The Trials of Amanda Knox and Raffaele Sollecito: Part 26

Status
Not open for further replies.
The same book where he said DNA doesn't transfer after 24 hours? Oh, wait...

Speaking of which, here is what Gill has to say about DNA transfer in an interview:


(Transcript of Professor Peter Gill’s interview on Italian documentary, Delitti & Misteri, January 29, 2015. The documentary was produced by Francesco Mura and aired on Retecapri.)

Note that the secondary transfer of Scott's DNA occurred after two weeks...just a tad bit longer than 24 hours.

A couple of weeks back Chris posted an article discussing a case of secondary transfer that occurred more than two years after the DNA was originally deposited. Now THAT'S a tab bit longer than 24 hours. But what's the point of presenting facts when dealing with someone who willfully disregards facts that contradict the BS they're pedaling?
 
A couple of weeks back Chris posted an article discussing a case of secondary transfer that occurred more than two years after the DNA was originally deposited. Now THAT'S a tab bit longer than 24 hours. But what's the point of presenting facts when dealing with someone who willfully disregards facts that contradict the BS they're pedaling?

We have enough to publish a book of PGP falsehoods:

"Reinventing the Facts" by the TJMK Main Contributors and TMofMK
 
We have enough to publish a book of PGP falsehoods:

"Reinventing the Facts" by the TJMK Main Contributors and TMofMK

In fairness to the remaining PGP, little of what they advance which is false started out that way. What they advance is the almosr-decade old stuff that the original prosecution advanced, stuff claimed as true with no actual evidence cited to substantiate it.

Sadly for the remaining PGP in 2017 - more than 2 years **after** the exonerations - it seems like all those original factoids have, in fact, been "reinterpreted".

Why? Because that's exactly what has happened, indeed they have been reinterpreted; except the way I'd put it is that those original factoids have been exposed for what they are and always have been.

Evidenceless assertions of a prosecutor which magically become unassailable "judicial truths" of a court. As we have seen as multiple trials tried to navigate this, even acquitting courts felt themselves bound by judicial truths, even while often pointing out the original lack of evidence of the now binding assertion.

So - in the hands of those who owned the field until Oct 2011, they are quite correct to claim that the facts have been reinvented.......

..... except what is being "reinvented" is the judicial outcome when those facts are put in proper perspective. The final Italian Supreme Court panel put it in the persective of, as they wrote, that even if all that original stuff had been true, it still does not overcome one unassailable reality.

In this case, the "facts" need to always be set next to the one unassailable fact of no forensic presence of the pair in the murder room. None.

That's the one fact which a believer in guilt cannot circumvent. So in a sense, I feel their pain for no longer owning the field.
 
Last edited:
The same book where he said DNA doesn't transfer after 24 hours? Oh, wait...

Speaking of which, here is what Gill has to say about DNA transfer in an interview:


(Transcript of Professor Peter Gill’s interview on Italian documentary, Delitti & Misteri, January 29, 2015. The documentary was produced by Francesco Mura and aired on Retecapri.)

Note that the secondary transfer of Scott's DNA occurred after two weeks...just a tad bit longer than 24 hours.


But you are claiming tertiary transfer of a strong RFU and full profile DNA.
 
Many months ago (in my opinion) Vixen went on a slut-shaming bout of posts about which she was criticized. If nothing else, all Vixen was doing - two years after the exoneration no less - was reaching back to what original prosecutors had to do.....

..... when there's a lack of evidence, ramp up the emotive stuff.

But to her credit, Vixen backed off the slut-shaming. At the time it was reminiscent of what Peggy Ganong had done (as moderator) on the now defunct PMF website.

Peggy was no stranger to vilifying Knox - but the only time I had ever, ever seen Peggy discipline a guilter for their undue excess against Knox, was when that guilter had called Knox a slut. Peggy was having none of it and did a one-time moderation surrounding the use of that singular word.

With Vixen, though, the post you refer to is her putting her big toe back into the slut-shaming water to see if anyone will point it out again. My opinion only.

As it relates to the "Trials of Amanda Knox and Raffaele Sollecito" (the title of this thread) the undue sexualization of Knox and to a far lesser extent Sollecito was part of the miscarriage of justice....

.... and was, as you say Stacyhs, completely irrelevant anyway to the crime itself - where the evidence (remember that!) points in one direction; Rudy Guede. Remember him?



This is reminiscent of how guilters - the ones who are left anyway - try even to blame Knox for what they seriously contend was her manipulation of police at her interrogation(s). Once again the bleeding obvious - the police and prosecutor were required to record/videotape them, so that those of us way up in the bleachers wouldn't need to be arguing about it almost 10 years later!

I suppose that is Knox's fault, too!

Here's a test to the most sincere guilter - take the fire out of your belly that pushes you to blame Knox for everything. Put it aside for five minutes. Don't worry, no one will take it, you can have it back if you wish.

But put it aside and look at the evidence. I know, I know, why would anyone do that!?


I don't 'slut shame'. I couldn't give a toss about the pair's personal details.

Knox herself keeps portraying herself as a rampant nymphomaniac who invented sex. <fx YAWN>
 
I don't 'slut shame'. I couldn't give a toss about the pair's personal details.

Knox herself keeps portraying herself as a rampant nymphomaniac who invented sex. <fx YAWN>

It is evident you do not read what you write.

This post is a classic!
 
negative controls that turn out positive

The Adam Scott case is also of interest in that there had been a contaminated negative control that had been observed in the lab at about that time. IIRC this was not disclosed immediately. Regrettably, this is not the only time in which the finding of DNA in a negative control was not disclosed (Leiterman and Avery come to mind). This is why open discovery is so important.
 
I don't 'slut shame'. I couldn't give a toss about the pair's personal details.

Knox herself keeps portraying herself as a rampant nymphomaniac who invented sex. <fx YAWN>

Consider this:

Knox told the 500+ people at the Westside Bar Association that slut-shaming played a role in her wrongful conviction.

Perhaps a healthy portion of those people later on fired up their iPads and laptops to scour the 'net for what is what with that claim. They run across TJMK as well as some of the more bizarre stuff on .PMF these days.

And here? They run across a poster who first claims that she, herself, does not slut-shame, who then says in the very next breath:

Knox herself keeps portraying herself as a rampant nymphomaniac who invented sex. <fx YAWN>​
I'll let you in on a secret. Most of those people could not care less if some random Seattleite is or isn't a "rampant nymphomaniac". Who on earth cares about that? All of those people have never heard Knox describe herself as a raving-anything, so right off the bat you're trying to shoehorn a concept into their experience of her that does not include what you're claiming.

What they are looking for is if there was, as the first prosecutor had said, a sexual angle to this crime. The crime, Vixen, the crime.

When Knox then claims that there had been no actual evidence to support her original conviction in front of these people, and further suggests that "slut shaming" was substituted for actual evidence......

..... and they then come over here and read you describing her as a "rampant nymphomaniac", it's not so much that that is slut-shaming per se against a person whom you've never met.....

.... here's the thing.....

.... you have not connected that to the crime! Are you saying that the Nencini court's conviction, now annulled, was wrong when it said the motive for murder was rent money and an argument between Meredith and Amanda? There's nothing slutty about an old fashioned argument about money! (Even if the sole source of that story was Rudy Guede, the real murderer!)

I would suspect that those people fresh from hearing Knox claim slut-shaming as a reason for a wrongful conviction, would come over here and say, "I see what she means!"

Either that or posters here are looking for any excuse to use the word "nymphomaniac" in a sentence for their own internal reasons, the reasons of which are no one's business either.

That's the deal, Vixen. It's about the way slut-shaming was used as a substitute for actual evidence! You never get that.
 
Last edited:
But you are claiming tertiary transfer of a strong RFU and full profile DNA.

You continue to fail to understand the burden of proof and who has to prove what. Nobody here is making a claim. The prosecution is the one making the claim. Their claim is in spite of the crime scene, witness reports, camera evidence, and the perps own unassisted confession all demonstrating that the crime was just about certainly a burglary gone bad homicide committed by a known knife carrying criminal - we should invent an alternative scenario where he is merely the pawn accomplice to two students he has no connection to and never communicated with (and indeed spoke a different language than) because just before the police had to cut the student loose for a complete lack of evidence from their initially wrong theory, they miraculously turned up a bra clasp they allegedly didn't collect the first time around and it allegedly had their key suspects DNA on it before being conveniently destroyed before anyone outside the prosecution team could examine it.

It didn't convince anyone but the shedevil obsessors who already think the way AK breathes is incriminating. That's why the case didn't survive past the first stage and Amanda has been freed for going on six years now, and all our posts have been academic.
 
And here? They run across a poster who first claims that she, herself, does not slut-shame, who then says in the very next breath:

Knox herself keeps portraying herself as a rampant nymphomaniac who invented sex. <fx YAWN>​

I have noticed that PGP have trouble integrating information, and therefore are not able to stay consistent in their claims and arguments.

Someone saying they do not slut-shame, and then in the very next sentence claiming Amanda portrays herself as a rampant nymphomaniac may be a good example of this lol.

Is it any wonder why they still cannot figure this case out after 8 years?
 
I have noticed that PGP have trouble integrating information, and therefore are not able to stay consistent in their claims and arguments.

Someone saying they do not slut-shame, and then in the very next sentence claiming Amanda portrays herself as a rampant nymphomaniac may be a good example of this lol.

Is it any wonder why they still cannot figure this case out after 8 years?

I've had it put to me, "It's not slut-shaming if it is true."

The answer to that is - "who on earth cares if it is true!?" I can only repeat, is the slut-shamer then claiming that Mignini was right when he advanced the motive for this crime as a "sex-game gone wrong"? Remember also that when the 2013 Supreme Court overturned the first acquittals, they did it (in part) because the "sex-game gone wrong" motive had not been explored enough at the lower-court.

And then the new, lower Court court, the 2013-2014 Nencini court proceeded to ignore that as a motive, and substituted its own - for some equally inexplicable reason they decided to believe Rudy Guede, who was the sole source of the "rent money" motive.

One develops over time the suspicion that there are some posters to internet threads who enjoy using words like "nymphomaniac" in a sentence, applying it to people they've never met. The suspicion comes from the inability - eventually they give up trying - to connect that lurid claim to the crime.
 
One develops over time the suspicion that there are some posters to internet threads who enjoy using words like "nymphomaniac" in a sentence, applying it to people they've never met. The suspicion comes from the inability - eventually they give up trying - to connect that lurid claim to the crime.

One does have to wonder if their repeated use of terms like "nymphomaniac" stems from some underlying psychology of their own. Let's put it this way -- I have never seen anyone obsess over someone's sexual history unless they have some underlying issue. Speaking in hypotheticals, of course.

Unless they can somehow provide actual evidence of Amanda being a "nymphomaniac" and connect it in some way to the alleged pagan sex game murder (that uh, has been proven to not have occurred. So that one may be tough.) Then it may look like a legitimate topic of discussion and not some filthy personal attack. Not holding my breath on that though.
 
But you are claiming tertiary transfer of a strong RFU and full profile DNA.

Sigh. May I remind you that we can still see what was previously posted? Your claim was this:

Peter Gill says secondary transfer can only take place within 24 hours, so we all await your reply with interest as Raff's DNA must have been on the door frame six weeks.

Note that your claim was about secondary transfer, not tertiary. You failed to provide a quote from Gill saying any such thing. On the other hand, I provided a statement from Gill discussing an actual case where secondary transfer was proved after 2 weeks. We're going to need binoculars soon to see that goalpost you keep moving. Why don't you just admit Gill never said what you claim and that secondary transfer can happen, and has happened, even years later? And if secondary transfer can occur after that long, why not tertiary? Or will you claim again that tertiary transfer doesn't happen?
 
Last edited:
I don't 'slut shame'. I couldn't give a toss about the pair's personal details.

Knox herself keeps portraying herself as a rampant nymphomaniac who invented sex. <fx YAWN>

Classic. Just classic.

Others have already pointed out what is wrong with your post, but may I ask exactly how you think Knox portrayed herself as a "rampant nymphomaniac who invented sex"? I'd ask you for some actual quotes or incidents where Knox does this, but I know better. I'd just like to know how you came up with this idea. The psychology fascinates me.
 
I have noticed that PGP have trouble integrating information, and therefore are not able to stay consistent in their claims and arguments.

Someone saying they do not slut-shame, and then in the very next sentence claiming Amanda portrays herself as a rampant nymphomaniac may be a good example of this lol.

Is it any wonder why they still cannot figure this case out after 8 years?

Kinda like when Vixen claims the M/B decision was political because...

"The Italians didn't want to see their boy serve life whilst the person found guilty of the actual killing roams free in the USA. "

Even though the two courts that preceded M/B did everything they could to convict Raffaele, all while Amanda was home in the USA. Doh!
 
You continue to fail to understand the burden of proof and who has to prove what. Nobody here is making a claim. The prosecution is the one making the claim. Their claim is in spite of the crime scene, witness reports, camera evidence, and the perps own unassisted confession all demonstrating that the crime was just about certainly a burglary gone bad homicide committed by a known knife carrying criminal - we should invent an alternative scenario where he is merely the pawn accomplice to two students he has no connection to and never communicated with (and indeed spoke a different language than) because just before the police had to cut the student loose for a complete lack of evidence from their initially wrong theory, they miraculously turned up a bra clasp they allegedly didn't collect the first time around and it allegedly had their key suspects DNA on it before being conveniently destroyed before anyone outside the prosecution team could examine it.

It didn't convince anyone but the shedevil obsessors who already think the way AK breathes is incriminating. That's why the case didn't survive past the first stage and Amanda has been freed for going on six years now, and all our posts have been academic.

Bagels, if I've not mentioned it before, I really enjoy your way with words!

I've always had trouble trying to envision subsequent visits to the cottage by the police, SP and others, all walking around or over a severed bra clasp left at the scene of a sexual assault murder and none of them thinking it just might be important to collect and test it. :jaw-dropp I really wish some photos or video of Meredith's room were available from after the initial investigation and prior to 18 December. I still think it's entirely possible it was collected, tested and then surreptitiously returned so it could be collected again, this time with a trace of Raffaele's DNA on it. I don't say this because I'm convinced the police actively framed Raffaele per se, but rather because I find it impossible to believe the entire investigative team was so incompetent that no one thought to collect the clasp for 47 days.
 
Kinda like when Vixen claims the M/B decision was political because...

"The Italians didn't want to see their boy serve life whilst the person found guilty of the actual killing roams free in the USA. "

Even though the two courts that preceded M/B did everything they could to convict Raffaele, all while Amanda was home in the USA. Doh!

When one wanders into thinking they know what Italians or Amanda or Raffaele or the courts "think" or "want" rather than sticking to the evidence and facts, they cannot help but "step in it".
 
I still think it's entirely possible it was collected, tested and then surreptitiously returned so it could be collected again, this time with a trace of Raffaele's DNA on it. I don't say this because I'm convinced the police actively framed Raffaele per se, but rather because I find it impossible to believe the entire investigative team was so incompetent that no one thought to collect the clasp for 47 days.

Both the real Frank Sfarzo, as well as the "Frank" character in the Winterbottom film (Edoardo) said that the issue was complete incompetence.

There was also judicial incompetence mixed in. Given that guilters behold the Follain book from 2011 as their bible, it is incredible to read, even in Follain's account, that Monica Napoleoni testified that there had been no access to the murder room without forensic counter measures..... well, all except for the medical team who'd been granted entrance to see the body while wearing none. That had been Nov 2.

Then we find out that this crack group of investigators said that the reason why they'd not forensically examined the outer-door-handle to Meredith's room to see who may have left fingerprints or DNA on or around it, was because they deemed, "that was not part of the crimescene." At some point that stuff rises to judicial incompetence when at least two courts convicted anyway....

Apparently Sfazo knew from the git-go that these investigators were not exactly rocket scientists....
 
Last edited:
Both the real Frank Sfarzo, as well as the "Frank" character in the Winterbottom film (Edoardo) said that the issue was complete incompetence.

There was also judicial incompetence mixed in. Given that guilters behold the Follain book from 2011 as their bible, it is incredible to read, even in Follain's account, that Monica Napoleoni testified that there had been no access to the murder room without forensic counter measures..... well, all except for the medical team who'd been granted entrance to see the body while wearing none. That had been Nov 2.

Then we find out that this crack group of investigators said that the reason why they'd not forensically examined the outer-door-handle to Meredith's room to see who may have left fingerprints or DNA on or around it, was because they deemed, "that was not part of the crimescene." At some point that stuff rises to judicial incompetence when at least two courts convicted anyway....

Apparently Sfazo knew from the git-go that these investigators were not exactly rocket scientists....

As I generally don't buy into conspiracies, and since I think if they did actively frame (didn't Grinder have an issue with this discussion??..) they would have planted more material in more places, then yeah, I can believe it was incompetence. But it truly is difficult to imagine all those buffoons milling about and not one suggests they collect the clasp. Yeah, we have the bra so who needs the clasp. Yeah, the crime took place inside the room so who needs forensics from the backside of the door or door frame. Oops, the clasp has rusted and can't be tested. Oops, fried three hard drives. I mean DAMN, these people made the Keystone Kops look downright competent!
 
As I generally don't buy into conspiracies, and since I think if they did actively frame (didn't Grinder have an issue with this discussion??..) they would have planted more material in more places, then yeah, I can believe it was incompetence. But it truly is difficult to imagine all those buffoons milling about and not one suggests they collect the clasp. Yeah, we have the bra so who needs the clasp. Yeah, the crime took place inside the room so who needs forensics from the backside of the door or door frame. Oops, the clasp has rusted and can't be tested. Oops, fried three hard drives. I mean DAMN, these people made the Keystone Kops look downright competent!


One person’s competence is another person’s connivance . . . .
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom