The Trials of Amanda Knox and Raffaele Sollecito: Part 26

Status
Not open for further replies.
I noted years ago that the PGP often tend to have some kind of fascination with Amanda's sex life, both before and after the murder. They are prone to slut-shaming, calling her a ◊◊◊◊, wh***, nymphomaniac, accusing her of cheating on boyfriends, of using sex to get jobs, etc. This obsession with her sex life is psychologically fascinating.

http://www.nytimes.com/2013/11/19/science/a-cold-war-fought-by-women.html?pagewanted=all

It is also noted in the same article that married women are less inclined to this kind of catty behavior than single (and that would include older divorced/widowed) women:



Does this need to slut-shame, denigrate, and insult younger and more attractive females have a connection to sexual frustration in older, single, less attractive women who just aren't getting sex anymore? I suspect it does.

Perhaps you are able to provide an answer to your own question?

AIUI She wrote a post in which she appears to claim that only she is 'happily married' and a lot of weird stuff about female sexuality. Yet omits to mention any male equivalent.

She seems to be insinuating something disgusting, but you'll have to ask her to explain what she means. <shrug>

Oh dear, oh dear.... Once again you fail to remember we can read past posts.

Do try and follow the conversation. The article I quoted clearly said it is mostly single women who slut shame, not married women. You then asked if I could answer my own question. I said

I don't qualify as I am neither single, divorced, nor widowed.
and posted a Carry On sign that said "Happily married".
Would you care to point out exactly where I "appear to say only (I) am 'happily married'"? Thought not.

Why should I mention any male equivalent when the article and we were discussing the phenomenon of female on female slut-shaming as pertains to the slut-shaming of Amanda Knox?

As for me "insinuating something disgusting", that is something you inferred yourself. Why is that?
 
Last edited:
I really don't understand how anyone familiar with the evidence in this case believing that Raffaele and Amanda were involved. Vixen has to create lie after after lie to try and make a semi-plausible argument for guilt. My question is why do they do this?

It would be one thing if we were looking at the same evidence and you believe they were involved. You would still be intellectually challenged, but hat least you were honest about it.

Mignini's case against the pair was predicated on reverse engineering the evidence, an enterprise which started with the assumption that Knox, Sollecito and Lumumba, and then Guede (replacing Lumumba) had done the crime. Then compatabilities were collected.

What Mignini's case was, was searching for compatibilities with the assumed conclusion. What is evident in what all the courts decided about those compatibilities - convicting and acquitting courts - is that the courts didn't buy Mignini's version of reverse engineering.

The convicting courts, instead, substituted their own compatibilities - which is all you really need to hear as to how bizarre this was. For instance, Mignini's theory that Amanda had brought the kitchen kinfe from the apartment with malice aforethought, became Judge Massei's theory that she'd carried the knife for protection out on the street, and only by coincidence then used it in the crime. (And Massei had said that not because there was any evidence, but that that theory was compatible.)

I've run across hard core Mignini-surrogates, one of whom said that one of the psychological motives for Amanda killing Meredith, was because Amanda was in love with Meredith:

Obviously Amanda liked Meredith. But the problem is that she liked her too much, also sexually, and she was hurt, both humiliated - opening multiple instances of jealousy - and rejected.​
This same Mignini surrogate posted what to him was a summary of Mignini's closing argument (I believe to the Massei court in 2009) where a sex-crime gone wrong (Mignini faux-quoting Knox as saying, "I will make you have sex!") in the end became some bizarre psychosexual reason for Knox taking out sexual rejection onto Meredith.

Such is the origin of the psychopathologizing that Mignini-surrogates do, which is remarkable because none of the courts, even the convicting ones, agree.

For Massei this was Rudy's crime, and Massei said that his court was hardpressed to even imagine a motive for Amanda urging Rudy to sexually attack Meredith.

For Nencini, all sex was removed except for Rudy's claimed consensual sex. The murder was because of rent money.

So, this is why when one hears a guilter go all psychopathological on us, what they're doing is defending Mignini. They're not even defending the convicting courts - indeed, eventually they have to argue against them.
 
Last edited:
I have zero respect for unreformed murderer rapists and other criminals, regardless of whether they are the butcher the baker or the candlestick maker.

Meredith was far better looking than Knox, who I wouldn't describe as 'beautiful' at all, but very ordinary. If anything, gaunt, haggard and scraggy. However, comparisons are odious.

But of course she is not a murderer rapist.

As for whether Amanda is beautiful or not that is subjective. A lot of people believe that she is. I think Meredith was pretty too.

Nevertheless, Amanda is living the good life traveling throughout the world with a young smart intelligent handsome boyfriend. Did you see the pictures of them together in Germany? It must bother old bitty prudish spinsters. Envy can just eat away at some people.
 
I notice you haven't pulled up acbytesla on this matter as he is the one making the scurrilous claims.

Be specific. I can't think of a single post that was anything but spot on. So feel free to point out anything that was not accurate.
 
Mignini's case against the pair was predicated on reverse engineering the evidence, an enterprise which started with the assumption that Knox, Sollecito and Lumumba, and then Guede (replacing Lumumba) had done the crime. Then compatabilities were collected.

What Mignini's case was, was searching for compatibilities with the assumed conclusion. What is evident in what all the courts decided about those compatibilities - convicting and acquitting courts - is that the courts didn't buy Mignini's version of reverse engineering.

The convicting courts, instead, substituted their own compatibilities - which is all you really need to hear as to how bizarre this was. For instance, Mignini's theory that Amanda had brought the kitchen kinfe from the apartment with malice aforethought, became Judge Massei's theory that she'd carried the knife for protection out on the street, and only by coincidence then used it in the crime. (And Massei had said that not because there was any evidence, but that that theory was compatible.)

I've run across hard core Mignini-surrogates, one of whom said that one of the psychological motives for Amanda killing Meredith, was because Amanda was in love with Meredith:

​
This same Mignini surrogate posted what to him was a summary of Mignini's closing argument (I believe to the Massei court in 2009) where a sex-crime gone wrong (Mignini faux-quoting Knox as saying, "I will make you have sex!") in the end became some bizarre psychosexual reason for Knox taking out sexual rejection onto Meredith.

Such is the origin of the psychopathologizing that Mignini-surrogates do, which is remarkable because none of the courts, even the convicting ones, agree.

For Massei this was Rudy's crime, and Massei said that his court was hardpressed to even imagine a motive for Amanda urging Rudy to sexually attack Meredith.

For Nencini, all sex was removed except for Rudy's claimed consensual sex. The murder was because of rent money.

So, this is why when one hears a guilter go all psychopathological on us, what they're doing is defending Mignini. They're not even defending the convicting courts - indeed, eventually they have to argue against them.

This is precisely what I had in mind when I said not only was their a fictional 'Amanda' but a fictional 'crime' and a fictional 'investigation' as well.

Mignini believed a sexual orgy (no evidence suggested this, but it's what he thought so he created his very expensive fictional cartoon to help share his vision to others). This was part of the fictional crime that people bought into. To support that, they argued no defensive wounds (which was incorrect, there were defensive wounds, just not extensive), they argued multiple knives (fictional 'evidence' .. this one is really interesting as it only came about when the idiot cop grabbed a knife that couldn't have made any of the wounds except one). Six of seven experts reviewed the autopsy results and concluded the wounds are consistent or compatible with a single attacker yet the courts concluded the lack of defensive wounds and the use of two knives all but proves this was done by more than one attacker (a conclusion based on fictional evidence and a fictional investigation, one that contradicts or ignores physical evidence and expert testimony). interestingly, they then take it a step further when they determined it's an attack done not by two or four attackers, but three. Why? Because Amanda and Raffaele are guilty and Guede was definitely there, so it has to be three (fictional crime).

Just consider some of what went into creating Amanda - she's obsessed with sex; having major issues with Meredith; jealous of Meredith; she's friends with Guede; a drug habit which requires money she doesn't have; over $4K in the bank means you don't have money; the violence of the war that broke out at Amanda's loud party; the photo of Amanda behind a machine gun; the "endless parade" of strange men brought to the house; the pink bathroom photo; -- that's just the tip of it, all designed to created the fictional Amanda who can then be easily plugged into the fictional crime, bolstered by the fictional evidence and suddenly the crime is solved.

But as AC ponders... why are there still people, nearly ten years after the murder, that still don't understand just how much fiction this case generated? I don't get it either.
 
Oh, please!!!! You must be confusing me with someone else. I have NEVER made fun of anyone with autism. I have a very close family member with autism so I know that you are wrong, wrong, wrong.

Do not use the excuse that you won't quote them because you'd be repeating them here to hide behind. Do it!

I'll ask this of everyone in this group: Have any of you seen me make any such remarks? If so, please speak up.

Of course you didn’t. This is sad. But this lie will get lost with all the others. Think about the things she has said about Hellman, Conti and Vecchiotti, Dr. Gill, Dr. Hampikian, Detective Douglas. You're in good company Stacyhs.
 
Of course you didn’t. This is sad. But this lie will get lost with all the others. Think about the things she has said about Hellman, Conti and Vecchiotti, Dr. Gill, Dr. Hampikian, Detective Douglas. You're in good company Stacyhs.

I was thinking about this earlier and I remembered that Vixen made this same false allegation before. Of course, she had no proof then just like now. You'd think she'd learn. But no...
 
But of course she is not a murderer rapist.

As for whether Amanda is beautiful or not that is subjective. A lot of people believe that she is. I think Meredith was pretty too.

Nevertheless, Amanda is living the good life traveling throughout the world with a young smart intelligent handsome boyfriend. Did you see the pictures of them together in Germany? It must bother old bitty prudish spinsters. Envy can just eat away at some people.

Is this anybody we know? Strange company you keep.
 
I was thinking about this earlier and I remembered that Vixen made this same false allegation before. Of course, she had no proof then just like now. You'd think she'd learn. But no...

If Amanda had gone on an internet forum and made a false a accusation over what someone had said, Vixen would be shouting from the rooftops about Amanda lying.
 
This is precisely what I had in mind when I said not only was their a fictional 'Amanda' but a fictional 'crime' and a fictional 'investigation' as well.

Mignini believed a sexual orgy (no evidence suggested this, but it's what he thought so he created his very expensive fictional cartoon to help share his vision to others). This was part of the fictional crime that people bought into. To support that, they argued no defensive wounds (which was incorrect, there were defensive wounds, just not extensive), they argued multiple knives (fictional 'evidence' .. this one is really interesting as it only came about when the idiot cop grabbed a knife that couldn't have made any of the wounds except one). Six of seven experts reviewed the autopsy results and concluded the wounds are consistent or compatible with a single attacker yet the courts concluded the lack of defensive wounds and the use of two knives all but proves this was done by more than one attacker (a conclusion based on fictional evidence and a fictional investigation, one that contradicts or ignores physical evidence and expert testimony). interestingly, they then take it a step further when they determined it's an attack done not by two or four attackers, but three. Why? Because Amanda and Raffaele are guilty and Guede was definitely there, so it has to be three (fictional crime).

Just consider some of what went into creating Amanda - she's obsessed with sex; having major issues with Meredith; jealous of Meredith; she's friends with Guede; a drug habit which requires money she doesn't have; over $4K in the bank means you don't have money; the violence of the war that broke out at Amanda's loud party; the photo of Amanda behind a machine gun; the "endless parade" of strange men brought to the house; the pink bathroom photo; -- that's just the tip of it, all designed to created the fictional Amanda who can then be easily plugged into the fictional crime, bolstered by the fictional evidence and suddenly the crime is solved.

But as AC ponders... why are there still people, nearly ten years after the murder, that still don't understand just how much fiction this case generated? I don't get it either.

It is Amanda who claims she was obsessed with sex when she went to Italy. The person spinning the most lies, is Knox herself. You only have to see the lie after lie on the Netflix film.

I certainly don't think Meredith's family consider her death to be 'fictional'. It was brutal. It was horrible. There is nothing glamorous at all about Amanda and Raff. They mistake notoreity for celebrity.
 
It is Amanda who claims she was obsessed with sex when she went to Italy. The person spinning the most lies, is Knox herself. You only have to see the lie after lie on the Netflix film.

I certainly don't think Meredith's family consider her death to be 'fictional'. It was brutal. It was horrible. There is nothing glamorous at all about Amanda and Raff. They mistake notoreity for celebrity.

O Lord. Your misunderstanding is either willful or out of not being able to read.

We're now up to two dozen requests from you for a cite, but this one is for where anyone called the death "fictional".

Why do you do this? How can it possibly advance understanding the case, or homour the original victim or her family?

That you would bring the family into your nonsense is just vile.
 
It doesn't refer to me, Honey, if that's what you are hoping to imply.
I never said it was you. Sorry if it felt like it hit a little too close to home.
Can't win an argument, so attack the person with pathetic sexist ad hominem.
You should know considering the countless sexist ad hominems you have directed toward Amanda.
 
It is Amanda who claims she was obsessed with sex when she went to Italy. The person spinning the most lies, is Knox herself. You only have to see the lie after lie on the Netflix film.

I certainly don't think Meredith's family consider her death to be 'fictional'. It was brutal. It was horrible. There is nothing glamorous at all about Amanda and Raff. They mistake notoreity for celebrity.

No, a fictional Amanda created by the police, the media, etc., and embraced by you, made that claim - the real Amanda made no such claim. Apparently you've been building and revising your fictional Amanda for so long you no longer have any idea how to separate fact from fiction. The real Amanda, in fact, had spoken to Meredith about feeling uncomfortable about having sex without emotional involvement and Meredith advised "maybe uninvolved sex just isn't for you". That hardly sound like someone obsessed with sex. I don't suppose you have a cite, do you?

I never said Meredith's death was fictional and I would appreciate an apology from you for suggesting as much. I said there was a fictional crime. Meredith died as a result of a sexual assault. There is physical evidence of one, and only one person in Meredith's room other than Meredith herself. The only prints recovered from the room belonged to that same person. DNA belonging to that same person was found in and on Meredith, her clothes and her purse. Only one person fled the country and it was this same individual. There was an apparent break-in at the cottage and that was by way of throwing a rock through the window. This same individual was caught just days earlier illegally inside a school and in possession of a computer and mobile phones taken from a law office that was broken into also by throwing a rock through a window. ALL of the facts surrounding the death of Meredith Kercher pointed to one person, and only one person committing the crime and that was Rudy Guede. Adding perpetrators , a scandalous motive and events completely out of whole cloth is how you create a fictional crime and that is exactly what was done in this case.
 
It is Amanda who claims she was obsessed with sex when she went to Italy. The person spinning the most lies, is Knox herself. You only have to see the lie after lie on the Netflix film.


When did Knox ever claim she was "obsessed with sex" when she went to Italy?

Or is your hatred for Knox resulting in your changing "decided to become more sexually liberated" to "was obsessed with sex"? Of course it is.

(And don't they teach punctuation lessons in your expensive no-barrier-to-entry creative writing summer schools...? :o )


I certainly don't think Meredith's family consider her death to be 'fictional'. It was brutal. It was horrible. There is nothing glamorous at all about Amanda and Raff. They mistake notoreity for celebrity.


Ah nice straw man once again. Nobody was claiming Kercher's murder was "fictional". Rather, what was "fictional" was the prosecution's theory of the crime, certain elements of the crime (e.g. the staged break-in, the mixed blood in the sink, the embarrassingly wrong attribution of show prints....) and its characterisations of Knox and Sollecito in particular.

And I realise YOU think Knox and Sollecito are "notorious". But you are in the tiny minority, Vixen. It seems, for example, that large numbers of law firms and bar associations in Knox's home country (who know something about the law and about fame vs infamy) come down rather conclusively in the "celebrity" (or rather, "worthy of being heard for the right reasons") camp rather than the "notoriety" camp, wouldn'tcha say, Vixen? :D
 
By the way, Vixen: evidence or apology in respect of your claim that I am "prone to hero-worship or infatuation".

Hurry along now. Chop chop. Tout de suite!

(Or, if you prefer, I can hold that if you haven't ponied up any evidence within, say, 24 hours from now, we can all safely conclude that no such evidence ever existed, and that you simply made up a derogatory claim about me? Your choice!)
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom