UBL is indicted for 911

stateofgrace

Unregistered
Joined
Aug 31, 2006
Messages
3,843
By Spain.

I was doing a bit of reading on the " FBI has no hard evidence against Bin laden " theory when I came across this
MADRID, Spain -- Spain's leading investigating judge issued the first known indictment against Osama bin Laden in the Sept. 11 attacks on Wednesday, accusing al-Qaida of using the country as a base to plot the devastating strikes on New York and Washington.

The indictment charged bin Laden and nine others with membership in a terrorist organization and ''as many crimes of terrorist murder . . . as there were dead and injured'' in the Sept. 11 attacks.

There are no indications that U.S. prosecutors will seek an indictment of bin Laden in the Sept. 11 attacks any time soon. U.S. officials believe they have the legal tools necessary to arrest him with the existing indictment in the 1998 embassy bombings as well as the Defense Department's authority to detain enemy combatants.

http://www.911injured.org/Media/News/chicagosun091803.htm

Also reported here.

http://media.www.michigandaily.com/...n.Indicts.Bin.Laden.For.Attacks-1418654.shtml
This story was from 2003

To be honest this is the first time I have come across this. It does appear that UBL is actually indicted for the Sept 11 attacks; I have not really been able to find any follow on from this other than this from 2005.

MADRID, Spain (CNN) -- Spanish Judge Baltasar Garzon has indicted eight more people on terrorism charges in connection with a group that had a suspected role in the September 11 attacks in the United States, a court official told CNN Monday.
The eight men allegedly provided logistical support for other suspects, including Ramzi Binalshibh, whom investigators say was a key al Qaeda operative involved in the 2001 attacks, the official said

http://www.cnn.com/2005/WORLD/europe/01/17/spain.terror.charges/index.html

Maybe Spain is in on the conspiracy also. Seriously though, does anybody know what become of this story and is UBL indicted for the 911 attacks by Spain?
 
By Spain.

I was doing a bit of reading on the " FBI has no hard evidence against Bin laden " theory when I came across this






http://www.911injured.org/Media/News/chicagosun091803.htm

Also reported here.

http://media.www.michigandaily.com/...n.Indicts.Bin.Laden.For.Attacks-1418654.shtml
This story was from 2003

To be honest this is the first time I have come across this. It does appear that UBL is actually indicted for the Sept 11 attacks; I have not really been able to find any follow on from this other than this from 2005.



http://www.cnn.com/2005/WORLD/europe/01/17/spain.terror.charges/index.html

Maybe Spain is in on the conspiracy also. Seriously though, does anybody know what become of this story and is UBL indicted for the 911 attacks by Spain?

Thank you for this.
 
By Spain.

I was doing a bit of reading on the " FBI has no hard evidence against Bin laden " theory when I came across this






http://www.911injured.org/Media/News/chicagosun091803.htm

Also reported here.

http://media.www.michigandaily.com/...n.Indicts.Bin.Laden.For.Attacks-1418654.shtml
This story was from 2003

To be honest this is the first time I have come across this. It does appear that UBL is actually indicted for the Sept 11 attacks; I have not really been able to find any follow on from this other than this from 2005.



http://www.cnn.com/2005/WORLD/europe/01/17/spain.terror.charges/index.html

Maybe Spain is in on the conspiracy also. Seriously though, does anybody know what become of this story and is UBL indicted for the 911 attacks by Spain?
What evidence does Spain have or is one not innocent until proven guilty in Spain?
 
I was just reading the UBL wanted page on the FBi site, and I noticed this for the first time...lol

The Rewards For Justice Program, United States Department of State, is offering a reward of up to $25 million for information leading directly to the apprehension or conviction of Usama Bin Laden. An additional $2 million is being offered through a program developed and funded by the Airline Pilots Association and the Air Transport Association.

Seems all of Robbie Balsamo's comrades think UBL did 9/11...why else would they offer 2 Million for his capture?

http://www.fbi.gov/wanted/terrorists/terbinladen.htm

TAM:)
 
Also from the site....

The alleged terrorists on this list have been indicted by sitting Federal Grand Juries in various jurisdictions in the United States for the crimes reflected on their wanted posters. Evidence was gathered and presented to the Grand Juries, which led to their being charged. The indictments currently listed on the posters allow them to be arrested and brought to justice. Future indictments may be handed down as various investigations proceed in connection to other terrorist incidents, for example, the terrorist attacks on September 11, 2001.

Now i know we usually quote this as proof of why UBL hasnt been indicted yet, but the bolded section is also the reason that should be explained to the truthers why they CANNOT have access to all the photos, videos, and documents they so desperately crave...it is still AN ONGOING INVESTIGATION!!!!

http://www.fbi.gov/wanted/terrorists/fugitives.htm

TAM:)
 
What evidence does Spain have or is one not innocent until proven guilty in Spain?

I guess there was something in the 700 pages. Perhaps they don't have quite as strict chain od costody laws there so that OBL's numerous confessions can be used there?

I noted this part as well:

In the United States, bin Laden is charged in an indictment returned by a grand jury in New York stemming from the Aug. 7, 1998, bombings of the U.S. embassies in Kenya and Tanzania, that killed more than 200 people.

The only person charged in connection with the Sept. 11 attacks in the United States is Zacarias Moussaoui.

Bin Laden has been named as an unindicted co-conspirator in U.S. court documents in other cases involving al-Qaida, such as the prosecution of Moussaoui.

Trouble with indictments being by Grand Jury in the US is that even if there is no defence raised there, the evidence still have to be shown to have been collected in a constitutional manner, hence the best evidence against OBL (his videos and tapes claiming responsiblity and the video of him with the Hijackers as they trained) wouldn't be allowed to be used in the US without proof of the chain of custody.
 
Also from the site....



Now i know we usually quote this as proof of why UBL hasnt been indicted yet, but the bolded section is also the reason that should be explained to the truthers why they CANNOT have access to all the photos, videos, and documents they so desperately crave...it is still AN ONGOING INVESTIGATION!!!!

http://www.fbi.gov/wanted/terrorists/fugitives.htm

TAM:)

It's still an ongoing investigation until such time as OBL is caught, dragged kicking an screaming to the US and faces a court trial, well that, or all the main conspriators who are likely to face trial are confirmed as dead.
 
So why did Condo Rice say after 911 that noone had imagined them flying planes into buildings?

Please do not derail this thread. I have presented news reports of an indictment of UBL.

This thread is for that purpose and no other, if you wish to raise other issues, either start another thread or post them in the appropriate thread.

Thank you.
 
So why did Condo Rice say after 911 that noone had imagined them flying planes into buildings?

Because she was either misinformed or deluded.

In actuality, it was imagined. It was just dismissed as unlikely, because we hadn't had it brought home to us yet that terrorism is, by its very nature, unpredictable and capable of performing even highly unlikely acts.

I have said this before, and I will say it again as many times as it takes to get it to sink into your head, Rev; prior to 9/11, intelligence analysts would look for PATTERNS in the intelligence they received to try and determine what the next course of action for a particular person or group would be. Suicide hijackings did not fit Al Qaeda's then MO of using strictly explosives for their big demonstrations (the Kenya, Tanzania, and another country whose name escapes me at the moment embassy bombings, the first WTC bombing, the USS Cole; all explosives delivered in one form or another.) To add to that, prior to 9/11 all hijackings, except perhaps one or two (although I've never heard of any, to be honest) were done with the intent of keeping everyone on the planes alive as long as possible to hold them for some form of political or monetary gain on the part of the hijackers, such as release of a political prisoner or financial gains.

Was Condi Rice wrong for saying that we didn't imagine it? Absolutely. But she was accurate insofar as it wasn't conceived of as a LIKELY course of action. We had our thumb up our collective [rule8]s and didn't fully understand the lengths these people would go to, but we darn sure have a good idea now.

Apologies for the further derailment of the thread, but I wanted to respond to this statement of Rev's. Back on topic; I'm wondering what evidence Spain had that we didn't that allowed them to actually indict the man in the first place. Was there anything on that in particular?
 
Because she was either misinformed or deluded.

In actuality, it was imagined. It was just dismissed as unlikely, because we hadn't had it brought home to us yet that terrorism is, by its very nature, unpredictable and capable of performing even highly unlikely acts.

I have said this before, and I will say it again as many times as it takes to get it to sink into your head, Rev; prior to 9/11, intelligence analysts would look for PATTERNS in the intelligence they received to try and determine what the next course of action for a particular person or group would be. Suicide hijackings did not fit Al Qaeda's then MO of using strictly explosives for their big demonstrations (the Kenya, Tanzania, and another country whose name escapes me at the moment embassy bombings, the first WTC bombing, the USS Cole; all explosives delivered in one form or another.) To add to that, prior to 9/11 all hijackings, except perhaps one or two (although I've never heard of any, to be honest) were done with the intent of keeping everyone on the planes alive as long as possible to hold them for some form of political or monetary gain on the part of the hijackers, such as release of a political prisoner or financial gains.

Was Condi Rice wrong for saying that we didn't imagine it? Absolutely. But she was accurate insofar as it wasn't conceived of as a LIKELY course of action. We had our thumb up our collective [rule8]s and didn't fully understand the lengths these people would go to, but we darn sure have a good idea now.

Apologies for the further derailment of the thread, but I wanted to respond to this statement of Rev's. Back on topic; I'm wondering what evidence Spain had that we didn't that allowed them to actually indict the man in the first place. Was there anything on that in particular?

Here is my take on the statement...

Lets say a group of neighbours are talking together about a recent child abduction, and someone shakes their head and says,

"Noone could have imagined this would happen."

Now does that person mean that "imagining" such a thing was imppossible, or that such an event was never contemplated by anyone? No, of course not, it is an expression used to explain that the act was so unexpected, so unanticipated, so as to not have been planned for.

Though the wording is slightly different, this is what Condi likely meant by saying that noone had imagined them flying planes into buildings. Of course it was "considered" in the enormously wide spectrum of possibilities, but it was not seriously considered as a likely form of terrorist attack. Of all terrorist attacks prior to 9/11, how many involved flying jet airliners into buildings?

Even though people in the neighbourhood know a child could be abducted, most still let their children go out to play, because said abductions (fortunately) are very rare events. Similarly the USG, while knowing that planes as weapons, along with nuclear suitcase bombs, biological weapons, etc.. were all rare possibilities, never thought, with any degree of seriousness, that this would happen...This was, obviously, a mistake.

TAM:)
 
I'm wondering what evidence Spain had that we didn't that allowed them to actually indict the man in the first place. Was there anything on that in particular?

I doubt they had anything different in evidence, I suspect that what they have is a difference in what the law allows to be considered evidence. The US has this peiceof paper called the Constitution. While some times it can be very good, at other times it is the most stupid pieceof paper ever designed. That time is when it comes to actaually being able to take out the bad guys without violating their rights, and what violating their rights can mean.

Over here a police officer can randomly stop you when you are driving and check your beath alcohol level, just because he felt like it. In the States this would violate so many laws that the officer get a boot in the butt so hard he'd land in next century. Of course it also means that more people can get away for drunk driving in the US and your road toll reflects that.

It's a tightrope that the US has to come to understand. Freedom is a great thing, but it comes at a price. Dispite the protests and cries by the CTs that the States is a Police state, it is far from one, and if they don't want to see another 9/11 then they're going to have to lose more freedoms. The US has a choice. Keep it's extrordinary (by world standards) levels of freedom, keep it's law enforcement hamstrung, and put up with acts of those that will abuse the freedom to strike terror into the population, or give up some of their rights, allow the law enforcement more freedom to act, and catch the terrorists before they can act. Yes it is a hard decision, but sometimes it's worth it. That's not to say that such steps will 100% prevent acts of terror, look at the 7/7 attacks and the more recent attempts, but it does mean that they are more likely to be prevented, and the perpertrators captured when they get through the defences.
 
Here is my take on the statement...

Lets say a group of neighbours are talking together about a recent child abduction, and someone shakes their head and says,

"Noone could have imagined this would happen."

Now does that person mean that "imagining" such a thing was imppossible, or that such an event was never contemplated by anyone? No, of course not, it is an expression used to explain that the act was so unexpected, so unanticipated, so as to not have been planned for.

Though the wording is slightly different, this is what Condi likely meant by saying that noone had imagined them flying planes into buildings. Of course it was "considered" in the enormously wide spectrum of possibilities, but it was not seriously considered as a likely form of terrorist attack. Of all terrorist attacks prior to 9/11, how many involved flying jet airliners into buildings?

Even though people in the neighbourhood know a child could be abducted, most still let their children go out to play, because said abductions (fortunately) are very rare events. Similarly the USG, while knowing that planes as weapons, along with nuclear suitcase bombs, biological weapons, etc.. were all rare possibilities, never thought, with any degree of seriousness, that this would happen...This was, obviously, a mistake.

TAM:)

That's it exactly, TAM. However, due to the context that Rev and other twoofers are interpreting Ms. Rice's remarks, I responded the way I did because, if she WAS actually thinking it had not ever been imagined, she WOULD have been either misinformed or deluded. And given her position at the time, I seriously doubt she was misinformed. However, even bearing that in mind, I believe your interpretation of Ms. Rice's comment is correct and the twoofers are severely misinterpreting the context of her statement.

I wonder if Rev will ever respond to this. I was polite, wasn't I? I didn't refer to his age anywhere or speak down to him, did I?
 
That's it exactly, TAM. However, due to the context that Rev and other twoofers are interpreting Ms. Rice's remarks, I responded the way I did because, if she WAS actually thinking it had not ever been imagined, she WOULD have been either misinformed or deluded. And given her position at the time, I seriously doubt she was misinformed. However, even bearing that in mind, I believe your interpretation of Ms. Rice's comment is correct and the twoofers are severely misinterpreting the context of her statement.

I wonder if Rev will ever respond to this. I was polite, wasn't I? I didn't refer to his age anywhere or speak down to him, did I?

The typical truther response, will be something similar to:

"How naive. You don't honestly think she was telling the truth do you? Remember she was warned, she was briefed. You have to be a moron to actually think she didn't know."

TAM:)
 
*chuckles*

Yeah, I'm a moron. I only happen to work in the very community they keep denigrating for failing to anticipate the events of 9/11; nope, I know nothing about it at all.[/extreme sarcasm]
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom