The Smithsonian is closing the dinosaur wing of the Natural History Museum

It answers why the renovation costs so much. It doesn't answer WHY the renovation should take place at all. They have to dismantle, clean and remount every specimen? Why can't they just hose them down? And I still don't buy it. After all, this is the federal government we're talking about here. There's got to be pork and graft built into the bottom line. Not to mention the inevitable cost overruns.

Very possibly for the cost issues. Still, not being privy to the actual projected costs, it's hard to tell... and when was the last time they renovated? The article talks about restoring the wing to it's 1910 glory, but doesn't answer when it was renovated last, nor how frequently museums renovate in general. If it's been that long, though, it's likely long past time for renovations.

As for the "just hosing them down," that's likely to be a poor option when dealing with what are, frankly, extremely ancient relics.

So they're not really closing the dinosaur wing, then?

Temporarily, with the note that there will be a separate dinosaur exhibit elsewhere.
 
Last edited:
But... but... my nephews just turned 8. That's prime dinosauring time. By the time it reopens, they'll be 13, and dinos won't be cool for another 20 years!
That's also the prime spacing out period. Take them to the Smithsonian hangar out by Dulles instead. They've got a space shuttle there, the Enola Gay, a Blackbird... plenty of dinosaurs for them to ogle.
 
It answers why the renovation costs so much. It doesn't answer WHY the renovation should take place at all. They have to dismantle, clean and remount every specimen? Why can't they just hose them down? And I still don't buy it. After all, this is the federal government we're talking about here. There's got to be pork and graft built into the bottom line. Not to mention the inevitable cost overruns.

You obviously have no idea what's going on.

First, these specimens are EXTREMELY fragile. Even the casts are old at this poiint, and the non-casts (ie, the actual fossils) need to be handled with extreme care. The issue is, a lot of dinosaur bones have pyrite in them, and can get what's called "pyrite disease". This condition can reduce valuable fossils to mere rubbish astonishingly quickly. What all this means is that it takes experts not only in handling fossils, but in museum displays to even consider taking apart a single dinosaur display.

"Just hose them off" is perhaps the worst possible things anyone could do to these fossils. I've been backhanded by curators for saying far, far less (to be fair, we had that kind of relationship--a slap upside the head now and then was considered all in good fun). NO paleontologist EVER would EVER "just hose them off". We spend our lives hunting for these fossils. We all know how valuable and irreplaceable these remains are. Seeing pyrite disease is absolutely heartbreaking, and anyone who's seen it happen once takes extreme precautions to prevent it from happening again. And remember, these are relics not just of past life, but of HUMAN history. The Smithsonian includes the remains found during the Bone Wars, and fossils involved in the great scientific controversies--tectonics, the Alvarez Hypothesis, etc. These fossils are a part of us, biologically, intellectually, professionally, and historically.

Second, these things are heavy. This requires specialized equipment and techniques to remove and relocate them. This also involves things like putting holes in the floor and ceiling, and fixing the ones that are there. So not only is this a major paleontological and curatorial project, it's an enormous construction project.

Third, you've got to make sure the things are right when you put them back up. Our understanding of dinosaurs has changed radically in the past few decades, and displaying that information in an easy and accessible way isn't easy. I've helped with small displays in universities, and it can take days to figure out what you want one of those to look like. This requires a very specialized skillset--part scientist, part teacher, part entertainer. You don't just slap some stuff together and call it good. How do you illustrate predator/prey relationships? How do you illustrate feeding behavior? Mating behavior? Raising of young? How do you illustrate time? Do you jumble the dinosaurs together, or separate them by time? If you do it by time, WHICH time? Age? Era? Period? Or do you skip time and focus on taxonomy and cladistics? How do you illustrate the soft tissue? The internal organs? How do you deal with the controversies?

Fourth, you have to pick which fossils go on display--and that's a whole other nightmare anyone not aquainted with data control can't imagine. I've had to deal with checking materials into and out of a very, very small collection at a jobsite, and it was nearly a full-time job. The Smithsonian has collections from all over the world, some of which it owns, some of which are on loan, some of which are donated and not fully through the accession process. Just keeping track of which stuff is on display and which is in the shelves is a job that will take a team of people months to work out. And you have to remember, we don't have complete skeletons for pretty much any dinosaur. Those complete skeletons you see in museums are actually partial skeletons, with the holes filled in via casts from other specimens and casts made based on the remains of the mostly-complete skeleton itself (for example, if you have a right tibia but not a left you can make a model of the left tibia).

Related to that, you have to make casts. They degrade over time, after all, and sometimes you want to put a rare fossil on display that previously wasn't. Casting fossils is an art unto itself. It's easier to cast metal than to make a plaster cast of a fossil--I've done both, and would rather cast the metal any day. You have to make the mold, which is extremely tricky because you have to not have any air bubbles and you can't damage the fossil (the curators get REALLY upset if you do, and they all have rock hammers!). Then you have to mix the plaster in specific ways, to ensure that there are no air bubbles. Then you have to pour the plaster in specific ways, to ensure there are no air bubbles. Then you have to agitate the plaster in specific ways, to ensure there are no air bubbles. Then you have to dry the plaster in specific ways, to ensure there are no air bubbles. See a trend here? Then you have to extract the mold, during which time you always have breakage and a certain percentage of loss.

They may be doing fiberglass or plastic casting. I have not worked with either technique, so cannot comment too much on them. However, certain things will remain the same--you need to take extreme care doing this, and you'll have a certain percentage of loss. The only people with the appropriate skillset to cast fossils are paleontologists, and then only a small percentage of us. I wouldn't trust myself to cast a dinosaur fossil; I stick with the <12" range for casting.

Then of course there's advertisement, merchendizing, revamping the toy lines and book lines, all that good stuff that generates income and helps spread scientific knowledge. This is actually pretty important, in my opinion--I've been reading my son my old dinosaur books, and it struck me anew just how much my career path was influenced by those books. At any rate, all of that costs money.

Then there's the oversight, and if you don't think that's worth the money you're an idiot. There will be MILLIONS of moving parts to this, all over the world, including countries the USA isn't exactly on good terms with. There will be contractors, OSHA inspectors, lab supervisors, maintenance folks....just feeding the people involved will be a logistical headache (where will the food trucks park? how much time do they get? how often will you audit them to check? if people are traveling, who reviews their expense reports?).

This is a tad more expensive than I'd have expected, but it's the upper end of reasonable in my opinion. It could be a lot worse.
 
You obviously have no idea what's going on.

First, these specimens are EXTREMELY fragile. Even the casts are old at this poiint, and the non-casts (ie, the actual fossils) need to be handled with extreme care. The issue is, a lot of dinosaur bones have pyrite in them, and can get what's called "pyrite disease". This condition can reduce valuable fossils to mere rubbish astonishingly quickly. What all this means is that it takes experts not only in handling fossils, but in museum displays to even consider taking apart a single dinosaur display.

Shemp has made the false assumption that everyone knows he is joking.
 
But... but... my nephews just turned 8. That's prime dinosauring time. By the time it reopens, they'll be 13, and dinos won't be cool for another 20 years!

I see several posters have recommended Utah as an alternate destination. Also, if you want to spend time in an exotic foreign country, a trip to Drumheller Alberta would provide a good dino fix. It is also way closer to you in OR than DC would be.
 
Shemp has made the false assumption that everyone knows he is joking.

And in return for pretending shemp was joking, everyone got a lecture on the importance of being careful and thorough when handling natural history specimens, and on the often unappreciated difficulties behind museum work, so everyone wins!
 
I see several posters have recommended Utah as an alternate destination. Also, if you want to spend time in an exotic foreign country, a trip to Drumheller Alberta would provide a good dino fix. It is also way closer to you in OR than DC would be.

The Natural History Museum in Salt Lake City has NO meaningful plastic dinosaurs in the gift shop, however... Only the generally crappy Safari collection...
 
I presume you mean, until they have 8 year old children/nieces/nephews of their own.

As a matter of completely irrelevant information - but interesting (to me) at least - "niece"/"nephew" also mean "the illegitimate daughter/son of an ecclesiastic who has taken a vow of celibacy".

You live and learn. That's today's useless information to be trotted out at some future date when of marginal (no) relevance.

Oddly, they are the children of a clergyman, but he married my sister, so it's all kosher, except that they're not Jewish.

All truth be told, they live right by the John Day Fossil Beds, and they saw the roaming dino exhibit at OMSI last year (And every roaming non-dino exhibit they had). So, they're not exactly deprived.

But, The Smithsonian is The Smithsonian

That's also the prime spacing out period. Take them to the Smithsonian hangar out by Dulles instead. They've got a space shuttle there, the Enola Gay, a Blackbird... plenty of dinosaurs for them to ogle.
Thank you so much for reminding me that the Pacific Northwest was the only corner of the US to not get a shuttle, while the northeast got two.
 
You obviously have no idea what's going on.

First, these specimens are EXTREMELY fragile. Even the casts are old at this poiint, and the non-casts (ie, the actual fossils) need to be handled with extreme care. The issue is, a lot of dinosaur bones have pyrite in them, and can get what's called "pyrite disease". This condition can reduce valuable fossils to mere rubbish astonishingly quickly. What all this means is that it takes experts not only in handling fossils, but in museum displays to even consider taking apart a single dinosaur display.

"Just hose them off" is perhaps the worst possible things anyone could do to these fossils. I've been backhanded by curators for saying far, far less (to be fair, we had that kind of relationship--a slap upside the head now and then was considered all in good fun). NO paleontologist EVER would EVER "just hose them off". We spend our lives hunting for these fossils. We all know how valuable and irreplaceable these remains are. Seeing pyrite disease is absolutely heartbreaking, and anyone who's seen it happen once takes extreme precautions to prevent it from happening again. And remember, these are relics not just of past life, but of HUMAN history. The Smithsonian includes the remains found during the Bone Wars, and fossils involved in the great scientific controversies--tectonics, the Alvarez Hypothesis, etc. These fossils are a part of us, biologically, intellectually, professionally, and historically.

Second, these things are heavy. This requires specialized equipment and techniques to remove and relocate them. This also involves things like putting holes in the floor and ceiling, and fixing the ones that are there. So not only is this a major paleontological and curatorial project, it's an enormous construction project.

Third, you've got to make sure the things are right when you put them back up. Our understanding of dinosaurs has changed radically in the past few decades, and displaying that information in an easy and accessible way isn't easy. I've helped with small displays in universities, and it can take days to figure out what you want one of those to look like. This requires a very specialized skillset--part scientist, part teacher, part entertainer. You don't just slap some stuff together and call it good. How do you illustrate predator/prey relationships? How do you illustrate feeding behavior? Mating behavior? Raising of young? How do you illustrate time? Do you jumble the dinosaurs together, or separate them by time? If you do it by time, WHICH time? Age? Era? Period? Or do you skip time and focus on taxonomy and cladistics? How do you illustrate the soft tissue? The internal organs? How do you deal with the controversies?

Fourth, you have to pick which fossils go on display--and that's a whole other nightmare anyone not aquainted with data control can't imagine. I've had to deal with checking materials into and out of a very, very small collection at a jobsite, and it was nearly a full-time job. The Smithsonian has collections from all over the world, some of which it owns, some of which are on loan, some of which are donated and not fully through the accession process. Just keeping track of which stuff is on display and which is in the shelves is a job that will take a team of people months to work out. And you have to remember, we don't have complete skeletons for pretty much any dinosaur. Those complete skeletons you see in museums are actually partial skeletons, with the holes filled in via casts from other specimens and casts made based on the remains of the mostly-complete skeleton itself (for example, if you have a right tibia but not a left you can make a model of the left tibia).

Related to that, you have to make casts. They degrade over time, after all, and sometimes you want to put a rare fossil on display that previously wasn't. Casting fossils is an art unto itself. It's easier to cast metal than to make a plaster cast of a fossil--I've done both, and would rather cast the metal any day. You have to make the mold, which is extremely tricky because you have to not have any air bubbles and you can't damage the fossil (the curators get REALLY upset if you do, and they all have rock hammers!). Then you have to mix the plaster in specific ways, to ensure that there are no air bubbles. Then you have to pour the plaster in specific ways, to ensure there are no air bubbles. Then you have to agitate the plaster in specific ways, to ensure there are no air bubbles. Then you have to dry the plaster in specific ways, to ensure there are no air bubbles. See a trend here? Then you have to extract the mold, during which time you always have breakage and a certain percentage of loss.

They may be doing fiberglass or plastic casting. I have not worked with either technique, so cannot comment too much on them. However, certain things will remain the same--you need to take extreme care doing this, and you'll have a certain percentage of loss. The only people with the appropriate skillset to cast fossils are paleontologists, and then only a small percentage of us. I wouldn't trust myself to cast a dinosaur fossil; I stick with the <12" range for casting.

Then of course there's advertisement, merchendizing, revamping the toy lines and book lines, all that good stuff that generates income and helps spread scientific knowledge. This is actually pretty important, in my opinion--I've been reading my son my old dinosaur books, and it struck me anew just how much my career path was influenced by those books. At any rate, all of that costs money.

Then there's the oversight, and if you don't think that's worth the money you're an idiot. There will be MILLIONS of moving parts to this, all over the world, including countries the USA isn't exactly on good terms with. There will be contractors, OSHA inspectors, lab supervisors, maintenance folks....just feeding the people involved will be a logistical headache (where will the food trucks park? how much time do they get? how often will you audit them to check? if people are traveling, who reviews their expense reports?).

This is a tad more expensive than I'd have expected, but it's the upper end of reasonable in my opinion. It could be a lot worse.

Other than the parts where you insulted me, tl;dr.
 
Yes, I can get my fill of dinosaurs whenever I want.

Unfortunately, the really good ones are all in the Carnegie Museum, which sponsored the first dig in the area. But you can't beat the Wall o' Bones.

No, no you can't!!! It is one of the world's interesting features I would love to have in my home!!!:):):):)
 
All truth be told, they live right by the John Day Fossil Beds, and they saw the roaming dino exhibit at OMSI last year (And every roaming non-dino exhibit they had). So, they're not exactly deprived.

You encourage them to go to or accompany them of a visit to Hancock Field Station, if you want to see fossils in the "wild".
 
Shemp has made the false assumption that everyone knows he is joking.

Even if he was, it's not necesassrily a bad thing to have an opportunity to outline the processes involved in something of this magnitude. Most people simply don't know what goes into a museum display, despite that being one of hte key components in transmitting scientific knowledge to the public.

shemp, I didn't insult you. I spoke harshly, but there was no insult. Your comments indicated that you DON'T have any idea what goes into this type of thing--and it's no insult to state that someone, in fact, doesn't know something. These are arcane mysteries no one outside the brotherhood of curators (and a few of us who've dipped into it a few times) knows exist, much less understands. I dobut there's five people on this forum who have curatorial experience.

For example, subjects like pyrite disease aren't known outside of paleontology circles (I don't mean "are rarely known", I mean that I have never heard anyone outside of paleontology acknowledge the existence of such things). I acknowledge that you weren't being 100% serious here--but even people trying to be careful frequently do far more harm than good. Propar care of specimens is a time-consuming, expensive, and labor-intensive task requiring specialized training and tools, and is something that most people simply cannot calculate the cost of. I was more using the comment as a vehicle for discussing that issue. The vitriol and intensity comes from the fact that, to put it bluntly, that's how these topics are discussed in my line of work. If the topic arises, it's not a pleasant conversation. Curators get REALLY intense on this issue, and after dealing with a small collection myself I understand why.

Short version: I didn't say anything, or use any tone, that I wouldn't say or use to a student or colleague I had to discuss this with. And I was honestly far more polite and civil than some of the folks who discussed this with me. I'm not kidding when I say I've been hit during these discussions, and my experience is pretty mild truth be told.

Also, if you think that's long, you should see the documents one needs to draft to do any part of what I described. What I wrote wouldn't be long enough to count as a decent introduction. It's a full page shorter than I would expect the outline (minus callouts to figures, tables, plates, and appendixes) to be. That was the Cliff's Notes version.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom