UBL is indicted for 911

Here is my take on the statement...

Lets say a group of neighbours are talking together about a recent child abduction, and someone shakes their head and says,

"Noone could have imagined this would happen."

Now does that person mean that "imagining" such a thing was imppossible, or that such an event was never contemplated by anyone? No, of course not, it is an expression used to explain that the act was so unexpected, so unanticipated, so as to not have been planned for.

Though the wording is slightly different, this is what Condi likely meant by saying that noone had imagined them flying planes into buildings. Of course it was "considered" in the enormously wide spectrum of possibilities, but it was not seriously considered as a likely form of terrorist attack. Of all terrorist attacks prior to 9/11, how many involved flying jet airliners into buildings?

Even though people in the neighbourhood know a child could be abducted, most still let their children go out to play, because said abductions (fortunately) are very rare events. Similarly the USG, while knowing that planes as weapons, along with nuclear suitcase bombs, biological weapons, etc.. were all rare possibilities, never thought, with any degree of seriousness, that this would happen...This was, obviously, a mistake.

TAM:)
No. Condi Rice wasn't talking amongst a group of friends. I believe she was testifying under oath to a congressional committee. Is this what you’re talking about? When people are trying to get to the bottom of something like 3000 dead Americans you don't say "Never" as figure of speech. You only claim "NEVER” under oath if you were completely in the dark about something and truly believed "never", or you say it to mislead.

That being said and I don’t really have any sympathy for Condi but she shouldn’t have had to testify alone. The President and the VP should have had some answers for the American public and given those answers under oath instead of hiding behind Condi’s skirt when the heat came down like the two draft dodging Chicken Hawk cowards they are.
 
I guess there was something in the 700 pages. Perhaps they don't have quite as strict chain od costody laws there so that OBL's numerous confessions can be used there?

I noted this part as well:



Trouble with indictments being by Grand Jury in the US is that even if there is no defence raised there, the evidence still have to be shown to have been collected in a constitutional manner, hence the best evidence against OBL (his videos and tapes claiming responsiblity and the video of him with the Hijackers as they trained) wouldn't be allowed to be used in the US without proof of the chain of custody.
If the FBI really had anything on Bin Laden for 9-11 they would have indicted him. Do you really think they would deny the families of 9-11 victims the chance to see him go down for 9-11 and just put him on trial for something he did in Kenya?

No way.

They got nothing on him.
 
No. Condi Rice wasn't talking amongst a group of friends. I believe she was testifying under oath to a congressional committee. Is this what you’re talking about? When people are trying to get to the bottom of something like 3000 dead Americans you don't say "Never" as figure of speech. You only claim "NEVER” under oath if you were completely in the dark about something and truly believed "never", or you say it to mislead.

That being said and I don’t really have any sympathy for Condi but she shouldn’t have had to testify alone. The President and the VP should have had some answers for the American public and given those answers under oath instead of hiding behind Condi’s skirt when the heat came down like the two draft dodging Chicken Hawk cowards they are.

Please, everybody stop derailing this thread. This thread is about an indictment issued by Spain against UBL. If this story is incorrect, false or fabricated, please provide your evidence.

The story stands, Bin Laden has been indicted by
Spain for 911, unless you or anybody else can prove this story or Spain is incorrect.
 
No. Condi Rice wasn't talking amongst a group of friends. I believe she was testifying under oath to a congressional committee. Is this what you’re talking about? When people are trying to get to the bottom of something like 3000 dead Americans you don't say "Never" as figure of speech. You only claim "NEVER” under oath if you were completely in the dark about something and truly believed "never", or you say it to mislead.

That being said and I don’t really have any sympathy for Condi but she shouldn’t have had to testify alone. The President and the VP should have had some answers for the American public and given those answers under oath instead of hiding behind Condi’s skirt when the heat came down like the two draft dodging Chicken Hawk cowards they are.

Could you have more speculative opinion in two paragraphs if you tried. Your diatribe is nothing more than what you "think" people at a congressional hearing should speak like, or what you think they "mean".

How is this any different than my opinion on why she said what she did, and my take on what she meant by it.

At least I had the guts to state that it was MY TAKE on things, not try to pass it off like gospel...

That said, we will let both our opinions stand, and let the fence sitters decide which one is more reasonable, and makes more sense...fair enough?

TAM:)
 
If the FBI really had anything on Bin Laden for 9-11 they would have indicted him. Do you really think they would deny the families of 9-11 victims the chance to see him go down for 9-11 and just put him on trial for something he did in Kenya?

No way.

They got nothing on him.

They indicted him with crimes, that at present, they are positive they have enough to go to trial and win with. I am sure they have a fair bit of evidence against him.

Why would they indict him now, when they can indict him with it once they capture him...

That said, I actually think that they do NOT HAVE ENOUGH to convict at present, so they have held back.

Did they ever convict Al Capone for the contracts he had carried out by others?

TAM:)
 
I notice that the OP refers to an "investigating judge". AFAIK, there is no corresponding function in the US legal system. Apart from the fact that the indictment is for acts committed in Spain in furtherance of the 9/11 plot, the fact that an indictment has been issued in Spain rather than the USA might have less to do with the evidence available in the two countries than with the differences between the Continental and Anglo-Saxon legal traditions.

Reconciling the two philosophies was a major issue in organizing the IMT in Nuremberg, as the USA and UK had systems derived from one tradition while those of France and the USSR were descended from the other.

That's the whole extent of my layman's knowledge; perhaps one of our resident lawyers will help clarify things.
 
The only thing that hates your freedom is the Patriot Act.

I'm pretty sure the last time Bin Laden was indicited for anything in the US was during the Clinton Administration which was also the last time anyone even came close to killing him. Right after 9-11 Dubya flew the Bin Laden family (long time close friends of the Bush's) out of the US when all other planes were grounded. It has since come out in FBI documents released under the Freedeom of information act that Bin Laden himself might have very well chartered some of the flights for his family. Dubya then took many of the military resources allocated for Afganastan and diverted them to Iraq. He them came out and stated he's "truly not concerned" about Bin Laden. Dubya also shutdown the CIA unit Alec station setup during the Clinton administration to track and kill Bin Laden. Just shut it down. The FBI then stated there is no hard evidence connecting Bin Laden to 9-11.

I ask you.. who HAS the supposed 19 hijacker idenities been connected to if not Bin Laden? How where did they learn to fly? While you're at it who has Bin Laden and his family been connected to over the years?


So after all of this Spain indicts Bin Laden is offered up. So what? Face it. How's Spain ever going to capture Bin Laden anyway? It means nothing. There is no hard evidence connecting Bin Laden to 9-11.

If you don't believe me ask the FBI.

The War on Terror is a fraud.

The only thing that hates your freedom is the Patriot Act.
 
I doubt they had anything different in evidence, I suspect that what they have is a difference in what the law allows to be considered evidence. The US has this peiceof paper called the Constitution. While some times it can be very good, at other times it is the most stupid pieceof paper ever designed. That time is when it comes to actaually being able to take out the bad guys without violating their rights, and what violating their rights can mean.

Over here a police officer can randomly stop you when you are driving and check your beath alcohol level, just because he felt like it. In the States this would violate so many laws that the officer get a boot in the butt so hard he'd land in next century. Of course it also means that more people can get away for drunk driving in the US and your road toll reflects that.

It's a tightrope that the US has to come to understand. Freedom is a great thing, but it comes at a price. Dispite the protests and cries by the CTs that the States is a Police state, it is far from one, and if they don't want to see another 9/11 then they're going to have to lose more freedoms. The US has a choice. Keep it's extrordinary (by world standards) levels of freedom, keep it's law enforcement hamstrung, and put up with acts of those that will abuse the freedom to strike terror into the population, or give up some of their rights, allow the law enforcement more freedom to act, and catch the terrorists before they can act. Yes it is a hard decision, but sometimes it's worth it. That's not to say that such steps will 100% prevent acts of terror, look at the 7/7 attacks and the more recent attempts, but it does mean that they are more likely to be prevented, and the perpertrators captured when they get through the defences.
Thanks but, no thanks.
 
. Right after 9-11 Dubya flew the Bin Laden family (long time close friends of the Bush's) out of the US when all other planes were grounded.

It has since come out in FBI documents released under the Freedeom of information act that Bin Laden himself might have very well chartered some of the flights for his family.

triple false

you are getting worse at this, is it fun just making stuff up, or repeating stuff others make up
 
I'm pretty sure the last time Bin Laden was indicited for anything in the US was during the Clinton Administration which was also the last time anyone even came close to killing him. Right after 9-11 Dubya flew the Bin Laden family (long time close friends of the Bush's) out of the US when all other planes were grounded. It has since come out in FBI documents released under the Freedeom of information act that Bin Laden himself might have very well chartered some of the flights for his family. Dubya then took many of the military resources allocated for Afganastan and diverted them to Iraq. He them came out and stated he's "truly not concerned" about Bin Laden. Dubya also shutdown the CIA unit Alec station setup during the Clinton administration to track and kill Bin Laden. Just shut it down. The FBI then stated there is no hard evidence connecting Bin Laden to 9-11.

I ask you.. who HAS the supposed 19 hijacker idenities been connected to if not Bin Laden? How where did they learn to fly? While you're at it who has Bin Laden and his family been connected to over the years?


So after all of this Spain indicts Bin Laden is offered up. So what? Face it. How's Spain ever going to capture Bin Laden anyway? It means nothing. There is no hard evidence connecting Bin Laden to 9-11.

If you don't believe me ask the FBI.

The War on Terror is a fraud.

The only thing that hates your freedom is the Patriot Act.


Translated --> I can't win this arguement so I will simply say "the War on Terror is a fraud".

NEXT!!

TAM:)
 
You mean that an indictment is without merit if the country issuing it doesn't have the capacity to carry it out?

In other words, Zensmack89 you feel confident declaring Spain's indictment of OBL as fake, or contrived, or without proper evidence because of that, or because it falls under the category of 'stuff that contradicts your world view so must be ignored'? You know, kind of like you accuse us of doing all the time.

You do the same stuff. You're a sheep of the truth movement.
 
Last edited:
I'm pretty sure the last time Bin Laden was indicited for anything in the US was during the Clinton Administration which was also the last time anyone even came close to killing him. Right after 9-11 Dubya flew the Bin Laden family (long time close friends of the Bush's) out of the US when all other planes were grounded. It has since come out in FBI documents released under the Freedeom of information act that Bin Laden himself might have very well chartered some of the flights for his family. Dubya then took many of the military resources allocated for Afganastan and diverted them to Iraq. He them came out and stated he's "truly not concerned" about Bin Laden. Dubya also shutdown the CIA unit Alec station setup during the Clinton administration to track and kill Bin Laden. Just shut it down. The FBI then stated there is no hard evidence connecting Bin Laden to 9-11.

I ask you.. who HAS the supposed 19 hijacker idenities been connected to if not Bin Laden? How where did they learn to fly? While you're at it who has Bin Laden and his family been connected to over the years?


So after all of this Spain indicts Bin Laden is offered up. So what? Face it. How's Spain ever going to capture Bin Laden anyway? It means nothing. There is no hard evidence connecting Bin Laden to 9-11.

If you don't believe me ask the FBI.

The War on Terror is a fraud.

The only thing that hates your freedom is the Patriot Act.

Maybe this will clear it up for you.

In order to be listed on the FBI Ten Most Wanted Fugitive list, the suspect must have been indicted for the crime. To indict Bin Laden formally for the 9/11 attacks would require presenting evidence in a court of law; such evidence linking Bin Laden to 9/11 would include intelligence sources, and Al-Qaeda detainees. Making such sources (and methods) publicly known, perhaps isn't advised. In the Zacarias Moussaoui case, a big deal was made over access to detainee witnesses and about handling evidence from other intelligence sources.
In all, the 9/11 attacks were viewed as an "act of war", and the U.S. government is responding accordingly. During the Clinton administration, terrorism was handled more as a matter of law enforcement. This change in how terrorism is handled may be yet another reason why the U.S. government has not bothered to formally indict Bin Laden for the 9/11 attacks.


Regarding this matter, FBI officials told the Washington Post:
"There's no mystery here," said FBI spokesman Rex Tomb. "They could add 9/11 on there, but they have not because they don't need to at this point. . . . There is a logic to it." [1]​
The FBI also maintains a list of "Most Wanted Terrorists". This list is accompanied by a note:
The alleged terrorists on this list have been indicted by sitting Federal Grand Juries in various jurisdictions in the United States for the crimes reflected on their wanted posters. Evidence was gathered and presented to the Grand Juries, which led to their being charged. The indictments currently listed on the posters allow them to be arrested and brought to justice. Future indictments may be handed down as various investigations proceed in connection to other terrorist incidents, for example, the terrorist attacks on September 11, 2001. [2]​

http://www.debunk911myths.org/topics/index.php?title=Osama_bin_Laden

So are you saying Spain is wrong to indict Bin Laden?

Added, because I know he won't read the links..

The absence has also provided fodder for conspiracy theorists who think the U.S. government or another power was behind the Sept. 11 hijackings. From this point of view, the lack of a Sept. 11 reference suggests that the connection to al-Qaeda is uncertain.
Exhaustive government and independent investigations have concluded otherwise, of course, and bin Laden and other al-Qaeda leaders have proudly taken responsibility for the hijackings. FBI officials say the wanted poster merely reflects the government's long-standing practice of relying on actual criminal charges in the notices.

http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2006/08/27/AR2006082700687.html
 
Last edited:
If you don't believe me ask the FBI.

Why is it that the troofers say the federal government lies about everything regarding 9/11 except the OBL indictment? Why in that case only, is the FBI telling the truth?

In regard to the Spain story, how is the Spanish government able to make indictments on crimes that occured in the United States?
 
Maybe this will clear it up for you.



http://www.debunk911myths.org/topics/index.php?title=Osama_bin_Laden

So are you saying Spain is wrong to indict Bin Laden?

Added, because I know he won't read the links..



http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2006/08/27/AR2006082700687.html
All lip service.

Got hard evidence? What is it? And an unconfirmed untraceable video tape is NOT hard evidence of anything especially when there’s the same kind of tape that states the opposite.
 
All lip service.

Got hard evidence? What is it? And an unconfirmed untraceable video tape is NOT hard evidence of anything especially when there’s the same kind of tape that states the opposite.

This is what happens when you don't open links and read them.

Interviews with Bin Laden
[edit] Pre 9/11

During the late 1990s, several journalists interviewed Bin Laden in Afghanistan including:
  • 1997 - Interview with CNN reporter, Peter Bergen, Peter Arnett, and cameraman Peter Jouvenal. [13]
  • May 1998 - Interview with Rahimullah Yusufzai, journalist with The News in Peshawar.[14]
  • December 1998 - Second interview with Rahimullah Yusufzai[14]
[edit] Post 9/11

Al Jazeera correspondent, Tayseer Alouni interviewed Bin Laden in October 2001.
They [the hijackers] did this, as we understand it, and this is something we have agitated for before, as a matter of self-defense, in defense of our brothers and sons in Palestine, and to liberate our sacred religious sites/things. If inciting people to do that is terrorism, and if killing those who kill our sons is terrorism, then let history be witness that we are terrorists.[15]
[edit] Al Qaeda video and audiotapes


[edit] November 2001

November 2001 - A video taken in November, and made public on December 13, 2001, shows Bin Laden talking to a group of supporters. He explains, "We calculated in advance the number of casualties from the enemy who would be killed based on the position of the tower. We calculated that the floors that would be hit would be three or four floors. I was the most optimistic of them all. (...Inaudible...) Due to my experience in this field, I was thinking that the fire from the gas in the plane would melt the iron structure of the building and collapse the area where the plane hit and all the floors above it only. This is all that we had hoped for."
The videotape indicates that five days before the attacks, which occurred on a Tuesday, bin Laden knew the date and time they would occur:
"We had notification since the previous Thursday that the event would take place that day. We had finished our work that day and had the radio on. It was 5:30 p.m. our time [8:00 am in New York and Washington]. ... Immediately, we heard the news that a plane had hit the World Trade Center. We turned the radio station to the news from Washington. The news continued and no mention of the attack until the end. At the end of the newscast, they reported that a plane just hit the World Trade Center. ... After a little while, they announced that another plane had hit the World Trade Center. The brothers who heard the news were overjoyed by it. ..."
Bin Laden knew there would be multiple attacks:
"They were overjoyed when the first plane hit the building, so I said to them: be patient. The difference between the first and the second plane hitting the towers was twenty minutes. And the difference between the first plane and the plane that hit the Pentagon was one hour."
The video indicates that bin Laden was very familiar with the operational planning for the attacks:
"Muhammad Atta from the Egyptian family (meaning the Al Qaeda Egyptian group), was in charge of the group. ... The brothers, who conducted the operation, all they knew was that they have a martyrdom operation and we asked each of them to go to America but they didn't know anything about the operation, not even one letter. But they were trained and we did not reveal the operation to them until they are there and just before they boarded the planes. ... Those who were trained to fly didn't know the others. One group of people did not know the other group."

[edit] 2002
  • April 2002 - Flight 93 hijacker Ahmed al-Haznawi was shown in a video reciting a prepared statement, which al-Jazeera described as a last will and testament.[16]
  • September 2002 - Al Jazeera aired excerpts from a videotape in which a voice said to be bin Laden's is heard naming the leaders of the 19 9/11 hijackers.
  • October 6, 2002 - Al Jazeera broadcasts audiotape message from Osama bin Laden.
Message to the US people. Greetings to those who follow the just path. I advise you in all sincerity and call upon you to follow Islam which stands up for justice and opposes injustice and crime. I also call upon you to seize the messages of the conquests of New York and Washington, which was the response to a part of your past crimes. However, the criminal gang in the White House, those agents of the Jews, are preparing to attack the Muslim world and carve it up, without you dissuading them, meaning that you have not learnt anything. I tell you, as God is my witness, that if America does not cease or reduce the scope of this tension, we will respond in kind, God willing. The youth of Islam are preparing something to strike fear in your hearts and will target the vital sectors of your economy until you renounce your injustice and hostility. We pray for God to help you in this.[17]
[edit] October 2004
  • October 30, 2004 - Bin Laden unequivocally admitted that he and al Qaeda had planned and directed the September 11 attacks. He stated, "I shall talk to you about the story behind those events (the September 11 attacks) and shall tell you truthfully about the moments in which the decision was taken ...." He confirmed his direction of the details of operational planning, stating, "for the record, we had agreed with the Commander-General Muhammad Atta ... that all operations should be carried out within twenty minutes, before Bush and his administration notice."
[edit] 2006
  • May 23, 2006 - Osama bin Laden said "I was responsible for entrusting the 19 brothers - Allah have mercy upon them - with those raids ...." Bin Laden added, "the participants in September 11th were two groups: pilots and support teams for each pilot in order to control the aircraft."

http://www.debunk911myths.org/topics/index.php?title=Osama_bin_Laden

Now, again are Spain wrong to indict Bin Laden, yes or no ?
 
I'm not saying Spain is wrong. They can do what they want. They probably feel in shows a kind of solidarity with the US which is a brave gesture considering what happened there with the train attacks. I just don’t think Bin Laden will be going on vacation in Spain anytime soon. So chances of them catching him are none.

Besides 9-11 didn't happen in Spain in happened in the US where he's not indicted for it. And some are right on here in what they point out... it would be disastrous to bring Bin Laden in and put him on trial for 9-11 without hard evidence. How would that go over? It’s better to keep him a boogey man to pull out when ever they need a distraction or feel the need to take away more of our freedoms. He serves them better in the dark where they can make him out to be whatever they want.
 
I'm not saying Spain is wrong. They can do what they want. They probably feel in shows a kind of solidarity with the US which is a brave gesture considering what happened there with the train attacks. I just don’t think Bin Laden will be going on vacation in Spain anytime soon. So chances of them catching him are none.

Besides 9-11 didn't happen in Spain in happened in the US where he's not indicted for it. And some are right on here in what they point out... it would be disastrous to bring Bin Laden in and put him on trial for 9-11 without hard evidence. How would that go over? It’s better to keep him a boogey man to pull out when ever they need a distraction or feel the need to take away more of our freedoms. He serves them better in the dark where they can make him out to be whatever they want.

STOP.

So you agree when Spain says

The indictment charged bin Laden and nine others with membership in a terrorist organization and "as many crimes of terrorist murder ... as there were dead and injured" in the deadly Sept. 11 attacks.

Spain's leading investigating judge issued the first known indictment against Osama bin Laden in the Sept. 11 attacks on Wednesday, accusing al-Qaida of using the country as a base to plot the devastating strikes on New York and Washington.

So you agree with these statements, yes or no?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom