The world according to Samuel Huntington

Berlin turning brown from red took place in the thirties. There was not any major 'killing' going on then. In Russia yes, but not in Germany. Many communists turned Nazi voluntarily. Before the war the number of killingsin Germany was in the hundreds; in the USSR in the millions.

That statement is so dishonest and so far removed from reality that I don´t know where to start.
 
In response to post 40, and a couple of egslims posts:

I disagree with you both for different reasons.

1. The rise to prominence of both the UN and globalization has fundamentally changed the possibilities of how power blocs coalesce and disperse. Also, beginning with satellite TV, and followed by the internet, the ability to connect into blocs and interest groups has magnified in the past generation or so, lending new opportunity for new models of group/alliance cohesion. Take a look at where US - India relationships were in the 70's. India was a player in the 'non aligned bloc' and reasonably friendly with the Soviets. Why? In part (I am simplifying a complex issue here) The anti-imperialist meme running rampant after WW II.

Today, US India relationships are pretty substantial.

I suggest, Pacal, that you try not to get too semantic. The "Latin American" civilization Huntington suggests is, absent Brazil, a linguistic identity group. Gee, where have we seen that before? Anglophone linguistic identity groups are still with us, and not to long ago there was the Francophone group in Africa that established a certain group affiliation ... though I suspect the French tried to advertise the bonds as stronger than they were, for their own reasons.

Is Huntington right? I have no idea.

At the macro level he tries to operate at, the brush is so broad you are prone to error no matter what you try. He may be partly right, but as egslim notes, and a few others, there are significant enough cracks within his large "blocs" of assumed mutual interest that I'd not wager the rent money on him.

Also, once you predict Y on day X, your prediction begin to degrade a bit (or demonstrate a certain half-life decay rate) as things change over time, which they always do.

It is my opinion that the "Islamic World" is going to have a few more cat fights before anything settles down.
 
That statement is so dishonest and so far removed from reality that I don´t know where to start.

That's not very smart then.

I said: before 1939:
- Hitler killed hundreds (mainly of his own kind)
- Stalin killed millions

Chaos says: before 1939:
- Hitler killed xxx people
- Stalin killed yyy people

Please give rough estimates for xxx and yyy.

Not that difficult.
 
That's not very smart then.

I said: before 1939:
- Hitler killed hundreds (mainly of his own kind)
- Stalin killed millions

Chaos says: before 1939:
- Hitler killed xxx people
- Stalin killed yyy people

Please give rough estimates for xxx and yyy.

Not that difficult.

OK, so Stalin killed an order of magnitude or more of his people consolidating power in the USSR. He had a different problem to solve in his rise to power than Hitler did. He was trying to put together the new Russian Empire ... and that was a bloody difficult thing to do.

Germany had been unified by Bismarck over a generation prior, which itself cost a few lives ... not all of them German ... and saved Hitler the trouble. I don't doubt that if he thought he'd have to, he'd have shed what blood he felt necessary to create his Reich.
 
That's not very smart then.

I said: before 1939:
- Hitler killed hundreds (mainly of his own kind)
- Stalin killed millions

Chaos says: before 1939:
- Hitler killed xxx people
- Stalin killed yyy people

Please give rough estimates for xxx and yyy.

Not that difficult.

Are we now contending that Hitler was better than Stalin because Stalin killed innocent people first?

Really?
 
Are we now contending that Hitler was better than Stalin because Stalin killed innocent people first?

Really?

That is just SO wrong!

Stalin was clearly morally superior because he froze and starved people to death. Whilst Hitler shot and gassed.
 
He only likes the Russian Slavs, from the way he holds the Poles and the Czechs in contempt.

I wonder if he has a picture of Charley Sheen hanging up now since Sheen's now notorious Mel Gibsonesque Jew baiting rant yesterday.

Where did you get this idea? Ever visited Poland, Czech Republic and Russia, ? Saw it's cities?

Then you would have known that the first 2 have the full potential of rejoining European mainstream in another decade or two. Czechoslovakia once was one of Europe's premier addresses concerning industrial progress and Prague is still one of the most beautifull cities in Europe.

Russia in contrast always has been a backward country and is even more so today after it lost it's best genetic stock under the murderous anti-aristocratic bolshevik regime. Today it is a country of drunkards as compared to Eastern Europe. But it still is a real nation in contrast to the neo-Babylon US. And it is it's nationalism that is most useful in assembling counter forces for that NWO of yours. And a nice nuclear stockpile at that. Not that we in Europe would be unable to come to nuclear strategic parity with the US in a matter of months but we don't want to provoke things... not yet...
 
In response to post 40, and a couple of egslims posts:

I disagree with you both for different reasons.

1. The rise to prominence of both the UN and globalization has fundamentally changed the possibilities of how power blocs coalesce and disperse. Also, beginning with satellite TV, and followed by the internet, the ability to connect into blocs and interest groups has magnified in the past generation or so, lending new opportunity for new models of group/alliance cohesion. Take a look at where US - India relationships were in the 70's. India was a player in the 'non aligned bloc' and reasonably friendly with the Soviets. Why? In part (I am simplifying a complex issue here) The anti-imperialist meme running rampant after WW II.

Today, US India relationships are pretty substantial.

I suggest, Pacal, that you try not to get too semantic. The "Latin American" civilization Huntington suggests is, absent Brazil, a linguistic identity group. Gee, where have we seen that before? Anglophone linguistic identity groups are still with us, and not to long ago there was the Francophone group in Africa that established a certain group affiliation ... though I suspect the French tried to advertise the bonds as stronger than they were, for their own reasons.

Is Huntington right? I have no idea.

At the macro level he tries to operate at, the brush is so broad you are prone to error no matter what you try. He may be partly right, but as egslim notes, and a few others, there are significant enough cracks within his large "blocs" of assumed mutual interest that I'd not wager the rent money on him.

Also, once you predict Y on day X, your prediction begin to degrade a bit (or demonstrate a certain half-life decay rate) as things change over time, which they always do.

It is my opinion that the "Islamic World" is going to have a few more cat fights before anything settles down.

I wouldn´t put too much stock in the Spanish-speaking linguistic identity group in Latin America. There is plenty of discord in there. Argentina vs Chile, for example (they were close to war in the 70s), Bolivia vs Paraguay, I think, Bolivia vs Peru... a big happy family with lots of long-running feuds.
 
That's not very smart then.

I said: before 1939:
- Hitler killed hundreds (mainly of his own kind)
- Stalin killed millions

Chaos says: before 1939:
- Hitler killed xxx people
- Stalin killed yyy people

Please give rough estimates for xxx and yyy.

Not that difficult.

You left out the big honking lie you posted previously. I will take that as an admission that you never had any intention to honestly debate anything in this thread.
 
You left out the big honking lie you posted previously. I will take that as an admission that you never had any intention to honestly debate anything in this thread.

Translation: Chaos refuses to give us vallues for xxx and yyy because he knows I am right but he does not want to admit that.

Total derail. Please mods AH these posts.
 
Trans-national corporations will probably throw an enormous monkey wrench into the works and Huntingdon and whacky old Uncle Pat will be left by the side of the road drawing flies.

Trade companies having their own armies is a pretty old concept. It looks to be on the rise again.

As for the cultural blocks, yes they have a bit of merit but this OP is blowing it completely out of proportion. (Who are you more likely to fight over rights to a river for irrigation, your neighbour or those pesky heretics across the ocean.)

Try study the Eurovision song contest, the claims of block voting are plentiful but does not enable anyone to predict a winner. :D
 
Translation: Chaos refuses to give us vallues for xxx and yyy because he knows I am right but he does not want to admit that.

Total derail. Please mods AH these posts.

Wrong. You refuse to either prove or take back your idiotic statement that masses of communists converted to Nazis. And you repeatedly attempt to derail this discussion by bringing Stalin into it.

Question: are you aware of the total idiocy and dishonesty of your posts, or has your Aryan pride exalted you above such petty concerns as facts and reality?
 

Well not backward like in Africa;

let's say somewhere between the First World and the Third world.

Can we settle for the Second World?

This is still the norm between Smolensk and Wladiwostok:

http://www.emelibrary.org/images/Soviet-EraApartments0709.jpg

Left-wing values in action. :o

But I would agree, if the Bolshevik revolution had not happened, Russia likely would have been nearly as prosperous as Europe. But Russia killed it's best people, the aristocrats, during that revolution.

Tob Shebbe Goyim Harog. - Kill the best gentiles.
 
Last edited:
Back on topic after derail attempt by Wroclaw: geopolitics.

Recent article in Der Spiegel, very America friendly largest German magazine, in English, about the state of decline of our benevolent hegemon:

http://www.spiegel.de/international/world/0,1518,726447-4,00.html

And here a reference and review to that article by lefty blog dailykos:

http://www.dailykos.com/story/2010/...uments-the-decline-of-the-American-superpower

And here we have it:

Hart's worries, in other words, have become the new American nightmare for many. In a country with a limited concept of social cohesion, laughable from a European perspective, the quiet demise could have unforeseen consequences. How strong is the cement holding together a society that manically declares any social thinking to be socialist?

I can tell you what these 'unforseen consequences' could be for a society with 'limited concept of social cohesion': falling apart.

Not that difficult, really. If you can't hold together a country with Arab semites like Iraq, or a European country like Yugoslavia, Czecho-Slovakia, why on earth should a neo-Babylon like the US, with much larger ethnic differences than Iraq and Yugoslavia stay together if the going gets tough?

Answer: it won't.

And the key event will be the dumping of the dollar by the rest of the world. The only question will be: when is that going to happen?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom