Truthers and anti-Semitism

MaGZ said:
The Odigo warning was significant. It was likely sent by one of the Mossad agents when he saw the hijackers board the planes. The warning was just reported in Israel, others likely received it.

http://s3.amazonaws.com/911timeline/2001/wpost092801.html

"The Odigo service includes a feature called People Finder that allows users to seek out and contact others based on certain interests or demographics. Diamandis said Thursday that it was possible the attack warning was broadcast to other Odigo members, but the company has not received reports of other recipients of the message."
Click to expand...


So? How would a late warning indicate that Jews did 9/11?
I mean the German and the US did receive warnings concerning an immediate attack, too. Are they in it as well? :rolleyes:

They Tried to Warn Us: Foreign Intelligence Warnings Before 9/11
 
Oliver said:
So? How would a late warning indicate that Jews did 9/11?
I mean the German and the US did receive warnings concerning an immediate attack, too. Are they in it as well? :rolleyes:

They Tried to Warn Us: Foreign Intelligence Warnings Before 9/11
Click to expand...

From you link:

"Also in late July 2001, the US was given a “concrete warning” from Argentina’s Jewish community. “An attack of major proportions” was planned against either the US, Argentina, or France. The information came from an unidentified intelligence agency."

So the Mossad knew.
 
MaGZ said:
From you link:

"Also in late July 2001, the US was given a “concrete warning” from Argentina’s Jewish community. “An attack of major proportions” was planned against either the US, Argentina, or France. The information came from an unidentified intelligence agency."

So the Mossad knew.
Click to expand...

Knew what specifically?
 
MaGZ said:
The Jews did not do 9/11. The Israeli Mossad had the hijackers under surveillance. They reported to the CIA some of their findings and not others.

Israel allowed 9/11 to happen.
Click to expand...


Well, but then the Germans and Americans did allow to let 9/11 happen as well, did they not?

As far I researched that specific topic of foreknowledge, a lot of Governments had pre-knowledge, but it was to vague to act on it. You're implying that the Israeli Government had specific knowledge, yet wasn't capable to warn the Jews that actually died in the towers. So what is it? Did Israel know more than others without sharing that information - or did they know as much as other Governments and tried to avert the dangers of an imminent attack just as other Governments tried to?

In other words: You are basically saying that all the Governments having knowledge of an imminent attack are involved in "letting it happen", are you not?
 
MaGZ said:
From you link:

"Also in late July 2001, the US was given a “concrete warning” from Argentina’s Jewish community. “An attack of major proportions” was planned against either the US, Argentina, or France. The information came from an unidentified intelligence agency."

So the Mossad knew.
Click to expand...


Well, that's cherry-picking, no? I mean the same level of immediate threat was known to several Governments, yet you choose to pick the Jewish ones, right? I mean I'm skeptical about Israel's policies as well, but your focus on Jewish involvement seems to be "out of the park", are they not?
 
Oliver said:
Well, but then the Germans and Americans did allow to let 9/11 happen as well, did they not?

As far I researched that specific topic of foreknowledge, a lot of Governments had pre-knowledge, but it was to vague to act on it. You're implying that the Israeli Government had specific knowledge, yet wasn't capable to warn the Jews that actually died in the towers. So what is it? Did Israel know more than others without sharing that information - or did they know as much as other Governments and tried to avert the dangers of an imminent attack just as other Governments tried to?

In other words: You are basically saying that all the Governments having knowledge of an imminent attack are involved in "letting it happen", are you not?
Click to expand...

Israel had day-to-day knowledge of the coming attacks via the Israeli Art Students/Spies. Other governments monitoring intelligence "noise" had an idea something big was going to happen but no specifics.
 
MaGZ said:
Israel had day-to-day knowledge of the coming attacks via the Israeli Art Students/Spies. Other governments monitoring intelligence "noise" had an idea something big was going to happen but no specifics.
Click to expand...


While we all know that Israels intelligence has a focus on Muslim extremist groups in light of their struggle, are you implying that they had more knowledge of an attack than they're willing to share with the US-intelligence?

In other words: What intelligence didn't the Israeli Mossad share with their US counterparts? And how are you capable to confirm that lack of US knowledge given the fact that some information is classified anyway? :confused:
 
MaGZ said:
Israel had day-to-day knowledge of the coming attacks via the Israeli Art Students/Spies. Other governments monitoring intelligence "noise" had an idea something big was going to happen but no specifics.
Click to expand...


I really wish I could intuit things out of the ether in this way. As it is I have to rely on this stinking enlightenment project.
 
beachnut said:
How do you find all these dirt dumb neoNAZI web sites spewing lies? What happen to the moronic missile lie from the other bigoted white power web site? Why are the neoNAZI web sites so anti-intellectual?
Click to expand...

Uh, antiwar.com is not a neo nazi site. It's one of the best, most comprehensive news sites reporting on any conflict across the globe. Your hair trigger response is dare I say, dirt dumb, to borrow your charming, little phrase.
 
Why are truthers so bad with timelines?

The art students were in the US long before the vast majority of the hijackers (and detected and arrested before most of them arrived, too). For all the articles written on them, and all the data available, no-one has yet pointed to any evidence that places the art students and the hijackers in close proximity at the same time, let alone showed the students "tracking" or "monitoring" them.

Seems like a relevant point to me. And yet truthers won't even acknowledge it exists. Why's that, I wonder? Are they waiting for (lying fraud) Chris Bollyn to tell them what to think?
 
Oliver said:
While we all know that Israels intelligence has a focus on Muslim extremist groups in light of their struggle, are you implying that they had more knowledge of an attack than they're willing to share with the US-intelligence?

In other words: What intelligence didn't the Israeli Mossad share with their US counterparts? And how are you capable to confirm that lack of US knowledge given the fact that some information is classified anyway? :confused:
Click to expand...

The Mossad had AQ under surveillance in Hamburg, Germany. When they came to America; the Mossad moved with them with the help of the CIA. Able Danger suggested this when Atta was connected with the AQ cell in New Jersey before he came to the US.

The Mossad knew when the attacks would happen and what planes were involved when they learned which flights were booked by the hijackers over the Internet at Kinko's in Florida.
 
MikeW said:
Why are truthers so bad with timelines?
Click to expand...

I suppose Paul Thompson is no truther, then, whatever a truther is. Even you would have to admit you rely on what is probably the most thorough and comprehensive 9/11 research site on the web.
 
Oliver said:
While we all know that Israels intelligence has a focus on Muslim extremist groups in light of their struggle, are you implying that they had more knowledge of an attack than they're willing to share with the US-intelligence?

In other words: What intelligence didn't the Israeli Mossad share with their US counterparts? And how are you capable to confirm that lack of US knowledge given the fact that some information is classified anyway? :confused:
Click to expand...

Here is an article by one of you namesakes.

http://www.physics911.ca/Schrom:_Next_Door_to_Muhammed_Atta
 
Oliver said:
While we all know that Israels intelligence has a focus on Muslim extremist groups in light of their struggle, are you implying that they had more knowledge of an attack than they're willing to share with the US-intelligence?

In other words: What intelligence didn't the Israeli Mossad share with their US counterparts? And how are you capable to confirm that lack of US knowledge given the fact that some information is classified anyway? :confused:
Click to expand...

Atta and Able Danger
http://911review.org/Alex/Able-Danger-3.html
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Back
Top Bottom