The US was NOT strongly isolationist before Pearl Harbor.

Then expressing the findings as 69% vs 31% is a distortion designed to pump up the significance of poll findings (regardless of if it was just the way things were done). It raises the value of the affirmative from barely half of the people asked to make it seem like better than a 2/3 majority.


It's well documented that over 73% of people in the 1940s didn't understand statistics.
 
It was stated up front that this is how the numbers would be presented. If you have a problem with that, see Mr. Gallup.

no need for that, it seems that these polls are of little or no utility and given the shaky methodolgy and framing, are inadequate to support the contentions for which they are being offered. If these polls are rejected, what other evidences do you have to lend weight to your argument?
 
Well, the fine folks at the Institute for Historical Review did a piece a few years back on the book "Hollywood Goes to War", and cites a lot of anti-Nazi "propaganda" from the late 30s, prior to Pearl Harbor (as proof of how those American meanies and Hollywood Jews and Rossevelt were plotting against that nice paper-hanger, fella!).

There were a number of films that were quite popular in the pre-PH years that were distinctly calls to arms. Casablanca was released in '42, but was shot before Pearl, also. Rick, the epitome of the American loner and anti-hero, is clearly getting ready for join the fray. The Great Dictator was also hugely popular.

Today, you'd generally cite film trends as just film trends. But back in the 30s? Movies drove the public taste and opinion.


Sorry, but you are mistaken about Casablanca being shot before Pearl Harbor.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Casablanca_(film)

Warner's was always very anti Nazi. "Confessions Of A Nazi Spy" in 1939 was the first openly Anti Nazi film made by a major Hollywood studio.
A number of Anti Nazi films had additional scenes shot very quickly after Pearl Harbor to address The US's entry into the war.
 
Last edited:
And this came out nearly a year before Pearl Harbor...and was the biggest sucess the infant Comic Book industry had seen since Superman and Batman made their debut in 1938:



I would say that is not very isolatonist......
 
OCTOBER 18
EUROPEAN WAR
Interviewing Date 10/5-10/39
Survey #173-A Question #4a
Hitler says that the Polish question is settled and England and France have no reason to continue the war with Germany. Do you agree?
Yes................................ 14%
No................................ 86
Thirteen per cent expressed no opinion.
OCTOBER 20 EUROPEAN WAR
Interviewing Date 10/5-10/39
Survey #172 Question #5
If it appears that Germany is defeating England and France, should the United States declare war on Germany and send our army and navy to Europe to fight? Yes................................ 29% No................................ 71OCTOBER 23 EUROPEAN WAR
Interviewing Date 10/5-10/39
Survey #172-A Question #3
Which side do you want to see win the war?
Allies.............................. 84%
Germany........................... 2
No opinion, neutral.................. 14
Interviewing Date 10/5-10/39
Survey #172-A Question #5
What should be the policy of the United States in the present European war — Should we declare war on Germany and
send our army and navy abroad to fight or should we not send our armed forces over' seas?
Should fight......................... 5%
Should not fight..................... 95
Interviewing Date 10/5-10/39
Survey #172-A Question #4a
Do you think the United States should do everything possible to help England and France win the war, except go to war ourselves?
Yes................................ 62%
No................................ 38
Interviewing Date 10/5-10/39
Survey #172-B Question #1
Do you think Congress should make changes in the Neutrality Law so that England and France or any other nation can buy war supplies, including arms and airplanes, in the United States?
Yes................................ 60%
No................................ 40
By Region
Yes No
New England................. 56% 44%
Middle Atlantic............... 59 41
East Central.................. 57 43
West Central.................. 60 40
South........................ 75 25
West......................... 68 42
Interviewing Date 10/5-10/39
Survey #172-A Question #4b
Do you think the United States should do everything possible to help England and France win the war, even at the risk of getting into the war ourselves?
Yes................................ 34%
No................................ 66
186 THE GALLUP POLL

MOST IMPORTANT PROBLEM
Interviewing Date 11/10-15/39
Survey #176-A Question #1
What do you think is the most important problem before the American people today? Keeping out of war..................47% Solving unemployment...............24Recovery for business................ 6
Adjustment of labor problems......... 3
Threats to democratic institutions...... 3
Adequate relief...................... 3
Balancing the budget................. 2
Farm aid........................... 1
Old-age pensions.................... 1
Spiritual needs...................... 1
Others............................. 9

Looks like isolationist sentiments to me.
 
no need for that, it seems that these polls are of little or no utility and given the shaky methodolgy and framing, are inadequate to support the contentions for which they are being offered. If these polls are rejected, what other evidences do you have to lend weight to your argument?

Sorry, don't see a problem. Gallup's procedures are well-known. And as I have said AT LEAST THREE TIMES NOW, they'll be uploaded when I get the time.

As for the polls themselves, take 'em or leave 'em, I care.
 
Don't forget that there is always an element that wants war - any time anywhere. They don't much care whom they are fighting or why, just want to fight. But, they are (I hope) a small segment.

Then, sad to say, our professional army makes its career on war. I'd rather not go into that as it has two very strong sides.

But, there you are. Two groups in the minority who, combined and with dangers becoming more and more apparent, can become a strong force for war.

I've not seen statistics on this; statistics do not impress me much since the gatherers of such data can tend to pick and choose who will answer. But, there is this. When it became obvious that Britain was in grave danger of being defeated by Germany, there were more people wanting to go to their aid. However, FDR was never in favor of that. He had pledged to keep us out of war and that he was determined to do.

Given that, I wonder how your statistics changed as December 6, 1941 approached. Is that worth taking into account?
 
Last edited:
Don't forget that there is always an element that wants war - any time anywhere. They don't much care whom they are fighting or why, just want to fight. But, they are (I hope) a small segment.

Then, sad to say, our professional army makes its career on war. I'd rather not go into that as it has two very strong sides.

But, there you are. Two groups in the minority who, combined and with dangers becoming more and more apparent, can become a strong force for war.

I've not seen statistics on this; statistics do not impress me much since the gatherers of such data can tend to pick and choose who will answer. But, there is this. When it became obvious that Britain was in grave danger of being defeated by Germany, there were more people wanting to go to their aid. However, FDR was never in favor of that. He had pledged to keep us out of war and that he was determined to do.

Given that, I wonder how your statistics changed as December 6, 1941 approached. Is that worth taking into account?

First off, they're not my statistics. They're Gallup's. I'll be getting the Public Opinion Quarterly as a crosscheck.

Second, yes they change as events occur. The Fall of France has an effect on the US that is palpable.

Third, polls are not the only thing I will be looking at. For example.

And last, I think FDR understood we needed to get into the war to help defeat the Axis. I don't think he was doing everything possible to avoid it, as the "short of war" attitude shows.
 
no need for that, it seems that these polls are of little or no utility and given the shaky methodolgy and framing, are inadequate to support the contentions for which they are being offered.


I don't know about that. I think that if they were conducted by phone, they probably disproportionately undersampled the poor and the young. My father just now told me that an entire freshman dorm shared one pay phone as late as 1962.

At the same time, that means that the people being polled were probably more likely than those not polled to vote and to make their political opinions known to their representatives.

I would certainly call the opinion polls interesting evidence, even if not statistically perfect. An eyewitness to a crime, after all, gives evidence that also is incomplete and biased - that doesn't make his testimony worthless.

However, so far the data is convincing me that the US was indeed isolationist to a greater extent than I suspected at the start of 1940.


Given that, I wonder how your statistics changed as December 6, 1941 approached. Is that worth taking into account?


I would imagine that a poll taken December 8, 1941 would show 98% of Americans checking the box marked "Kill 'em all."
 
Last edited:
The Great Depression would be the major factor I think. Considering that I think "the anti-war/isolationist strain in American Politcs" is mostly myth, and am in the process of demonstrating that, it's not suprising that I don't agree with you.

So if we assume your premise as true, then your premise proves your premise to be true?
 
Your highlighted items sound contradictory, don't they? That aside, notice the date. Let's see what happened in 1941. To tell the truth, I do not know. I am only curious. I know we were all getting more and more nervous as we saw that our friends, relatives and classmates might have to go. That would be enough to make us shout "no more war".

As I remember, there was an attitude that we had already fought in one European war and here they were fighting again just twenty years later. Leave them to it.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom