was used but they don't know if it came from a rifle or handgun as some use the same ammo.
 
Machine guns, AOW's, DD's perhaps? I think it most likely means a projectile weapon was used but they don't know if it came from a rifle or handgun as some use the same ammo.

Interesting, they should have said unidentified then. Its the second largest category after hand guns.
 
If you kept the current US society and just took the guns away you'd likely end up with a society with many more stabbings, vehicular attacks, improvised weapons attacks and such. It would be a step up from the gun violence - it's easier to kill people with a gun than with a hammer - but the situation would still be quite bad. Furthermore achieving this is next to impossible, given that the country is awash with guns.



The proper way to address the issue is to examine the causes why the US culture is so violent. I don't know what causes it, gun ownership may well contribute to it, but it's clear that it's not the only, or even main cause. Figuring out what the other causes are and addressing them should come before gun control.



Why? Gun control is next to impossible to achieve in USA and given the current availability of guns and is unlikely to improve the situation in anytihng less than a generation ... a generation during which the legislation could well change, with the somewhat valid reason "see, your way didn't fix anything". It's a high hanging fruit that isn't even particularily sweet to begin with. It's best to start elsewhere and revisit the issue when you addressed the parts of the problem that don't need the political capital of several generations to fix.



McHrozni



Well perhaps having an administration that recognizes that having less not more guns, and introducing legislation to make a start at changing things is the first step to changing a countries culture. Lead from the top. And since USA is a very Christian nation, perhaps the various churches should do more to get the point across? Does USA have public service broadcasts?

In any event I have always said the place to start is to set up a publicly funded research project into the issue. Gun violence is clearly a problem, so let’s find out why. Could take 10 years but it would be a start and at least then any laws past after that should/could be based on research and evidence. There has to be a willingness first though.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
Please help me to not make nonsense arguments then. I am not well versed in guns. In what way is an AR-15 suitable for hunting? I'm just using AR-15 as it's the gun name that crops up most often. You could substitute any high capacity semi-auto or similar type of gun here.

If such types of guns were restricted so they were not outright banned, but much harder to get. Would many hunters go through the extra time and expense to obtain one as opposed to a less restricted bolt action rifle say. i.e. are they much better for hunting such animals than a bolt action rifle?



Would it be fair to say that such guns are significantly harder to obtain for an average US citizen?

If that is the case then I'd be happy with new gun legislation in the US that made guns that fire "lots of bullets very fast" (high capacity semi-autos as I understand things) just as difficult to obtain. It needn't be a full ban.
While some people have taken deer with intermediate calibers like 5.56 (AR-15) or 7.62x39 (AK variants), I think most would consider those a bit on the weaker side and prefer a more powerful cartridge.

Intermediate calibers are very good for small predators (fox, coyote) and varmint control. 5.56 is especially good, being a small, high velocity bullet that has a fairly straight trajectory within reasonable ranges for these activities. A 50 yard zero for common 5.56 loads will a +/- 2.5" point of impact out to about 250-300 yards, which is very helpful. Semi autos with light recoil and large magazines are well suited for killing nuisance rodents like ground hogs, where a bolt actions limited rate of fire would be very detrimental both for following up on misses and killing scattering groups of varmint/predators. Low cost per cartridge makes 5.56 even more attractive.

Dangerous prey animals, like the highly invasive wild boar, absolutely call for semi auto weapons because follow up shots may be the difference between a fast kill or getting gored. Many places in the US have no "bag" limits for these animals as total eradication is the goal for these invasive, destructive, and non-native species. 5.56 can be appropriate for your small to average boar, while larger examples may require a step up in power.
 
Last edited:
Dangerous prey animals, like the highly invasive wild boar, absolutely call for semi auto weapons because follow up shots may be the difference between a fast kill or getting gored. Many places in the US have no "bag" limits for these animals as total eradication is the goal for these invasive, destructive, and non-native species. 5.56 can be appropriate for your small to average boar, while larger examples may require a step up in power.

Of course the actual boar hunter I know uses a bolt action rifle.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom