The Trials of Amanda Knox and Raffaele Sollecito: Part 26

Status
Not open for further replies.
She should grow up. Since when was a 20-year old a 'kid'? As for, 'the Black guys call me their "little baby girl"' - snorts of scepticism - and prancing about in a little red riding hood outfit, who is she kidding?

Mind you, they do say psychopaths are arrested at a young emotional age, usually because of a traumatic incident. For example, Mary Bell, child killer aged 8, was used by her prostitute mum as a toddler prostitute.

I see you didn't bother to read the article as Knox did not refer to herself as a "kid" in it. She said "'I went into prison as not yet a woman and I came out an adult woman and that period defined me." But, yes, she has referred to herself as a "girl" or "kid" when she went to Perugia in 2007. And she was. Legally and physically she was an adult, but for you to nitpick about her being a "kid" at barely 20 is just yet another example of a need to disparage her at every opportunity. I look back at myself at 20 and know I was emotionally still a "kid" who thought she was a mature adult. My life, like Amanda's, had consisted of going to school, odd jobs, and a life sheltered by a loving family. Neither of us was a mature woman.

Please cite your source for your quote "'the Black guys call me their "little baby girl". Amanda is not responsible for what other people call her.

Regarding her "Red Riding Hood" pictures, why do you have such a problem with a few fantasy pictures with her boyfriend while vacationing in Germany? Is everyone who takes these kinds of fun photos to be disparaged or only Knox?

Please stop diagnosing Knox as a "psychopath" as she has not been diagnosed as such nor does she meet the criteria. Oh, wait... I forgot she was diagnosed as a psychopath by a recent college grad who falsely paraded herself as a psychologist on TJMK. Quennell and others on TJMK embraced and lauded "Miss Represented". They ended up with egg on their faces when she was exposed as a complete and utter liar.
 
She should grow up. Since when was a 20-year old a 'kid'? As for, 'the Black guys call me their "little baby girl"' - snorts of scepticism - and prancing about in a little red riding hood outfit, who is she kidding?

Mind you, they do say psychopaths are arrested at a young emotional age, usually because of a traumatic incident. For example, Mary Bell, child killer aged 8, was used by her prostitute mum as a toddler prostitute.
She explained in the article where she grew up, with drug dealers and thieves. At least she escaped. I agree with you on one matter, it was political interference from US state department that got the right result. Of course for the wrong reasons, but that seems to be the Italian scenic route.
 
Nice collection of falsehoods. I wasn't sure at first if this litany of falsehoods was Vixen's or Trump's. So much in common.You can add to the list her claim that Dr. Peter Gill said that DNA doesn't transfer after 24 hours and that there was no grill under Filomena's window at the time of the murder. There are more but there is, by necessity, a limit on how many can be posted due to space limitations.

Just to clarify the highlighted part: blood was found on Raff's underwear, but it was Knox's menstrual blood. Having no underwear due to her inability to access the cottage after the discovery of the murder, Amanda had to borrow Raff's underwear. This is why she bought the "sexy g-string lingerie" at Bubbles. Of course, it wasn't really sexy or a G-string (they were cotton with a cartoon cow on them), but why let facts get in the way of a good and lucrative story?

One of the most ridiculous claims made by the PGP is the notion there was a mountain of evidence and a solid case against Amanda and Raffaele when the conduct of the police/prosecution and the fact PGP have to resort to lying to argue their case indicates the complete opposite. The tactics the police/prosecution had to resort to are a textbook example of the tactics police/prosecutors would use when they have a weak case and a lack of evidence and the facts don’t support the prosecution’s case. For instance, there is a golden rule the prosecution should never have to resort to lying when they have a slam dunk case. As can be seen from the link I attached in a previous post, the prosecution told numerous lies. Vixen constantly bangs on about Amanda and Raffaele telling umpteen lies whilst slavishly defending corrupt prosecutors who told umpteen lies. One of numerous examples where PGP posters have defended liars whilst viciously attacking Amanda and Raffaele for lying.

I have attached the appeal documents for Amanda and Raffaele for the Hellman court and the Supreme Court ruling. The appeal documents for Amanda and Raffaele made very effective arguments which punched massive holes in the prosecution’s case. The Supreme Court motivation report ripped the prosecution’s case to shreds. How is this explained if there was a slam dunk case against Amanda and Raffaele?

http://www.injusticeinperugia.org/Appeal.html

http://www.injusticeinperugia.org/appeal4.html

http://www.amandaknoxcase.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/09/Marasca-Bruno-Motivations-Report.pdf

Vixen likes to argue that there must be overwhelming evidence and a solid case if courts found Amanda and Raffaele guilty. This indicates PGP posters can’t think for themselves and automatically regard something as valid because a court says so. Courts can come to the wrong decision. In a country like Italy courts may find defendants guilty because an innocent verdict would undermine the reputation of the justice system. Judges may take the side of the prosecution.
 
Last edited:
No, he was not found 'incontravertibly innocent', the verdict was found to be unsafe after his doctor came forward to vouch for his sperm count.


For all we know, his doctor might have done a 'Peter Gill'; ie., use his position and influence to get his client off the hook.

I am not saying he did this, but simply pointing out that it is not 'proof of innocence', just an expert opinion claiming that someone with Kiszko's condition was unlikely to produce much live sperm. You note, he didn't say 'none at all'. There have been cases of men deemed infertile, with weak or few spermotozoa successfully becoming fathers normally.

An undercover reporter on tv documentary 'Panorama', a respected BBC feature, demonstrated that by approaching various 'expert witnesses' who were listed on a register, under the guise of needing an expert to get him out of an accident charge, and with bogus details, deliberately designed to enable the 'expert' to see through the phoney claim, he was able to persuade almost all of them to agree to give expert evidence on his behalf to get him off the hook in court, subject to greasing their palms with money (or rather, 'fees').

Just sayin'.

If this is true of defense experts, it must also be true of prosecution experts. Rinaldi and Boemia were paid experts. Were they also shills paid to give evidence to support the prosecution? How about Norelli, the only expert who said there had to be multiple killers? Or Torricelli? All paid prosecution experts.

Who weren't paid experts for either the defense or prosecution? Conti and Vecchiotti. They were independent.

When you have to resort to accusing or implying that any expert who doesn't support your confirmation bias is somehow bought off or a shill, it only undermines your position. To suggest a person's private physician would lie under oath about his patient's infertility is just sheer desperation.

Just sayin'.
 
Last edited:
She explained in the article where she grew up, with drug dealers and thieves. At least she escaped. I agree with you on one matter, it was political interference from US state department that got the right result. Of course for the wrong reasons, but that seems to be the Italian scenic route.

Can you please cite the source for this? Give a link?

There is no evidence whatsoever that the US State Dept. interfered in this case at all.
 
Last edited:
Can you please cite the source for this? Give a link?
I mean in Capanne prison, making another assumption that most women are in for drugs and property offences. I will try to be less confusing.
 
If this is true of defense experts, it must also be true of prosecution experts. Rinaldi and Boemia were paid experts. Were they also shills paid to give evidence to support the prosecution? How about Norelli, the only expert who said there had to be multiple killers? Or Torricelli? All paid prosecution experts.

Who weren't paid experts for either the defense or prosecution? Conti and Vecchiotti. They were independent.

When you have to resort to accusing or implying that any expert who doesn't support your confirmation bias is somehow bought off or a shill, it only undermines your position. To suggest a person's private physician would lie under oath about his patient's infertility is just sheer desperation.

Just sayin'.

Also if you look at the forensic pathologists the only one who said that there had to be more than one assailant was the pathologist acting for the party with a financial interest in the conviction of Knox and Sollecito. Neither the defence nor the prosecution experts said that the assault could not have been the result of a single assailant. This seems to be an example of a paid shill.

ECHR case law requires that where there is doubt the court must follow an assumption of innocence. If Marasca understood the significance of ECHR case law he had no option than to state 'the physical findings from the post mortem were compatible with a single assailant (but could not exclude more than one)'. The evidence from the post mortem cannot be used to support the case against Sollecito or Knox.

So proper application of the law by Marasca would have excluded the DNA findings from the bathroom and the post mortem findings as evidence of guilt. 'All the evidence' seems to be rapidly disappearing into court rulings that are contrary to ECHR case law and thus invalid.
 
Also if you look at the forensic pathologists the only one who said that there had to be more than one assailant was the pathologist acting for the party with a financial interest in the conviction of Knox and Sollecito. Neither the defence nor the prosecution experts said that the assault could not have been the result of a single assailant. This seems to be an example of a paid shill.

ECHR case law requires that where there is doubt the court must follow an assumption of innocence. If Marasca understood the significance of ECHR case law he had no option than to state 'the physical findings from the post mortem were compatible with a single assailant (but could not exclude more than one)'. The evidence from the post mortem cannot be used to support the case against Sollecito or Knox.

So proper application of the law by Marasca would have excluded the DNA findings from the bathroom and the post mortem findings as evidence of guilt. 'All the evidence' seems to be rapidly disappearing into court rulings that are contrary to ECHR case law and thus invalid.

You make excellent points. Why is it that Vixen never considers that the prosecution experts could be paid shills? Is it only defense experts who lack the morals and ethical fortitude to withstand the temptation of money?
 
I mean in Capanne prison, making another assumption that most women are in for drugs and property offences. I will try to be less confusing.

I still can't find the source for that quote. I did ask Vixen for it and we'll see if she actually provides it. Miracles do happen occasionally.

Update: I found it. Her actual quote was "The black impoverished men took me in and called me their baby girl." She was referring to others who had similar experiences.
 
Last edited:
Can you please cite the source for this? Give a link?

There is no evidence whatsoever that the US State Dept. interfered in this case at all.
There is plenty. Charlie Wilkes has detailed exactly how the state department lawyers were educated. He will not state it, but the inference is unavoidable. I started a thread,

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=295661

Considering this was a first in Italian law, both nicking an American girl then acquitting at final recourse, go figure.
But you should bump the thread. It is to me the most interesting aspect of the case.
 
Last edited:
I still can't find the source for that quote. I did ask Vixen for it and we'll see if she actually provides it. Miracles do happen occasionally.
I simply embellish her article where she says she entered prison not a woman, and emerged a woman. She was living for 4 years with mainly petty criminals clearly. I really thought my meaning was straight forward, but then it has been suggested here English may be my second language...
 
There is plenty. Charlie Wilkes has detailed exactly how the state department lawyers were educated. He will not state it, but the inference is unavoidable. I started a thread,

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=295661

Considering this was a first in Italian law, both nicking an American girl then acquitting at final recourse, go figure.
But you should bump the thread. It is to me the most interesting aspect of the case.

I'll take a look at it. I have no idea who Charlie Wilkes is.

I did find the video, as edited above, and produced the actual quote.
 
I simply embellish her article where she says she entered prison not a woman, and emerged a woman. She was living for 4 years with mainly petty criminals clearly. I really thought my meaning was straight forward, but then it has been suggested here English may be my second language...

I assumed it is also your second language.
 
Stacyhs said:
Can you please cite the source for this? Give a link?

There is no evidence whatsoever that the US State Dept. interfered in this case at all.

There is plenty. Charlie Wilkes has detailed exactly how the state department lawyers were educated. He will not state it, but the inference is unavoidable. I started a thread,

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=295661

Considering this was a first in Italian law, both nicking an American girl then acquitting at final recourse, go figure.
But you should bump the thread. It is to me the most interesting aspect of the case.

I don't see how it's possible to conclude that the US State Dept did not "interfere" in this case - it all depends on what you mean by the word "interfere".

At the very least the US State Dept might have been formally asked by someone from Italy what American politicians like Senator Cantwell meant with her own remarks about the way the prosecution(s) proceeded. Informally, it is easy to imagine one rep from each government sitting down over a glass of wine, with the American laying out what American forensic-DNA experts (for instance) were saying about the nature of the evidence.

Given that no one can name one - not even one - forensic-DNA expert in either the US or in Italy who agreed with Stefanoni's work, all the Italian would have been able to fall back upon (over wine) would be the implied insult to the Italian legal system.

What would not be forthcoming from the Italian would be anyone - Italian, American or otherwise - who would stand by Stefanoni's work. It might even resemble the last 2 years of posting here on ISF - one guilter, Vixen, makes citationless claims, and the rest of us ask for citations which never come.

It's not much of a stretch to imagine a State Department official saying something akin to, "Do what you want with your own citizen, but on the basis of what we've seen there would be no extradition from the US over this."

As an aside, Andrea Vogt claims to have some info in this regard, but even she has admitted that the 2015 acquittals were definitive, and there's no point in trying to suggest otherwise.
 
I don't see how it's possible to conclude that the US State Dept did not "interfere" in this case - it all depends on what you mean by the word "interfere".At the very least the US State Dept might have been formally asked by someone from Italy what American politicians like Senator Cantwell meant with her own remarks about the way the prosecution(s) proceeded. Informally, it is easy to imagine one rep from each government sitting down over a glass of wine, with the American laying out what American forensic-DNA experts (for instance) were saying about the nature of the evidence.

Given that no one can name one - not even one - forensic-DNA expert in either the US or in Italy who agreed with Stefanoni's work, all the Italian would have been able to fall back upon (over wine) would be the implied insult to the Italian legal system.

What would not be forthcoming from the Italian would be anyone - Italian, American or otherwise - who would stand by Stefanoni's work. It might even resemble the last 2 years of posting here on ISF - one guilter, Vixen, makes citationless claims, and the rest of us ask for citations which never come.

It's not much of a stretch to imagine a State Department official saying something akin to, "Do what you want with your own citizen, but on the basis of what we've seen there would be no extradition from the US over this."

As an aside, Andrea Vogt claims to have some info in this regard, but even she has admitted that the 2015 acquittals were definitive, and there's no point in trying to suggest otherwise.

Exactly. I don't consider the state department discussing it as "interfering" but as "doing their job". The implication that pressure was put on Hellmann and Marasca/Bruno to acquit/annul against their wishes is absurd.
 
I'll take a look at it. I have no idea who Charlie Wilkes is.

I did find the video, as edited above, and produced the actual quote.
Charlie Wilkes was an activist and friend to Amanda from an outlying island near Seattle. He posted extensively here till a couple of years ago.
You may find it interesting to breeze through the early days at Injustice anywhere thread. His avatar is always the blue and red pills. At the risk of offending others, he is regarded by some as the finest writer and analyst anywhere on crime.

http://www.injusticeanywhereforum.com/viewtopic.php?f=20&t=747

It is truly archival, 56,000 posts starting 2011.
 
Political reasons.

The Italians didn't want to see their boy serve life whilst the person found guilty of the actual killing roams free in the USA.

If that were the case then why did Cheffi annul Hellmann and why did Nencini convict them - all while Amanda was already back home in the USA. Do you ever think before you comment?
 
Peter Gill wasn't a defense expert. He was never part of the case. Had nothing to do with Knox's exoneration. He was just a private citizen that took interest in a blatant miscarriage of justice and used his substantial expertise to give his own opinion. It's a real thorn in the side for the PGP, whose experts consist of online psychics and obsessive internet weirdos.

Not quite true is it? Peter Gill is quoted extensively in Raff's appeal to Fifth Chambers.

We have all these obsessive PIP internet weirdos who want to reinvent the truth and infantalise a 30 year old woman and idolise anyone who takes up their cause, including two people who had their sentences commuted as cop killers. We have people justifying Jacobs buying a cop killer his guns.
 
Did you miss the part where the real culprit was discovered because he had given a DNA sample in relation to another alleged offence, and his DNA matched that left on Molseed's underwear/body? And the real culprit had no connection whatsoever with Kiszko. THIS is the evidence which shows that Kiszko categorically had nothing to do with Molseed's murder - the evidence showing Kiszko could not produce sperm led to the vacation of his conviction, but his total innocence was proven by the discovery of the real culprit. I pointed this out pretty simply in both my previous posts. You seem not to have taken it on board......

So, Vixen: back to the actual matter at hand. The court in Kiszko's original trial decided that there was sufficient evidence to prove his guilt beyond all reasonable doubt. Yet we now know for certain that Kiszko definitely was not the culprit. So..... the original court, by definition, made a (serious) error in deciding that Kiszko had, beyond all reasonable doubt, been the man who sexually assaulted and murdered Lesley Molseed.

And then I ask you once again, Vixen: how do you imagine we can take the example of the court's error of judgement in the Kiszko case, and apply it to the Massei and Nencini courts in the Knox/Sollecito case?


The gaping difference between the Molseed case and this one is that Knox and Sollecito have not been exonerated.
 
What possible relevance does this comment have in relation to the horrible murder in Perugia in 2007? The comment shows a completely unhealthy obsession with a public figure - like tuning into BBC4 to hear the latest about Diana.

However, if this thread ever becomes one of examining the challenges facing exonerees - including the dynamics of being subject to multiyear abuse, slut-shaming and stalking from unhinged individuals - perhaps that comment would at least be in the ballpark of interest.....

..... as a case in point.

Why does this woman constantly seek publicity? Why does she fill our papers with fake news?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom