The Trials of Amanda Knox and Raffaele Sollecito: Part 26

Status
Not open for further replies.
By the way, Vixen: evidence or apology in respect of your claim that I am "prone to hero-worship or infatuation".

Hurry along now. Chop chop. Tout de suite!

(Or, if you prefer, I can hold that if you haven't ponied up any evidence within, say, 24 hours from now, we can all safely conclude that no such evidence ever existed, and that you simply made up a derogatory claim about me? Your choice!)

As I said in my response, if you do not fall under the 'White Knight to the rescue' category, it must be under one of the others. Which is, it?

I understand it is difficult for some to look at the case without a jaundiced eye.
 
LOL. Are we back in the locker rooms? Do we have tic tacs in one's pocket...just in case?

No, we are talking about why people engage in slut shaming. I propose that much of it has to do with their own inadequacies. That they are unhappy because they haven't had a fulfilling sex life. It's the ugly girls and guys that can't get a date so they call the cheerleader a slut.
 
I never accused Vixen of that. I just proposed that individuals that are obsessed with the sex lives of others might be doing that out of envy and jealousy caused by their own failings to attract any interest from the opposite sex.

It's not uncommon for ugly spinsters and lonely men to take out their resentment by slut shaming.



Oh silly me! I keep forgetting: Amanda Knox invented sex and none of the rest of us even know we have been born.
 
No, we are talking about why people engage in slut shaming. I propose that much of it has to do with their own inadequacies. That they are unhappy because they haven't had a fulfilling sex life. It's the ugly girls and guys that can't get a date so they call the cheerleader a slut.

I don't know anyone who has called Knox a slut. It is Amanda herself who keeps claiming Mignini didn't like her because she slept around (as if half the girls in Italy don't do the same).

It's Knox who fills half her book with her sordid antics.

Not many people brag about their private sex lives. If they do not, it doesn't follow they are 'ugly spinsters or bachelors'.

One of the plainest girls I ever knew freely 'gang-banged' men at parties, as they waiting in a queue outside the door.

There is no correlation between number of sex partners and attractiveness.
 
I don't know anyone who has called Knox a slut. It is Amanda herself who keeps claiming Mignini didn't like her because she slept around (as if half the girls in Italy don't do the same).

It's Knox who fills half her book with her sordid antics.

Not many people brag about their private sex lives. If they do not, it doesn't follow they are 'ugly spinsters or bachelors'.

One of the plainest girls I ever knew freely 'gang-banged' men at parties, as they waiting in a queue outside the door.

There is no correlation between number of sex partners and attractiveness.

Do you not see how bizarre and what a non sequitor this post is? Do you even read the posts you respond to?
 
I don't know anyone who has called Knox a slut. It is Amanda herself who keeps claiming Mignini didn't like her because she slept around (as if half the girls in Italy don't do the same).

It's Knox who fills half her book with her sordid antics. Not many people brag about their private sex lives. If they do not, it doesn't follow they are 'ugly spinsters or bachelors'.

One of the plainest girls I ever knew freely 'gang-banged' men at parties, as they waiting in a queue outside the door.

There is no correlation between number of sex partners and attractiveness.

No, you're not engaging in slut shaming. :rolleyes:

Pretty DAMN SAD and a TOTAL LIE.
Obviously, you didn’t read Amanda's book. There are no 'sordid antics' or any graphic detail. There is more sex discussed in one episode of The Big Bang Theory then there is in Waiting to Be Heard.

But why would anyone ever expect you to tell the truth?
 
No, you're not engaging in slut shaming. :rolleyes:

Pretty DAMN SAD and a TOTAL LIE.
Obviously, you didn’t read Amanda's book. There are no 'sordid antics' or any graphic detail. There is more sex discussed in one episode of The Big Bang Theory then there is in Waiting to Be Heard.

But why would anyone ever expect you to tell the truth?

Come of it. When the book came out it was touted in the papers and media as Amanda's sexcapades by rather shocked-looking tv hosts.
 
I never accused Vixen of that. I just proposed that individuals that are obsessed with the sex lives of others might be doing that out of envy and jealousy caused by their own failings to attract any interest from the opposite sex.

It's not uncommon for ugly spinsters and lonely men to take out their resentment by slut shaming.

You know, I think there is an element of projection here. People often think that what is at the forefront of their mind is also the same for others, thus we have people assuming everybody has the same desires as oneself, whether it be money, the perfect body, the perfect house, car, lots of money, lots of sex, etc.

I recall when my son was about three, he brought me over his toy helicopter and said - with his characteristic thoughfulness - "Mummy, you can play with it now".

As for your comment about 'ugly spinsters' (but not ugly bachelors???) I am far too modest to correct you, but I will say I am extremely privileged, although perhaps not in the way you might think, given your professed criteria.
 
As I said in my response, if you do not fall under the 'White Knight to the rescue' category, it must be under one of the others. Which is, it?

I understand it is difficult for some to look at the case without a jaundiced eye.


No, Vixen. This doesn't cut it at all.

You explicitly accused me of being "prone to hero-worship or infatuation". You didn't say it was one of a number of possibilities, Vixen. Are you incapable of owning your own claims, Vixen?

And for the record Vixen, the "category" I fall into is the one where I have correctly analysed this case in an objective, logical manner, and have reached the correct conclusion. Your amusingly ironic final sentence is an apt description of effectively every pro-guilt commentator's approach.

(And..... embarrassing attempt at misdirection in respect of the embarrassing punctuation error in the prior post. Oh dear.)
 
Come of it. When the book came out it was touted in the papers and media as Amanda's sexcapades by rather shocked-looking tv hosts.


1) No it wasn't.

2) In any case, you're now attempting to shift the onus from what Knox actually wrote and implied in her book to the way the media might have attempted to portray it.
 
Here come the reinforcements to the "personality deficiencies of some random Seattleite" crew.

The thread here, though, is called:

The Trials of Amanda Knox and Raffaele Sollecito: Part 26​
Like in the days of 2008-'09 when Mignini was trying to make an unmakeable case, by inventing dialogue and proporting it to be from Knox, "I will make you have sex," there will be some for whom that is the sum total of the "Trials of...."

In other words, what does "striving for attention and are soul mates," or "wearing a jacket which says Amanda", or "being a great match" have to do with.....

The Trials of Amanda Knox and Raffaele Sollecito: Part 26?​
Like Mignini's case in 2008-'09, when you got nothing of substance you invent stuff, like an Italian prosecutor in his 50's adopting a hi-pitched, women's voice for the court and saying, "We will make you have sex," and offer that to the court as "evidence".

Vixen boasts about all the evidence against Amanda and Raffaele. It is strange Mignini has to resort to inventing dialogue. You would not expect a prosecution with a slam dunk case to have to resort to this tactic.
 
You know, I think there is an element of projection here. People often think that what is at the forefront of their mind is also the same for others, thus we have people assuming everybody has the same desires as oneself, whether it be money, the perfect body, the perfect house, car, lots of money, lots of sex, etc.

Yes, that seems about right. It certainly would explain a lot.
 
Vixen said:
Come of it. When the book came out it was touted in the papers and media as Amanda's sexcapades by rather shocked-looking tv hosts.

1) No it wasn't.

2) In any case, you're now attempting to shift the onus from what Knox actually wrote and implied in her book to the way the media might have attempted to portray it.

Vixen continually overlooks that little back-arrow beside the name of the poster in the quote box. It means one can actually track a convo.....

...... meaning it is useless to shift goalposts so clumsily like Vixen has done with this particular example of slut-shaming.

Take a trip down back-arrow lane. Vixen claimed that half of Knox's book was an accointing of sexual escapades.

Vixen said:
I don't know anyone who has called Knox a slut. It is Amanda herself who keeps claiming Mignini didn't like her because she slept around (as if half the girls in Italy don't do the same).

It's Knox who fills half her book with her sordid antics.

Not many people brag about their private sex lives.
The ONLY reason Knox covered any of this in her book is because of what she'd been accused. Now random internet posters turn that into "bragging about their private sex lives".

On such is Wrongful Convictions 101. Force someone to account for this private stuff (in their self-defence) and then turn it round on them by accusing them of bragging.

Pure Mignini surrogacy. It's neither Crini nor Nencini advocacy is it. Then Vixen retreats, claiming that that was the eay the tabloids had covered Knox's book..... all the while denying that the tabloids bore any responsibility for their own slut-shaming of a wrongly accused.

This is the resson why ISF should remove that back-arrow.
 
Last edited:
Come of it. When the book came out it was touted in the papers and media as Amanda's sexcapades by rather shocked-looking tv hosts.

1) No it wasn't.

2) In any case, you're now attempting to shift the onus from what Knox actually wrote and implied in her book to the way the media might have attempted to portray it.

Clever how Vixen dodges having to back up her lies. I read Amanda's book as have many here. I know what she wrote. Vixen DOESN'T HAVE A DAMN CLUE. My guess is she is confusing the NUTJOBS at TJMK and PMF with the actual press. (Not that the press is likely to get it right either) Still, it beats that echo chamber that Vixen lives in.

This post a disparaging lie and blame it on someone else over and over and over again really is disgusting. Vixen blames Amanda for doing this to Patrick on a single occasion. But Vixen has done EXACTLY the same thing countless times on this forum.
 
Clever how Vixen dodges having to back up her lies. I read Amanda's book as have many here. I know what she wrote. Vixen DOESN'T HAVE A DAMN CLUE. My guess is she is confusing the NUTJOBS at TJMK and PMF with the actual press. (Not that the press is likely to get it right either) Still, it beats that echo chamber that Vixen lives in.

This post a disparaging lie and blame it on someone else over and over and over again really is disgusting. Vixen blames Amanda for doing this to Patrick on a single occasion. But Vixen has done EXACTLY the same thing countless times on this forum.

PGP constantly bang on about Amanda lying whilst lying on an industrial scale themselves and have no concept this is hypocritical. This is a sign of people with serious mental health issues.
 
PGP constantly bang on about Amanda lying whilst lying on an industrial scale themselves and have no concept this is hypocritical. This is a sign of people with serious mental health issues.

Taking a tour of the remaining hate-sites, and having a read of "the lies Knox told in her book", necessitates a reposting of what had always been wrong with accusing Knox and Sollecito:

Tunnel vision. It's not as if this is not a well-known, investigative trap that some police and prosecutors (and judges and juries!) fall into:

https://www.psychologytoday.com/blog/maybe-its-just-me/201005/tunnel-vision-in-the-criminal-justice-system

A prime example is provided in this Psychology Today piece:

In 1982, a man named Marvin Anderson was convicted of robbery, forcible sodomy, abduction, and the rape of a woman in Virginia, despite very weak evidence supporting the prosecution's case, questionable eyewitness identification, and four alibi witnesses that testified to seeing him in the same place (nowhere near the crime). Twenty years later, DNA evidence conclusively proved that Anderson was innocent, and pointed to the true offender, Otis Lincoln; much evidence available during Anderson's trial also indicated Lincoln was the likely attacker, but this was never investigated after Anderson was chosen as the main suspect.​
Given that the hate-sites evaluate if Knox had lied from assuming the conclusion that she was guilty.....

Working hand-in-hand with confirmation bias, hindsight bias describes another natural tendency to regard a past event as inevitable, or at least much likely than originally thought, after it is confirmed by later information. Otherwise known as the "knew-it-all-along" effect, it stems from the way we construct our memories of events, using all of the information gathered since the original occurence to arrive at a much more definite causal chain of events than is objectively warranted.​
It's bad enough that we are treated on a daily basis to examples of this on this very thread.

What with Google and other web-hosting services now cracking down on hate-sites with regard to Naziism and such, it's probably only a matter of time.

Unfortunately, there are true-believers on that side of the fence who would relish taking this into a courtroom, as per the Florence courtroom which had a private citizen in Italy wanting to bring a suit against those who had acquitted Knox and Sollecito.
 
Last edited:
PGP constantly bang on about Amanda lying whilst lying on an industrial scale themselves and have no concept this is hypocritical. This is a sign of people with serious mental health issues.

I really don't get the lying and the slut shaming. Maybe I was raised better. I was taught in Sunday School not to lie and be judgmental. This petty picking at everything Amanda says and does is immature and certainly isn't Christian. I mention the latter because Vixen pretends to be one.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom