The War on Drugs is Useless

Cocaine would be about $10/kilo if it was a legal product. Far cheaper than imprisoning millions every year.

And like tobacco sufficiently difficult to manufacture locally that you can put rather point high taxes on it.

The drug war is a disaster.
Sure there is a human cost to the availability of drugs, but a legalisation would lessen those, save the enforcement cost, and shift the (reduced) profit from criminals to the government.
Try think of the saving in tax money. :)
 
Wouldn't save anything because the cost of illicit drug use to the community is greater than the cost of enforcement. More users would only increase that.
 
Absolutely. I don't think any anti-prohibitionist would say otherwise.

I do! Why would you "persecute" them? No criminals should be "persecuted", that isn't what law and order is about. No, I would PROSECUTE them, but also impose mandatory treatment on them.

I would also massively, and I mean massively, crack down on distribution of drugs into prisons. All prisons should be 100% dry. A prison warden bringing drugs in should be given a lengthy prison sentance. An inmate helping to prove a warden (or anyone else) is smuggling in drugs (eg by tipping off the authorities so they can search), should get benefits.

I would reform the whole prison system to make it much more CARROT and STICK. Prisoners would earn (and lose) access to TVs, video games, conjugal visits etc by completing good works (eg educational achievements, civics, counseling other prisoners etc). I would make it much less boring in prison and much more rewarding for those willing to put the effort in to improve and help themselves and others. Prison should be about reform not punishment.
 
It just shows the hypocrisy and inconsistency of those who want to throw people in prison for selling/using drugs that are currently illegal.

In other words, it's an ad hominem.

And the two are clearly not enough. Evidenced by the fact that there is a large demand for other substances. A demand that is currently being largely met by Mexican thugs who just kill anybody that gets in their way.

People will always want more, that much is obvious. You can't block out all intoxicants, but that doesn't mean the only legitimate possibilities are either allow all or allow none.

I do think the US law enforcement is making a severe mistake by persecuting drug users, and that there is perhaps some merit in permitting some of the softer illegal drugs in order to focus on the harder stuff. That will not do much to solve the problem, and I doubt that the increased number of afflictions caused by increased usage (that the lower prices and better availability would bring) from a relatively minor array of drugs would improve things sufficiently to justify it, but it has some potential.

McHrozni
 
Sure there is a human cost to the availability of drugs, but a legalisation would lessen those,

This is doubtful. It's not impossible, but since improved availability would almost certainly increase usage - perhaps not at first, but over a few years that is a certainty - and since we do know that the toll from the already legal drugs exceeds the human cost of the war on drugs by about two orders of magnitude, this argument isn't something anyone should take for granted.

McHrozni
 
Do you know that the Dutch have less dope smokers than the US?
It makes the connection between legality and frequency of drug use rather iffy.
 
but since improved availability would almost certainly increase usage

This relies on the assumption that availability would increase under a legalisation regeime. I myself find it hard to believe that the numbers of users of any given drug actually increase, as evidenced by the reduction in the numbers of users and abusers in total in states which have decriminalised possession.

If the ultimate aim of the drug war is to reduce the numbers of people who use drugs and therefore the numbers who abuse them, then a prohibitionist approach has been a failure, would you agree McHrozni?
 
In other words, it's an ad hominem.

No, just an observation.


People will always want more, that much is obvious. You can't block out all intoxicants, but that doesn't mean the only legitimate possibilities are either allow all or allow none.

I don't think that allowing none is a legitimate possibility, but it is at least consistent. Allowing them all is the only legitimate possibility. At least if you care about personal freedom and preventing murderous thugs from making billions of dollars selling drugs, it is.
 
Last edited:
I do! Why would you "persecute" them? No criminals should be "persecuted", that isn't what law and order is about. No, I would PROSECUTE them, but also impose mandatory treatment on them.

I assumed he meant "prosecute."
 
<SNIP>
People will always want more, that much is obvious. You can't block out all intoxicants, but that doesn't mean the only legitimate possibilities are either allow all or allow none.
<SNIP>
McHrozni


I like this, it's a valid point, but if you base the decision about which substances are legal and which are not on how harmful they are to the human body and how harmful someone abusing them can be to the rest of society, then the wrong ones are legal, surely?
 
Tax all substances (including current legal ones) in proportion to the value of their externalities (eg healthcare, treatment, crime, prevention etc).

People will quickly gravitate towards the less harmfull ones as they become cheaper, a lot of drugs are substitutes based on cost/availability (see Mephedrone vs MDMA).
 
Allowing them all is the only legitimate possibility. At least if you care about personal freedom and preventing murderous thugs from making billions of dollars selling drugs, it is.

And if you don't care the misery of millions who get addicted on cheap, dangerous substances, you mean. It was stated in this thread that there are about 75 alcohol-related deaths per year in the US alone for each death in the drug war of the last three years combined.
I really don't see how widely available heroin and similar dangerous substances would somehow reduce the human misery caused.

McHrozni
 
I like this, it's a valid point, but if you base the decision about which substances are legal and which are not on how harmful they are to the human body and how harmful someone abusing them can be to the rest of society, then the wrong ones are legal, surely?

If you're only focused on the effects they have on the body, then maybe we could have a better choice, yes. This is not, however, the only issue. You don't need a whole lot to produce alcohol - naturally occurring yeast and sugar are enough. Unless you ban fruit and grains anyone can produce alcohol with minimal training and equipment. Enforcing a ban on alcohol is therefore impossible.

Cigarettes are different in this regard, but with proper restrictions on indoor smoking and such - which can be enforced - addicts to nicotine will at least harm only themselves, and that only in the long run. This can not be said for a vast majority if not all banned drugs.

I should probably say this again - I'm not saying all currently legal substances should remain legal or that all illegal substances should remain illegal. However, some of the illegal substances should remain illegal, and some of the substances should remain (or perhaps become) legal, either because a ban on them is impossible to enforce, or because some intoxicants are simply needed for our society to function normally.

McHrozni
 
If you're only focused on the effects they have on the body, then maybe we could have a better choice, yes. This is not, however, the only issue. You don't need a whole lot to produce alcohol - naturally occurring yeast and sugar are enough. Unless you ban fruit and grains anyone can produce alcohol with minimal training and equipment. Enforcing a ban on alcohol is therefore impossible.

Cigarettes are different in this regard, but with proper restrictions on indoor smoking and such - which can be enforced - addicts to nicotine will at least harm only themselves, and that only in the long run. This can not be said for a vast majority if not all banned drugs.

I should probably say this again - I'm not saying all currently legal substances should remain legal or that all illegal substances should remain illegal. However, some of the illegal substances should remain illegal, and some of the substances should remain (or perhaps become) legal, either because a ban on them is impossible to enforce, or because some intoxicants are simply needed for our society to function normally.

McHrozni

The bold bit is important. Experience seems to indicate that it is impossible to enforce a ban on any substance that enough people wnat to get their hands on, no?
 
The bold bit is important. Experience seems to indicate that it is impossible to enforce a ban on any substance that enough people wnat to get their hands on, no?

You misunderstood the point somewhat. Completely eliminating any such substance is indeed impossible. Significantly reducing it's availability, however, is quite possible in some cases, but not in others. Just because an effort isn't completely succeeding doesn't mean it's useless, right?

McHrozni
 
You misunderstood the point somewhat. Completely eliminating any such substance is indeed impossible. Significantly reducing it's availability, however, is quite possible in some cases, but not in others. Just because an effort isn't completely succeeding doesn't mean it's useless, right?

McHrozni


I have a habit of doing that. I'll read it again and see if I have any further reply when I get the chance.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom