The Trials of Amanda Knox and Raffaele Sollecito: Part 28

Status
Not open for further replies.
Indeed it is! And apart from the major networks, there's some pretty good TV on these days with Netflix :p, AMC, etc. I come here strictly for the daily, sometimes hourly, laughs that Vix's inanities provide. Not accepting Popovic's testimony? Delusional....and that's being kind.

It's a well known fact that what's available, re: Popovic's testimony, is riddled with typing errors.

Praise Jesus we have Vixen to properly interpret for us.
 
Let me get this straight (after wading through all the feces): you're now claiming that Popovic never asked Raffaele to take her to the station to pick up a suitcase? That it was all a lie? That Popovic colluded with Vanessa S. to provide an alibi? You get more and more ludicrous as time goes on. It's why I keep coming back for more of your comedy. It's better than anything on TV.

I was giving her the benefit of the doubt and assuming this was just a weak attempt at sarcasm/humor. If she was being serious with this post then it would suggest she's reached a level of desperation never before seen among the PGP rank and file.
 
Let me get this straight (after wading through all the feces): you're now claiming that Popovic never asked Raffaele to take her to the station to pick up a suitcase? That it was all a lie? That Popovic colluded with Vanessa S. to provide an alibi? You get more and more ludicrous as time goes on. It's why I keep coming back for more of your comedy. It's better than anything on TV.

It's actually progress of a sort, as it shows Vixen acknowledges Popovic provides logistical problems to a PGP theory, problems most just ignore.
 
Vixen, please clarify your position on Popovic. Do you believe that her testimony was false and that there was never an actual plan for RS to take her to the station to pick up a suitcase sent by her mother?
 
There is an interesting case from Missouri; David Robinson. He was convicted of murder. There were concerns about his conviction and after many years a judge was appointed to review the case. The judge ruled he was factually innocent in February. The problem was Missouri had no mechanism to void the conviction of someone who was factually innocent who has gone through the full appeal process. The judge was very clear that keeping someone in jail who is innocent because of the lack of a process to release an innocent person was both immoral and should be illegal. Eventually in May he is released, but on a 'technicality'. He has not been technically exonerated, in theory the prosecution could bring a case to retry him. The original trial was voided so it would not be double jeopardy. This may mean (and people with familiarity with Missouri law may know better) that he will not be eligible for compensation.

So the judicial fact is that he is not exonerated despite a judge ruling that he is factually innocent. However outside the narrow confines of the law (and no doubt Vixen) he is exonerated.

http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/av/world-us-canada-44133282/free-at-last

Unfortunately for you, that scenario does not apply to Raff and Knox.
 
No, the fallacy is Raffaele had a knife, therefore he's a killer. Post Hoc Ergo Propter Hoc.

That Raffaele owned a knife is not evidence of anything other than he owned a knife.

Wrong again and off context. The context was, a trait for sociopathy is 'an exaggerated sense of entitlement'. We see this in both Knox and Raff.

Raff swaggering into the Questura with a knife on his person exemplifies his arrogance.

Nothing at all to do with your false homily.
 
Vixen, please clarify your position on Popovic. Do you believe that her testimony was false and that there was never an actual plan for RS to take her to the station to pick up a suitcase sent by her mother?

I suspect it's contrived to help out Raff.

We have not seen or heard anything more of her since.
 
No - acbytesla's argument was not at all an example of argumentum ad populum (surprised you missed out on the chance to use the Latin in your own post, incidentally....). What actually happened was this: you were trying to argue that Sollecito owning or carrying round a pocket knife was somehow deviant/unusual behaviour (which, of course, in your own mind, fed in turn into supporting your belief that he participated in Kercher's murder). By way of attacking your argument, acbytesla was pointing out just how many American men own a pocket knife (with its obvious implication that this therefore cannot be viewed as unusual deviant behaviour).


It is not illegal to be in the possession of an offensive weapon in America, so a false equivalence.
 
Wrong again and off context. The context was, a trait for sociopathy is 'an exaggerated sense of entitlement'. We see this in both Knox and Raff.

Raff swaggering into the Questura with a knife on his person exemplifies his arrogance.

Nothing at all to do with your false homily.

Another trait for sociopathy is stabbing a girl in cold blood, feeling no remorse about it, then going on TV smiling about your made up date with her.
 
Unfortunately for you, that scenario does not apply to Raff and Knox.
You are quite right under Italian law Sollecito and Knox are innocent of murder. Italian law is clear; until guilt is confirmed by the court of cassation a person is innocent. Since the guilt of Sollecito and Knox for murder was not confirmed they are (and always were) innocent. That is a simple fact of Italian law.
 
By the way, for the record (and for any ongoing discussion on this issue), the apparel brand mentioned by Guede is spelled

Napapijri

Several posters have spelled it incorrectly (including, inevitably, Vixen....)

As you were :D

Napapijri is the Norwegian Laplander (Saami) for 'Arctic Circle', derived from the Finnish for the Artic Circle, napapiiri hence the term is correctly interchangeable by me.

I speak from a superior vantage to you.
 
Many people, especially you, Bill, use the term 'exonerated' to mean something vernacular, along the lines of, 'released from prison'.

This is not the legal definition.

I would say they're using it more in the sense of "found not guilty with prejudice" which is a pretty strong finding, though perhaps not as strong as proving an invisible tea cup doesn't orbit the earth.
 
I read your comment properly and understood your implication completely. You were implying that most Italians have black hair which made Guede's claim of the man having brown hair important. Why else would you have written "brown hair (as opposed to Italian black)"?
Yes, plenty of Italians have black hair and some even blond hair...but I never said otherwise. So why you inferred otherwise indicates it is you who needs to read comments properly.

So Raffaele opened his laptop at least once with his left hand. So have I. And I'm right-handed. I've also been known to hold many things in my left hand, scratch an itch with my left hand, pet my dog with my left hand, etc. But I never, ever write with my left hand. And Raffaele writes with his right hand. For you to claim that "He will have been taught to write with his right," is based on absolutely zero evidence. It's just another baseless claim pulled out of your...well...we all know where.

Please learn the rules of debating: making "facts" up is not permitted.

Wrong again. Please read more carefully. You claimed that there was nothing remarkable about Rudy saying the supposed intruder he chanced upon 'had brown hair'. I pointed out that this was not a given. My Italian friend Luigi from Sicily has a head of curly black hair (and a lot of female interest). Another London Italian friend, Guiseppe, has fair hair, and another, Bernie, has long dark hair down his back.

So getting the 'brown hair' right (let's say odds of 1/3), plus a native-speaking Italian in a city that is choccabloc with foreigners (lets say odds of 50:50) plus 'he held a blade in his left hand (1/5 to reflect % 'sinister' population), plus Napapirje-style clothing (1/10) and a beanie (1/3), plus 'shorter than Rudy' (50:50) gives us a probability of :

(0.33333 x 0.5 x 0.2 x 0.10 x 0.33 x 0.5) = 0.000005499

Or, five in ten thousand.

So, a good description of Raff.
 
Well......

1) The two statements "most Italians have brown hair" and "plenty (of Italians) have black hair and few blonde (sic)" aren't even mutually incompatible in any case. But....

2) ....available evidence seems to suggest that most Italians do indeed have brown hair. For example, plenty of Italians have commented here to state that brown hair is the most common colour in Italy, and that in fact black hair colour is rare:

https://answers.yahoo.com/question/index?qid=20101102122528AAWnoUS&guccounter=1

This is, in fact, wholly unsurprising - especially in the northern part of Italy down to around Rome (including, of course, Perugia itself). That's because this more northerly element of Italian population is predominantly ethnically far closer to central and western European genomes than the coastal north-Mediterranean genome. Ironically in the context of this discussion, Sollecito (being from Bari in southern Mediterranean Italy) comes from the part of Italy that might be expected to have a higher proportion of black-haired inhabitants. Yet he himself has brown hair.







Well......

1) Sollecito was holding his knife in his left hand for the purpose of that photograph. He was holding the knife in the tips of his fingers to display it to the camera, and was not holding it as one would hold a knife to use it. In addition, the position and orientation of the camera in that photo suggests that Sollecito himself may have taken the photo using his mobile phone attached to a selfie stick (the photo is taken from waist height pretty close to Sollecito: a very unusual position for another person to have taken the photo from, but an entirely feasible and logical position for Sollecito to have taken a selfie from, holding a selfie stick at waist level). And if that's the case, that's actually extremely strong evidence for Sollecito being dominant RIGHT-HANDED - the fine control and dexterity of the dominant hand would be much more important for the holding and operation of the phone camera than for the fingertip holding of the knife for the photograph.

2) Really????? Sollecito opening his laptop with his left hand is evidence of his left-hand dominance?????!!!!! Even by your standards, this is an astonishingly ridiculous "argument". In fact, I (for example) am strongly right-hand dominant and yet I open my laptop with my left hand - using the fingers of my dominant right hand to press and hold the catch to release the lid/screen. I suggest that most right-hand-dominant people do exactly the same thing themselves. Regardless, what I certainly know is that how one opens one's laptop is in no way a reliable indicator of hand dominance (though, as I said, I suggest that it tends to indicate a dominance entirely opposite to that of your claim....)

3) You obviously don't know many left-hand-dominant people, do you? Because it's incredibly difficult for a left-hand-dominant person to write with their right hand. The degree of hand-eye co-oordination and fine motor control required for neat, legible handwriting virtually requires that one writes with one's dominant hand. And because of that, schools across the modern industrialised world (including, yes, Italy) many decades ago stopped trying to force left-hand-dominant children to learn to write with their right hands. Every single left-hand-dominant person I know (and I think I know around 12) writes with his/her left hand. I am confident that if Sollecito were left-hand-dominant, he'd write with his left hand also. And I'm certain that if Sollecito were left-hand-dominant but had been forced to learn to write right-handed, he'd have only been able to write in a very slow, gauche, untidy style.






Are you aware of a little thing named "irony", Vixen.......?

Wrong. It was not a 'selfie'. Raff took a mate to the questura with him; if you followed the news reports, you'd know this. It was his chum who took the pics.
 
And do you know why that is, Vixen? (That's a rhetorical question, obviously - because you clearly don't know why that is, probably on account of an ongoing ignorance of judicial remits, which I shall now attempt to explain to you once again)

So, here goes. Please try to listen carefully this time.

It was simply not the remit of the Marasca SC panel, in its acquittals of Knox and Sollecito, to declare them "innocent" or to state that they were "exonerated". The role and remit of the SC panel was explicit and specific: to determine whether Knox and/or Sollecito should lawfully be convicted or acquitted of the crimes with which each of them were charged, based on the totality of the evidence presented at trial and the (correct) application of Italian law (and to provide written reasoning for how it arrived at its judgements). Nothing more or less than that. So the ONLY thing that an entity such as the Marasca SC panel could/would come out with in respect of a case such as this (and with the same prior judicial rulings) would be: "uphold and confirm the conviction(s)", "annul the conviction(s) and remand the case to a lower court for retrial", or "annul the conviction(s) and acquit". That's all.

However..... when it comes to commentary and analysis about the SC panel's verdict and reasoning - THAT'S when terms such as "(presumed) innocent" and "exonerated" can (correctly, in this situation and context) be employed*. The definitive nature of the Marasca panel's annulments and acquittals, coupled with the severe criticism of the investigative process towards Knox/Sollecito and the unlawful "reasoning" of the convicting courts, can only lead any disinterested, intelligent commentator/analyst to conclude that the Marasca panel's verdicts were total exonerations** for Knox and Sollecito.


* Just as it is, for example, correct for commentary/analysis of the Marasca SC verdict to conclude that the Marasca panel excoriated the work of police, prosecutors and the convicting courts in this trial process - even though (obviously) the Marasca MR neither used the word "excoriate" nor even uses directly intemperate tones: however, the context and a proper understanding of what the Marasca MR actually DID write in this respect leads to the clear and correct conclusion that the Marasca panel was indeed severely critical of police, prosecutors and convicting courts.

** Incidentally, ANY time a prior guilty verdict is annulled and the person is acquitted on appeal, the person is by definition exonerated - there's either sufficient (credible/reliable) evidence, assessed lawfully, to prove guilt BARD, or the defendant is entitled to the full presumption of innocence and stands as judicially innocent as literally anyone else in the World at that point.

Wrong. It could have given them a Paragraph 1 acquittal, but it did not. It gave them a 'not proven' one instead. ('The politicians loophole' [cf Berlusconi and the other chap].)
 
You are quite right under Italian law Sollecito and Knox are innocent of murder. Italian law is clear; until guilt is confirmed by the court of cassation a person is innocent. Since the guilt of Sollecito and Knox for murder was not confirmed they are (and always were) innocent. That is a simple fact of Italian law.

Good piece of sophistry. Very advanced.
 
Suppose the law says a man's legally adopted son is his son. As far as the law is concerned the son is the issue of the man and he is entitled to inherit (at least in Europe). The history books will say whatever the law decrees. Assuming it never comes to light that the son was actually adopted, it will still remain a historical fact that the boy was not the man's biological son.

A historical fact still must be true or it is not a fact, but a historical error.

An adopted child becomes a de facto legitimate child in law. There are many adopted people who never found out they were adopted.

What you are thinking about is in the days when a child borm out of wedlock was described in church records as a 'base child' or even 'bastard'.

Yes, in those cases, historians will ascribe the correct status, which in those days was Church (Cannon) Law.

In modern times, if a person decides to keep their adoption status a secret, then who is to know? They have the same rights as a birth child.

(Step children do not.)
 
Vixen is fond of showing the one photo of Raff holding the knife with his left hand. However, she does not show the photo (taken at the same time) of him holding the knife with both hands.
http://www.umbria24.it/cronaca/quat...ez-nessun-risarcimento-per-raffaele-sollecito

Here's a photo of RS talking on the phone he's holding in his right hand. According to Vixen's reasoning, this is definitive proof he's right-handed. But I'm sure he was taught to hold his phone in his right hand against his natural left-handed dominance. I'm sure his teachers and parents must have slapped him silly every time he tried to use his left hand.

http://www.umbria24.it/cronaca/quat...ez-nessun-risarcimento-per-raffaele-sollecito


Er, no. A knife is held by its handle. The handle is in Raff's left hand, even if he is touching the blade with the other.

He is spelling it out to you in plain sight.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom