The US was NOT strongly isolationist before Pearl Harbor.

Interviewing Date 2/4-9/39
Survey #147-A Question #3a
If Germany and Italy go to war against England and France, do you think we should do everything possible to help England and France win, except go to war ourselves?
Yes................................ 69%
No................................31
Six per cent expressed no opinion.

Survey #147-A Question #4a
If Germany and Italy defeated England and France in a war, do you think Germany and Italy would then start a war against the United States?
Yes................................62%
No................................ 38
Sixteen per cent expressed no opinion.

69+31+6 = 106%

62+38+16 = 116%

I didn't know that Gallup used to be a FOX corporation entity?!
 
I think that if Germany hadn't shifted its focus to London, and continued to bombard the airbases as successfully as they did during the first half of the Battle of Brittain, we would have gone to war to protect England from invasion.


Strictly speaking, even a continued effort against the RAF airfields would not have produced victory for the Luftwaffe. Indeed, the Germans, given the technology, equipment, tactics, intelligence, and commander-in-chief it had, stood relatively little chance of winning the Battle of Britain. Even if by some amazing stroke of luck it gained air superiority, the invasion would have been a very risky endeavour. It's 'landing craft' for the operation consisted mostly of river barges towed by tugs at a speed of three or four knots. Not the kind of stuff that successful amphibious assaults are made of.
 
SEPTEMBER 8
EUROPEAN WAR
Interviewing Date 9/1-6/39
Survey #168-SA Question #7
Which country or countries do you consider responsible for causing the present war?
Germany......................... 82%
England and France................. 3
Versailles Treaty..................... 3
Poland............................. 1
All others........................... 5
No opinion......................... 6
 
SEPTEMBER 29
WAR WITH GERMANY
Interviewing Date 9/13-18/39
Survey #169-A Question #4
If Germany should defeat England, France, and Poland in the present war, do you think Germany would start a war against the United States sooner or later?

Yes................................63%
No................................37
Seven per cent expressed no opinion.
 
OCTOBER 18
EUROPEAN WAR
Interviewing Date 10/5-10/39
Survey #173-A Question #4a
Hitler says that the Polish question is settled and England and France have no reason to continue the war with Germany. Do you agree?
Yes................................ 14%
No................................ 86
Thirteen per cent expressed no opinion.
OCTOBER 20 EUROPEAN WAR
Interviewing Date 10/5-10/39
Survey #172 Question #5
If it appears that Germany is defeating England and France, should the United States declare war on Germany and send our army and navy to Europe to fight?
Yes................................ 29%
No................................ 71
OCTOBER 23 EUROPEAN WAR
Interviewing Date 10/5-10/39
Survey #172-A Question #3
Which side do you want to see win the war?
Allies.............................. 84%
Germany........................... 2
No opinion, neutral.................. 14
Interviewing Date 10/5-10/39
Survey #172-A Question #5
What should be the policy of the United States in the present European war — Should we declare war on Germany and
send our army and navy abroad to fight or should we not send our armed forces over' seas?
Should fight......................... 5%
Should not fight..................... 95
Interviewing Date 10/5-10/39
Survey #172-A Question #4a
Do you think the United States should do everything possible to help England and France win the war, except go to war ourselves?
Yes................................ 62%
No................................ 38
Interviewing Date 10/5-10/39
Survey #172-B Question #1
Do you think Congress should make changes in the Neutrality Law so that England and France or any other nation can buy war supplies, including arms and airplanes, in the United States?
Yes................................ 60%
No................................ 40
By Region
Yes No
New England................. 56% 44%
Middle Atlantic............... 59 41
East Central.................. 57 43
West Central.................. 60 40
South........................ 75 25
West......................... 68 42
Interviewing Date 10/5-10/39
Survey #172-A Question #4b
Do you think the United States should do everything possible to help England and France win the war, even at the risk of getting into the war ourselves?
Yes................................ 34%
No................................ 66
186 THE GALLUP POLL
 
But isn't one b ig reason the military was allowed to atrophy because of the anti-war/isolationist strain in American Politcs?

The Great Depression would be the major factor I think. Considering that I think "the anti-war/isolationist strain in American Politcs" is mostly myth, and am in the process of demonstrating that, it's not suprising that I don't agree with you.
 
MOST IMPORTANT PROBLEM
Interviewing Date 11/10-15/39
Survey #176-A Question #1
What do you think is the most important problem before the American people today?
Keeping out of war..................47%
Solving unemployment...............24
Recovery for business................ 6
Adjustment of labor problems......... 3
Threats to democratic institutions...... 3
Adequate relief...................... 3
Balancing the budget................. 2
Farm aid........................... 1
Old-age pensions.................... 1
Spiritual needs...................... 1
Others............................. 9
 
Well, the fine folks at the Institute for Historical Review did a piece a few years back on the book "Hollywood Goes to War", and cites a lot of anti-Nazi "propaganda" from the late 30s, prior to Pearl Harbor (as proof of how those American meanies and Hollywood Jews and Rossevelt were plotting against that nice paper-hanger, fella!).

There were a number of films that were quite popular in the pre-PH years that were distinctly calls to arms. Casablanca was released in '42, but was shot before Pearl, also. Rick, the epitome of the American loner and anti-hero, is clearly getting ready for join the fray. The Great Dictator was also hugely popular.

Today, you'd generally cite film trends as just film trends. But back in the 30s? Movies drove the public taste and opinion.
 
The Great Depression would be the major factor I think. Considering that I think "the anti-war/isolationist strain in American Politcs" is mostly myth, and am in the process of demonstrating that, it's not suprising that I don't agree with you.

Were you there? I was and I can assure you that the anti-war/isolationist strain was very strong. We were determined not to become involved and worked hard at it.

True, behind the scenes and as secret as we could keep it, we were sending aid to Britain but we were certain we, ourselves, were not going there.

Sorry to disagree with you but that's a fact.
 
Well, the fine folks at the Institute for Historical Review did a piece a few years back on the book "Hollywood Goes to War", and cites a lot of anti-Nazi "propaganda" from the late 30s, prior to Pearl Harbor (as proof of how those American meanies and Hollywood Jews and Rossevelt were plotting against that nice paper-hanger, fella!).

There were a number of films that were quite popular in the pre-PH years that were distinctly calls to arms. Casablanca was released in '42, but was shot before Pearl, also. Rick, the epitome of the American loner and anti-hero, is clearly getting ready for join the fray. The Great Dictator was also hugely popular.

Today, you'd generally cite film trends as just film trends. But back in the 30s? Movies drove the public taste and opinion.
The Nye Committee investigated the link between Hollywood and "interventionism". The Hearings ran into Sept. of 1941. They were due to reconvene in Jan. of '42. For some reason that didn't happen.
 
Were you there?
I wasn't at Thermopylae. SFW?
I was and I can assure you that the anti-war/isolationist strain was very strong. We were determined not to become involved and worked hard at it.
Well, I'm going to prove you are wrong. I've been looking at this for a few decades and the facts don't line up with that myth.
 
I wasn't at Thermopylae. SFW?

Well, I'm going to prove you are wrong. I've been looking at this for a few decades and the facts don't line up with that myth.

:blush: I will listen. But, I fear I remember too much to believe. We were watching Britain sink and doing nothing other than those few ships with materials. Even FDR said that Britain was lost and nothing we could do but prepare to protect our own shores.

Carry on.
 
:blush: I will listen. But, I fear I remember too much to believe. We were watching Britain sink and doing nothing other than those few ships with materials. Even FDR said that Britain was lost and nothing we could do but prepare to protect our own shores.

Carry on.

I'm working on the Gallup Polls for '39-'41. That will be interesting, I think. I should have '39 online today or tomorrow.
 
The Great Depression would be the major factor I think. Considering that I think "the anti-war/isolationist strain in American Politcs" is mostly myth, and am in the process of demonstrating that, it's not suprising that I don't agree with you.


I'm not sure you're demonstrating it successfully. So far, the polls you've published have indicated that the US was more anti-war than I had thought.

I was under the impression that we spent all of 1939 and 1940 revamping our military for the inevitable fight. I would not have guessed that 7 in 10 Americans didn't want to fight even if England was losing.
 
I'm not sure you're demonstrating it successfully. So far, the polls you've published have indicated that the US was more anti-war than I had thought.

I was under the impression that we spent all of 1939 and 1940 revamping our military for the inevitable fight. I would not have guessed that 7 in 10 Americans didn't want to fight even if England was losing.

Those are just "fun" items I found as I'm coding the polls. And you'll see a progression in attitudes as we get closer to 1942.

Also, do keep in mind that the polls are just one facet of the matter. If you weren't there ;) or haven't read what was published AT THE TIME, you may only have Wayne Cole's highly biased books to go on.
 
Quite possibly. Or the numbers represent those that did express an opinion, 69% vs 31% of those who had an opinion.

Then expressing the findings as 69% vs 31% is a distortion designed to pump up the significance of poll findings (regardless of if it was just the way things were done). It raises the value of the affirmative from barely half of the people asked to make it seem like better than a 2/3 majority.
 
Then expressing the findings as 69% vs 31% is a distortion designed to pump up the significance of poll findings (regardless of if it was just the way things were done). It raises the value of the affirmative from barely half of the people asked to make it seem like better than a 2/3 majority.

It was stated up front that this is how the numbers would be presented. If you have a problem with that, see Mr. Gallup.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom