Three Professors of Psychiatry call for "neuropsychiatric evaluation"

Consider: he's going to be in the highest office in the land, the most powerful man in the free world, and still the people he picks for his team are unqualified lickspittles out for their own personal enrichment. Even now, at the apex of his or anyone else's career, he'd rather work with someone who'll kiss his ass every single day for giving them their posts than someone who knows what the hell they're doing.

That's why all his businesses have crumbled. That's why we're in for a rough couple of years.

I think you make the point as well or better as I've seen it..
 
Personally, I think Obama has a level of narcissism commensurate with Trump's. It just doesn't manifest as crudely. Obama's last press conference was a real doozy.

You're either in denial or you still don't understand NPD.

Trump is a sociopathic liar to the extent that nothing that comes out of his mouth can be believed. No living person has seen a presidential candidate who lies with such shameless abandon. He uses those lies to manipulate people to get what he wants: mainly attention and adulation, money (which is just how he keeps score), and now political power as King of America. He takes advantage of people at every opportunity, and he does so because he has no empathy whatsoever. His enormous ego requires constant self-inflation, but that's not the problem: it's also extremely fragile. A "narcissistic injury" can trigger a vindictive and irrational "narcissistic rage" where getting even is his only thought.

He cannot stop himself from any of this. If you don't see it yet, you will, because it's impossible for him to turn "presidential."

And your comparison of Obama to Trump is deplorable.
 
No, I don't think Trump will be "okay." I think he will be directed and controlled by the right-wing extremists who want to eliminate Social Security, Medicare, environmental regulations etc., etc. Newt Gingrich has said he sees the Trump administration as an opportunity to turn the clock back to the pre-FDR era. But I don't think Trump will be operating on his own, and I don't think he will do or be allowed to do anything that would get him impeached by a Republican House and Senate.

If those right wing extremists are Putin and Trump's hand picked advisors, then I agree on some levels. But it's still Trump in charge. As for Gingrich and the GOP legislators who think they can manipulate Trump, I think they are in for a rude awakening.

Impeachment has a high probability in my book, with overt corruption being the basis of the charges.
 
Huh.

I should be more surprised that you don't care about medical malpractice but you have already demonstrated that you believe that "appeal to authority" is a legitimate form of argument and not a fallacy.

You may want to look into the difference between a malpractice suit and libel or slander for one's public comments.

The issue with diagnostic comments about a patient one has not seen is an ethics issue, not a malpractice issue and ethical standards do not have any weight of law behind them. Like it or not qualified professionals making a diagnosis of Trump without seeing him has occurred and is in the public record.

Back to what I said, your problem, not mine. I'm not worried about being sued or having my practice affected because I concluded, as have other professionals more qualified than I am, that there is more than sufficient evidence of Trump's personality disorder in the public record to make a diagnosis.

What you don't seem to get (Dunning–Kruger) is that there is nothing an exam of Trump is going to show which is not already on display. That is the nature of a narcissistic personality disorder.
 
And?

Top politicians often have the trait of being able to lie convincingly. The job actually filters for people with that skill.
And, you know damn well a double standard is being applied to Clinton to make her appear to be something she is not.

Who do Clinton haters think they are fooling?
 
Traits can be set aside when the situation calls for it. Disorders can't.

The problem with Trump having NPD isn't that he's a narcissist - you don't run for President without a bit of an ego - but that he can't stop being a narcissist.

Consider: he's going to be in the highest office in the land, the most powerful man in the free world, and still the people he picks for his team are unqualified lickspittles out for their own personal enrichment. Even now, at the apex of his or anyone else's career, he'd rather work with someone who'll kiss his ass every single day for giving them their posts than someone who knows what the hell they're doing.

That's why all his businesses have crumbled. That's why we're in for a rough couple of years.
Well said.
 
You're either in denial or you still don't understand NPD.

I wonder if my denialism, or, alternatively, my lack of comprehension is a disorder or only a trait.

Trump is a sociopathic liar to the extent that nothing that comes out of his mouth can be believed. No living person has seen a presidential candidate who lies with such shameless abandon. He uses those lies to manipulate people to get what he wants: mainly attention and adulation, money (which is just how he keeps score), and now political power as King of America. He takes advantage of people at every opportunity, and he does so because he has no empathy whatsoever. His enormous ego requires constant self-inflation, but that's not the problem: it's also extremely fragile. A "narcissistic injury" can trigger a vindictive and irrational "narcissistic rage" where getting even is his only thought.

He cannot stop himself from any of this. If you don't see it yet, you will, because it's impossible for him to turn "presidential."

He tweets from the hip. There doesn't seem to be any evidence that he shoots from the hip. No record of violence; no record of acting rashly with respect to important decisions. In any case, my theory of the Presidency is that the President's most important role is as a decision maker. His job is to decide from a range of equally reasonable choices, presented to him by competent advisers who are having trouble reaching a consensus on their own. If only option A is viable, then the President will be asked to decide A. If options A and B are viable, then the President will be asked to choose between them. It doesn't matter which choice the President makes. The important thing is that the choice is made, that it is definitive, and that everybody gets on board with it. I think Trump would be good at that. Obama wasn't. He was a bit of a ditherer, like Hamlet.

And your comparison of Obama to Trump is deplorable.

Well, actually, I think Obama's narcissism is much worse than Trump's. Trump's is so obvious that it's almost a joke. It's either an act or a mask for perhaps a deeper insecurity or lack of confidence. Obama's is more subtle, but no less problematic for his grasp of reality. Although Trump claims to be the smartest man in the room, I don't think he actually believes it. Obama doesn't claim to be the smartest man in the room (except every now and then when his mask slips), but I think he believes it anyway.
 
I can't think of anyone who fits this description, except perhaps Ben Carson. Although, ironically, I think Carson will prove to be a good match for the job he'll have. Do you have any examples in mind?

Exactly how does a neurosurgeon become a good match for housing and urban development? The two disciplines are so far apart they're practically in different universes.

That aside, while the "out for personal enrichment" part is debatable for many of Trump's picks, I can list you out multiple members of his cabinet who have little or no experience in the area Trump has called upon them to fill. Off the top of my head:

Rex Tillerson for SOS (being CEO of a oil company does not prepare you for being the country's top diplomat, despite having had to navigate uncertain waters in other countries), Betsy DeVos for SOEd (in what world does this woman think everyone would be able to afford to send their children to private school or take classes online?), Rick Perry for SOE, the aforementioned Ben Carson for SOHUD, Nikki Haley for Ambassador to the UN, Scott Pruitt for head of the EPA (yes, let's put someone in charge of the agency that ensures we don't **** up the environment who doesn't actually believe we DO **** up the environment), and Linda McMahon for head of Small Business Administration (the woman helped run a WRESTLING foundation, not a small business in any way, shape or form).

I'm sure there will be others. I'm quite frankly skeptical of the bona fides of many of the people who do at least have a background in the area Trump has asked them to take over; particularly the Labor and Treasury secretaries, since those two have a history of enriching themselves at the expense of others, but I will give Trump props for one position, namely SECDEF. Mattis was a good choice, although I would have preferred he find someone that didn't need a waiver to take the position.
 
Exactly how does a neurosurgeon become a good match for housing and urban development? The two disciplines are so far apart they're practically in different universes.

He's going to be tasked with dismantling many of the social engineering programs at HUD. Democrats will attack such dismantling as racist. Their accusations will seem even more ludicrous given Ben Carson's race. So, yes, I believe it was an affirmative action hire, in a way.

That aside, while the "out for personal enrichment" part is debatable for many of Trump's picks, I can list you out multiple members of his cabinet who have little or no experience in the area Trump has called upon them to fill. Off the top of my head:

Rex Tillerson for SOS (being CEO of a oil company does not prepare you for being the country's top diplomat, despite having had to navigate uncertain waters in other countries), Betsy DeVos for SOEd (in what world does this woman think everyone would be able to afford to send their children to private school or take classes online?), Rick Perry for SOE, the aforementioned Ben Carson for SOHUD, Nikki Haley for Ambassador to the UN, Scott Pruitt for head of the EPA (yes, let's put someone in charge of the agency that ensures we don't **** up the environment who doesn't actually believe we DO **** up the environment), and Linda McMahon for head of Small Business Administration (the woman helped run a WRESTLING foundation, not a small business in any way, shape or form).

I don't disagree that many of the picks lack experience in their future role. I don't consider that a bad thing though. Also, sometimes the claimed experience is just nonsense. These are managerial roles, and good managers can manage anything, just as bad managers can screw up anything. Obama seemed to be very proud of his pick of Stephen Chu for Energy Secretary. Chu is a great physicist, but he was a joke as a manager, particularly a high profile political one. What does pioneering the field of laser trapping and cooling of atoms have to do with energy policy, or nuclear weapons policy? Absolutely nothing. He was a prop and nothing more to Obama.
 
You may want to look into the difference between a malpractice suit and libel or slander for one's public comments.

The issue with diagnostic comments about a patient one has not seen is an ethics issue, not a malpractice issue and ethical standards do not have any weight of law behind them. Like it or not qualified professionals making a diagnosis of Trump without seeing him has occurred and is in the public record.

Back to what I said, your problem, not mine. I'm not worried about being sued or having my practice affected because I concluded, as have other professionals more qualified than I am, that there is more than sufficient evidence of Trump's personality disorder in the public record to make a diagnosis.

What you don't seem to get (Dunning–Kruger) is that there is nothing an exam of Trump is going to show which is not already on display. That is the nature of a narcissistic personality disorder.
A diagnosis of NPD in any of it's forms cannot be made through observation alone. This, is an established fact that anyone can easy look up and verify.

Any TV psychiatrist, wannabe mental health expert, nurse practitioner, or other unqualified/unprofessional individual who says otherwise should have whatever credentials/licenses they have, if they actually have any, reviewed and possibly suspended.

I don't care who does not like whom politically or otherwise, you DO NOT get to change established diagnostic procedures simply because the guy or gal you voted for, lost.
 
I don't care who does not like whom politically or otherwise, you DO NOT get to change established diagnostic procedures simply because the guy or gal you voted for, lost.
What's a sensible critical thinker like you doing on a forum like this? :thumbsup:
 
What is this "unity" you speak of? It's entirely possible that Trump will function -- or only be allowed to function -- as a figurehead, and that the government will actually be run by Pence, the SecDef, SecState and his kids. The Republicans have made plain, pretty much since Obama's election, that they have no interest in unity, and Republican interests benefit most from a weak President who will do whatever they want.

No actually the dems have made quite clear they aren't interested in unity, this is political war, lets get to it!!!
 
A diagnosis of NPD in any of it's forms cannot be made through observation alone. This, is an established fact that anyone can easy look up and verify.
Do tell us what would be added to the dx in an in-person exam? A questionnaire? A blood test? A trick question?

If one can look up the test, how about a link?

Any TV psychiatrist, wannabe mental health expert, nurse practitioner, or other unqualified/unprofessional individual who says otherwise should have whatever credentials/licenses they have, if they actually have any, reviewed and possibly suspended.

I don't care who does not like whom politically or otherwise, you DO NOT get to change established diagnostic procedures simply because the guy or gal you voted for, lost.
And your qualifications are?

Do your qualifications exceed these people's:

THE MIND OF DONALD TRUMP - Narcissism, disagreeableness, grandiosity—a psychologist investigates how Trump’s extraordinary personality might shape his possible presidency.
Asked to sum up Trump’s personality for an article in Vanity Fair, Howard Gardner, a psychologist at Harvard, responded, “Remarkably narcissistic.” George Simon, a clinical psychologist who conducts seminars on manipulative behavior, says Trump is “so classic that I’m archiving video clips of him to use in workshops because there’s no better example” of narcissism. “Otherwise I would have had to hire actors and write vignettes. He’s like a dream come true.”

They are not the only professionals to weigh in.
 
Last edited:
What's a sensible critical thinker like you doing on a forum like this? :thumbsup:

IOW agreeing with you equates to a sensible critical thinker. Maybe you can answer my questions above then?

What would you add in your in-person exam: A questionnaire? A blood test? A trick question?
 
A diagnosis of NPD in any of it's forms cannot be made through observation alone. This, is an established fact that anyone can easy look up and verify.
Any TV psychiatrist, wannabe mental health expert, nurse practitioner, or other unqualified/unprofessional individual who says otherwise should have whatever credentials/licenses they have, if they actually have any, reviewed and possibly suspended.

I don't care who does not like whom politically or otherwise, you DO NOT get to change established diagnostic procedures simply because the guy or gal you voted for, lost.

You don't have to look it up because that's what the letter actually says, but Trump apologists seem to be saying we can't get a professional diagnosis because we don't already have a professional diagnosis. Never mind that psychology professors were using him as a textbook case of NPD even before he ran.
 
How about a professional evaluation conducted under well established medical procedures by people who are not biased?

And those procedures are?

You seem to think you know something the rest of us don't. I imagine you imagine there are magic procedures one uses to make a diagnosis.

Guess what? The bulk of a diagnosis of personality disorder is based on observation.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom