The Trials of Amanda Knox and Raffaele Sollecito: Part 28

Status
Not open for further replies.
Let me get this straight (after wading through all the feces): you're now claiming that Popovic never asked Raffaele to take her to the station to pick up a suitcase? That it was all a lie? That Popovic colluded with Vanessa S. to provide an alibi? You get more and more ludicrous as time goes on. It's why I keep coming back for more of your comedy. It's better than anything on TV.

I am sceptical. Who puts an unattended suitcase on a train (arriving at midnight) and Raff is needed to drive to the station. (Which, like his ordination to be Pope and the trip to Gubbio, never happened.)
 
Good piece of sophistry. Very advanced.
You claim this is sophistry. Please explain how this is a false argument; if you are unable to show that this is a false argument then you will have to agree this is a legal fact.
 
You claim this is sophistry. Please explain how this is a false argument; if you are unable to show that this is a false argument then you will have to agree this is a legal fact.

There is a legal difference between someone who has never been tried, and someone who has been tried and yet another between someone found 'not guilty' (Italian paragraph 1) and 'not guilty due to insufficient evidence' (paragraph 2).
 
There is a legal difference between someone who has never been tried, and someone who has been tried and yet another between someone found 'not guilty' (Italian paragraph 1) and 'not guilty due to insufficient evidence' (paragraph 2).

Yet Italian law is explicitly clear. Persons are innocent until their conviction is confirmed by cassation. It is irrelevant the exact words used unless guilty they are innocent. This is a binary choice, their is no grey. The legal fact is Sollecito and Knox are innocent of murder, theft etc.
 
There is a legal difference between someone who has never been tried, and someone who has been tried and yet another between someone found 'not guilty' (Italian paragraph 1) and 'not guilty due to insufficient evidence' (paragraph 2).

O Lordy. You're not on about this again are you? Despite being proven wrong multiple times - with nothing but re-assertions from you - you simply.....

.... wait a few days and reassert that the Italian section 1 acquittal is different than a section 2 acquittal.

It's pointless to repost subsequent Italian courts' interpretations of what had happened on March 27, 2015, namely that subsequent courts in Italy were very comfortable calling that action both an acquittal and an exoneration.

And around and around the merry-go-round we go......!!!
 
Yet Italian law is explicitly clear. Persons are innocent until their conviction is confirmed by cassation. It is irrelevant the exact words used unless guilty they are innocent. This is a binary choice, their is no grey. The legal fact is Sollecito and Knox are innocent of murder, theft etc.

Only insofar there is 'insufficient evidence', notwithstanding the Supreme Court setting out the facts that:

  • Amanda Knox was definitely present at the murder and washed Meredith Kercher's blood from her hands (blood is only wet for 30" - 60" , at the outside, so she was there whilst the blood was viscuous.
  • That Raffaele Sollecito was 'almost certainly' also there.
  • That it was not credible the murder was by a 'random burglar' (i.e., Rudy Guede) as the killing had the hallmarks of a serial killer (cold sadism).
  • Amanda and Raff lied and lied and lied again. They remain 'strongly suspicious'.
  • In telling police Patrick Lumumba was the rapist .murderer - and as witnessed by Amanda Knox herself - she was covering up for Rudy Guede.
  • The burglary WAS staged. (Ask yourself, who would have a motive to fake a burglary?)
  • There were multiple attackers.
  • The imputed 'other attackers' are not being sought.


This is certainly not 'an exoneration'. If anything, by Marasca sitting on the fence, things remain pretty damning of Knox and Raff.

They can't claim compensation because of their behaviour and they cannot claim libel as it is set in law that the facts are as above. A defence to libel is, that it is true. Can't get truer than a court certification.
 
[*]That it was not credible the murder was by a 'random burglar' (i.e., Rudy Guede) as the killing had the hallmarks of a serial killer (cold sadism).

Many killers start out as burglars:

Here, only 3 offenders had a history of prior sexual offenses while 12 (28%) had a record of burglary. Four of the 12 (33%) combined burglary with assault on the female occupant

Source: https://pdfs.semanticscholar.org/4558/accdeeb60f1666a1ec56de4bfc637a1b1941.pdf

Interesting read. Describes Guede to a T, 8 years before he sliced open Kercher's neck and sexually assaulted her then left her to choke on her own blood and bleed out while he dug through her purse for goodies.
 
Napapijri is the Norwegian Laplander (Saami) for 'Arctic Circle', derived from the Finnish for the Artic Circle, napapiiri hence the term is correctly interchangeable by me.

I speak from a superior vantage to you.


No. You are simply wrong. A brand name is a brand name. End of. I don't give a toss that it might have an alternative spelling in a whole other context entirely unrelated to a brand of apparel. It's NOT "interchangeable by you". The apparel company is called Napapijri. It is not called Napapiiri. Or Napapirje (another of your misspellings - do you remember misspelling it in that way too?).

Where do you actually get off with this sort of crap? Something isn't so simply because you announce it is so. And, in this instance (one of literally tens of dozens over the pages of these threads emanating from you), you don't get to decide how the brand name of an apparel company "could" be spelled, just because you happen to know a crappy Nordic word which might have informed the brand name originally.

The apparel company's name is spelled N A P A P I J R I, Vixen. No other collection of letters. You're unbelievable, so very often. "Superior vantage to me" HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA Jesus.
 
Last edited:
Only insofar there is 'insufficient evidence', notwithstanding the Supreme Court setting out the facts that:

  • Amanda Knox was definitely present at the murder and washed Meredith Kercher's blood from her hands (blood is only wet for 30" - 60" , at the outside, so she was there whilst the blood was viscuous.
  • That Raffaele Sollecito was 'almost certainly' also there.
  • That it was not credible the murder was by a 'random burglar' (i.e., Rudy Guede) as the killing had the hallmarks of a serial killer (cold sadism).
  • Amanda and Raff lied and lied and lied again. They remain 'strongly suspicious'.
  • In telling police Patrick Lumumba was the rapist .murderer - and as witnessed by Amanda Knox herself - she was covering up for Rudy Guede.
  • The burglary WAS staged. (Ask yourself, who would have a motive to fake a burglary?)
  • There were multiple attackers.
  • The imputed 'other attackers' are not being sought.


This is certainly not 'an exoneration'. If anything, by Marasca sitting on the fence, things remain pretty damning of Knox and Raff.

They can't claim compensation because of their behaviour and they cannot claim libel as it is set in law that the facts are as above. A defence to libel is, that it is true. Can't get truer than a court certification.
You are correct. Technically this was not an exoneration. Someone who is and according to law always was innocent cannot be exonerated. What happened was that an innocent person was imprisoned for three tears.

Italian law is clear, until confirmation of conviction by court of cassation, a person is innocent. As the conviction was not confirmed Sollecito and Knox were and always had been innocent.

I note you do not disagree with legal fact. What you do is throw mud. What you quote is evidence that the court of cassation determined did not meet the standard to prove guilt beyond reasonable doubt as required by Italian law. Since they were not guilty they are innocent. That is a legal fact. If they are not guilty then they are innocent.
 
There is a legal difference between someone who has never been tried, and someone who has been tried and yet another between someone found 'not guilty' (Italian paragraph 1) and 'not guilty due to insufficient evidence' (paragraph 2).


Hahahahahaha oh this is rich! And indicative of a gross ignorance of judisprudence and the law.

There is NO legal difference between a) someone who was never charged with a crime, and b) someone who was charged with a crime and acquitted (and acquitted in any manner).

Even in Italy.

I really do suggest you read some reliable information on 1) general jurisprudence in modern democracies, and 2) Italian legislation as it pertains to charging and acquittal. You may gain some enlightenment and education. Though judging from the ongoing combination of ignorance, misdirection, latent subjective bias, low intellect and echo-chamber-mantra-repeating of all your "arguments" to date, I suspect the chances of that are pretty low indeed.
 
I am sceptical. Who puts an unattended suitcase on a train (arriving at midnight) and Raff is needed to drive to the station. (Which, like his ordination to be Pope and the trip to Gubbio, never happened.)


Ahhh, a GENUINE logical fallacy: argument from incredulity.

So I'm guessing Popovic's claims were exposed as fabricated in the course of the trial process, then? What's that? No they weren't? Oh, right. It just happens to be that Popovic allowed herself to be drawn into a (criminal) conspiracy, which - if uncovered and exposed - could have resulted in her own conviction on perjury-related charges and a significant prison sentence. Yes, that sounds about right. To an illogical, low-intellect nutter.
 
Wrong. It could have given them a Paragraph 1 acquittal, but it did not. It gave them a 'not proven' one instead. ('The politicians loophole' [cf Berlusconi and the other chap].)


NO.

The Marasca panel, for the last time, could not have issued 530.1 acquittals. Do you know why not, Vixen? (Again that's entirely rhetorical: you obviously don't know the reason).

Here's the reason. Read carefully and try to comprehend this time. OK? Ready? So:

The Marasca panel could, in practice, only have acquitted under 530.1 if either a) it had deemed that no crime had even taken place (and clearly a crime DID indeed take place here - Kercher was murdered by SOMEONE), or b) Knox or Sollecito could have PROVEN their factual innocence (and they could not - but crucially (even though I know you either fail or refuse to understand this point) that is in no way an indicator of guilt, and indeed every single person within, say, 30 miles of Perugia that evening who could not PROVE they could not possibly have been at the cottage at around the time of the murder would be in exactly the same boat).

So neither of the available reasons to acquit under 530.1 was ever even available to the Marasca panel. You still, however, manifestly and stubbornly refuse to (or are intellectually unable to) understand that a 530.2 acquittal is NOT a "not proven" verdict, and similarly you still refuse (or are intellectually unable to) understand the true difference between 530.1 and 530.2, and the relative implications of each.
 
Wrong. It was not a 'selfie'. Raff took a mate to the questura with him; if you followed the news reports, you'd know this. It was his chum who took the pics.


Yes. I see now that it was a third party who took the photos.

However:

1) I only ever stated that it "might" have been the case that Sollecito took the photos himself using a selfie stick. I didn't state it as fact (you might want to take note of the difference for your own "arguments".....);

2) You interestingly avoided the entire rest of my post - 7/8 of which was unrelated to that one narrow aspect of the "selfie stick supposition", and which instead dealt with other hugely significant reasons why your position was illogical and untenable. As I said...... INTERESTING.........
 
Here in the British Army, we have the officers' mess.


1) "Here in the British Army"?

2) UK military messes are not at all analogous to US military mess halls. A US military mess hall is purely a place where meals are prepared and served. Whereas a UK military mess is a far more broad-ranging construct, and usually refers to a building (or complex of buildings) where military personnel have bedrooms, conference rooms, leisure facilities, bars and eating facilities.
 
You are correct. Technically this was not an exoneration. Someone who is and according to law always was innocent cannot be exonerated. What happened was that an innocent person was imprisoned for three tears.

Italian law is clear, until confirmation of conviction by court of cassation, a person is innocent. As the conviction was not confirmed Sollecito and Knox were and always had been innocent.

I note you do not disagree with legal fact. What you do is throw mud. What you quote is evidence that the court of cassation determined did not meet the standard to prove guilt beyond reasonable doubt as required by Italian law. Since they were not guilty they are innocent. That is a legal fact. If they are not guilty then they are innocent.

Logical fallacy. A 'not proven' verdict means neither guilty nor innocent.

An example of why a court 'sitting on the fence' is not doing its job.
 
I suspect it's contrived to help out Raff.

We have not seen or heard anything more of her since.

Vixen makes the allegation Popovich had lied. If there was any evidence Popovich has lied why was this never used by the prosecution? Vixen conveniently forgets the several witnesses who testified against Amanda and Raffaele where the was conclusive proof they had lied :-

Hekuran Kokomani claimed he saw Amanda, Raffaele and Rudy together on the night of the murder. Kokomani was proved to have lied because he said Amanda had gaps in her teeth and an Italian uncle.

Fabio Gioffredi said he saw Amanda, Raffaele, Meredith and Rudy on the October 30th 2007 between 4.30 and 5.30 pm. Raffaele's computer shows itense activity from 5.30 pm to 6.30 pm which proved Fabio had lied.

Quintavelle the shop owner initially said he did not see Amanda in his shop the morning after the murder and then changed his story a year later to say he had seen Amanda in his shop. There is no doubt Quintavelle lied. He either saw Amanda in his shop and lied about it in his interview to the police or lied about seeing Amanda in his shop a year later.

Curalto like Quintavelle said nothing about seeing Amanda and Raffaele in the square and changed his story months later. Like Quintavelle Curalto either saw Amanda and Raffaele in the square and lied when questioned by the police or later lied he saw Amanda and Raffaele months later.

As can be seen from the link below the British girls were caught lying in court when their court testimony differed from their original testimonies.
http://www.amandaknoxcase.com/the-british-girls/

Vixen has defended witnesses where there was conclusive evidence they had lied. Vixen has no problem with witnesses lying as long as their testimony works against Amanda and Raffaele and only has an issue with witnesses lying if their testimony is favourable to Amanda and Raffaele but is too dishonest to admit this. Yet another example of disgusting hypocrisy by PGP.
 
Logical fallacy. A 'not proven' verdict means neither guilty nor innocent.

An example of why a court 'sitting on the fence' is not doing its job.


Will you never stop?

1) Knox and Sollecito were NOT found "not proven". And that is NOT what 530.2 means or implies.

2) There are only an extremely narrow - and extremely rare - number of reasons when a defendant can actually be found "innocent" (i.e. factually innocent) in a trial process. This has been explained to you numerous times. Virtually all acquitted defendants in criminal trial processes (in E&W and the US as well as in Italy) are acquitted for reasons that would map onto 530.2. And we call those people found "not guilty" at trial. Not "innocent". Do you still actually think, for example, that a person acquitted in an E&W trial is ever found "innocent" by the court? Rather, that person is found "not guilty". There are very important ethical and jurisprudence reasons why this should be so, but I won't bother to explain them here because I am near-certain that you will either be incapable of, or unwilling to, understand them.

3) The SC panel in the Knox/Sollecito trial process was not "sitting on the fence". And a 530.2 acquittal in Italy is NOT "sitting on the fence". Once again, I strongly suggest that you at least try to properly acquaint yourself with proper intellectually-sound research into these matters.

4) PLEASE stop mis-employing the term "logical fallacy". It's neither big nor clever when you use the term to describe something which is NOT, in fact, a logical fallacy (amusingly, it's the polar opposite of big or clever....).
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom