Originally Posted by Darth Rotor
In response to post 40, and a couple of egslims posts:
I disagree with you both for different reasons.
1. The rise to prominence of both the UN and globalization has fundamentally changed the possibilities of how power blocs coalesce and disperse. Also, beginning with satellite TV, and followed by the internet, the ability to connect into blocs and interest groups has magnified in the past generation or so, lending new opportunity for new models of group/alliance cohesion. Take a look at where US - India relationships were in the 70's. India was a player in the 'non aligned bloc' and reasonably friendly with the Soviets. Why? In part (I am simplifying a complex issue here) The anti-imperialist meme running rampant after WW II.
Today, US India relationships are pretty substantial.
I suggest, Pacal, that you try not to get too semantic. The "Latin American" civilization Huntington suggests is, absent Brazil, a linguistic identity group. Gee, where have we seen that before? Anglophone linguistic identity groups are still with us, and not to long ago there was the Francophone group in Africa that established a certain group affiliation ... though I suspect the French tried to advertise the bonds as stronger than they were, for their own reasons.
Is Huntington right? I have no idea.
At the macro level he tries to operate at, the brush is so broad you are prone to error no matter what you try. He may be partly right, but as egslim notes, and a few others, there are significant enough cracks within his large "blocs" of assumed mutual interest that I'd not wager the rent money on him.
Also, once you predict Y on day X, your prediction begin to degrade a bit (or demonstrate a certain half-life decay rate) as things change over time, which they always do.
It is my opinion that the "Islamic World" is going to have a few more cat fights before anything settles down.