Split Thread USA Gun control/regulation

The issue is relevant, the reply was not.

I think it was.

You could also try to address the other points I raised. They don't bite.

I'll be honest, the things I've ignored are either things that I don't have the time or energy to go into enough detail to correct you on (such as your linking of mental health with violence, when people with mental health issues are no more likely to be violent than anybody else - or even less violent given that the percentage of people who have experience mental health issues is lower than the proportion of violent acts that are carried out by people with mental health issues - and are more than 10 times as likely to be victims of violent crime than people without mental health issues), or which are victims enough of the whole "talking past each other" thing that I simply can't be arsed. Instead I've chosen a strategy of trying to stick to what's most relevant to the topic at hand.
 
I'll be honest, the things I've ignored are either things that I don't have the time or energy to go into enough detail to correct you on (such as your linking of mental health with violence, when people with mental health issues are no more likely to be violent than anybody else - or even less violent given that the percentage of people who have experience mental health issues is lower than the proportion of violent acts that are carried out by people with mental health issues - and are more than 10 times as likely to be victims of violent crime than people without mental health issues), or which are victims enough of the whole "talking past each other" thing that I simply can't be arsed. Instead I've chosen a strategy of trying to stick to what's most relevant to the topic at hand.

Ostrich method, got it.

ttyl

McHrozni
 
Furthermore, if you want to make a dent in gun deaths you absolutely must ban those guns that cause the overwhelming majority of gun deaths. Or at least you should explain how would a ban on assault rifle derivates reduce the number of deaths by handgun.


The point of gun control in the US is not to reduce overall gun deaths, per se. At least that's not how I see it.

America has enshrined the gun as something that the nation was founded upon. (erroneously as it happens but that's a whole different topic) It has the 2nd amendment in it's constitution which isn't going to be changed anytime soon, and for gun control regulations of the type that would restrict ownership of handguns, then the 2nd amendment has to be rescinded. (not happening in my lifetime at least)

The point of gun control in the US in the shorter term is to limit mass shootings.

Yes more people die from handguns, or from suicide using guns and limiting handguns would probably be a good thing to do, but, in todays climate that's just never going to happen.

What might well happen is for the US to tighten existing regs and add a few new ones that make it much harder for someone to flip and then kill lots of people very quickly with high powered weaponry.

That kind of change I might get to see in my lifetime. (I'm 40ish)

The US is the only(?) western country where school shootings in particular and mass shootings in general occur frequently.

So restricting the guns that can, as one poster here puts it, "fire lots of bullets, very fast" would help to reduce the number of mass shooting events, and also the numbers of casualties of the ones that do still occur.


There are people that want a total ban on guns and people that don't see anything wrong with civilians owning nuclear weapons, and all shades of people in between.
As I see it though, support is growing, slowly, for more restrictions on "mass shooter" guns as well as tightening loopholes and improving background checks for gun sales.
That wouldn't make much of a dent in overall gun deaths in the US, but it would reduce significantly the mass shooting events that occur in the US with grim regularity.
 
The point of gun control in the US in the shorter term is to limit mass shootings.

For now, certainly, because USA is unable to get anything better through. The thing is, it's quite possible to conduct a mass shooting with a handgun.

On the other hand if you could study the reasons for mass shootings and prevent them from happening in the first place, that would be superior to any advantage any gun ban could ever bring. These people were damaged, perhaps even destroyed before they ever picked up a gun.

The US is the only(?) western country where school shootings in particular and mass shootings in general occur frequently.

School shootings are a US peculiarity, but mass shootings occur elsewhere too. Europe had more deaths in mass shootings per capita in the past decade than US. Granted, most of those weren't random acts of nutjobs, but the work of terrorists (most by ISIS plus Brevik), which probably should go in a different category than school kids loosing it and going postal.

That said, Finland too is a bit of an outlier, to cite a few examples:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jokela_school_shooting
https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/wo...ng-Gunman-planned-massacre-for-six-years.html
https://yle.fi/uutiset/osasto/news/helsinki_police_21_year-old_woman_planned_school_shooting/9180914

Finland has a population 1/60 of US, the first two incidents above are equivalent to 120 school shootings in the US. The problem is of course in that Finland does have a low GINI, functional school and healthcare system. But it also has gun control and their gun ownership rate is indistinguishable from that of, say, Germany.

If you want to stop school shootings gun control is probably not going to help much. It could stop an incident here or there I guess, which is a plus, but the time and energy it would take to implement it are probably better spent elsewhere.

As I see it though, support is growing, slowly, for more restrictions on "mass shooter" guns as well as tightening loopholes and improving background checks for gun sales.

That's welcome, but don't expect it to have a rapid effect. There are hundreds of millions of guns in circulation, it will take years, decades for enough guns to be weeded out to have a significant effect.

McHrozni
 
Gun control is like carbon control -- it's too late to do anything, so you might as well have as much fun as possible. Mostly it'll be the young suffering and dying, so who cares?
 
Finland has a population 1/60 of US, the first two incidents above are equivalent to 120 school shootings in the US. The problem is of course in that Finland does have a low GINI, functional school and healthcare system. But it also has gun control and their gun ownership rate is indistinguishable from that of, say, Germany.

2 is too small a sample size to draw any conclusions from.

It's also worth noting that both examples took place a decade ago, that the first saw a change in the Finnish approach to gun violence, including tighter gun controls, the second was at a college, not a school, and your third example is not of a school shooting but of the prevention of a school shooting.

According to [url#=https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_unsuccessful_attacks_related_to_schools]this list[/url], and being generous and including everything listed since 2007 in the US regardless of whether or not it was an actual school shooting and whether or not it was police work that prevented it, there were 13 incidents in the US. Since you seem to think that you can just multiply Finland's figures by 60 and come up with a valid result, that means that Finland's school shooting prevention policies are more than 4 times more effective than the US's, right?
 
2 is too small a sample size to draw any conclusions from.

Sure. But in that case you can't claim US is an outlier in school shootings, because there is nothing to compare it to.

It's also worth noting that both examples took place a decade ago, that the first saw a change in the Finnish approach to gun violence, including tighter gun controls, the second was at a college, not a school, and your third example is not of a school shooting but of the prevention of a school shooting.

I'm not saying tighter gun controls aren't a workable approach to the problem at hand. I'm saying they aren't workable in the US at this time.

McHrozni
 
Gun control is like carbon control -- it's too late to do anything, so you might as well have as much fun as possible. Mostly it'll be the young suffering and dying, so who cares?

I wouldn't say that is true for either. Both are difficult, next to impossible even, if you approach them from the wrong way. What is true is that both are approached from the wrong way. I already explained how you approach the school shootings and gun violence in general above, the way to approach carbon control with the likes of Trump is a whole lot easier: "Who do you want to control the worlds' energy supply, us or the towelheads?" and collect your Nobel prize a few years down the line.

Sure, it's not as easy as I make it sound. But since the care for enviroment isn't working and he's a fraction of the racist xenophobe he appears to be, this approach should work a lot better than what we've seen so far.

McHrozni
 
Last edited:
You have to take into account that gun deaths in the US is really several issues that are only somewhat related.

You have:

Gangland/urban crime:Lot of gun violence comes from crime related to densely populated, endemically poor urban areas of cities like Chicago and Baltimore. The gun violence there is just a component of a larger endemic crime problem related to concentrated, long-term, and hopeless poverty. People of any wealth or influence don't live or work in these areas, so it's often ignored in the political arena. Removing guns would likely reduce lethality of these areas somewhat, but root cause of violence would remain. Gun laws here usually focus on handguns, licensing, and background checks.

School/spree killings: Obviously these make a much bigger news impact. More emphasis placed on controlling rifles since shooters use much more firepower than the average street criminal. More emphasis is placed on mental illness, restricted persons, and magazine/rifle bans.

Crimes of passion: Includes your domestic violence and road rage scenarios. Scenarios where having a gun present exasperates a volatile situation. Home of your domestic violence prohibition on gun ownership, emergency protective orders to remove guns.

Suicides: Similar to above.

I break these up because, generally, these problems have been addressed politically as separate issues in the past. Laws that address one rarely have much impact on the other, unless we're talking about outright prohibition across the board.
 
A rising tide raises all ships.
A better killing machine kills more people, regardless of the "why's" and "who's".
 
A rising tide raises all ships.
A better killing machine kills more people, regardless of the "why's" and "who's".
This generalization ignores the reality that the weapon of choice for spree killers, semi-auto rifles, are not commonly used in ordinary street crime. Rifle deaths in the country are practically insignificant compared to pistols and revolvers, despite those being inferior killing tools. Portability and concealibility are important factors unless you're a lunatic going on a suicide mission.
 
For now, certainly, because USA is unable to get anything better through. The thing is, it's quite possible to conduct a mass shooting with a handgun.

Yes.

But put yourself in the situation of being somewhere where a mass shooting was taking place. Which weapon would you rather the shooter was using?

I'd much prefer it if the shooter was using a weapon that wasn't very accurate outside of point blank ranges, that needed frequent reloading and could only shoot 1 bullet per trigger pull.

On the other hand if you could study the reasons for mass shootings and prevent them from happening in the first place, that would be superior to any advantage any gun ban could ever bring.

If we could study the ways that stars work we could re-produce fusion power and use it to provide energy "too cheap to meter" to the whole of the planet without burning fossil fuels.

If we could work out what gravity is and how to produce it on demand we could completely revolutionise air travel.

Preventing mass shootings from happening is about as likely, perhaps even less so, than either of those statements.

People are complicated and we live in a complex, chaotic world and working out the causes of mass shooting events, before they happen and identifying and stopping people from committing them before they happen is *extremely* difficult. In fact doing so without severely curtailing an individuals freedoms might be impossible.

If you want to stop school shootings gun control is probably not going to help much. It could stop an incident here or there I guess, which is a plus, but the time and energy it would take to implement it are probably better spent elsewhere.

It's worked very well for every other western nation, why shouldn't it work well for the US? the US isn't THAT special. We're all humans, whether we are European, Asian, American. We have the same needs and wants and desires and all the rest of it. Why can't a solution that's worked well everywhere else also work in the USA?
 
Yes.

But put yourself in the situation of being somewhere where a mass shooting was taking place. Which weapon would you rather the shooter was using?

I'd much prefer it if the shooter was using a weapon that wasn't very accurate outside of point blank ranges, that needed frequent reloading and could only shoot 1 bullet per trigger pull.

It's an improvement, sure. Whether or not it would be worth it is another matter. You do realize it would take at least 5-10 years after the ban for there to be any significant improvement, right? The country is awash with guns and even if such weapons were banned today, the illegal supply would last quite a long while. Sure you'd end up in a marginally better place in regards to guns but in the meantime you would also energize the deplorables to vote for politicians who will promise to "return their rights".

They only need to win once and they undo all of your work. Good luck getting a new gun ban in that case.

If we could study the ways that stars work we could re-produce fusion power and use it to provide energy "too cheap to meter" to the whole of the planet without burning fossil fuels.

If we could work out what gravity is and how to produce it on demand we could completely revolutionise air travel.

Preventing mass shootings from happening is about as likely, perhaps even less so, than either of those statements.

Perhaps, I don't know.

What I do know is that banning guns to a sufficient extent to significantly curb mass shootings is harder than all of the above combined. What's your point again?

People are complicated and we live in a complex, chaotic world and working out the causes of mass shooting events, before they happen and identifying and stopping people from committing them before they happen is *extremely* difficult. In fact doing so without severely curtailing an individuals freedoms might be impossible.

Sure. But there is a very valid question: is it worth it? Mass shootings kill perhaps a few hundred people in the US a year. Car crashes kill well over 30,000 a year. There is a very valid question of whether or not mass shootings are a significantly large problem to address in such hammerhanded manner.

Whether you agree or not, please consider what is your answer to increased surveilliance and intrusive security to secure against terrorism. The issue is broadly similar and so was the solution. Do you support that, would you support increased police authority to deal with terrorism? If not, why not and how does the main argument there - that terrorism is a minor threat anyway - not apply to gun bans as well?

It's worked very well for every other western nation, why shouldn't it work well for the US? the US isn't THAT special. We're all humans, whether we are European, Asian, American. We have the same needs and wants and desires and all the rest of it. Why can't a solution that's worked well everywhere else also work in the USA?

A deeply ingrained gun culture with lots of money to throw around, for starters.

What's keeping the Arab world from embracing secularism and enlightenment? Same answer.

You can't fix these problems by ignoring the reasons for their existence.

McHrozni
 
Last edited:
Rifle deaths in the country are practically insignificant compared to pistols and revolvers, despite those being inferior killing tools. Portability and concealibility are important factors unless you're a lunatic going on a suicide mission.
It's true that any restrictions targeting a certain type of gun are going to be subject to "whataboutism," to some extent justified, since the weapons of choice run the gamut. In general it's true that mass shootings are done with guns that are useful for mass shootings, but there are enough exceptions to confound things.

Hawaii has a relatively high rate of gun ownership but few homicides. Alaska has the highest rate, but it's still only 61 percent. (Lots of homicides too). What I'm wondering is whether ownership of multiple firearms in a home correlates with or facilitates mass shootings. A cursory look tells me that many mass shooters come prepared with more than one firearm. Of course there are exceptions to that as well.

Though I do tend to agree that the critical mass of guns in the U.S. makes any attempt to force down the numbers problematic, I also would like to see states continue to chip away at issues that are viable in those states. I don't think anything much will happen at a federal level, but it might at a state level.

The country is awash with guns and even if such weapons were banned today, the illegal supply would last quite a long while. Sure you'd end up in a marginally better place in regards to guns but in the meantime you would also energize the deplorables to vote for politicians who will promise to "return their rights".
I don't think it's pointless for states to do what they can. You're right that large-scale laws would take a long time to work and would promote a backlash.

What I'm wondering about is if anything can be done about multiple firearms in a home. Maybe require a special collectors license or increased safe-storage requirements. On the other hand even tracking such collectors would be met with massive resistance. But I'm wondering if a concentration of guns in one household is any kind of risk factor. It's a way to recast the narrative somewhat. At any rate I think state-level laws chipping away at high-capacity magazines etc. are worth it only if as symbolic gestures. A little bit of pushback would be nice at this point and Florida actually did something about it. NO of course it won't eliminate mass shootings.
 
I don't think it's pointless for states to do what they can. You're right that large-scale laws would take a long time to work and would promote a backlash.

Yep. That's what makes the gun control far more difficult than it seems at a first glance. It's not just introducing control, it's maintaining it. Unless you amend the constitution it'll likely just get tossed out after the next election, which you will lose precisely because of gun control.

Again, "if we ban guns only bad guys will have guns" will be true and accurate at least for the first few years of the ban, perhaps more. There's just no way around it. In a democracy with a two year election cycle there is just no way to conceal this from the electorate and get away with it. It will be a contencious issue for another twenty years at least.

What I'm wondering about is if anything can be done about multiple firearms in a home. Maybe require a special collectors license or increased safe-storage requirements. On the other hand even tracking such collectors would be met with massive resistance. But I'm wondering if a concentration of guns in one household is any kind of risk factor. It's a way to recast the narrative somewhat. At any rate I think state-level laws chipping away at high-capacity magazines etc. are worth it only if as symbolic gestures. A little bit of pushback would be nice at this point and Florida actually did something about it. NO of course it won't eliminate mass shootings.

If I really wanted to fix the issue and was in a position to do something about it no matter what it would do to my reputation I'd go out and claim how I was pro-guns and whatnot and demand legalization of assault rifles for those that can prove they're mentally capable of doing so.

I'd use the momentum to introduce a national gun licence, similar to a car licence. The car licence actively seeks for vision impairment so a gun licence should include active screening for undiagnosed mental diseases and underlying aggression from at least two therapists. Military and police forces already do that, just extend it to regular gun owners.

It wouldn't eliminate mass shootings, but it's a great foundation for more reasonable gun control in the future. If it disqualifies a lot of deplorables from owning guns in the first place maybe, just maybe, the issue will drop below the radar to the point when something else could be done as well. Addressing it head on in the current enviroment is a waste of time and effort.

Note: I would never actually go through with the relaxation of laws for assault rifles, it's just something I'd vocally support to get the deplorables to reelect me.

McHrozni
 
Last edited:
If I really wanted to fix the issue and was in a position to do something about it no matter what it would do to my reputation I'd go out and claim how I was pro-guns and whatnot and demand legalization of assault rifles for those that can prove they're mentally capable of doing so.
Aren't they already legal? Isn't the de facto position of virtually all congressional Republicans that everything short of a fully assembled machine gun is legal?

I'd use the momentum to introduce a national gun licence, similar to a car licence. The car licence actively seeks for vision impairment so a gun licence should include active screening for undiagnosed mental diseases and underlying aggression from at least two therapists. Military and police forces already do that, just extend it to regular gun owners.
Something like that in the pipeline would be GREAT for firearms manufacturers. I think they could actually manipulate people into stockpiling firearms by getting a few friendly candidates or congresspeople to propose just such a law - knowing that it will go nowhere. Meanwhile marketing a range of firearms to people and pushing the line that you need a different one for all occasions. My nephew (26, Trump guy, super-patriot) has begun collecting guns and I think it's clear that ultimately he is increasing the odds of one of his weapons being used in an unintended manner. I don't think he makes any pretense that all of them are needed for self-defense; he just loves guns.
 
It's an improvement, sure. Whether or not it would be worth it is another matter. You do realize it would take at least 5-10 years after the ban for there to be any significant improvement, right? The country is awash with guns and even if such weapons were banned today, the illegal supply would last quite a long while. ....

I think it would take much longer than that.

There are a lot of people who would not cooperate with a ban and hide guns.

There would still be legal sales and mass shootings etc can still happen with shotguns, rifles etc.

There are tons of originally US guns in Central America, which would form a new supply source.

There are lots of gun makers outside the USA who could also provide a new supply source.

Any ban is unlikely to consistently over the long term as so many people would campaign against it.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom