The world according to Samuel Huntington

Back on topic after derail attempt by Wroclaw: geopolitics.

If by "Back to topic after derail attempt by Wroclaw" you mean "9/11-investigator is running away from his responsibility to prove his ridiculous claims or admit they are false"...
 
And the key event will be the dumping of the dollar by the rest of the world. The only question will be: when is that going to happen?

Told you so, merely 24 hours later:

http://www.spiegel.de/wirtschaft/soziales/0,1518,748730,00.html

China attackiert den Dollar
China attacks dollar

Die chinesische Notenbank überrascht mit einer spektakulären Ankündigung: Die angehende Supermacht will ihren kompletten Außenhandel künftig in Yuan abwickeln, nicht mehr in Dollar. Peking rüttelt an Amerikas Anspruch, die Leitwährung zu stellen - mit gravierenden Folgen für die USA.

A few hours ago the Chinese central bank surprised with a spectacular announcement: the coming superpower wants to conduct it's complete foreign trade in Yuan, no longer in the dollar. Peking challenges Americas claim to define the world's reserve currency, with grave consequences for the USA.
 
Last edited:
Told you so, merely 24 hours later:

http://www.spiegel.de/wirtschaft/soziales/0,1518,748730,00.html

China attackiert den Dollar
China attacks dollar



A few hours ago the Chinese central bank surprised with a spectacular announcement: the coming superpower wants to conduct it's complete foreign trade in Yuan, no longer in the dollar. Peking challenges Americas claim to define the world's reserve currency, with grave consequences for the USA.

Are the Chinese going to float their currency anytime soon? If not, how will this news impact their exports?
 
Originally Posted by Darth Rotor
In response to post 40, and a couple of egslims posts:

I disagree with you both for different reasons.

1. The rise to prominence of both the UN and globalization has fundamentally changed the possibilities of how power blocs coalesce and disperse. Also, beginning with satellite TV, and followed by the internet, the ability to connect into blocs and interest groups has magnified in the past generation or so, lending new opportunity for new models of group/alliance cohesion. Take a look at where US - India relationships were in the 70's. India was a player in the 'non aligned bloc' and reasonably friendly with the Soviets. Why? In part (I am simplifying a complex issue here) The anti-imperialist meme running rampant after WW II.

Today, US India relationships are pretty substantial.

I suggest, Pacal, that you try not to get too semantic. The "Latin American" civilization Huntington suggests is, absent Brazil, a linguistic identity group. Gee, where have we seen that before? Anglophone linguistic identity groups are still with us, and not to long ago there was the Francophone group in Africa that established a certain group affiliation ... though I suspect the French tried to advertise the bonds as stronger than they were, for their own reasons.

Is Huntington right? I have no idea.

At the macro level he tries to operate at, the brush is so broad you are prone to error no matter what you try. He may be partly right, but as egslim notes, and a few others, there are significant enough cracks within his large "blocs" of assumed mutual interest that I'd not wager the rent money on him.

Also, once you predict Y on day X, your prediction begin to degrade a bit (or demonstrate a certain half-life decay rate) as things change over time, which they always do.

It is my opinion that the "Islamic World" is going to have a few more cat fights before anything settles down.
I wouldn´t put too much stock in the Spanish-speaking linguistic identity group in Latin America. There is plenty of discord in there. Argentina vs Chile, for example (they were close to war in the 70s), Bolivia vs Paraguay, I think, Bolivia vs Peru... a big happy family with lots of long-running feuds.


Asside from the fact that Peru, Bolivia, Guatemala Ecuador and Paraguay have large populations that speak various Indian languages. More than 1/2 of the population of both Guatemala and Bolivia is Indian according to Latin American definitions. And I shouls point out it is generally recognized that Latin American censuses undercount Indians. Then there is the case of Paraguay where there are two official languages Spanish and Gurani, an Indian language, and more people there are unilingual Gurani than unilingual Spanish. (more than 80% can speak Gurani). In modern day Mexico the Indian languages are disapearing fairly fast to be replaced by Mexican Spanish which as a large number of Indian words in it. Still about 15% of the population speaks an Indian language.

What your missing is my point that in various Latin American countries, Mexico, Guatemala, Ecuador, Bolivia for example the precolumbian past exercises a very powerful impact on society and culture in those places, which is apparent just by strolling in say Mexico city. If you go to Argintina and and Uruguay you enter counties that are very European in culture and feel. It makes no sense to me to assimilate the very European cultures of countries like Argentina to the very Mestizo cultures of countries like Mexico. Lumping them all together in my opinion is simply simple-minded. The anglophone identity is based on more than just language it is based on shared cultural traits and history. Well the history of many countries in Latin America are quite different from each other. You have places like Mexico where there was a massive suurvival of the pre-columbian population and culture and a Indian majority until the mid 19th century. (Mestizo in much of Latin America is a cultural identity not genetic). Also you have places like Argentina where the native population was almost entirely displaced / destroyed and a European population settled along with a European culture. This is not a semantic issue but a fundemental issue in terms of how Huntington defined his "civilizations". To put it bluntly if i was defining "civilizations" I would put Argentina and Uruguay with "Western" for example. If linguistic identity is so important than why did Huntington lump Spain with "Western" and not with "Latin American"?
 
You misunderstand... I was trying to poke holes into the "Latin America is one group" thing. Pity that "big happy family" doesn´t carry the sarcasm I put into it.

I´ve been to Buenos Aires, and I´ve been to Barcelona. If you dropped me in either cities, away from the iconic parts, I would not be able to tell which of the two cities I was in. Well, until I hear a local pronounce the "ll", but that´s besides the point really.

And I think to a degree you can probably add Chile to the list of "European" countries in Latin America. At least judging from the few parts I´ve seen.
 
Are the Chinese going to float their currency anytime soon? If not, how will this news impact their exports?

Here more detail about the Chinese plans:

http://www.spiegel.de/wirtschaft/unternehmen/0,1518,748796,00.html

China wants the Yuan to compete with the dollar on the world market.
It should be a gradual process but the endgoal is the replacement of the dollar as world currency. I have my doubts that this plan has been coordinated with the IMF. :D

As a first target, Asia should become a Yuan area.
 
You misunderstand... I was trying to poke holes into the "Latin America is one group" thing. Pity that "big happy family" doesn´t carry the sarcasm I put into it.

I´ve been to Buenos Aires, and I´ve been to Barcelona. If you dropped me in either cities, away from the iconic parts, I would not be able to tell which of the two cities I was in. Well, until I hear a local pronounce the "ll", but that´s besides the point really.

And I think to a degree you can probably add Chile to the list of "European" countries in Latin America. At least judging from the few parts I´ve seen.

I was actually referring to Darth Rotor's post. But I grapped it in your response. My bad.
Sorry for the confusion. I did realize that you did not accept Dartyh Rotor's dubious contention.

Appologies.
 
I wouldn´t put too much stock in the Spanish-speaking linguistic identity group in Latin America.

I don't disagree, I am aware of it not being some monolithic bloc. That said, there's been a few moves afoot in the past two decades to do less bickering and more cooperating. The Brits and the US did a bit of scrapping despite being linguistically related ...
 
Talking about geopolitics: one of the major geopolitical new facts is the rise of the internet. Even in Washington this insight starts to sink in. Auntie Hillary:

US Losing Information War to Alternative Media

http://tv.globalresearch.ca/2011/03/hillary-clinton-us-losing-information-war-alternative-media

The US is losing the global information war, Secretary of State Hillary Clinton declared while appearing before a congressional committee to ask for extra funds to spread US propaganda through new media.

Clinton said existing private channels are not good enough to handle the job, naming as rivals Al Jazeera, China's CCTV and RT -- which she watches, she added.

And any moron can start a blog with global reach, I would like to add.
(Keep the compliments coming! :D )

The internet is a threat to all those states who base their power on stories that cannot stand up to scrutiny.

Hillary knows she is losing and does not like it. Neither do the Jews that govern Washington:

http://www.lewrockwell.com/maloney/maloney32.1.html

But not liking and (being able to) do something about it are 2 different things. The internet is going to be the backbone (pun intended) of the future localized 'devoluted' economy, replacing the car economy in a resource starved world.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom